Blood and treasure
By Steve Benen Friday Jul 06, 2007 8:06am
When it comes to U.S. losses in Iraq, obviously the top concern is the tragic rate of fatalities and casualties. Nothing else comes close.
But if we’re going to consider the latter half of the “blood and treasure” equation, Noah Shachtman reminds us today that the financial cost of the war is soaring.
It’s not just the troops that are surging. War costs are up for American operations in Iraq — way up, more than a third higher than last year. In the first half of this fiscal year, the Defense Department’s “average monthly obligations for contracts and pay is running about $12 billion per month, well above the $8.7 billion in FY2006,” says a new report, obtained by DANGER ROOM, from the non-partisan Congressional Research Service:
“Additional war costs for the next 10 years could total about $472 billion if troop levels fall to 30,000 by 2010, or $919 billion if troop levels fall to 70,000 by about 2013. If these estimates are added to already appropriated amounts, total funding about $980 billion to $1.4 trillion by 2017.”
No matter how one looks at it, “surging” ain’t cheap.









Login or Register to post comments.
Money is the heart of everything . . . or greed.
Numbers this big deserve to be written out, 12 bln doesn't hit home to the average dumb America,
but $12,000,000,000 might......??.....................naw.........they'll just shrug.
Yeah, but by the hour it's pure evil.....$16,666,666.66
The war pigs (who seem to be running the show badly)aint gonna get my "income" tax anymore!
No matter how one looks at it, “surging” ain’t cheap.
But it sure is profitable.
And what's it all for? Nothing but lining the pockets of Bush's corporate whores and to use Iraq as the dashboard for when the warmongering fascists want to steal the rest of the Middle East's oil, so they can control the planet! Whoever controls the oil controls the planet. Sick.
Making Iraq into a budding democracy is just pure bullshit.
Hey, I got an idea President Cheney...why don't we load a plane to the brim with good ol' American cash, and fly it into Iraq and hand it out? How many Iraqis are left alive? I'm sure they'd all stop fighting if we flew in billions and handed it out.
Johnny 2bad, you've done well to extrapolate to the hourly cost. Let's do another analysis. Fairly well paid workers in our country may earn $2 million in a lifetime. Divide that into a trillion.
Is there enough apathy in the world to squander 500,000 lifetime earnings in Iraq in addition to 40,000 dead and wounded in addition to the casualties of the shadow armies and the myriads of mercenaries that we employ there to do what was once the work of the military. And of course, we do not give any consideration at all to the hundreds of thousands of Iraquis that we have destroyed deliberately or indirectly. This war is not only a crime against humanity, it is a war against reason and sanity as well! The insatiable oil companies would spend every American Government dollar and the lives of every American citizen and whatever else it takes to get that once free oil that is so easily extracted from the sands of Iraq. It is time to make them pay for this war, and their lucre is not deep enough to do it! It is time for the pigs that ate America to return to us their bad investment!
Gosh, you know it might not have been wise to elect a stupid guy president and a legendary bad guy co-president.
Maybe Americans will get it right next time...Nah, they'll elect Thompson president, he's already a celebrity.
Buy shiny stuff, worship celebrity, leave the driving to us.
No worries for the Republicans, the Democrats will be called fiscally irresponsible and big government, big spenders of the tax payers money for trying to spend 100th of the the money spent in Iraq for the benefit of the American people. Some sort of social program that might really help. The giant talking heads will be set loose and saying the focus group tested lines about this is the kind of spending that has gotten us in the situation that we are in now. The press and the average American will buy it hook line and sinker.
►Shiva H Vishnu◄ @ 2:
Give them a paperclip, and put in their hand. Then tell them that one billion paperclips weigh approximately 1,000 metric tons.
No it isn't cheap, but it is a wonderful profitable business for Dick Cheney to be in. Americans will be paying him and his family for the next 100 years.
Some democrats are joining with republicans to keep troops in Iraq FOREVER, and calling it a "change in direction".
War,.. huh....what is it good for???? War profits, of course.
This is no longer the peoples government, but Cheney's Imperial Government. It isn't enough that he has everything. Everyone else must have nothing.
Bush's, Cheney's and Lieberman's kids aren't part of the casualty list. Had there been any danger of that we would not be over there now. It's other people's lives and the lives of someone else's kids. The don't give a shit so long as Halliburton and the war profiteering defense contrators and big oil can continue to make windfalls on the broken bodies and lives of other innocent people.
...and on the backs of the American taxpayer.
It's not as if there's anything better that money could be used to do...
I agree with a previous poster who said the average person would shrug off a $12,000,000,000 figure, but not with the idea that it is because Americans are dumb. We have been jaded by having to accept that morally bankrupt leadership is the norm. Before Bush, who knew you could be born into wealth and privilege and still achieve full-fledged trailer trash status?
How many hospitals could be built with this this huge amount of money? How many schools and libraries could have been financed with this amount of cash? As Noah Shachtman and Steve Benen point out, this is another example of the stupidity of war. Perhaps if those who are so quick to advocate war were to have actually fought in a war, then just perhaps they might not have been so eager to drag this country and its citizens into an event which strips people of their humanity as well as their common sense.
well what did you expect? its not easy being israels real army!! we must defend the zionest government if it takes every last soldier we have, oh yeah and the corporations that own america too, say arent they the same thing?
Blue Buddha @ 11:
Then they'll say, "Metric? What are you? French?" Then they'll call homeland security and report you.
By YAHYA BARZANJI, Associated Press Writer
7 minutes ago
TUZ KHORMATO, Iraq - Suicide bombings killed nearly 50 people and wounded dozens in two Shiite villages to the north, including a large truck bombing Saturday that ripped through an outdoor market and buried victims in rubble, officials said.
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070707/ap_on_re_mi_ea/iraq_070629184860;_yl...
Uh ya, we sure is worried about all that cash. As the Daily Show states, what a cluster@#$ck
Keep in mind that these costs are structured as debts that are kept off the official Fed. gov't balance sheet until such time as the Fed. gov't can work them off with 'paired gains' using various U.S. bond trading schemes, etc. this works as long as foreign creditors keep playing along and keep buying U.S. treasury bonds - as they have been doing during these recent years of lower interest rates - but no longer. Now that the long term trend for rates around the world is up, the cost of financing America's off-balance sheet debts becomes too much for these foreign creditors to bear so they pull back from buying any more U.S. bonds... Forcing the U.S. gov't itself to make up the difference by putting these off-balance sheet (iraq's 1 trillion dollar cost for example) costs back onto America's balance sheet in the form of a huge, one-time (hopefully) U.S. dollar devaluation... dropping the purchasing power of all Americans cash sharply lower, i.e., gas and other commodities double in price rather quickly.
say todays the 7th day of the 7th month and the 7th year of 2000, wouldnt it make a great day for another attack on something here in america by our government again? sure why not its an easy number to remember,
Well the military industrial complex is happy.
What is the average annual cost of providing healthcare? Divide that into the cost and see what could be done. But then again, that wouldn't keep them from following us home.
As William Proxmire once remarked, "A billion here, a billion there, pretty soon you're talking SERIOUS money." Meanwhile the Chinese can spend the interest on the loans that America owes them building their military.
So much for the world's only superpower.
Wrecking Iraq: One Million Dead, 2 Million Wounded, 3 Million Displaced
Collateral Genocide By MIKE FERNER
Two elements are necessary to commit the crime of genocide:
1) the mental element, meaning intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, and
2) the physical element, which includes any of the following: killing or causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; deliberately inflicting conditions of life calculated to bring about the group's physical destruction in whole or in part; imposing measures intended to prevent births; or forcibly transferring children to another group.
Considering that such clear language comes from a UN treaty which is legally binding on our country, things could start getting a little worrisome -- especially when you realize that since our government declared economic and military warfare on Iraq we've killed well over one million people, fast approaching two.
This summer will be one year since researchers from Johns Hopkins University collected data for a study which concluded 655,000 additional deaths were caused by the military war, and things have only gotten worse since then. Then consider that the economic war killed an additional 500,000 Iraqi kids under the age of five during only the first seven years of sanctions which were in force for a dozen years, according to a 1999 U.N. report.
Based on the Johns Hopkins estimate of Iraqis killed in the war, one could conservatively estimate that another 2.6 million people have been wounded. The U.N. estimates that between 1.5 million and 2 million Iraqis are now "internally displaced" by the fighting and roughly the same number have fled their country, including disproportionate numbers of doctors and other professionals.
ya know...
some day in the future people are gonna wonder what really drove the US to war with Iraq...
and some lawyer is gonna say. "the law."
come again? "the law of corporations is to maximize profits and deliver dividend cheques. the wars were necessary to many of the largest corporations to provide the right stimulation to provide those profit-taking structures."
and how is this right? it isn't. but it's the law.
Taking on more debt moves the Federal Govt. closer to the Repug goal of bankrupting OUR Government and selling off it assets to their friends and associates.
the sonner this guy and his cronies are impeached the sooner this war comes to an end and the spending takes a drastic dip. he needs to be removed before the entire country is left in ruin. what part of that is so difficult to understand????
Radically Moderate @ 28:
Rep. Jim Cooper: Bush is Hiding the True National Debt. It's Worse than You've Heard. Much Worse.
Submitted by BuzzFlash on Thu, 09/07/2006 - 5:15am. Alerts
Though the Bush Administration's official budget lists the national debt and deficit as being incredibly high, they are actually far worse than reported, according to Rep. Jim Cooper (D-TN). But don’t just take his word for it, even if Cooper is a Rhodes Scholar and Harvard Law graduate. The following figures appear in the official U.S. Financial Report, released by the Treasury Department:
* The true national debt is $49 trillion, not the $8.3 trillion Bush reported
o That's $156,000 for every citizen, or $375,000 for every working American
o This figure has more than doubled in the past five years
o We paid $327 billion last year on interest alone
* The true 2005 deficit was $760 billion, not the $318.5 billion Bush reported
o This is 6.2% of the GDP, not 2.6%
* It's all getting worse
What accounts for the huge discrepancy? Unlike businesses, the government uses "cash" instead of "accrual" accounting. This means that the government does not report future spending promises like Medicare and Social Security, or even future spending guarantees like veterans' benefits and federal employee pensions.
"Cash accounting tells you what's in your bank account. Accrual accounting tells you what's in your bank account and what's on your credit card statement," Cooper told BuzzFlash in an interview. "Whether you're promising to buy a road or something at Target, you need to know what you promised to buy. That should be a binding obligation of the government. We've made a world of promises to folks that we need to keep."
But wait, there's more! The U.S. Financial Report does not mention that if Medicare and Social Security are factored into the equation (which the Treasury Department did not), the true deficit was actually a whopping $3.3 trillion last year, over ten times more than Bush claims. And when Social Security projections are adjusted to reflect current life expectancies instead of the old 75-year mark, Cooper said the true national debt is "probably closer to $65 trillion."
Worried that a new Democratic majority in the House would be blamed for the higher numbers in the future, Cooper has taken it upon himself to make it clear that the problem has already been created by Bush's failed economic policies. "This has to be announced on their watch, using their voice," he said. "There's a great urgency about this: we only have two months left to educate all Americans about how the Bush deficits are literally destroying America's credit." [more]
ron @ 29:
look for anthrax in the offices of the leaders of the impeachment movement.
US debt could trigger dollar collapse, UN warns
Submitted by Desha Priya on Thu, 2007-05-31 16:47.
The United States dollar is facing imminent collapse in the face of an unsustainable debt, the United Nations warned today.
United States debt, which had now deepened to well over $3 trillion, might turn out to be unsustainable in the rest of 2007 or next, putting further downward pressure on the United States dollar, Rob Vos, the Director of the Development Policy and Analysis Division of the Department of Economic and Social Affairs (DESA), told correspondents at a Headquarters press conference.
He pointed out that since its peak in 2002, the dollar had depreciated vis-à-vis the major currencies by some 35 per cent and by 25 per cent against a broader range of other currencies.
Vos made these comments at the launch of the 2007 World Economic Situation and Prospects report midyear update.
With that increased debt the risk of a sharp depreciation of the dollar continued, he warned. If countries willing to invest in United States dollar assets expected further depreciation, they might be less willing to hold dollar assets, triggering a much sharper fall in the United States dollar. The risk of disorderly adjustment and the steep fall of the dollar existed. The policy challenge was how to prevent a hard landing of the United States dollar and forge a benign adjustment of the global imbalance.
Radically Moderate @ 28:
small enough to drown in a bathtub
“surging” ain’t cheap...but it is profitable.
$144 billion a year would buy a lot of beer. It would also buy a lot of other things. This country would sooner spend it on beer than universal health care, schools, student loans or grants, mass transit, global warming correction or anything else that is deemed "socialism" by the right. When it comes to war and dismemberment this country spares no expense.
"The insatiable oil companies would spend every American Government dollar and the lives of every American citizen and whatever else it takes to get that once free oil that is so easily extracted from the sands of Iraq."
Well, let's name some names. Here are the primary beneficiaries of the blood of Pat Tillman and all the other heroic marines and military people who have paid the ultimate price in Iraq. Here are the names of the people who make the most money when we gas, burn, and "pacify" places like Fallujah.
They must feel REALLY GREAT and have TOTALLY CLEAN CONSCIENCES know that they are financially secure no matter how many Americans pay them directly in blood.
You want bad guys? - these are them.
CEOs
Exxon - Lee Raymond
Texaco - Peter I. Bijur
Shell Oil - Steve Miller
BP - John Browne
These are gods to whom George W Bush sacrifices human beings on his altar of delusion.
Write them and let them know you know that the blood of 3500 American soldiers and 500,000 Iraqis (80% of whom are civilians) are their responsibility.
When will we wake up and stop using the WH rhetoric. This is not a surge. It it re-enforcement. You don't need re-enforcements for a war your claiming to win. "Surge" has a positive conotation that everyone has seemed to latch on to instead of evaluating reality. I would really like to see the democratic party stop responding to republican talking points and start creating their own. Isn't that what a majority party does?
My point has always been THE TRUE COST OF A GALLON OF GAS. I mean we say we're paying like $3.00 a gallon now, but that's just not true when you look at the in-direct costs. The amount of military engagements we must endure to protect our vital interests around this natural resource inlcuding the casualties and financial costs probably raises the cost to well over $100.00 per gallon.
We ALWAYS hear how the big business say it's TOO expensive to make thing energy efficient or change to a alternate fuel source. I always believed it was a short-term investment for LONG-TERM gains. They figure they get around most taxes anyway, and they're chickenhawks who don't have loved one fighting in these military engagements, so those costs never reach their books so they don't care.
It's a shame if you ask me....
If there is problems, the best way to solve it is to find the source and begin fixing it there. We all know the source of the problems is the Bush Administration. The People of our country know it, The Senate knows it, and last and sadly least, Congress knows it. The very body that is supposed to be Our first voice in the government. Yet the only ones who want anything done about it but are being ignored are, The People. The VERY entity that our government is supposed to be built around. Are country has been hemorrhaging blood and treasure at alarming rates for over the last six years from a terrible and insidious cancer known as the Bush Administration. If you have a cancer and it can't be killed, you remove it it from the body.
This bill is going to have to paid by all of us and the way we will pay is through higher taxes. I only hope when the republicans are finally herded into a political corner from which they can do no more harm that the Democrats stick it down the throats of the corporate fascists who have profited from the last 13 years of GOP rule. I know its asking too much for these wimps to stand up straight and snarl they should:"You complain about the taxes? Why the hell weren't you complaining when your guys were running up the bill? Now you're going to pay for the abuses of power -- fiscal and political -- that you've funded since Newt Gingrich mouthed his fiction about a "contract with America" -- you know, the one that has turned out to be a "contract ON America"?
I say tax the bastards until they have to get in line with the rest of us and sweat over monthly bill payments and how they're going to educate their kids and take care of their health needs. Tax them and or jail them. The CEO's and their second, third, down to the fifth in command -- all of the Bush/Cheney millionaires -- including Bush and Cheney -- who have gotten fat, fatter, fattest off of the giveaways the Bushies have sponsored and legislated.
Maybe that way we can get our country back.
BaScOmBe @ 31:
Or bombs from conservative right wing terrorists like Tim McVeigh and Eric Rudolph.
Saddam was a ruthless despost who murdered countless innocents and paid the ultimate price for it. Cheney commits the same crimes, as well as war crimes and as a result more innocents have died then under Saddam's reign yet Cheney doesn't even get impeached let alone have to worry about paying the ultimate price for his killing spree. Such is the benefit of being an unelected despot of the world's only superpower. Who's gonna stop him? The Democrats?
Bend over America.
While George and his Mafia gang are giving it to you up the ass, you can kiss your money goodbye.
Your presidents arrogance has put your imperialistic, consumer economy at risk.
I'll invest my dough in Canada.
NChomsky @ 7:
This is actually not a bad idea - to have been considered at the beginning of the war. The cost of a Leveraged Buy Out of Iraq would probably have been less than the 2 trillion u.s. will ultimately spend... without any assurances the u.s. will have access to the oil. plus, the oil would have continued flowing.. and the oil fields there would have started to be developed... so the price would not have spiked as it has these past two years (with $100 oil now in sight). contrast u.s. in iraq to way China has been acquiring oil in africa - spending lots of the money (we send them every month with our purchases at wal-mart) - And what is really interesting is that there is evidence that the insurgents in Iraq, it's been reported, are using weapons that come from China... HAHAHA wouldn't it be incredible if the u.s. faces off with china in iraq who is also interested in oil reserves and who has the weapon of dumping close to 1 trillion in u.s. gov't bonds (they hold in reserve) to crash the u.s. bond market any time they wish...
Just in from MSNBC:
"TUZ KHORMATO, Iraq - A suicide bomber detonated a truck full of explosives in the market of a Shiite farm town on Saturday, killing more than 100 people and levelling nearby mud-brick buildings, police officials said.
Separately, eight American troops and a British soldier were killed in fighting over two days."
Next time you hear the Three Stooges of Human Garbage - Graham, Lieberman, and McCain - tell you about the remarkable progress the "surge" is making, chalk up another piece of evidence for their impending war crimes trials
Re: Cost of Iraq War -
Before the shooting started, Deputy Defense Secretary Wolfowitz told the House Budget Committee that various scenarios would result in a costs which would “range from $10 billion to $100 billion".
This has got to stand as one of the most blunderous, inept as well as decietful calculations of modern times. He will forever be the fool in the eyes of history.
A trillion dollars ain't what it used to be.
What if.....1/2 that money had been placed buffering up the police and civilian anti-subversive efforts rather than being put into the military, would it had made a difference? But then again, maybe not. Homeland Security is financing security cameras for city parks and waterfronts in Idaho.
A billion dollars a month for any war would be a travesty.
A billion dollars a month for THIS war is in itself a war crime.
Put aside the staggering dollar amounts: We're getting less security despite the expenses, and no better security for the oil. This is making things worse. What a waste of money. Too much money is being spent on not enough troops and nothing to show for it. This is reckless.
Still...the cost comes nowhere near projected windfalls for US Petrocoms if the Oil Law makes it round to Home and a few other niceities fall into place. (We are talking about trillions of projected USD denominated profits at oil prices close to current levels.)
The surge is about putting a surge of pressure on the Iraqis to bring this piece of legislation home to daddy. Unfortunately the Iraqis understand this and the surge together with the revved up oil law machinations are just ratcheting up the violence and making sure things will only get worse.
Anyways, the costs are shouldered by the US taxpayers and the limbs and lives of their sons and daughters. Potential windfalls will be kept by the petrocoms (they pay next to zero tax in the U.S. - in fact they get sizable tax financed kickbacks)
Netto, this expedition is still a great deal. It's just that the investors won't see the dividends. But that's not new in this kind of game, is it? That's the macro-economics I've learned to love.
Like all the other stats released by this administration the number of US deaths and casualties far exceed what has been reported according to documents obtained by Veterans for Common Sense through the Freedom of Information Act. (FOIA).
Although the piece did not separate the total number of those dead from the wounded it follows the pattern of this administration's penchant for cooking the books.
This is an insult to every soldier lost in this bloody and violent occupation. It does not take a rocket scientist to figure out hiding the caskets arriving at Dover -- now in the dead of night (pun intended) -- forbidding photographs and barring reporters from the area are not done out of respect for the families; it is to hide the numbers of caskets carrying the remains of a wife or husband, father or mother, son or daughter, sister or brother, friend or a beloved to someone, somewhere.
see here for full article:
http://www.politicalaffairs.net/article/articleview/
5530/1/32/
Americans will vote for who they're told to vote for once the corporations have made their minds up who they're happy with.
Login or Register to post comments.