Go Home

Open Thread

The English language befriends the grand American expression … it is brawny enough and limber and full enough … on the tough stock of a race who through all change of circumstance was never without the idea of political liberty, which is the animus of all liberty, it has attracted the terms of daintier and gayer and subtler and more elegant tongues. It is the powerful language of resistance … it is the dialect of common sense. It is the speech of the proud and melancholy races and of all who aspire. It is the chosen tongue to express growth faith self-esteem freedom justice equality friendliness amplitude prudence decision and courage. It is the medium that shall well nigh express the inexpressible.

Walt Whitman - Leaves of Grass

In related news...Drifty channels Whitman.

About Bluegal aka Fran
Bluegal aka Fran's picture
Executive Producer of The Professional Left Podcast. On staff at Crooks and Liars since 2007. Master's degree from Harvard. Happy wife of Driftglass. Mother of three geniuses. Obsessive knitter. Blogs at http://bgalrstate.blogspot.com. .
Share This Post

Link To This Post


50 Comments
paranoia's picture

I did my tax return and did it by electronic with my bank account, and the IRS said I made a mistake and that I owe them $600 dollars. So they sent me a letter and we work out a payment plan and they sent me a payment plan booklet. I just sent them $52 for the month, and they proceed to go to my bank and withdrawal another $40. No Letters or consent, or any indication that they would be doing this. I contact the bank to find out how this happen. The banks have said that they have been doing this to everyone, and take money without any warning. The bank have nothing to do with any of the proceeding of this or any knowledge that they would do this. That from the IRS they can go in and do whatever they want into the banking system.

The bank have said they took one guy $600 dollar outright with no warning, and that they have been seeing a lot of this on a daily basis. So anyone owing the IRS is in for a surprise. Just a warning for those that are protesting the govt.

paranoia's picture

No to say I was protesting, as I am truly an idiot when doing my taxes.

L.A. Confidential's picture

Whitman was light years ahead of his time.

Tequila's picture

The White House doesn't like a pro-Clinton, anti-Bush ad, because it's true.

azprogress's picture

Today on Hardball with Chris Matthews, Iraq war hawk and former soldier Mark Finelli admits that Bush's invasion of Iraq was a deliberate act of imperialism to provide a location in order to locate US soldiers in the region justified by a Saudi threat to kick out America's 20,000 troops.

He cited the book "America's Secret War" as for more reading on the subject.

Here's the video...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_MS0go6M8Go

You can Digg it here:
http://digg.com/politics/War_hawk_admits_Iraq_was_about_imperialism_not_WMD

Gekke's picture

what an asshat, I guess english was the only language he spoke fluently.

nonny mouse's picture

W@ wd the l8 gr8 Wlt Wtmn thnka how we use Englsh 2day?

kablooie's picture

Camerado, this is no book,
Who touches this touches a man,
(Is it night? are we here together alone?)
It is I you hold and who holds you,
I spring from the pages into your arms--decease calls me forth.

O how your fingers drowse me,
Your breath falls around me like dew, your pulse lulls the tympans
of my ears,
I feel immerged from head to foot,
Delicious, enough.

-- excerpted from Walt Whitman's poem "So Long"

anonymous's picture

Gekke @ 6:

what an asshat, I guess english was the only language he spoke fluently.

I take his statement as a sort of excuse for the prosaic and robust nature of his own poetry. I do like this part;

"—when the swarms of cringers, suckers, doughfaces, lice of politics, planners of sly involutions for their own preferment to city offices or state legislatures or the judiciary or congress or the presidency, obtain a response of love and natural deference from the people whether they get the offices or no … when it is better to be a bound booby and rogue in office at a high salary than the poorest free mechanic or farmer with his hat unmoved from his head and firm eyes and a candid and generous heart … and when servility by town or state or the federal government or any oppression on a large scale or small scale can be tried on without its own punishment following duly after in exact proportion against the smallest chance of escape … or rather when all life and all the souls of men and women are discharged from any part of the earth—then only shall the instinct of liberty be discharged from that part of the earth."

anonymous's picture

azprogress @ 5:

Today on Hardball with Chris Matthews, Iraq war hawk and former soldier Mark Finelli admits that Bush's invasion of Iraq was a deliberate act of imperialism to provide a location in order to locate US soldiers in the region justified by a Saudi threat to kick out America's 20,000 troops.

He cited the book "America's Secret War" as for more reading on the subject.

Here's the video...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_MS0go6M8Go

You can Digg it here:
http://digg.com/politics/War_hawk_admits_Iraq_was_about_imperialism_not_WMD

Ah, another piece of puzzle. With so many nefarious reasons to invade, how could these bastards have held themselves back?

anonymous's picture

Oh, holy s*&t...

We're going to declare Iran's Revolutionary Guard a terrorist organization...
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/15/world/middleeast/15diplo.html?ref=world

Udon Nomee's picture

I thought I'd take advantage of the 'Open Thread' to pass on this link to an AP report on the kidnapping in eastern Baghdad of an Iraqi Deputy Oil Minister, during a raid on the State Oil Marketing Organization complex.

Mmmmm.... Smell that!?! Smells like the 'surge' in bloom...

http://tinyurl.com/2pg96s

Udon Nomee's picture

Re: my above post, the last line of the article is priceless!

"I think that the circumstances require us to do our best to bring the country out of this difficult situation," Iraq's Sunni Vice President Tariq Hashemi said.

CappuccettoRossso's picture

paranoia @ 1:

I did my tax return and did it by electronic with my bank account, and the IRS said I made a mistake and that I owe them $600 dollars. So they sent me a letter and we work out a payment plan and they sent me a payment plan booklet. I just sent them $52 for the month, and they proceed to go to my bank and withdrawal another $40. No Letters or consent, or any indication that they would be doing this. I contact the bank to find out how this happen. The banks have said that they have been doing this to everyone, and take money without any warning. The bank have nothing to do with any of the proceeding of this or any knowledge that they would do this. That from the IRS they can go in and do whatever they want into the banking system.

The bank have said they took one guy $600 dollar outright with no warning, and that they have been seeing a lot of this on a daily basis. So anyone owing the IRS is in for a surprise. Just a warning for those that are protesting the govt.

NEVER EVER do anything electronically with the govt, specifically IRS: PAPER ONLY !! File/fill the forms manually, the old fashioned way. If refund due, do not cash the IRS check through your regular bank account. Use any other, or, if in the big city go to a check cashing place as all the Mexicans do, they will cash for a small fee. DHS is monitoring our bank accounts - we don't need IRS breething down our necks about everyting. By filing electronically, you get yourself 'missionary' in their data base, without their lifting a finger to screw you.

Rasputin's picture

Since we're doing American Authors on the thread and the quotes of Thomas Paine had someone who appeared to be Will Rogers... thought I'd throw some of him into the mix!

Ancient Rome declined because it had a Senate; now what's going to happen to us with both a Senate and a House?
--Will Rogers

Be thankful we're not getting all the government we're paying for.
--Will Rogers

I belong to no organized party. I am a Democrat.
--Will Rogers

On account of being a democracy and run by the people, we are the only nation in the world that has to keep a government four years, no matter what it does.
--Will Rogers
(A personal Favorite)

There ought to be one day-- just one-- when there is open season on senators.
--Will Rogers

The income tax has made more liars out of the American people than golf has.
--Will Rogers,

I don't make jokes. I just watch the government and report the facts.
--Will Rogers,

Thorson Welles's picture

Best. Headline. Ever.

Bush's Brain Quits

Unfortunately it's different online but my local broadsheet had a large photo of Bush and Rove over a very large type headline, "Bush's Brain Quits". It's priceless with the photo which can be seen below.

http://www.thechronicleherald.ca/World/853193.html

That one is going up on my fridge!

le pire's picture

I find this "my language is the best to express everything and encompasses all senitments" statement to be kind of shallow. Especially considering that when I read translations of whitman in french it really hit home.

ALL language is interesting, nuanced and complex. Not one moreso than another.

etienne

EZ's picture

This is kind of long to read but don't miss the message:

Have Christians Already Accepted The Mark Of The Beast?
By Chuck Baldwin
August 14, 2007

This column is archived at
http://www.chuckbaldwinlive.com/c2007/cbarchive_20070814.html

[Deleted. The link will suffice]

> Have Christians Already Accepted The Mark Of The Beast?

Hell, they already accept the cross (the instrument of Jesus' death) as something to worship. Of course they accept the mark of the beast as well.

enigma4ever's picture

You know this summer I have seen people FINALLY peeling these off their cars ( middle america) ...I had three on this street, and all are gone now....( three W stickers)

Dan's picture

what would Whitman say about the language of today?

I bet he would have been enthusiatic that it remains as plastic and accomodating as ever... English has always been the bog's breakfast. Bits and pieces of whatever culture was on the accendency and a general amalgam of terminology and newly coined expressions. How many different influences can we see in any bit of writing? Germanic, Scandinavian, the Romance languages, Latin, Greek, on and on.... and as a poet Whitman would be willing to wrestle with all those new materials to express his feeling and impressions.

at least, I hope so... maybe he'd be a grumpy ol' bastard who'd just be barking at us "git off my isogloss!!!"

enigma, they've been pretty much gone from here in so-called Bush country (Houston, Texas) for a couple of years now. Every now and then I see a Bush/Cheney sticker or a W sticker, maybe once every two weeks. If their window is open, I open mine and yell "TRAITOR" at the driver.

Orangutan's picture

In honor of Rasputin and Will Rogers...

“Freedom is about authority. Freedom is about the willingness of every single human being to cede to lawful authority a great deal of discretion about what you do. ”
- Rudy Giuliani.

“First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they attack you, then you win.”
- Mahatma Gandhi

"Without debate, without criticism, no Administration and no country can
succeed-and no republic can survive. That is why the Athenian law-maker Solon decreed it a crime for any citizen to shrink from controversy." - JFK - April 27, 1961

"They say that patriotism is the last refuge to which a scoundrel clings" ~ sweetheart like you ~ bob dylan.

"The Truth is an offense, but not a sin" ~ bob marley

Udon Nomee's picture

Have Christians Already Accepted The Mark Of The Beast?

Actually, that'd be the 'Euro' of the beast... (a little 'currency exchange' humor, there!)

yenehC hcaepmI's picture

Where the 2008 Presidential Candidates stand in an easy to compare chart...

http://www.2decide.com/table.htm

Notice who flip flop on the Iraq war and who opposed it all along.

Kucinich should be getting way more support from Democrats than he's been getting.

Ron Paul should be getting way more support from Republicans than he's been getting.

I can't believe Billary with the media's help has got everyone fooled once again.

yenehC hcaepmI's picture

Dennis Kucinich does an excellent job in this interview with George Stephasnuffalupugus

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnKsuzoDalI

I'd love to see this posted on C&L later today and read the comments because he is just so right on so many levels in this interview.

Nerrin's picture

"The problem with defending the purity of the English language is that English is about as pure as a cribhouse whore. We don't just borrow words; on occasion, English has pursued other languages down alleyways to beat them unconscious and rifle their pockets for new vocabulary."
-James D. Nicoll

English is a delightful language for its flexibility and tendency to absorb whatever it feels like from any other language. I confess to never being a very good student of non-English languages, but I look back and realize that English tended to be my best subject in general, not just to the negligence of my Spanish classes. It's a tool I've learned and am still learning as a means to express myself, and I'd rather perfect my proficiency with it than dabble in everything else. I love the language and what it lets me do, yet I am not blinded by it; I'll gladly honor and wish good fortune to anyone who finds their perfect expression in another language or art. We're in all this together, after all.

Curtilingus's picture

I like Whitman and his writings, but I do not share the same respect for my native tongue.

Did you know that English is also known as the Liar's Language? You have to speak another language to fully understand why, but one aspect is how specifics are eliminated out of words, such as gender and tense, where as with many foreign languages, the specifics are conjugated into the word and cannot be removed or casually omitted by the liar.

Hardly the dialect of common sense!

nonny mouse's picture

From Mark Twain's 'A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court':

I was gradually coming to have a mysterious and shuddery reverence for this girl; nowadays whenever she pulled out from the station and got her train fairly started on one of those horizonless transcontinental sentences of hers, it was borne in upon me that I was standing in the awful presence of the Mother of the German Language. I was so impressed with this, that sometimes when she began to empty one of these sentences on me I unconsciously took the very attitude of reverence, and stood uncovered; and if words had been water, I had been drowned, sure. She had exactly the German way; whatever was in her mind to be delivered, whether a mere remark, or a sermon, or a cyclopedia, or the history of a war, she would get it into a single sentence or die. Whenever the literary German dives into a sentence, that is the last you are going to see of him till he emerges on the other side of his Atlantic with his verb in his mouth.

apishapa's picture

Yesterday, when I heard that Karl Rove was leaving, my very first thought was that Cheney was behind it, becaue Rove was basically the only obstacle between Cheney and an attack n Iran. This morning the first thing I hear on Washington Journal is that Bush is declaring the Iranian National Guard a terrorist organization. This is the first time a National Army has gotten that designation. I believe an invasion of Iran is next on the Agenda.

Every other reason given for Rove's departure makes no sense. He is not afraid of any Congressional subpeona. He won't show up and Congress will just sit there and gripe about it. THe only person with enough power to remove Rove is Cheney, and the only person who had a chance in stopping Cheney was Karl. Karl is a bad, bad man, but Cheney is an evil, murderous lunatic. Rice will either get with Cheney's program or she will "move on down the road", too.

Spud's picture

le pire @ 18:

I find this "my language is the best to express everything and encompasses all senitments" statement to be kind of shallow. Especially considering that when I read translations of whitman in french it really hit home.

ALL language is interesting, nuanced and complex. Not one moreso than another.

etienne

He was shallow. That's what he's struggling against and arguing for. He was a poet who was using the infant language of American English and he sought to stretch it out. What he's doing with the poem is pulling the language over the continent that Americans went into dumbly, with nothing but brut force.
To say Whitman was shallow or that French best expresses Whitman's ideas is a hoot.

pissed off patricia's picture

apishapa, I'm afraid you're right. That is the only thing that makes sense. Cheney is evil and we know Cheney wants to blow up Iran. Probably even Rove knew this was an awful idea and his job was to look after bush and the republican party. Bombing Iran will be the last straw for the party and bush. This is getting uglier by the hour.

hello's picture

"I'm the commander — see, I don't need to explain — I do not need to explain why I say things. That's the interesting thing about being president." GW

battle_axe's picture

Bush Administration to 'move' on Iran's Revolutionary Guard, deems Group "Global Terrorist"

The United States has decided to designate Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps, the country's 125,000-strong elite military branch, as a "specially designated global terrorist," according to U.S. officials, a move that allows Washington to target the group's business operations and finances.

The Bush administration has chosen to move against the Revolutionary Guard Corps because of what U.S. officials have described as its growing involvement in Iraq and Afghanistan as well as its support for extremists throughout the Middle East, the sources said. The decision follows congressional pressure on the administration to toughen its stance against Tehran, as well as U.S. frustration with the ineffectiveness of U.N. resolutions against Iran's nuclear program, officials said.

The designation of the Revolutionary Guard will be made under Executive Order 13224, which President Bush signed two weeks after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks to obstruct terrorist funding. It authorizes the United States to identify individuals, businesses, charities and extremist groups engaged in terrorist activities. The Revolutionary Guard would be the first national military branch included on the list, U.S. officials said -- a highly unusual move because it is part of a government, rather than a typical non-state terrorist organization.

..continues @ link...

ujk's picture

Asheville Flag arrest late nite update

Mr. XXXX's picture

http://www.howardstern.com/rundown.hs?month=August&day=14&year=2007&x=54...

The Howard Stern Show Tuesday, August 14, 2007

ANCHOR OR CHIMNEY?
Howard started off the show by saying he was sitting in front of the CNN building in his limo, and saw Lou Dobbs talking with a friend. Lou was smoking a cigarette, and then immediately smoked another, and then three more. The whole time, Lou was having an animated conversation with his friend and getting excited when people recognized him. Robin said that no one ever talks about Lou's crazy cigarette addiction, which is weird to her, because she feels that it's a big personality flaw. Howard agreed, saying it was really weird.

actor212's picture
PollM's picture

Could the US position of placing Irans' armed forces on US State Departments' terror list be getting us closer to a War with Iran? http://www.youpolls.com/details.asp?pid=328

Swashbuckler's picture
mystic's picture

"Where the 2008 Presidential Candidates stand in an easy to compare chart…
http://www.2decide.com/table.htm
yenehC hcaepmI "

The link has been censored!!! They don't want us to know and be an informed electorate? If so, that spells trouble already. I can just imagine what is to come in the future. They want us to be discouraged and not vote?

JohnnyThief's picture

paranoia @ 1:

I did my tax return and did it by electronic with my bank account, and the IRS said I made a mistake and that I owe them $600 dollars. So they sent me a letter and we work out a payment plan and they sent me a payment plan booklet. I just sent them $52 for the month, and they proceed to go to my bank and withdrawal another $40. No Letters or consent, or any indication that they would be doing this. I contact the bank to find out how this happen. The banks have said that they have been doing this to everyone, and take money without any warning. The bank have nothing to do with any of the proceeding of this or any knowledge that they would do this. That from the IRS they can go in and do whatever they want into the banking system.

The bank have said they took one guy $600 dollar outright with no warning, and that they have been seeing a lot of this on a daily basis. So anyone owing the IRS is in for a surprise. Just a warning for those that are protesting the govt.

I'm not suprised. I paid an assload of taxes, & now I'm gettig bills that they were never paid, even though I have the cashed check.

I'd love to see a MM styled investigation of the IRS,...

tyree's picture

yenehC hcaepmI @ 28:

Dennis Kucinich does an excellent job in this interview with George Stephasnuffalupugus

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnKsuzoDalI

I'd love to see this posted on C&L later today and read the comments because he is just so right on so many levels in this interview.

its obviouse that the powers that be ,the corporations want the american people to vote for the next loosers for president hilley clinton or obamma, they think we are stupid and can pull another kerry on us, swift boatings an art with these faschist pigs , hillerys just republican light obammas not going anywhere hes black and just a one trick poney, who gave one good speach at the democratic national convention, dennis cucinich is the only candidate besides gravel thats talking turkey and isnt bought by the corporations ,want more george bush youll have that with hillery obamma!

tyree's picture

sorry kucinich 08!

Avedon's picture

"The problem with defending the purity of the English language is that English is about as pure as a cribhouse whore. We don't just borrow words; on occasion, English has pursued other languages down alleyways to beat them unconscious and rifle their pockets for new vocabulary."
--James D. Nicoll

mystic's picture

Chavez is now changing the Constitution so that he can eliminate his term limits, securing his dictatorship more firmly. While his support amongst the electorate is still strong because of promises to improve their lives, this remninds me of the early promises of Mugabe before he became the tyrant he is today. Rumblings here in the U.S.

ysbaddaden's picture

I've heard of people being Frenched and even Greeked, but what does it mean to be Englished

Spanked?

pluky's picture

To be "englished" is to be spun.

CappuccettoRossso's picture

Curtilingus @ 30:

I like Whitman and his writings, but I do not share the same respect for my native tongue.

Did you know that English is also known as the Liar's Language? You have to speak another language to fully understand why, but one aspect is how specifics are eliminated out of words, such as gender and tense, where as with many foreign languages, the specifics are conjugated into the word and cannot be removed or casually omitted by the liar.

Hardly the dialect of common sense!

English is a perfect language of business, economies, contracts, etc - very clear (conjugation not as crucial here, the worst lies are simply in small print, or as you say, just ommited, etc), however English is quite poor as langauge of emotions, feelings, and needs often several words what many other languages accomplish with one. Although we know Joseph and Joe, it does not indicate the age of Joeys. In other langauges (say Spanish, Italian, applicable to many other) if Jose is called Pepe, Peppito, Peppetino, etc - it mostly indicates a boy, child, a young Joe. Another example: a girl is just a girl, or boy is just a boy in English, without much saying in what age group could s/he be - one has to say 'a little girl/boy' to provide more age related info. In many languages (Russian and other Slavic ones, Italian ) there are very specific words (3-4 or more, each for different 'stage') that indicate the girl is much younger, a teenager, etc.. The same applies to many more. I am multilingual, fluent in several (alphabets as well), can 'operate' in ~ 10 langauges. It gets confusing sometimes (a great word in one language can be quite obnoxious in another !), one needs to practise to be current w/changing vocabulary. Am trying to get time and watch w/one eye the native daily news in 4 laguages from diff countries, while doing other stuff, occasionally in fifth .. Poetry of course gets more tricky - if one knows the original, very seldom the best translations are good and reflect the intent of the original. Knowledge of particular culture - living/immersed in it, history (as centuries, not the meager last 100 years !), being as familiar as possible w/native ALL is mandatory for some better understanding and translation, esp. poetry. The same applies for translation of English language (English-English, American-English, Oz/Kiwi-English, etc..) works/poetry into any other.

paranoia's picture

I would like to see the polls for what candidate that looks good for Democrats, and see how much play the media has in deciding for us who we want. Everywhere I go I hear Dennis name pop up and been consider 10times over any other choices.

Comments are closed on this entry