September 05, 2007 08:46 PM
Ohio Paper Portrays Iranians As Cockroaches Fleeing Sewer
Via After Downing Street:
Send polite comments about this Nazi-style cartoon depicting Iranians as roaches fleeing a sewer to: gsheller@dispatch.com, michael.ramirez@investors.com



First we need to get rid of the roaches in D.C.
step three: dehumanize
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genocide#Stages_of_genocide_and_efforts_to_...
I didn't even know that Dumbya and his posse stopped in Iran.
Wow! The Jews were portrayed as cochroaches by the German Nazi movement. They don't even change the insect for propaganda. Somebody has a copy of Mein Kampf by Adolf Hitler.
WTF....where do these people (and I use the term loosely) come from?
The fix is in. The brainwashing by the corporate controlled media has begun to ratchet upwards. God damned their souls to hell.
"We must kill the Tutsi cockroaches" - Hutu Power Radio.
Or... does anyone rememberanymore?
sonofabitch! That reminds me. I need to pick up a LAWN JOCKEY.
I don't get what they are trying to say other than to insult a nation. What am I missing?
The modern witch hunt is alive and well. Amazing how many still subscribe to branding and obliterating.
This cartoon was featured in the "right wing cartoon" post a couple of weeks ago on C&L. The same artist did one with roaches crawling out of Syria, I think.
Ah the Columbus Dog Patch. Of all the bad things about living in klumbus the Dog Patch ieditorial page is probably in the top 20. But doesn't that walking pool of dog vomit ramirez work for the LA Times and syndicated by the Tribune company?
Oh, whoops. Kaid seems to have answered my question while I was typing it.
Technically, cockroaches got TO water.
Meanwhile somewhere in hell Herr Goebbels smiles...
TYPO ... go TO water
On the positive side, if we attack Iran, then the invasion of Iraq will only be the second worst tactical error in U.S. History.
Whoever did this cartoon doesn't know how to draw a cockroach, I doubt he has actually seen one in his life. Nor an Iranian for that matter, it makes it so much easier to dehumanize them.
It is sick. Thanks for reminding us to be polite. It's hard after seeing this, but it is important.
Looks like Crawford, Tx.
Kald @ 7:
paranoia @ 4:
Yuppers. That's it, I'm going out to get a bottle of wine. I seem to have come out of the chocolate induced coma I ate myself into earliar.
What do you expect from Ramirez. His cartoons have been on the same comic level as the "1/2 Hour News Hour" for some time.
what year is this again!?
how do they let something like this print? disgusting.
How do I subscribe?
adam wykle @ 23:
1930s -- Germany.
Couldn't stand him when he drew this type of junk for the L.A. Times. I see he has gotten even more demented. Too much kool-aid for this sickie
i'd like a statement from the paper and from the artist. i'd like to know exactly what they are trying to say in this cartoon. maybe there is something we are missing.
Hrm. Does this mean that if we hit them with nukes, they won't be affected? The Iranian menace is more serious than I previously suspected.
http://www.rferl.org/featuresarticle/2007/02/36b123ce-693b-448e-bf7d-a54... Iran ..
Jeff @ 27:
You aint missing nothin Jeff. You obviously don't know what a sickie Ramirez is
Apparently Ramirez has forgotten how mexican-americans were once (and still are) referred to as cockroaches for breeding large families. But, then again, maybe he hasn't forgotten and he was looking for an opportunity to pass that on to some other ethnic group. Tag! Your it! Can't touch me cuz Ah gots the king's X.
I thought cartoons were supposed to be funny.
Blue Buddha @ 11:
I was about to say the same thing - something about this cartoon seems familiar. Extremely tacky, in poor taste, and downright pathetic, but familiar... I plan on showing this to my Media Analysis class tomorrow. Hopefully it will pop a few bubbles.
Looks more like the mass exodus from the Bush White House.
Goebbels and Fritz Hippler would be so proud!
What a disgusting cartoon.
mudshark @ 29:
You decide.
This image is the perfect defence for SINator Craig. He wasn't waving his hand under the toilet stall to solicit sex, he was just shooing those pesky terrorists down the drain of the airport lavatory pertecktin' Ahmurka from the brown hordes.
It's part of a plan to sell war on Iran to the american public via corporate media ... guess where it originates?
They [the source’s institution] have “instructions” (yes, that was the word used) from the Office of the Vice-President to roll out a campaign for war with Iran in the week after Labor Day; it will be coordinated with the American Enterprise Institute, the Wall Street Journal, the Weekly Standard, Commentary, Fox, and the usual suspects. It will be heavy sustained assault on the airwaves, designed to knock public sentiment into a position from which a war can be maintained. Evidently they don’t think they’ll ever get majority support for this—they want something like 35-40 percent support, which in their book is “plenty.”
Here's an article on the New Yorker about (with the above quote):
http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/georgepacker/2007/08/if-there-were...
.. and an article about the New Yorker post:
Cheney Orders Corporate Media to Sell Iran Attack
http://adereview.com/blog/?p=24
Could be a busy Autumn for the blogosphere if this does show up in the MSM! Heads up y'all - pay 'tention!!
Dear Columbus Ohio,
You know that we Iranian's have no sense of humor.
This can only fan the flames of terror and hatred.
A cock-a-roche can live through anything mind you
Just like U.S., more than 60% (maybe even more) of the Iran’s population doesn’t like it’s suppressive government. They can get rid of the extremists that are currently in power there, but why do that, when they can blow up Iran and then have Haliburton, etc., go there and charge the Iranians to build their country back up?"
Oh, yeah! That'll win hearts and minds...
Oh, wait! I get it!
Iranians are not human beings at all! They are cockroaches and we are allowed to step on them, shoot them or nuke them because we are sooo superior!
Foriegn policy run amock!
and next the war begins....
I don't get it. Are Iranians supposed to be cockroaches because they're selling/giving arms to further their interests in the region? If that's the case, did our giving Saddam Hussein weapons to use against the Iranians in the war he waged against them in the 80's make us (the U.S.) cockroaches, too?
Strawberry @ 21:
Mmmmmmmmm......Chocolate...
the question is will china produce enough hemp for all the public hangings for duely convicted warmongers in this country!
FABabe @ 43:
no were rats!
Uh, if I send a comment it will be anything BUT polite. The time to be polite has passed. The time to scream FUCK YOU into people's faces has arrived.
onama tin parden @ 39:
No kidding. Anyone see that old episode of Married with Children dedicated to the Cockroach?
sick
Yep, it must time to whip up some mass hysterical fear, loathing and hatred of another nation of people we know nothing about, so we can feel good about killing them for God and black Gold. As for nuclear weapons, why should we care if they make one in a year or ten years? We have thousands of them. The Israelis may have hundreds. A single Trident Submarine could turn Iran into radioactive glass, and the Iranians know it. They couldn't match us in the nuclear terror game of an arms race of a thousand years. Fearing Iran's "nuclear threat" is more ridiculous than an elephant fearing a mouse.
If your a Fascist and you know it clap your hands?
The next time a Ramirez cartoon is witty or insightful will be the first.
A little perspective here.
It's a cartoon.
Just like the cartoons the Iranians drew about the Holocaust last year after the Danish cartoon row.
OK, so it's a sucky cartoon, too.
Artie Dash Lange @ 52:
That is not really the point, is it?
We are once again being primmed to support yet another diasterous war (we currently have two in progress) and we can either sit here like fools and say and do nothing and let it happen or we can get pissed off and put a seop to it.
or a stop* if you prefer.
Ramirez is a flaming wing-nut. An excellent artist, but all his skills are in his hands, not in his heart.
One should remind such people as Ramirez and those who would think Iranians are cockroaches, that it has been said that when the world is devastated by nuclear war, only the cockroaches will survive.
Some one needs a time out!
Some one needs to stop hating the world!
sully18 @ 32:
Come on, it is funny...for all the wrong reasons.Cockroaches depicted as sugar ants,Iran as Iraq and, or New Orleans.An Ohio publication (there REALLY is something in the ground water there).
I'm laughing so hard that I'm crying....oh wait...
Par for the course from these hate-filled bastards, and utterly predictable. What's actually most disappointing about this is it's a reminder that Ohio may not have been stolen in 2004, and there may actually be enough knuckle-dragging Neandrathals there to have given BushCo their only real victory (& I've spent time in Ohio, know whereof I speak).
xoites defends Constitution @ 53:
The wingnuts are crazy, but they're not that stupid (I hope).
Iran has almost three times the population (and probably firepower) of Iraq.
And we don't even have the personpower.
The old-line patrician Republicans will not allow their sons and daughters to be drafted in order to fight a war with Iran.
Artie Dash Lange @ 59:
The plan, as i understand it from reading whatever i was able to come across in the past four years, is not to invade but to have an extensive bombing campaign. That seems to be the "safest" option. With this moron you never know.
Such thoughtful empty hate mongering on the Dispatch's part.
Exactly what have we turned Iraq into?
What a shameful display of cowardice.
chlorocardium,
We've turned it into exactly what the imperialist wants. A killing zone so that they may march over the Middle East in their quest for oil and domination. Al Quada is the least of our worries...Bush and the neocons are, or should readily be classified, as our enemy #1.
A few months back Herr Ramirez had a charming cartoon depicting a Marine with a giant knife sticking out of his back. The label on the knife: Congress. Dolchstoßlegende , anyone? I'm tellin' you these people know exactly what they're doing. They use as their historical antecedent, at least in media and propaganda, the most vile pieces of shit mankind has ever hocked up. They have no moral authority whatsoever to even tell the rest of our shoes are untied. Someone mentioned it earlier - an eternal "fuck you" screamed in their face is all these people deserve. Really.
Oh...*sigh*
Yes, let's just start talking about all us "knuckle-draggers" in Ohio. I knew someone would get to dissing the entire state over a few idiot publishers and their lackeys.
Maybe we need a snazzy editorial cartoon exposing all those knuckle-dragging Ohio hicks bringing down this country... in trees - yea, that's good! Maybe they can be flinging sh*t on all the fine upstanding, hardworking, patriotic folks below? Stupid Ape Buckeyes! Why do we put up with them?
Weeelll, maybe not. I heard *somewhere* it was wrong to generalize a group of people...
(PS the roach cartoon is reprehensible)
sulphurdunn @ 50:
I agree. I've often thought along those same lines.
Any sovereign state attacking the U.S. or U.S. allies with nukes is risking total annihilation within hours and they know it. No one is that crazy. Mutually Assured Destruction worked for 50 years, it will continue to work with Iran or North Korea.
Hell, even if 100 million crazed Iranian soldiers magically materialized on U.S. soil, we could still turn Iran into a glass desert at the push of a button just for spite.
The real threat is them giving a nuclear weapon or nuclear material to a terrorist group who wouldn't hesitate to use it.
Even so, if I was Iran, no matter how much I would want to hurt the U.S., I wouldn't think that would be in my interest. Nuclear material can be traced to country of origin and I would know that I'd risk getting nuked in response eventually anyway, when my involvement is known.
Plus terrorists aren't the most trustworthy people even if you are ideologically allied with them. Who's to say they wouldn't just turn around and threaten to use it against you. "Gee thanks for the nuke Iran, now unless you want to see Tehran wiped off the map, you better give me 5 more, or a billion dollars, or give me control of the country, etc."
That said, all this discussion is academic anyway cause I doubt they are even trying to develop nukes.
All this nuclear talk in the news lately has me wanting to play Defcon. Highly recommended. Nuclear holocaust at your fingertips, great fun :-) Now you too can fly B-52's with nuclear warheads across the country if you feel like it.
Why do we hate ourselves so much? Tribalism (nationalism) will doom us all
Gregg aus tx @ 63:
Come on people, don't you hate it when conservative whiners write the editorial boards about some left-wing cartoon that really stings? Here's an idea, dish it out AND take it, too.
Apologies for the html foul on #67. I will skulk away in shame now...
Are you sure he wasn't talking about Republicans?
I am a professional investor who uses Investor's Business Daily ($500 per year), IBD eTables, ($200 per year), and Investor's Equity Research ($1200 per year), or at least I did until I saw this. I have always thought of IBD's editorial page as a joke, their viewpoint is so far to the extreme right I usually laugh my ass off at them over my morning coffee. But now I think it's time to stop giving my money to what is clearly a fascist propaganda sheet. There are plenty of sources of good financial information that can be had for the same money. I will even pay more, if it meant none was going to William O'Nazi. Too bad, because their research is pretty good. The free market is a bitch, isn't it?
History repeats itself, and each time the price goes up.
lowly grunt @ 9:
Only a small minority of homo sapiens will kill other humans unless there is no alternative. Therefore, when a group of murderous political leaders wants to motivate its populace to comit genocide one of the necessary steps is to 'dehumanize' the humans that are to be mudered. De human ize To make not human. Note: The propagandist will not make the humans into another desirable animal like a dog. He will always make the target humans into an un desirable form like a cockroach, a pig, a dirty rat. etc. This is culturally sensitive. Pigs are considered dirty in the U.S. but are beloved in China. We love dogs but the Koreans eat them. Arabs will sometimes refer to Americans as PigDogs. I guess they do not like pigs or dogs very much! Heck, I am sure there are people somewhere who love cockroaches! They would be immune to this Columbus Dispatch attempt at dehumanizing the Iranians. In fact, they would like the Iranians more after reading this cartoon, not less! Cute little cockroaches. Unfortunately, the only thing that might be left of Iran if Bush goes to war with them will be cockroaches. The horror, the horror... He is insane enough to do it.
It just dawned on me that perhaps the intent of the cartoon was to portray the exportation of terrorism from Iran as cockroaches, not to portray all Iranians as cockroaches. This is quite a different take. Look at where most of the roaches are going: Iraq and Afghanistan. Perhaps a roach represent a terrorist, not just any Iranian.
I'm waiting for some rightwing bonehead to pull the freedom-of-speech card on this one.
I see that cartoonist-cockroach Ramirez has fled to Columbus since being fired by the L.A. Times. And here I thought he was circling a sewer.
As someone interested in Iranian culture, I'm utterly revolted by this cartoon, which inarguably (despite the paper's pathetic defense) depicts the entire country of Iran as a sewer with cockroaches teeming out of it.
Never mind that there's a thriving secular society in Iran. Never mind that there are millions of good, decent people living in Iran, trying to provide for their families, striving to create a free-er Iran, all while living under a repressive regime. Never mind that some of the most humanistic and life-affirming films I've seen in recent years have come from Iranian directors like Abbas Kiarostami and Bahman Ghobadi. No, to Ramirez, they all just roaches.
If we're ever to survive as a species, we have to stop this primitive urge to classify all of a nation's inhabitants according to the actions and beliefs of their leaders.
Rachel Maddow suggested today that the 5 (or 6) nuclear weapons that were mistakenly transported from North Dakota down to Louisiana might actually have been heading to the middle east region, ie. intentionally sent across US airspace on their way to the region. She suggested that perhaps someone intentionally leaked the info. to alert us of impending war.
I heard someone say that if the US attacks Iran he hopes Bush will be impeached. I was revolted by such an understatement. Nuremburg seems more appropriate.
Ramirez is the guy who resurrected the Dolschtosselegende - for real - in a cartoon last February.
The Columbus Dispatch, The Dayton Daily News, the Sprinfield News-Sun plus all of the local news channels in that area are very right wing biased. Makes me want to puke.
IraqIsDisaster @ 78:
hard to attack Iran the first week of Ramadan when the entire Air Combat Command is STANDING DOWN the first week of Ramadan.
When you are trying to counter nutcases, you take what you can get in the "stop a nuclear war" department.
Artie Dash Lange@52:
My poop don't stink as much as your poop. Well, let's face it, at the end of the day they're both poop. So take your pick, little-perspective boy. Which less smelly one are you?
You want perspective?
Put things in context, browse through a few pictures of the orphaned and maimed children in Iraq as a result of depleted uranium and what have you, now replace "Iraq" with "Iran" and give me the result. What do we get?
We get a guy, sitting in his home in West bumbf**k Idaho, typing away in a cozy room, sipping some hot cocoa while cartoons like this help sell a war that will kill hundreds if not thousands of innocent people. So, yeah, there's your "little perspective" you pretensious, arrogant f**k.
Time for bed - I'm constructing sentences that sound like I was raised by wolves. G'night.
The paper has the 1920's eugenics movement mindset
[Deleted. I fixed it. Go see-Sitemonitor]
On a positive note...
The editorial on the left of the picture seems to be on the need for health-care reform.
So, at least there's a little commone sense to balance the hate mongering.
Cheney Orders Media To Sell Attack On Iran
Fox News, Wall Street Journal instructed to launch PR blitz for upcoming military strike
http://www.prisonplanet.com/articles/september2007/040907_cheney_orders.htm
"Send polite comments about this Nazi-style cartoon depicting Iranians as roaches fleeing a sewer..."
Polite comments - You would have recomended polite coments to hitler?
Why would anyone be polite to Natzis - Am I missing somthing here?
We get the shit goverment and the dumb fucking media we desearve.
No, I guess we get the dumb media they choose to give us and we should put our eyes down and be polite...
Baaahahhhaaa
We's be good sheep maser, we never gone raise our ugly voice, no sir maser - We gona pull our christian cheeks apart and smile as it slides up in us...
'cause else they make you disapeared and tortured...
So polite rejection of genocide
Polite rejection of the killing of an additonal half million INOCENT peoples...
Hey I get it! We wring our hands and they simply build and exucute the next mass murder to get rich scheme...
And the polite response to this kind of (as you indicated) Natzi shit would be what prey tell?
Yeah we's gonna whip us some Natzi ass and overcome them with our politeness and kindness...
Hey it seems to be working look all around the world!!
If we could all just be more polite to our opressors and thier hench men, propaganda arms and what not - It will just go away!
But sure tell them we don't like what they are 'selling' lol I am sure they will change it all right away.
I guess the folks in Dufar could have been more polite - It couldn't have hurt!
scottarino @ 69:
Take it too?
This cartoon wasn't even aimed at us, if anything it makes all of us look like Nazi's to the way we dehumanize the Muslim as cockroaches. I don't see how this is a partisan issue cartoon. Unless you are trying to say that the Republicans are the Nazi party.
Are the oil pigs still mad that someone tried to stand up to them and their hedgemony? Maybe when congress and senate reconvene everyone can dress up in 'dom' gear ... That's how I imagine it from now on, they just want someone to suffer.
What the hell is wrong with you people? You read the headline and view the image, then don't stop to consider that the drawing could mean something other than your first reaction. Then you take up ridiculous closed-minded positions, such as
"As someone interested in Iranian culture, I’m utterly revolted by this cartoon, which inarguably (despite the paper’s pathetic defense) depicts the entire country of Iran as a sewer with cockroaches teeming out of it."
No, that's not the case. It not "inarguable." I CAN argue with you about the meaning of this message. Did you notice that the cockroaches are clustered in israel, iraq and afghanistan? Did you stop to think that maybe the artist was inferring that iran is supporting terrorist groups in those countries? If the drawing was portraying iranians in general fleeing iran, why wouldn't they be scattering in all directions equally? Why all grouping in countries some think to be suffering from iranian influence?
I would say that by depicting iran as a sewer could be expressing that iran is a major state sponsor of terrorism.
Whether you agree with these ideas is a different issue. Just stop with the knee-jerk reactions and get all the facts before forming an opinion. seriously, close-mindedness might seem like a cliche, but it's a very real, very dangerous reality. Admit that it's possible that you are wrong and your first interpretation might not be accurate. Email the artist of this drawing and ask him what exactly he was implying with the drawing instead of assuming you know his motivation and intent.
The cartoon is by Michael Ramirez, a conservative cartoonist. The original publication date I have for it is 6-22-07. (I featured it in a earlier installment of Right-Wing Cartoon Watch.) Ramirez and other conservative cartoonists use this sort of dehumanizing imagery pretty frequently. You're absolutely right about the Nazi analogy. In this specific case, conservative cartoonists have been accusing Iran of being a key instigator of violence in Iraq and have been urging Bush to bomb them.
I am awesome @ 93:
Yes, except that even if your point stood, the assertion is *still* wrong. The country with the largest sponsors of Islamic terrorism in the region is and has always been Saudi Arabia.
And even with your subtext, it doesn't make the use of the 'cockroach' image any less abhorrent.
[...] [image via CROOKS & LIARS] [...]
I am awesome @ 93:
... and arguably you have no clue that Iran is a Persian country, and Persians HATE Arabs, and that most countries in the map where the critters are flowing to are Arabs. Also there has been no direct implication between Iran and terrorist attacks in the near East, or Western world for that matter. And there is also the little matter that most Iranians are Shia, and the Sunni Al-Quaida and Hamas consider Shias to be higher in the scale of their enemies than even the US of A, as Shias are heretics according to Sunnis. And here is when it gets funny, Saudi Arabia has not only been directly linked to Palestinian terrorist groups... in fact they hold telethons on TV to get money for Hamas and co. You know, the same Saudi Arabia that just got a few billion $$$ in military aid from the US.
And you wanna know the hilarious part: there has not been a direct attack by Iran on US soil... yet the US shot down an Iranian Jet liner in the late 80s killing almost 300 civilian Iranian passengers. Talk about terrorism....
So I recommend you take your own advice and get them facts, because you have no fucking clue about what you are talking about. Yet another loud mouth ignoramus.
BTW, I am sure that had you lived half a century ago, you would try to tell us how the German propaganda was just making the point of the large number of Jewish left wing activists that were spreading communism.
This cartoon is disgusting. I did send them a polite, but very direct e-mail. Hitler did cartoons of the Jews like this, in the 1930's. We know where that leads.
Dr. Who:
-I know that the dominant ethnic group in iran are persians.
-the countries the "critters" are flowing to in the largest numbers are israel/palestine, iraq, afghanistan and pakistan. Are afghanistan and pakistan populated mostly by arabs?
-I never said that there have been any direct implication of terrorist attacks in the near east or the western world by iran.
-I am aware of the the two main religious groups in islam, their relations, and their dominance in particular countries.
-I know that saudi arabia financially supports hamas.
-I am troubled that a country such as saudi arabia is receiving high-tech weaponry from the united states.
-I never stated that there has been a direct attack by iran on u.s. soil.
-I am not familiar with the downing of the iranian jet liner in the 80's. Perhaps I'll get them facts, because i wouldn't want to have no fucking clue about what i am talking about.
-Why would you believe i would "try to tell us how the German propaganda was just making the point of the large number of Jewish left wing activists that were spreading communism." I wouldn't say that. That's nonsense.
In closing, you seemed to miss my entire point. I suggest that people should get the opinion of the cartoonist and hear him out as to his motivation before forming a lynch mob.
JPsy:
what was my point?
-I don't disagree with you about the issue of saudi arabia sponsoring and encouraging terrorism and fundamentalism.
-I don't find it "abhorrant" to compare cockroaches to people. I find it inaccurate and silly. Regardless. that comparison should be confronted and challenged. Doing so would dispel that belief more effectively than simply declaring it to be "abhorrant." Understand that other people will often not care whether or not you believe their opinion is offensive and stating you believe so will not change their minds. Address the accuracy of the issue, not the potential offensiveness and you will be more effective.
paranoia @ 4:
Well as one poster here said years ago, while most people were apalled at what was written in Mein Kampf, KKKarl Rove was writing down all the good ideas.
Is anyone who compared the cartoon to Nazi images of Jews aware of Ahmadimejad's attitude toward Israel? Puts a different twist on the easy analogy, doesn't it?
I see the cartoon as noting Iran's support and exportation of terror to other countries in the region. While I in no way support another incompetent war, that premise is sort of hard to dispute.
I am awesome @ 93:
Yeah sure. And the nazi portrayal of jews as rats wasn't really rascist or dehumanizing.
idiotland:
from what i can tell, judaism is a religion, not a race. Saying that a particular belief/belief system is superior to another is not the same as saying that one race is inherently superior to another. In that sense, all races are equal. However, not all beliefs are equal. Some beliefs are accurate, some beliefs are stupid bullshit (pardon my francois). Also, it is important to seperate a system of beliefs from those who follow it (or claim to). I would never say that any person(s) is subhuman.
Yes, the intent of portraying jews as rats by the german propogandists was mostly likely to give others the impression that jews were subhuman. If the intent were to portray muslims or persians as subhuman as well, your analogy would seem accurate. Again, the best way to find out the intent is to ask the cartoonist.
AGAIN, my suggestion is to stop the knee-jerk reactions and actually ask questions. Admit that you, as a human being, are capable of being mistaken and your understanding of the issue may be flawed.
Granted it's in poor taste but I have no idea what the hell it means or is implying.
They say roaches could survive a nuclear attack. So maybe the cartoonist is actually opposed to nuking Iran. "Look - they're cockroaches! It wouldn't do any good!"
Yeah, that's probably it.
Let's just hope we're equally immune to nuclear fallout, because a few more cartoons like this and we might have to be.
Michael Ramirez is one of the main reasons we invaded Iraq in the first place. He draws very well, but his politics are delusional.
He, like all other right-wing propagnists, spread lies and deceive the public. How he keeps getting published in my local newspaper is beyond me.
mudshark @ 5:
'MurKKKa!
Ramirez must be related to Gonzalez, at least politically.
I am awesome @ 93:
What flavor of koolaid did you drink before spewing that?
I understand your reasoning in saying "polite comments" but I gotta say I'm not sure polite works with people that would print such filth.
I live in Columbus, Ohio and i can't believe this got published! We are normally considered a pretty liberal city!
Well then, I guess we don't have to worry about taking in any of their refugees.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SXZxzgnnMTo
From Der Ewige Jude
Terrible @ 112:
I agree - I mean, shit, the moral argument is moot, with these people. They're "so over" that - and on to the next thing. For Ramirez and scumbag empty-headed flacks like him, this sort of debasement (he's debasing himself, making a public show of his lack of humanity) is only a way to make the right professional contacts and thus to pad his pockets...It's a win-win situation for folks like him (and I have a dread feeling that the Goebbels comparisons might even make him feel a glimmer of pride!)...
It takes cockroach tendencies to declare millions of people to be nasty bugs who need to be stomped.
Straight Shooter @ 56:
And the scorpions too - don't forget the scorpions!
Vierotchka @ 116:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=57CzNqgm8Fc
IraqIsDisaster @ 75:
To the best of my educated knowledge, Iran does not export terrorism.
Well, it's not like anyone has accused The Columbia Post-Dispatch of exercising class.
It'd be better if you included the CONTEXT of the editorial cartoon. It may have been vile and it may have not been; we can't tell since there's no caption or text included.
Tell me, are you just rabidly anti-administration / anti-Bush, or are you one of those people who have to denounce anything that isn't pro-any-islamic-anything?
ThunderMonkey @ 119:
Credibility, folks, involves getting your facts straight.
We are talking about the COLUMBUS (as in the capital of Ohio) DISPATCH (NOT the Post-Dispatch, which is the St. Louis paper).
And Iran DOESN'T export terror? That comment would come as a disappointment to Ahmadimejad, who is committed not only to supporting the Shiites in Iraq but also to the obliteration of Israel. Without Iran's support, even Bush wouldn't have been able to justify staying in Iraq this long.
Despite the stupidity and tragedy of this adventure, the fact remains that Iran is not our friend.
This is coming from someone who wants us out of Iraq and thinks we need an even-handed, less Israeli-centered Middle East policy. But yikes, I want the argument based on fact.
It hasn't been established that Iran exports terrorism. Now they have helped their Shia peers in Iraq (apparently), but they share a border with Iraq and have a vested interest in the outcome, if only for state security concerns. They've help (allegedly) finance Hezbollah and Hamas, but we also supported death squads in El Savadore and else where.
How do you draw an exacting dividing line between exercising foreign policy concerns and exporting terrorism?
"Terrorism" is a meaningless word. What the US is doing in Iraq is terrorism. What the Israelis do to the Palestinians is terrorism. Israel murders a lot more civilians than Iran does, and the U.S. is the all time champion of entire world in the postwar years at murdering civilians.
Iran's support for groups like Hezbollah has nothing to do with the U.S., and is no different than the types of meddling that the U.S. and Israel do in other countries. The only threat Iran poses to the U.S. is in the fevered imaginations of fanatics with an agenda.
The American people are some of the stupidest people on the entire planet to fall for this "war on terror" meme. They have actually been manipulated into believing that you can have a war on a military and political tactic. lol.
[...] Write To This Newspaper About Its Racist Cartoon September 7th, 2007 — RickB (Via Lenin’s Tomb & Crooks & Liars) [...]
cheesesauce @ 31:
If people see people being abused as a child growing up, they will go on to abuse others. Ramirez learned to hate from someone. Now, thanks to the Bush administration, people in Iraq are learning how to senselessly kill. Not good enough. They want to teach Iran now too. Was that polite enough?
Well, it was either this or the cartoon depicting Ohio as a giant asshole emitting shitloads of pollution:
"Ohio leads the nation with 83 million pounds of acid gases emitted every year. In addition, the Buckeye state ranks fifth in releases of arsenic (8,400 pounds), sixth in chromium (11,000 pounds), eighth in dioxins (19 grams) and ninth in lead (8,200 pounds), according to the report. 'It's quite a toxic hit parade,' said Jack Shaner, spokesman for the Ohio Environmental Council. 'Unfortunately, Ohio is at the top of the list.'"
Jesus Christ....Fuck sake... This is the kind of crap that really makes me embarrassed to have been born there.... And everytime I ponder the idea of maybe moving back... Stuff like this just confirms that... no.... I can't really go back to that place...Not under these conditions... I'd just end up in a fight with someone and in jail , probably every other day. Conservative columnists, conservative news outlets, conservative government... Conservative, conservative, conservative... That's the term they like to hide behind... I have another term for it.. snakeoil FASCISM!!!
Here's the weird shit.. I go back to see friends periodically and I swear I can't find a one who backs Bush or any of this shit... Not a one..... And they ain't all dems or liberals either....They just know this is all bullshit.... They know they were played in 04 and they don't like it... I don't get it.. Comeon Ohioans.... Step up for this great state and rid yourselves of those fascists hiding behind the republican political party......
These types are ruining the state of Ohio over time... But I will say one thing that is true People. I can tell you all Ohio was not always like this... During the time I was born, raised and lived there we were considered and rightfully and proudly so, one of the three most liberal states in the union.... Along with California and Michigan.. At the time I read this somewhere sometime in the early 70s.... So I know the people of my birth state are not a bunch of clueless hick morons.....
What the fuck happend??? I don't know... I go away to the navy for a few years, come home and it's all gone sideways.... I guess Reagan is what happend to Ohio......He and his tripe weaselled their way in after Ohio was beat up economically by the little recession no one really talks about anymore that was evident to anyone looking for work in 1978 or 79... Sad... sad, pathetic and depressing.... As to the larger geopolitical ramifications of this creepy little cartoon and whatever hidden messages the cockroaches are suppose to portray... I'm with Robert S @ 78...
I agree with his perspective on it...... We have got to stop villifying one another and get back to some kind of live and let live acceptance of all our differences as well as similarities... We just need to stop killing each other over money and other dumb shit or we ain't ever going to see 2100 as a species.....Maybe not even 2050...............JD
paranoia @ 4:
The Iranians haven't been any better at they're portrayal of Jews than the Germans or the portrayal of them in this story! So, you'll forgive me if I don't care to shed any tears for Iran. Remember, not long Achmadinajad (sp?) sponsored a contest to see who could come up with the best comic to debunk the holocaust!
Maybe they like a swig of their own medicine!
Jeff @ 2:
ooooh....good post
mudshark @ 5:
Ohio. Believe me, I grew up there, it's a weird place. Crazy people get to run the government. I have never seen a population more close-minded than those folks living in Ohio.
Fox's New York Post runs cartoons like this all of the time. Here's one from yesterday portraying New York cabdrivers (who are these days usually non-white immigrants) as chimpanzees.
http://www.nypost.com/delonas/delonas.htm?year=2007&month=09&day=06
For those asking, I think the cartoon is meant to communicate:
- Iranians are now spreading into the regions around them (Iraq), where they will be very hard to get rid of. A smart home owner (the US owns the Middle East naturally) would act now to prevent an infestation.
- Iranians are filthy, vile insects, that are crawling out of their hole-of-a-country to infect the surrounding regions with their diseases (like radical Islam, etc)
Bonus: Cockroaches are really hard to kill. You’ve got to hit them with everything you got. Maybe ever nukes. I once heard cockroaches can survive even a nuclear holocaust…
In summary--KILL KILL KILL!
The Iranians haven't been any better at they're portrayal of Jews than the Germans or the portrayal of them in this story! So, you'll forgive me if I don't care to shed any tears for Iran. Remember, not long Achmadinajad (sp?) sponsored a contest to see who could come up with the best comic to debunk the holocaust!
Maybe they like a swig of their own medicine!
----
why should 2 wrongs make a right? ... you should always do the right thing and not worry about what others are going to do, otherwise what is the difference between us and the ones we are criticizing
"Fox’s New York Post runs cartoons like this all of the time. Here’s one from yesterday portraying New York cabdrivers (who are these days usually non-white immigrants) as chimpanzees.
http://www.nypost.com/delonas/.....amp;day=06
Obviously you didn't get the point of this cartoon...which is that since the cab drivers were on strike they had to be replaced by chimpanzees...You love to see racism anywhere, even when it ain't there. Lighten up.
That kind of thinking is going to get a lot of people killed on both sides. I think there is ample evidence for this in those dusty, cobweb covered history books over at your local library.
Yet another reason I left the midwest 33 years ago.
One of those little "coackroaches" managed to escape here to Canada after his entire family was killed in a bombing raid.He got off lucky:he only lost both arms.Jesus wept.
First, this cartoon is far less abrasive and bias hate propoganda then ANYTHING published in the skewed hate-fueling media machines over there. What causes this hatred over there (and in general)? RELIGION...especially a religion that condones violence against non-believers (whom they value as less than cockroaches). Thier government ideology is founded on these principles and anyone who believes this without thinking critically has lost their humanity...and is therefore no better than AN INSECT. That's my interpretation.
The point of the cartoon is that Iran is a breeding ground for terrorists and extremists that are spreading across the Middle East. The point of the cockroaches is that the extremists are all but impossible to wipe out. I'm not saying that this is correct; however, the artist is not attempting to depict Iranians as cartoonists. The simplest of analysis reveals this to be a poor interpretation.
How in the hell can so many of you all talk so bad about America. Do you all understand that Iran has already said that once they get a Nuke it is going into Tel Aviv. Now lets back up for a second, first of all the Iranian govt has stated so many times that they are only trying to get Nuclear Technology for energy purposes, then they make a statement like this. #2 in charge in Iran has said that it would be worth killing 350 million muslims to wipe out Isreal, oh but Iran is such a peaceful country. Iran is a Terrorism Sponsored State, read, read, read.
Way to go jackass, rub your nose on a country and people that you neither understand nor have any knowledge about. Ignorant fools like you are why the rest of the world hates America, and why I'm even more ashamed than before of being both an Ohio resident and an American citizen.
Bryan @ 140:
Look kid when you get older you will realise that not everything is black and white.
Maybe we should portray them as people?
Maybe the black and white helps but that really is like something you'd imagine in a Nazi-era newspaper. Recently had a phone leech for the Democratic Committee try to tell me that we _really_ DO need to "do something about Iran." That's when I hung up on him. It's all one party. MILCOP. Military Industrial Complex Party.
mudshark @ 5:
Ohio, apparently. Apparently, slander, to dehumanize someone you want to turn into your enemy. It always starts with ad hominem type slander and accusations of crime, to in some way create the semblance that such attacks were justified. Iran is full of a civilian population just as Iraq was, and just as the US is, and any country in the world. Half the population in Iraq is under 18, and I wouldn't doubt the same is not true of Iran. Someone in the U.S. wants to try and justify an attack on a nation half of which are children?
Jake @ 139:
God, finally someone got the interpretation of the cartoon correct. How were there 1 comments and it took until 137 to get it right?
The cartoon is saying the following:
1. There are terrorists in Iran.
2. Iran allows terrorists to hide within their borders.
3. Terrorists are free to travel within Iran and move to neighboring countries.
4. You can never get them all.
Check your far left tendencies at the door people. This isn't as bad as it seems. In fact, it really isn't that bad at all, and the meaning (when correctly interpreted) is not a radical idea and taken as fact by a whole lot of people.
You guys must be mentally challenged to not see the parallel to today's geopolitical activities.
What's going on in the cartoon? What's going on in the world right now? Let's see...
The something is leaking out of Iraq... is it good things? No. It's bad things. We know it's bad things because they are coming from the sewer. Are the bad things all heading to Turkmenistan? Georgia? Ummm.... no. They are crawling into Iraq. They are crawling into Afghanistan. They are crawling into Lebanon.
What could this mean? Gee... does it mean that Iranians are like roaches? No, you retards! It means that Iraq (Iraq the state. Iraq the government.) is crawling over really bad things into these other countries under the radar, or in the dark of the kitchen, so to speak. Just like bugs. They are infesting some of these other countries by supplying them arms, personnel, intelligence. The government of Iraq is doing nefarious things that are not good for the region, and are making the middle east
So now that you have a clear understanding of what is actually going on in the world, perhaps you can put your myopic ignorance aside and try to not be so damn sensitive and PC.
Smart Buckeyes @ 147:
Do you know the difference between Iraq and Iran? I seriously couldn't follow whatever point you were trying to make.
My daughter went to school in Ohio. I like the place and the people I have met there, but I am continually amazed at the stuff that comes out of that state. Where do those people hide?
Ruthless People @ 34:
Couldn't have said it better, Ruthless. Mark the date because we will soon be asking ourselves how long it took to go from dehumanizing the Iranians to bombing them. You know that Bush painted himself into a corner -- he cannot leave behind a nuclear armed Iran. We will go to war with them. The Millennialists on both sides will not be denied their Armageddon.
Comments are closed on this entry