Go Home

"The Stuff of Life"

icon Download | play icon Download | play (Warning-Disturbing images. NSFW)

Brought to you by Amnesty International.

Here's what others thought of it:

Atty Gen John Ashcroft: It's about a young man forced by his Principal to attend a high school dance.

Sen Kit Bond: I particularly liked the parts where the guy was swimming freestyle and backstroke.

Gov Mike Huckabee: It seemed sort of like the star of the film was running for office.

SERE Instructor Malcolm Nance: It was a harrowing account of controlled drowning: a slow motion suffocation.

Unite against human rights abuses in the war on terror. Find out how at unsubscribe-me.org

Share This Post

Link To This Post


29 Comments
::mwah::'s picture

"Oops I cannot find that file"

Whitehouse's picture

Indeed...

Any chance we can get a terrorist organization to endorse McCain?

Can we make one up?

bill q's picture

OOPS - I can not find that file!

Whitehouse's picture

You can view this segment when you visit the Amnesty International link provided in the article.

Divyesh's picture

The technique involves placing a cloth of some kind over the person's face before pouring the water. Great idea, but a little accuracy would be nice.

Radically Moderate's picture

Ashcroft and Bond:
You are a disgrace to the state of Missouri.

Chuck's picture

McCain is a Bush Hugger !

McCain is a Bush Hugger !

justabill's picture

C&L's been notified. In the meantime you can view the video either by flash or QT on the Amnesty link in the post

http://www.unsubscribe-me.org/

Mike the Canuck's picture

next time your goverment goes after another nation about torture..... All I have to say is it's like the pot calling the kettle black

the 4th Reich is rising's picture

Divyesh @ 6:

The technique involves placing a cloth of some kind over the person's face before pouring the water. Great idea, but a little accuracy would be nice.

What´s your point? You can watch the video Making "The stuff of life" at the unsubscribe website. There you´ll find out that the people who made the film are well aware that in reality the torturers cover the victim´s face with "a cloth of some kind" to terrify the victim even more than shown in the film. And in case you really need it, you can even see the technique performed in the accurate fashion.
Moron!

Sitemonitor: Thanks for finally posting the film. I´ve posted it a few days ago about three times already and I was wondering why noeffingbody seemed to be interested the least bit.

[No need to thank the monitors. We're merely readers with magical powers, but not the magical powers to post blog content, necessarily. Thank Bill W.. He did all the work here. Site Monitor]

Jeanne's picture

I think Ashcroft has lost what little sanity he had.

the 4th Reich is rising's picture

@ Sitemonitor: Sorry, my fault.

@ Bill W.: Thank you for posting!

Radically Moderate's picture

Mike the Canuck @ 10:

next time your goverment goes after another nation about torture..... All I have to say is it's like the pot calling the kettle black

Picture an American Soldier before his captors, strapped to a board about to be immerced in a tub of water when he exclaims:
"You can't do this to me, it violates the Geneva Convention articles of cruel and unusual punishment".
As a veteran I feel dishonored by the actions taken by those who authorized torture techniques in the name of the United States, and I hope that they will be punished by the full measure of our laws some day soon.
BTW It is an embarassment to our Nation that some who served or are serving the BushCo LLC will not be able to travel to foreign countries because of their complicity in crimes of war and yet protected from extradition by our laws or rather those who are tasked to enforce our laws. It is a Dichotomy of Conscience.

Radically Moderate's picture

Radically Moderate @ 14:

Mike the Canuck @ 10:

next time your goverment goes after another nation about torture..... All I have to say is it's like the pot calling the kettle black

Picture an American Soldier before his captors, strapped to a board about to be immerced in a tub of water when he exclaims:
"You can't do this to me, it violates the Geneva Convention articles of cruel and unusual punishment".
As a veteran I feel dishonored by the actions taken by those who authorized torture techniques in the name of the United States, and I hope that they will be punished by the full measure of our laws some day soon.
BTW It is an embarassment to our Nation that some who served or are serving the BushCo LLC will not be able to travel to foreign countries because of their complicity in crimes of war and yet protected from extradition by our laws or rather those who are tasked to enforce our laws. It is a Dichotomy of Conscience.

Correction: It is a Corruption of Conscience!

andy's picture

Then it begs the question, if the techniques are so soft, as these absolute madmen would have us believe, what the point in doing it ?

dee's picture

Divyesh @ 6:

The technique involves placing a cloth of some kind over the person's face before pouring the water. Great idea, but a little accuracy would be nice.

Actually, the cloth over the mouth is used to make it worse. You saw the guy in the video cough out the water. The cloth over the mouth makes it harder to get enough water coughed back out, so you just become more and more aware that you are quickly starving for air and the second the water starts pulling up into your windpipe is the near death experience that makes this work.

I read this on some winger's blog. The guy waterboarded himself without the cloth and with the cloth to see what all the fuss is about, and even though he was in total control of the situation, he said it was traumatic and psychologically damaging and he would never want to go through it again.

bill q's picture

Radically Moderate @ 7:

Ashcroft and Bond:
You are a disgrace to the state of Missouri.

Also the state of mind of those who live here.

David Wolf's picture

Since the administration thinks this is an important tool for protecting our national security and the outing of secret agents is treason, should we be waterboarding Cheney and company to see who really outed Valerie Plame?

ferrofluid's picture

Theres another aspect to 'waterboarding' thats not mentioned,
when done on a pious Muslim, the torturers could (and prob did) make jokes about baptizing,
this woundnt worry the ethics and morality of the child rapists in the employ of the CIA and other outsourced 'thugs for hire'
Theres many reports of guards pissing on Korans and doing assorted religious mind tricks on the guests at Gitmo.

j swift's picture

Divyesh @ 6:

The technique involves placing a cloth of some kind over the person's face before pouring the water. Great idea, but a little accuracy would be nice.

If we every get any of our politicians who are so dismissive of waterboarding to give a try, you make sure that they use the cloth over the politician's face. It will add to the experience of "just" doing the backstroke while the pol is sucking in the cloth and can't see when to expect the next deluge of water.

Dana's picture

It's only torture when it's done to Americans...
but for everyone else it's like 'swim lessons'.

bitter Edwin Hussein's picture

Atty Gen John Ashcroft:
Sen Kit Bond:
Gov Mike Huckabee:

Three very sick people. They are not even mature enough to deal with the topic in a responsible "adult" manner. (Isn't that what school kids do when they're uncomfortable; "joke"?)

I wonder what they'd say if it were a fetus being drowned.

bitter Edwin Hussein's picture

18 bill q Says: Radically Moderate @ 7:

Ashcroft and Bond:
You are a disgrace to the state of Missouri.

Also the state of mind of those who live here.
========================
And the rest of us that inhabit the planet. It's not just an American issue: none of it is.

Mug's picture

File Doesn't work....

Now push 'submit comment' button.

Two minute white screen...

guess I take my chances...

Mug's picture

Still don't work...

I'm bitter...

gonna go pray and shoot!!

Loonie's picture

Anyone who can condone waterboarding has forfeited their humanity. Anyone who can condone waterboarding is a monster.

me's picture

Why is it that the ONLY people who say waterboarding is not torture are the ones who are guilty of doing it, and their supporters?

Loonie's picture

me @ 28:

Why is it that the ONLY people who say waterboarding is not torture are the ones who are guilty of doing it, and their supporters?

Torturers will always find some justification. No matter how perverse, contrived or distorted. They even torture their logic.

Comments are closed on this entry