Congress Overrides Bush Veto on Medicare Cuts
It's about time Congress stood up to the most unpopular President in American history. Unfortunately they can't do the same on some more pressing matters.
CNN:
Congress voted to halt planned cuts in Medicare payments to doctors Tuesday, overriding President Bush's veto in a battle that pitted health insurers against physicians.
The new law stops a 10.6 percent cut in Medicare payments to doctors, part of a scheduled cost-saving formula that went into effect July 1.
The money for the doctors will be taken from the government-subsidized Medicare Advantage program, which the Bush administration strongly supports.
Bush spiked the bill Tuesday, telling lawmakers they would be "taking choices away from seniors to pay physicians."
"I urge the Congress to send me a bill that reduces the growth in Medicare spending, increases competition and efficiency, implements principles of value-driven health care and appropriately offsets increases in physician spending," he said in his veto message.
The Senate voted 70-26 to enact the law over Bush's objections, the third time in his presidency that Congress has overridden his veto. The margin in the House of Representatives was a lopsided 383-41, well beyond the two-thirds majority needed.

the constituents as well as the physicians didn't want the cut.......reimbursement for medicare pts. is low already..lowering reimbursement further is not the answer better efficiency is
Support the troops?
Tricare (military health care) reimbursement fees are linked to Medicare fees so if Medicare fees had been cut, Tricare users would had their reimbursement reduced.
Teddy Kennedy embarrassed the GoPervs into it. Yay, Ted.
Great, they showed their no 100% impotent...now how about holding up the rule of law an impeaching the criminals who are destroying America? How about fulfilling your oath to defend the constitution?
Just 3 vetos overridden in 7 1/2 years of the worst president ever? That's a damn shame.
Signing Statements from the unitary president? anyone, anyone?
Oh Woopee!! The one bill they override is the one that will benefit the pharmaceuticals more than the average person. Probable a bought vote too.
Image doesn't move
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8WpwAWUpsXM
Hmmm. Denying seniors choices of which HMO to belong to? One of the more obscene provisions of the Medicare Modernization Act was the creation of these Medicare Advantage Plans. In a wonderful Republican style twofer this provision was designed to make the Medicare trust fund go broke faster by siphoning off more money and to drive seniors out of traditional Medicare and into HMO's. The Republican ideal was realized in the Medicare Advantage Fee for Service Plan where most of the enrollment was going. Under these plans the insurance companies provided no "advantage" over traditional medicare, unless limiting which doctors you can see is an advantage, and collected a 12%-15% federal subsidy.
Kennedy would probably have returned from the grave to reverse this obscenity.
Medicare for everyone!!!!!!
Maybe some of the them are just now starting to figure out the GOP playbook. anytime something benefits the average american vs. their big corporate donors, it isn't "fiscally responsible". to me that is just the Big Bell saying it must be a Good Idea then. Because everything is assbackwards in bushland.
Well consider that he didn't actually veto anything until 2006, and since then only vetoed 11 bills, 3 overturned is pretty weak percentage.
But OTOH, as Andrew pointed out above, he's just been Kingofyin' himself with Signing Statements and Executive Prvilege anyhow.
Whooopeee! So, the Bush Administration has now provided cover for the majority of Republican Congressional folk who can now go back and inform their constituents that they STOOD UP TO THE TYRANNY OF THE PRESIDENT (TM).
Puleeeze.
Anyone who can't see this for the political theater it is hasn't been paying attention to the past 8 years.
Look, this was a very pressing matter for millions of seniors, many of whom are trying to eke out a living on nothing but Social Security. A very, very pressing matter.
Ducks @ 9:
Yeah. One of the big players in these Medicare HMO "Advantage" scams, is UnitedHealthGroup. Their CEO pulls down about $30 million a year.
VeeKaChu @ 12:
exactly that's what the paper thin "majority" has been up against signing statements, executive privilage and secrecy....they get a lot criticism but this executive branch is impossible by design
Hasn't anyone ever heard of preventive maintenance?
BobbyG @ 15:
and they are getting bigger that's one of the problems.. interferes with competition..monopoly....plus they fudge on data....ever since the for profit model got traction it's become a disaster
Al Gore's speech today on climate change http://www.cnn.com/video/#/video/us/2008/07/17/sot.gore.speech.cnn?iref=... http://www.cnn.com/video/#/video/us/2008/07/17/sot.gore.speech.cnn?iref=...
This action is only a bandaid. It does nothing about the real, and serious, problems with Medicare.
Let us hope that the next President and next Congress will get serious about fixing Medicare, hopefully as part of universal medical coverage. Medicare Advantage (done right) for all!
Congress has an 18% approval rating. They're even less popular than the average Congress, and perhaps not doing anything about a Prez with a 28% approval reason is why.
rain @ 17:
We all have. I guess it begs the question if you have ever heard of genetic diseases. No amount of healthy living is going to make much of a difference here, especially if they manifest later in life:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_genetic_disorders
The dirty little secret of the originally scheduled 10% pay cut?
Medicate had been holding back making payments for treatment given this year until AFTER the pay cut was supposed to go into effect.
General_Rennenkampf @ 21:
Absolutely. Everyone I know, myself included, voted for this congress in part to put the breaks on (and impeach) the most lawless and corrupt administration in US history. They've failed miserably in this regard.
rain @ 17:
Ever hear of old age? Catastrophic illness? Car accidents?
Ruthless People @ 23:
Amen.
From The Capital Times (Wisconsin):
Mayors Make Good Move On Health Care
[all bold mine]
Well...It is very hard to stand up to a Republican President who will Veto anything Congress sends to him.
“I urge the Congress to send me a bill that reduces the growth in Medicare spending (cut spending), increases competition and efficiency (be more like the private sector), implements principles of value-driven health care (deny really sick folks treatment) and appropriately offsets increases in physician spending (cut more spending),” he said in his veto message.
"implements principles of value-driven health care "
WTF!
Is he really advocating denial of healthcare for those with prexisting conditions and the terminally ill?
Or am I reading this wrong?
Your life is of little too no value you poor sap, no healthcare for you, now hurry up and die because you're wasting oxygen!
It's just to distract us from noticing while they capitulate on the misleading and disasterous drilling scam.
Liberal AND Proud @ 25:
So you're saying sh*t happens?
kep306 @ 31:
I think maybe rain was saying that Bush gave this to the GOP so they could distance themselves from him. Like what Bart @ 13: was saying.
OF COURSE this PROVES they could do it all along on most pressing matters.
But PLEASE don't refer to life saving medical care as "less pressing" than other matters!
Without being ALIVE there isn't much point in everything else you know!!!!!
Dead is dead no matter what your beliefs are.
NATIONALIZED MEDICAL CARE IS THE MOST IMPORTANT THING WE NEED.
Americans are sick. They need to be made well, be fed well, be housed, be educated, and set free to do all the rest.
Without the government being an agent of oppression... which it currently IS.
Bart @ 13:
All politics is theater. The 18% Congress has never had an interest in standing up to Bush, it would possibly mean they don't get a cut of pork.
Yellowbird @ 33:
Chimpy how does it feel to be irrelevant? PWNED!!!
herr dubyah is going to start a war with Iran just to get back at the Congress.
wheeee @ 29:
No, I believe your assessment is correct. Remember, Bush cares nothing for people beyond those running the corporations that installed him.
Liberal AND Proud @ 25:
Try getting medicare to pay for preventive maintenance. If you get a physical this year, you can't get a pap smear. If you get a pap smear, no physical and on and on.........
Andrew Says: Signing Statements from the unitary president? anyone, anyone?
The beauty about the override is Dinkledoofus CANNOT make a signing statement. He is not asked to sign it since it is passed into law by being overridden. I got your signing statement right here.
Well that's just peachy. So glad all the pols have something to crow about back home now. Some bit of 'I stood up to the bad bad president for you good people who will vote for me again and again'...Yea, fine, whatever, but lets talk about donut holes.... No, not the kind Homer Simpson and some cops drewl over.... I'm talking about that famous donut hole that was being touted along with this so-called value-driven health care b.s not so long ago.....
I'm sure it looked good on paper to someone, probably an insurance C.E.O and the lobbyist who wrote it up for Senator Useless to sign on to... And for sure a full court press was used to sell it to the rest of us.... And whether anyone actually bought into it or not, we had to swallow it just like the big shit sammich from Full Metal Jacket fame... But I'll tell you how this shit plays out in reality..in the real world of the average middle class family or the working poor or anyone but the obviously wealthy, who skip it anyway, and get their designer healthcare thru other means..
You or someone you love gets seriously ill, your mom, your dad, grandma someone legitmately on medicare... maybe with some bit of additional insurance... Someone you care about, someone from that famous greatest generation fame yadda yadda.... Medicare kicks in and pays the health care industry to get you all better.. Yeesss!!!... But no, not really... It will get you some percentage of the way back to health.. then it just stops... At which point medicaid would kick it... but no, not the way it plays out or is even suppose to work... You find yourself in that donut hole.... Whats your options??? Well you use up whatever other existing insurance policy you have... Then?
'You' start paying, and if you don't have the cash? You end up liquidating your assets. The end result is that any family estate is syphoned off to pay what amounts to ridiculously astronomical health bills noone save the wealthy could afford anyway.... Think it's not astronomical? How bout $35.00 for a freaking aspirin just because it was someone in a hospital giving it to you... That ain't even scratching the surface of ridiculous..... And what's the alternative?? It's either that or you just lose whatever gains you made in recovery, your illness overtakes you and you die..... The stark choice is either allow a system to tranfer whatever little bit of wealth your family might have in the way of whatever over to a system that won't get you what you really need... Or you just wait for the end to come to your loved ones, watching helpless... And usually these loved ones end up warehoused in some ill ran nursing home for the final act in this perverse play, while you slowly watch them lose hope and die. If you can swing it, you care for them yourself which only prolongs the agony and spreads the syphoning from their direct assets, on over to yours as well. And what's a person to do in that situation??? Not help??? Yea, right, only if you have no soul..........
And our so-called greatest healthcare system the world?? The health'care' system??? (That racket??) It doesn't give a damn because the for profit model has undermined the hypocratic oath of physicians and everyone else connected to the industry system in the incessant need to max out profit or else... Even at the expense of the health of the nation...
'Preventive' healthcare??? Something that used to be preached in times past, and may still see some lip service... Just another casualty of the bean counters who are actually making the doctors decisions for them nowadays..... Preventive healthcare doesn't make money dammit!! Hell that gets people well and prevents them from getting sick in the first place thru advocation of good habits and Jesus fucking Christ, noone can make money that way... Not if people aren't getting sick!!!...
Wassamatterwitchuboy??? The for profit model, much like the cigarette industry model 'NEEDS' a constant flow or clients to remain viable as a business model...........
It may be all nice and neat and legal with all the i's dotted and t's crossed.... But that don't make it right. Just another shit sandwich forced down everyone throat in George W. Bush and the wall street privatizers America....... Morally repugnant is way too nice a phrase to throw at this shit... Fucking makes me sick!!! Anyone with a brain knows the answer, and unlike the morass that is the presidential campaign or our pathetic foreign policy and bullshit wars of choice.. I damn well have an idea to address this...
A national health care model from cradle to grave paid for by a taxation process. And for those who don't like the idea of a tax to fund a health care model that might prevent the kinds of nightmares I just outlined, please do tell me how you feel about the trillions being burned up over George and Dicks bullshit war of greed and desire to control someone elses oil... Those are tax dollars too you know. 'Our' tax dollars turning the world against us and getting innocent people killed!!!.... If we just stopped doing that, we'd probably have plenty to fund this idea right there with enough pocket change left over to fund publically financed election too.... Yea, I know, that's just crazy talk...
Much better for us to just say to hell with our parents, our middle class, our whole freaking society... After all, there's plenty of money to be made over all this fucking misery........right!!! RIGHT!!! YEA! Yer goddamned right I'm pissed!!!!!! JD
Am I the only one who thinks congress overrode this veto because senior citizens are a HUGE part of the voting block? Sure. it's nice if whatever they are voting for actually benefits someone other than millionaires(here, have another tax cut, and thank you for donating to my re-elction campaign), but I think this is just because they need people to vote for them, nothing else.
I googled it, and found out 42 million people are on Medicare. Next February I turn 65, and add me to that list. I was scared shitless after the first vote failed, and it appeared they would cut the payments to Doctors etc. I'm dumbfounded that Bush could actually still veto that bill. He's an idiot beyond words. I knew he threatened to veto it, but when it was passed veto proof, what kind of a monster would still rub it in the faces of 42 million VOTERS? I consider it a complete insult that McCain didn't consider this important enough to show up for that vote. I know he would have voted against it, so he's with the group who would step over the bodies of their mothers! Of every bill that has gone through Congress lately, nothing has been more critical and would have affected more people than this one. Bush should always be remembered for this heartless act, but then, it does pale in comparison to so much he's done! After the nightmare that our representatives in Washington have been, the final count in both Houses was just amazing! Who could have ever even hoped for a final vote that high?
I wonder if any Dems voted against it, you know, to be bipartisan.
Personally, I'm surprised the spineless Dems overrode a veto. You know, Bush is at a 28 percent approval rating! Most popular president in history!
Well come on! They gotta throw us a peanut every once in a while.
Wait. We have a congress? When did that happen?
Thanks to Ted Kennedy on this one, that's for sure.
Comments are closed on this entry