TOPICS

Howard Fineman: McCain "in danger of trivializing" POW past

  Someone had to say it.

icon Download | play   icon Download | play   (h/t Heather)

"I think they are going to it way too many times. It's the original story that defined John McCain, that still when you read it in his book 'Faith of my Fathers,' when you read about it in 'The Nightingale's Song,' you can't help but have admiration and respect for the guy. And I think he wisely for many years stayed away from it as a political tool, he really did. But now it not only defines him, it's become a crutch in the campaign. And I think he is in danger of trivializing it. By the time they get to the convention in St. Paul, there might not be much of it left to use."

This is just another sad chapter in the tragic descent of John McCain. Sure McCain has used his powerful biography to help him throughout his political career, but I highly doubt he's comfortable with the depths he's now forced to sink to in order to compete for the presidency. Again....tragic.

Brandon Friedman at VetVoice has more...



Login or Register to post comments.

96 comments

sorry.... we have MANY ex-POWs... not all were treated as well as McCain....
and while he SERVED HIS COUNTRY.... so did MANY PEOPLE

all that his experience is good for.... is that if he were captured AGAIN, the 5 years would still be applied toward his attaining SENIOR POW status

it has NOTHING TO DO with being PRESIDENT

This is just another sad chapter in the tragic descent of John McCain.

Tragic, yes, but I fear that it's enough to sway the lizard brains, who are a huge percentage of the American voting public, to vote for him. After the past eight years, it shouldn't even be close. It's looking like 2004 all over again.

2002, 2004 election strategy = 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, ...

2006 they wore out that rallying cry out soooo...

2008 election strategy = POW, POW, POW, POW, POW, POW, POW, POW, POW, POW, POW, ...

There would be more wars, my friends. so don't worry about the POW. as you may know more wars means more POW. McCain needs people to feel the same.

By the way, did anybody read the article about his Vietnamese captors rooting for him now? They want to see him elected. That article didn't last long on main pages, and never been posted here on C&L.

For me it is simple. I appreciate all that you did for your country, but being a POW is not going to make you a better President. If it would, we would have sent George there.

But...but...he KNOWS how to win wars! We must elect him before he reveals his war winning plans. He's not holding out because he's selfish or putting his party before his country or anything like that. It's just straight talk and stuff.

flamethrower @ 3:

2002, 2004 election strategy = 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, 9-11, ...

2006 they wore out that rallying cry out soooo...

2008 election strategy = POW, POW, POW, POW, POW, POW, POW, POW, POW, POW, POW, ...

Wait until he picks Rudy 9-11 9ui11any 9-11 of 9-11 America. did I mention 9-11 my friends? by the way, hint: Obama is a Muslim Christian extremist , he took Friday off from campaign, that means he is a Muslim. my friends, hint: 9-11.

He can't help himself; it's extended post truamatic stress syndrome. He obsessively buys more homes to make up for the five years he spent in just one.

When McCain receives an "unplanned" phone call from one of his Navy buddies in the middle of a speech, you know it's over.

"By the time they get to the convention in St. Paul, there might not be much of it left to use."

seriously, when was the last time any repube
A) tired of repeating the party line,
B) looked closely at the motivating factors of their candidates when they hide behind the party line that they alone are the true patiotic americans,
C) questioned the integrity of one of THEIR war heroes.

Repubes and their kind eat this great american hero and patriot stuff up. any actions after their time in the service is unimportant. Look at Ollie North, selling arms to our enemy and still lauded by the right as one of america's greatest military minds. all becasue he wore his old uniform to the congressional hearings. so all they have now is hiding behind past glories and the cross. and in my mind, that story about the cross in the sand tells alot more about the guards courage and convistion of faith than McCain's. but that is just my humble opinion.

I think he's perfectly comfortable. McCain is a whore of Babylon - probably one of the most "political" politicians around. His "maverick" credentials are built on going against the grain when it means lightbulbs flash and he gets a chance to appear like he is his own man. In the end, he's just been pimped out over and over and over...

The Pentagon has more soul thank John McCain.

No matter what it is, you can only go to the well so many times before the well runs dry.

but...but...but being a POW means knowing how to win wars.

It appears that by taking his elitist vacation in Hawaii Obama in reality gave the McSame camp the opportunity to display the big guns.
Obama certainly isn't a legacy student thrust into the limelight by a disproportionate sense of entitlement.
Multiple dwellings in gated communities can certainly lead someone to believe that it's necessary to have $5 million to be rich.
McSame is not a healthy person. Dunkin Donuts and Coke isn't going to get it.

The following is McCain's 98

McCain Guide on how to win wars for pilots:

1-Wreck the plane into electric cables while pracitcing.
2-In combat, when a missile locked on you, escape from plane immediately.
3-When faced with torture, sign a pledge.
4-After your release, dump your wife.
5-Marry a millionaire wife and enters politics.
6-Say my friends a lot.
7-Argue that torture sometimes is ok to other POWs but change the wordings.
8-Say racist epithet about your previous captors.
9-Run for president and ask for more wars.

McCain guide on how to win wars for presidents:

1-Bomb bomb bomb.
2-Surge surge surge.
3-bomb bomb bomb.
4-More wars, more wars.
5-My friends my friends.
6-bomb bomb bomb.
7-Surge again.
8-Repeat step 1.

i don't find it tragic at all. I think it's hysterically funny.

My friends, noun, verb, POW

my friend @ 7:
Wait until he picks Rudy 9-11 9ui11any 9-11 of 9-11 America. did I mention 9-11 my friends? .

Woah I was off.. it took 6 comments before someone made the obvious 9u11ani anaology.. I was guessing at 5-or-under.

look, he wasn't a very good pilot. that's just a fact. how many planes has he crashed? more than the one that got him captured I know that. and from what i understand his time in captivity wasn't as noble as some would have you believe.

of course nobody can raise these questions because to do so would be to denigrade his service to the country.

but that's exactly how dipshit became president.

by having a more than questionable past that is never studied or questioned by the traditional media.

If Guilliani is picked as McCain's VP -- I suggest that Obama start parading what is left of the 9/11 first responders on stage, who are suing this SOB. They don't show any of the Widows, Firemen, or other people involved anymore -- Guilliani and his cohorts just want to talk about the dead -- because they don't have questions.

McCain can put his illustrious past in a book, and that is fine. But if he uses it as a platform in a campaign, such that he can never be questioned on "I'm the go-to guy for warfare," he leaves it up for grabs as to critically analyze his past experience in war.

From what I've heard, he got to captain a boat, even being last in his class, because his dad was an Admiral. Affirmative action for the country club set came to the rescue.

The boat he was commanding was almost destroyed -- something to do with his drunken behavior and not properly securing explosives. Though I haven't seen that but on one site -- it's worth looking into.

Reportedly, he crashed 4 planes. I don't think that is typical and still be flying. It might mean he wasn't too serious. The 5th plane crash, probably led to him being a POW.

He did not "Stay to be with his men" -- he couldn't leave because his Dad was involved with shelling the crap out of Vietnam.

His nickname was the Canary, because he sang either 3 days or 3 hours after mistreatment. After that he made 30 or 40 videos for the Viet Cong propaganda -- would they mistreat their star?

I'm not 100% sure about any of this, because really -- we don't KNOW what happened. There was more proof of Kerry's heroism than McCains. But getting shot at, while a service to the country (if the country would actually get involved in wars that weren't for resources that is), doesn't tell me beans about character and the ability to guide a country.

The important thing to note, is there is no evidence of McCain having any intelligence in warfare. He's been against Veterans benefits at every turn, and wanted a 12 year requirement for Vets to get education -- that's like saying NO. He was in the way of Ross Perot trying to find POWs left in Vietnam. And, when looking deeper into this "Maverick Moderate" since he started kissing the hands that beat him in the Bush administration -- he seems to be a Class A Asshole and womanizer.

Another Republican phony.

Sung to the tune of Frere Jacque http://songsforteaching.com/french/soyonsamis/frerejacquesareyousleeping... :

John McAnus John Mc Anus
Is so famous Is so famous
He came to save us He came to save us
Now he blames us Now he blames us

New campaign slogan: "Vote McCain and We'll All Be POW's." (:>

You can't criticize John McCain for over-exploiting his POWness. The man was a POW, for christ's sake!

Nobody is going to vote for or against McCain because he's an ex-POW. That's just more irrelevant bullshit to argue about. The neocons are going to vote for him because he's the lesser of two evils.

We're going to vote against him because he sucks donkey nuts.

Over at Kos, someone has made up a Monopoly card for McCain. It's a, "POW, get out of gaffe free", card.

Rusty The One Shackleford @ 23:

You can't criticize John McCain for over-exploiting his POWness. The man was a POW, for christ's sake!

________________________________
Oh ya ! Well your last name is Shackleford, right ? Well, Mr. Rusty Shackleford --of course you think that way about POW-ness because the first part of your last name is Shackle(s).

(tongue in cheek sarcasm)

To suggest that John McCain, a former prisoner of war, would play the POW card, is an outrage.

I highly doubt he’s comfortable with the depths he’s now forced to sink to

You seem to be free-falling into a previously-established, very-convenient-for-McCain narrative. The harsh realities of politics have laid another good man low. Poor McCain, good hero daddy elect daddy good.
Nobody forced him. He hired the people who slimed his own family.

pissed off patricia @ 25:

Over at Kos, someone has made up a Monopoly card for McCain. It's a, "POW, get out of gaffe free", card.

I read a joke this morning at Huffington about John McCain owning enough houses to have a McCain version of monopoly.

V&A @ 20 Check out the Wikipedia for the 1968 USS Forrestal Fire to see how our patriotic flyboy behaved. Or google Vietnam Veterans against John McCain. This guy is a real piece of work. But you could probably have a beer with him as long as you buy it from his wife.

McCain is a trivial person. He trivializes war, torture, integrity, honesty, etc., etc.

He trivializes everything he speaks of in order to secure his longstanding ambition to be president and prove his worth to his dead Daddy.

He, like Georgie, will do or say anything to finally show the world, he is somebody. These are very sick folks.....

Joe Bourgeois @ 28:

I highly doubt he’s comfortable with the depths he’s now forced to sink to

You seem to be free-falling into a previously-established, very-convenient-for-McCain narrative. The harsh realities of politics have laid another good man low. Poor McCain, good hero daddy elect daddy good.
Nobody forced him. He hired the people who slimed his own family.

I would bet money that the GOP made a deal with McCain to allow him to be the nominee. And it went something like, "Only if you know how to be a puppet, John." And he said, "OK".

CafeenMan @ 24:

Nobody is going to vote for or against McCain because he's an ex-POW. That's just more irrelevant bullshit to argue about. The neocons are going to vote for him because he's the lesser of two evils.

We're going to vote against him because he sucks donkey nuts.

The neocons won't vote him as the lesser of two evils. They'll vote because he's supportive of neocon policies.

Ryko @ 33:

CafeenMan @ 24:

Nobody is going to vote for or against McCain because he's an ex-POW. That's just more irrelevant bullshit to argue about. The neocons are going to vote for him because he's the lesser of two evils.

We're going to vote against him because he sucks donkey nuts.

The neocons won't vote him as the lesser of two evils. They'll vote because he's supportive of neocon policies.

Yeah, but he's not as crazy (by sane people's definition) as the neocons want him to be. Their first choice is somebody not nearly as left-wing as Coulter.

I'm sure mccain is embarrassed by this use of his past war experience and captivity. The guys I served with never speak of any of went on in Vietnam
or Korea. Yesterdays are painful.

I'm sure this is the work of the Rove machine pushing desperately in the background deathly afraid of a loss of all three branches of Government to the Dems. As it is, many who served bush will be afraid to leave the shores of the USA for fear of being scooped up in War Trial hunts which I think will be hanging out there.

my friend @ 15:

3-When faced with torture, sign a pledge.

Nothing wrong with that in my book. What's foolish, IMHO, is his refusal of early release because it was 'out of turn'. As if others wouldn't have jumped at the chance. But that's a no-go for the Admiral's Son. There's a fine line between being a martyr, which is admirable, and making yourself one, which is plain stupid.

That's okay though. If McCain decided in Vietnam to follow macho pride and refusal to lose face, even over bullshit propaganda, that's okay. Because ultimately McCain was the only one to suffer for that decision.

What really scares me, is the fact that he's brought this same attitude into his politics. And that's dangerous because as President, McCain is not the one who suffers over that kind of decision. America is. It'll be American lives and American tax-payer's money that will continue to be spent on a war in Iraq that neither Americans nor the Iraqis want. A war based on lies, with no clear 'victory' or definition thereof in sight. A war which according to many, is simply unwinnable. There are limits to what the USA can hope to achieve there.

We must win it. We'll "never surrender" (whatever that would mean). And for what? Ultimately, to save face. It's telling that McCain holds the same attitude towards Vietnam. He firmly believes the USA could have won that wildly unpopular war. Even though it's almost as hard to envision what 'victory' would have meant there.

It's frightening. And it's a continuation of the failed foreign policies of Bush, which will go down as the worst in US history, I believe. Even Kissinger was better! For all his Machiavellian traits, at least his policy were based on reality. Not pride or wishful thinking.

I disagree with Fineman. Oh, I think McCain will be milking the POW bit until Nov 8th. The McCain camp has barely begun to swiftboat Obama, as evidenced today with this news tidbit:

WASHINGTON (AP) — A conservative nonprofit group with a past link to Sen. John McCain's presidential campaign wants to spend $2.8 million on an ad questioning Democrat Barack Obama's relationship to a founder of the 1960s radical group Weather Underground.

The ad, which is expected to begin airing Thursday in Michigan and Friday in Ohio, focuses on William Ayers, whose Weatherman organization took credit for a series of bombings, including nonfatal explosions at the Pentagon and U.S. Capitol four decades ago.

Just as the did to Kerry, by the time the election comes some people will believe it's a choice between a POW war hero or a black guy who was part of a radical 60's "terrorist" oragnization.

Time is running out for the Obama camp. They must attack.

I think they've already jumped the shark on this one, when they claimed that John McCain can't remember how many houses he owns because he was a POW!!!! It's made it seem not only silly, but did being a POW damage John McCain so mentally that he can't remember things and he imagines things that never happened????

Being a POW can be heoric, but it can also just be sad and pathetic.

I've noticed that they are starting a new line of defense though. Everything is Cindy McCain's fault. She is the rich one, she owns the houses, and she made up the lie about Mother Theresa and the adoption. They are now throwing Cindy McCain under the bus in an attempt to save John. So John is a victim of Cindy as well as the Vietnamese.

"This is just another sad chapter in the tragic descent of John McCain. Sure McCain has used his powerful biography to help him throughout his political career, but I highly doubt he’s comfortable with the depths he’s now forced to sink to in order to compete for the presidency. Again….tragic."

Ever since he won the GOP nomination, McSame has become a prisoner again, a prisoner of the Republican party. A POTRP if you will.

sad & tragic.

What did McCain think they were going to do, throw spitballs at him? Or that they'd want to prepare indictments and offer therapy and understanding for their attackers?

He's lucky his treatment was like a college fraternity prank that stacked up naked men. I'm talking about people having a good time, these people, you ever heard of emotional release? You ever heard of need to blow some steam off?

McCain was never tortured, according to the Bush/Cheney/McCain definition of "enhanced interrogation."

So why does he brag about it all the time? A little enhanced interrogation is no big deal, and it's been going on in Gitmo for more than five years to hundreds of un-tried captives.

Why is McCain so bitter when he wasn't even tortured?

Yeah, but he’s not as crazy (by sane people’s definition) as the neocons want him to be.

I disagree. It seems more and more clear that McCain fits the primary qualification for neoconhood: He never saw a war he didn't like.

It's the social cons, the Bible-thumpers, who are holding their noses and voting for McCain. The neocons will be pulling the lever with enthusiasm.

foolme1ns @ 38:

I think they've already jumped the shark on this one, when they claimed that John McCain can't remember how many houses he owns because he was a POW!!!! It's made it seem not only silly, but did being a POW damage John McCain so mentally that he can't remember things and he imagines things that never happened????

Being a POW can be heoric, but it can also just be sad and pathetic.

I've noticed that they are starting a new line of defense though. Everything is Cindy McCain's fault. She is the rich one, she owns the houses, and she made up the lie about Mother Theresa and the adoption. They are now throwing Cindy McCain under the bus in an attempt to save John. So John is a victim of Cindy as well as the Vietnamese.

Yes, but if that bus mangles Cindy McCain's face and limbs, John McCain will dump her faster than his opposition to bush's tax cuts for the wealthy.

If McCain wins, I'm actually afraid we will be saying "we're all POWs now"...

...in Russian.

I’m sure mccain is embarrassed by this use of his past war experience and captivity.

I'd like to think so, but I have a hard time believing McCain isn't beyond embarrassment at this point.

Or to sum it up, McCain seems to think that you can 'win' simply by refusing to 'lose'. I guess that's why he ended up 894th in his class at the Naval Academy.

Had he been a better student, maybe he'd have paid attention to his Sun-tzu..

Thus it is that in war the victorious strategist only seeks battle after the victory has been won, whereas he who is destined to defeat first fights and afterwards looks for victory.

Donald Hussein Cormac @ 22:

New campaign slogan: "Vote McCain and We'll All Be POW's." (:>

LOVE it!

McCaint Remember @ 43:

foolme1ns @ 38:

I think they've already jumped the shark on this one, when they claimed that John McCain can't remember how many houses he owns because he was a POW!!!! It's made it seem not only silly, but did being a POW damage John McCain so mentally that he can't remember things and he imagines things that never happened????

Being a POW can be heoric, but it can also just be sad and pathetic.

I've noticed that they are starting a new line of defense though. Everything is Cindy McCain's fault. She is the rich one, she owns the houses, and she made up the lie about Mother Theresa and the adoption. They are now throwing Cindy McCain under the bus in an attempt to save John. So John is a victim of Cindy as well as the Vietnamese.

Yes, but if that bus mangles Cindy McCain's face and limbs, John McCain will dump her faster than his opposition to bush's tax cuts for the wealthy.

The power that wealth creates will save the marriage under all circumstances.

theWalrus @ 37:

I disagree with Fineman. Oh, I think McCain will be milking the POW bit until Nov 8th. The McCain camp has barely begun to swiftboat Obama, as evidenced today with this news tidbit:

WASHINGTON (AP) — A conservative nonprofit group

Who knew there was such a thing?

Harry R. Sohl @ 44:

If McCain wins, I'm actually afraid we will be saying "we're all POWs now"...

...in Russian.

I'm thinking of running for president in 2060 or 2064 so this may come in handy.

(crashes plane into Moscow, deeeep in enemy territory)

Ron @ 48:

McCaint Remember @ 43:

foolme1ns @ 38:

I think they've already jumped the shark on this one, when they claimed that John McCain can't remember how many houses he owns because he was a POW!!!! It's made it seem not only silly, but did being a POW damage John McCain so mentally that he can't remember things and he imagines things that never happened????

Being a POW can be heoric, but it can also just be sad and pathetic.

I've noticed that they are starting a new line of defense though. Everything is Cindy McCain's fault. She is the rich one, she owns the houses, and she made up the lie about Mother Theresa and the adoption. They are now throwing Cindy McCain under the bus in an attempt to save John. So John is a victim of Cindy as well as the Vietnamese.

Yes, but if that bus mangles Cindy McCain's face and limbs, John McCain will dump her faster than his opposition to bush's tax cuts for the wealthy.

The power that wealth creates will save the marriage under all circumstances.

what if McCain finds a young twenty-something worth TWICE what Cindy is worth ??

buh-bye Beer Baroness

McCaint Remember @ 50:

Ron @ 48:

McCaint Remember @ 43:

foolme1ns @ 38:

Yes, but if that bus mangles Cindy McCain's face and limbs, John McCain will dump her faster than his opposition to bush's tax cuts for the wealthy.

The power that wealth creates will save the marriage under all circumstances.

what if McCain finds a young twenty-something worth TWICE what Cindy is worth ??

buh-bye Beer Baroness

Hands off--she's mine!

Alexdem @ 46:

Or to sum it up, McCain seems to think that you can 'win' simply by refusing to 'lose'. I guess that's why he ended up 894th in his class at the Naval Academy.

Had he been a better student, maybe he'd have paid attention to his Sun-tzu..

Thus it is that in war the victorious strategist only seeks battle after the victory has been won, whereas he who is destined to defeat first fights and afterwards looks for victory.

Know what you call a doctor who finished last in his class at med school?

A doctor.

dennis @ 52:

Know what you call a doctor who finished last in his class at med school?

A doctor.

But also, on occasion:

A malpractice suit. :)

Alexdem @ 18:

my friend @ 7:
Wait until he picks Rudy 9-11 9ui11any 9-11 of 9-11 America. did I mention 9-11 my friends? .

Woah I was off.. it took 6 comments before someone made the obvious 9u11ani anaology.. I was guessing at 5-or-under.

Between Guili, Mittens, and McMansions , the RNC will sound like "911, Reagan, POW, 911, Reagan, POW,911, Reagan, POW,911, Reagan, POW,911, Reagan, POW,911, Reagan, POW, 911...." with some squeeking from Lieberman.
Man, it's gonna be great.

StirFry @ 54:

Alexdem @ 18:

my friend @ 7:
Wait until he picks Rudy 9-11 9ui11any 9-11 of 9-11 America. did I mention 9-11 my friends? .

Woah I was off.. it took 6 comments before someone made the obvious 9u11ani anaology.. I was guessing at 5-or-under.

Between Guili, Mittens, and McMansions , the RNC will sound like "911, Reagan, POW, 911, Reagan, POW,911, Reagan, POW,911, Reagan, POW,911, Reagan, POW,911, Reagan, POW, 911...." with some squeeking from Lieberman.
Man, it's gonna be great.

RNC convention drinking game:

1. Take a shot if Reagan is mentioned

2. Take a shot if Sept. 11th is mentioned.

3. Take a shot if McCain being a POW is mentioned.

Be ready to call 911 in case someone gets alcohol poisoning.

How did boosh shutout the POW in 2000? If it works don't fix it.

dennis @ 52:

Know what you call a doctor who finished last in his class at med school?

A doctor.

True. But when he kills five of his patients you'd probably think twice about trusting him with your life.

I really don't understand why being a POW gives anyone "bragging rights". If you are a POW, that means that the "enemy" captured you and you failed at your mission. If he was shot down, then he did not do his job. That is the worst thing a soldier can do is to end up in "enemy" hands. It is not surprising that the dumb ass McDipstick (495th in a class of 500) did get shot down! Anyone that stupid should have been given a desk job. Certainly being captured does not make you a hero of any kind.

We know absolutely nothing about what he did after he failed as a pilot. We seem to have only McCain's constantly changing moronic anecdotes to go by. The creep is a compulsive liar and criminal. Remember that the "war" that he was fighting in was another bogus war against "world communism". Now McBush is a big supporter of shipping American jobs to the communist Chinese. What a total piece of shit that asshole is.

This Crazy Grandpa victimhood predicament falls totally on the lap of the Vietnamese.....they're the ones who let this fucker go.

Rusty The One Shackleford @ 57:

dennis @ 52:

Know what you call a doctor who finished last in his class at med school?

A doctor.

True. But when he kills five of his patients you'd probably think twice about trusting him with your life.

The guy at the top of the class can just as easily do the same thing, Russ. Both at med schools and the Naval Academy.

dennis @ 60:

Rusty The One Shackleford @ 57:

dennis @ 52:

Know what you call a doctor who finished last in his class at med school?

A doctor.

True. But when he kills five of his patients you'd probably think twice about trusting him with your life.

The guy at the top of the class can just as easily do the same thing, Russ. Both at med schools and the Naval Academy.

Could be, could be. But McCain actually did wreck five planes. I don't have the info at hand but I'll wager you the guys who graduated at the top of his class were far more competent than McCain turned out to be. Maybe if they had known how beneficial to one's career and pocketbook being a fuck-up could be, they would have gone McCain's route. Who knows?

McCain's primary political weakness was in not taking the moral high ground during the entire Bush administration. Instead, he chose to be the butt boy for George and Karl, the same George and Karl that f'd him in the a when he was running in 2000. How could McCain expect anyone to respect him, when he behaved so shamelessly by befriending his true political enemies. Tsk. Tsk.

dennis @ 60:

Rusty The One Shackleford @ 57:

dennis @ 52:

Know what you call a doctor who finished last in his class at med school?

A doctor.

True. But when he kills five of his patients you'd probably think twice about trusting him with your life.

The guy at the top of the class can just as easily do the same thing, Russ. Both at med schools and the Naval Academy.

Wow Dennis. A stroll into apologyville. Maybe we should disregard any form of statistical achievement indicators. Slackers like Grandpa would just love you.
Go ahead and be the first to say it....were picking on the old man.

Left&Left @ 64:

dennis @ 60:

Rusty The One Shackleford @ 57:

dennis @ 52:
True. But when he kills five of his patients you'd probably think twice about trusting him with your life.

The guy at the top of the class can just as easily do the same thing, Russ. Both at med schools and the Naval Academy.

Wow Dennis. A stroll into apologyville. Maybe we should disregard any form of statistical achievement indicators. Slackers like Grandpa would just love you.
Go ahead and be the first to say it....were picking on the old man.

LMAO!!!
dennis...true they are both capable of screwing up and costing someone their life...but WHICH is more likely to screw up? The one who graduated top of the class, or the one who graduated 5th from the bottom?

Oh, you think THIS is a sad chapter in John McCain's life? Well, let me tell you about ANOTHER sad chapter in John McCain's life...the five years he spent in Vietnam!

So, you see that your criticism is totally invalid and you should be ashamed of yourself.

Noun, verb, POW.

Big Russ, Left², and libNmod-

Carter graduated 59th at the Naval Academy out of a class of 820, Russ. I won't criticize him here but his Presidency will not go down in history as being stellar. Not top 7%, anyway. Unfortunately for Dems, they like to cling to the meme that Republican presidents and candidates for president are dumb fuck-ups, but the examples of the last two Dem presidents and their respective class ranks hardly makes a compelling argument that we should be concerned by that number.

You guys want to make the case that he was a fuck-up in his early years, so therefore he must be a fuck-up throughout his life. While at the same time you argue that he was once a maverick and a decent politician, but he's somehow now lost his way. Because he may now possibly be the next President, the decency he once possessed is now gone, but the negatives he had in his youth are forever. Am I getting that right? Funny how that works when someone runs for office.

He's no different than Gulianni. With Gulianni it was NOUN... VERB... 9/11

With McCain its NOUN... VERB... POW

Guess when all you have to show for your years is being a POW equates to experience, you run into the ground which McCain is doing nicely.

JasonS @ 66:

Oh, you think THIS is a sad chapter in John McCain's life? Well, let me tell you about ANOTHER sad chapter in John McCain's life...the five years he spent in Vietnam!

So, you see that your criticism is totally invalid and you should be ashamed of yourself.

Noun, verb, POW.

5 1/2 years as a POW is a dreadful experience! Sorry though, POW status alone isn't a qualification for President. In fact it it's the opposite. It scares me think how that will affect McCain's judgment in time of crisis. 8 years ago I thought it would make him a pacifist. After the "bomb bomb bomb Iran" song and dance, it scared the hell out of me that McCain (and not George W) would be the one to start nuclear war. McCain WILL lead us into WAR and millions of people will lose life and limb for what? The fight for freedom is here and now in America. Not in Iraq or Iran or some other country that we've blown back into the 16th century.

Rusty The One Shackleford @ 61:

Could be, could be. But McCain actually did wreck five planes. I don't have the info at hand but I'll wager you the guys who graduated at the top of his class were far more competent than McCain turned out to be. Maybe if they had known how beneficial to one's career and pocketbook being a fuck-up could be, they would have gone McCain's route. Who knows?

Well, I think Wesley Clarke made the better point when he pointed out that McCain retired a Captain. Respectable, but 'only' a middle-management type of position, so to speak. Presumably there was reason for it. But what's more important than whether he deserved it or not, is that he simply was never in one of those strategical, policy-making positions.

To continue that analogy.. Hospital administrators/Chiefs of Medicine are often doctors. That doesn't mean a doctor, who hasn't served in that position, is necessarily any good at it.

And we do happen to have a few of those upper-management types around in the political arena. General Clarke is one example, General Powell another. And I think it's noteworthy that both of them have taken a considerably less hawkish stance on Iraq than McCain has.

dennis @ 67:

Big Russ, Left², and libNmod-

Carter graduated 59th at the Naval Academy out of a class of 820, Russ. I won't criticize him here but his Presidency will not go down in history as being stellar. Not top 7%, anyway. Unfortunately for Dems, they like to cling to the meme that Republican presidents and candidates for president are dumb fuck-ups, but the examples of the last two Dem presidents and their respective class ranks hardly makes a compelling argument that we should be concerned by that number.

You guys want to make the case that he was a fuck-up in his early years, so therefore he must be a fuck-up throughout his life. While at the same time you argue that he was once a maverick and a decent politician, but he's somehow now lost his way. Because he may now possibly be the next President, the decency he once possessed is now gone, but the negatives he had in his youth are forever. Am I getting that right? Funny how that works when someone runs for office.

McCain HAS been a fuck-up throughout his life, just like Bush has been. This is amply demonstrated by his inability to keep even the simplest facts straight throughout this campaign. That doesn't concern you, fine. But it should. Unless you have enjoyed the quality of the Bush administration, in which case there's really no hope for you.

As for your swipe at Clinton: if I'm not mistaken, lil' d, you occupy some lilypad in the financial sector swamp. I don't even have to ask you which recent president exercised the most fiscal restraint, and presided over the most economic prosperity, because I know you know. And it hurts, doesn't it? Because you guys just hate him so much.

dennis @ 67:

Big Russ, Left², and libNmod-

Carter graduated 59th at the Naval Academy out of a class of 820, Russ. I won't criticize him here but his Presidency will not go down in history as being stellar. Not top 7%, anyway. Unfortunately for Dems, they like to cling to the meme that Republican presidents and candidates for president are dumb fuck-ups, but the examples of the last two Dem presidents and their respective class ranks hardly makes a compelling argument that we should be concerned by that number.

You guys want to make the case that he was a fuck-up in his early years, so therefore he must be a fuck-up throughout his life. While at the same time you argue that he was once a maverick and a decent politician, but he's somehow now lost his way. Because he may now possibly be the next President, the decency he once possessed is now gone, but the negatives he had in his youth are forever. Am I getting that right? Funny how that works when someone runs for office.

He was never a maverick; he was a sleaze with good p.r.
He was the main player in Keating Five. Name one policy in which McSame was a maverick. McCain-Feingold? He managed to worm out of that, didn't he?

Howard is now doing as other Bushie Journalist have been doing lately turning on the GOP to save their job. Howard has lie/spin/blame others for the mistakes and crimes of the GOP and White House for 7 years now that it looks like a Democrat will get in office their all changing their stories as if they had lied before.

Thank you Brandon this has needed to be said for a long time now. We EM out here understand that when it comes to Hero if an officer does it it's always some how bigger or better but john boy is special you see he is Admiral McCains boy Johnny

So you highly doubt McCain is comfortable with the depths he’s now "forced" to sink to? You are a trusting soul, indeed. Ever since I've been following politics (30 years now) he's always been a contemptible, power-abusing creep. He's just now less adept at masking it, now that he's reached his twilight years.

Sorry about #76 above--posted in the wrong comments!

dennis @ 68:

Big Russ, Left², and libNmod-

Carter graduated 59th at the Naval Academy out of a class of 820, Russ. I won't criticize him here but his Presidency will not go down in history as being stellar. Not top 7%, anyway. Unfortunately for Dems, they like to cling to the meme that Republican presidents and candidates for president are dumb fuck-ups, but the examples of the last two Dem presidents and their respective class ranks hardly makes a compelling argument that we should be concerned by that number.

You guys want to make the case that he was a fuck-up in his early years, so therefore he must be a fuck-up throughout his life. While at the same time you argue that he was once a maverick and a decent politician, but he's somehow now lost his way. Because he may now possibly be the next President, the decency he once possessed is now gone, but the negatives he had in his youth are forever. Am I getting that right? Funny how that works when someone runs for office.

Come dude, don't use that "maverick" bullshit myth...you know that Grandpa's moniker is for the criminally dumb. The greatest thing Grandpa ever did in his entitled, underachieving life(besides gold digging that beer bitch) was crashing his civilian murdering plane and becoming a POW. McGeezer has played along like a good Repuke soldier(even when those vile assholes totally disrespected him and his family(where was his "honor" then?) and he has benefited from that.
Crazy Grandpa and his pathetic "you owe me America" attitude is hardly any different than one of those Vietnam vets begging for change at the street corner.

George @ 70:

JasonS @ 66:

Oh, you think THIS is a sad chapter in John McCain's life? Well, let me tell you about ANOTHER sad chapter in John McCain's life...the five years he spent in Vietnam!

So, you see that your criticism is totally invalid and you should be ashamed of yourself.

Noun, verb, POW.

5 1/2 years as a POW is a dreadful experience! Sorry though, POW status alone isn't a qualification for President. In fact it it's the opposite. It scares me think how that will affect McCain's judgment in time of crisis. 8 years ago I thought it would make him a pacifist. After the "bomb bomb bomb Iran" song and dance, it scared the hell out of me that McCain (and not George W) would be the one to start nuclear war. McCain WILL lead us into WAR and millions of people will lose life and limb for what? The fight for freedom is here and now in America. Not in Iraq or Iran or some other country that we've blown back into the 16th century.

Yes, but you forget: noun, verb, POW. Therefore you have no right to question John McCain. Just sit back, relax, and enjoy the mavericky straight talk.

John McCain is a maverick....to the truth.

Left&Left @ 80:

John McCain is a maverick....to the truth.

Well, facts have a well-known liberal bias.

The gop produced a real stinker this election cycle. This old man doesn't have any other redeeming qualities so they try the pathetic "pow" card after Obama rightly identifies him to America as a rich elitist. The guy is toast.

Samuel @ 82:

The gop produced a real stinker this election cycle. This old man doesn't have any other redeeming qualities so they try the pathetic "pow" card after Obama rightly identifies him to America as a rich elitist. The guy is toast.

The GOP knew from the polling that this was going to be a bad year. That's why they went with McCain. They weren't going to sacrifice any of their political bench stars' futures in a no win year.

They pushed for and nominated the old guy and hoped they could throw a hail mary touchdown pass by using attack ads and lies against Obama.

I guess it's not surprising that Mccain doesn't know much about the economy. They probably weren't allowed to carry any money or conduct business in his POW camp where he draws from for most of his life experience.

Oh and it'll be great fun over the next 4 years anytime we face a crisis for the Whitehouse to simply reply, "Don't blame us! The president was a POW. That's a get out of jail free card don't ya know?!" That will work really well.

McCain is going to get Brain Cancer!
Every time he is shown on the news, when he is not talking that cellphone is glued to his ear.
Oh wait, I forgot that Republicans don't believe in that crap, since not being a believer means it won't happen to them
Just like they don't believe in Climate Change, if they don't believe in a theory it won't happen!
Just like "Time Tables" for withdrawal from Iraq... What? oh... now Bush believes in time tables!
How's that tumor working out for you?

You watch,tho, it'll work:

John McCain isn't "out of touch" because he can't remember how many houses he has. He's living the American dream?

The REAL question here is why it upsets Obama so much. Why does he hate success? Only an effete, argula-eating, liberal elitist would criticize someone for being TOO RICH.

And then Obama will make some comment about deciding whether to send his kids to private school (or something) and the script will reverse:

Well, it's all well and good for an out of touch, effete, liberal elitist to have "educational choice," I guess. Too bad Barack Obama doesn't want regular, hard working parents to have the same choices he has!

It'll work, too.

Arliss @ 85:

McCain is going to get Brain Cancer!
Every time he is shown on the news, when he is not talking that cellphone is glued to his ear.
Oh wait, I forgot that Republicans don't believe in that crap, since not being a believer means it won't happen to them
Just like they don't believe in Climate Change, if they don't believe in a theory it won't happen!
Just like "Time Tables" for withdrawal from Iraq... What? oh... now Bush believes in time tables!
How's that tumor working out for you?

You take that back! You take that back! Bush does NOT believe in arbitrary, namby-pamby, defeatocrat whiner time tables!

He's endorsing a common-sense, cool-headed time FRAME, based on the situation on the ground and listening to the generals so we can have victory.

Get it straight or....or I'll...or....FUCK IT!!!! WE'LL DO IT LIVE!!!!

I never understood the mystical nature of the veteran status to begin with. All it really says about a person is that they know enough to not get shot in the middle of a war.. and McCain, being a POW, has only shown that he doesn't know that much.

I highly doubt he’s comfortable with the depths he’s now forced to sink to in order to compete for the presidency. Again….tragic.

I would disagree. I think he is totally comfortable with it. He has sold his soul for the White House. He is accepting help from people who lied about him and exposed his wife to scorn in 2000 and now he licks their feet. These people will expect payback for a job well done if he is elected and their policies are not those that will benefit the middle class or the poor. We must keep the War Machine going to feed the Military Industrial Complex which benefits only the rich.

is there a reason the image is of Faux and Friends Mr. Admin?

Anyone willing to use the horrid abuse of their captivity as a supposed reason they are "better" than another person running for political office is not only a fool, but a fool full of themselves.

Hundreds of thousands of veterans of wars past could not bring themselves to talk of the atrocities and heartbreak of war. Not even to their own family members.

But here we have a guy who was supposedly tortured near death (though our current administration claims that type of conduct today is NOT torture) yapping about that experience as the reason he is a hero and more worthy of public office.

My, how modest.

Aha, so McPOW is in danger of committing 9iu11iani's 9/11 9/11 9/11 mistake.

Donald Hussein Cormac @ 22:

New campaign slogan: "Vote McCain and We'll All Be POW's." (:>

:)

CafeenMan @ 32:

Joe Bourgeois @ 28:

I highly doubt he’s comfortable with the depths he’s now forced to sink to

You seem to be free-falling into a previously-established, very-convenient-for-McCain narrative. The harsh realities of politics have laid another good man low. Poor McCain, good hero daddy elect daddy good.
Nobody forced him. He hired the people who slimed his own family.

I would bet money that the GOP made a deal with McCain to allow him to be the nominee. And it went something like, "Only if you know how to be a puppet, John." And he said, "OK".

Oh yeah, for sure. I couldn't agree more. Too bad they picked a puppet that can't speak well, but it worked with bu$h too.

Liberal AND Proud @ 83:

Samuel @ 82:

The gop produced a real stinker this election cycle. This old man doesn't have any other redeeming qualities so they try the pathetic "pow" card after Obama rightly identifies him to America as a rich elitist. The guy is toast.

The GOP knew from the polling that this was going to be a bad year. That's why they went with McCain. They weren't going to sacrifice any of their political bench stars' futures in a no win year.

They pushed for and nominated the old guy and hoped they could throw a hail mary touchdown pass by using attack ads and lies against Obama.

They weren't going to sacrifice any of their political bench stars' futures in a no win year

bench stars ???

wtf ???

I don't recognize most of these names, and the ones I do recognize are way past their prime

some of these guys never had a prime

this guy is dead ...

some days, a good movie quote says it best

let's look at the gop "bench"

rudy, mitt, huckleberry, the condiliar, jeb, jidal ...

see a name there that ain't a fucking joke ???

Heh, I guess if FAUX NOISE is allowed to "mistakenly" run the William Ayers ad instead of the McCain ad, C&L is allowed to mistakenly put up the William Ayers ad instead of a picture of Howard Fineman. ;)

96 comments

Login or Register to post comments.