September 10, 2008 08:12 PM
Candidates' Forum on National Service Open Thread
CNN [also being aired on MSNBC]:
Sens. John McCain and Barack Obama will come together Thursday night for half-hour appearances at a TIME-sponsored forum on national service at Columbia University in New York.
The candidates will not speak together at the forum, but they will both participate in a discussion about national service with Time Managing Editor Rick Stengel and PBS's Judy Woodruff.
[WWII National Service poster from here]




first!
Second!
Not even 10 minutes into this thing and McCain's already lying about "Georgia invading South Ossetia!!"
For God's sake, would someone in the media set him straight on this B.S.????
In McCain's defense (you won't hear me say that often), the Russia/Georgia thing is really a matter of perceptive. Personally, I think Russia in the right to invade Georgia, but more importantly... I didn't give a damn about it.
McCain believes that all the volunteer services are overstaffed with volunteers.
Does he believe this shit or does he just make it up?
woohoo - public sector question
why is he pushing volunteers so much?
uh oh, now they're playing gustav as a "get out of katrina free" card
"Have you chosen your job, if not do it today"
Personally, I'm more in favor of "We're at war and you don't get a f'ing choice!" model - it seems to discourage jingoism.
k @ 5:
...it's, uh... kinda what this whole shindig is about, more or less. :p
McCain's exploiting this forum to peddle the same BS as his Nazi-like
propaganda machine.
pow time!
The Realist @ 8:
hmmm, or is it?
k @ 5:
Not just pushing volunteers, but pushing the role of government.
That's because he is in NY.
When he's in Alabama...he'll be spitting venom at the idea of government as a solution.
McCain doesn't believe in anything but being President...to satisfy his ego.
He's a shill and a fake...a lying sack of shit with no scruples who would sell out his mother to win an election.
I refuse to watch. That Palin interview shook me to the core. They are beating the drums for Russia now. Serenity Now!
Is he fucking kidding ?
He "doesn't like talking about it" (his being a POW) ; it's all he fucking has , like 9/11 was all Drooliani had ............
What a lying , poisonous , treasonous , snake...............
Where the hell is "Wharshington"? Is this another country this warped SOB wants to bomb?
omg, mccain is coming down on colombia's non-recruiter rules
they trying to get us amped up for the draft?
Being a military man, I kind of agree with McCain, as far as allowing students the option of ROTC.
CNN [also being aired on MSNBC]:
also cspan.
I do like that their super fast response to the non event of hurricane custav seems to absolve them of the still horrifying lack of response to katrina.
He said I'm not a hero ..... I totally agree
But then he said we are meeting our recruitment goals
And then he said we are not meeting our quota
McWetstart's idea of "public service" is "block watchers". Welcome to Nazi America.
I hate to send people to another blog, but Huffpo right now has a lovely red headline....
mccain on financial rewards, oh bejeezus
I'll be glad to spend money .....
still dissing the govt
we have distinct govt role
YOU ARE THE F&*CKIN GOVT
This is news to me, that McCain has a bill calling for a compulsory draft?!
Whaddup with that?
wow, throwing community organizer at him, i likey
"The tone would have been different if I had had my way. Wah, wah."
What a damn joke.
Abby@26, I think it was crafted a year ago. If they reinstate the draft. There will be no deferments.
Also on C-Span:
http://www.c-span.org/
Real Player:
http://www.c-span.org/Watch/C-SPAN_rm.aspx
Windows Media Video:
http://www.c-span.org/Watch/C-SPAN_wm.aspx
awww, the town halls line
He defends Palin's community organizer insult
did he just admit he was out of touch?
Of course the tenure of the campaign is Baracks fault for not having town hall meeting - nice placement!
A-Hole
john mccain will tell any lie and put anything at risk to win. sickening.
I just caught McSame in a gaffe!!!!
He said that Jack Kennedy and Barry Goldwater had town hall debates, but those two didn't run against each other. It was Johnson vs. Goldwater.
He screws it up again.
If McCain believes in service...he should go volunteer in a nursing home.
OH....and he's lying about Palin again....he's blaming the victim...and he is just plain full of shit.
I believe in this program and that program...yeah...but he won't say how he's gonna pay for it...typical Republican...EVERYONE volunteer...but we won't provide any funding...so...pay for your own room and board and supplies, etc....good luck to you...God Bless America.
Wrinkled up old piece of shit.
I'm the student leader the Social Media & Democracy research group at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. We conducted a survey of political blog readers in 2006 and are following that up with a new study this year. This is a two-part study, the second part of which will happen after the elections in November. We would greatly appreciate if you could take 15-20 minutes to participate in the survey. Click here to access it.
If you are interested in our research group, we have a new and in-progress web site up, which has some of the papers we've produced with more on the way:
http://www.journalism.wisc.edu/smad/
The group is overseen by Professor Dhavan Shah, and if you have questions about the study you can contact him at dshah@wisc.edu or myself at asveenstra@wisc.edu. We hope to have initial results on our site by November and results from the full study by early 2009. Thanks for your help, we greatly appreciate it!
govt can't do it all - how about doing what it is supposed to do??
What a pig!
he's kinda saying, rely on your volunteers, and go f yourselves
P.D. @ 29:
I knew Rangel had a bill calling for compulsory draft for everyone ages 18-42 in the House of Reps, for both men and women, but it's been tabled I think.
JoeMarasmus @ 36:
The Kennedy/Goldwater thing was a myth that never happened. It was believed that the two were going to go across the country and do a bunch of town hall meetings together. Hell, they were even going to take the same flight and stay in the same hotel.
Then Kennedy got shot.
It's time to release the flying monkeys against the American cadaver and the Stepford nominee.
McWetstart does it again. He wants to have town hall meetings with Obama just like "Jack Kennedy had with Goldwater." Kennedy ran against Nixon. Lyndon Johnson ran against Goldwater.
Funny guy - pretending to fall asleep
Please no more comedian Presidents.
George Bush was a big enough clown to last us a century.
At last! The man who said our economy was fundamentally sound FINALLY admits that it's broken.
i'm listening from another room -
did he just blubber like a horse?
oh. my. gawd. ... how very presidential...
Our economy is broken???
I thought he said that the economy has a sound foundation?
Who got to him?
he totally made a joke, he's still got it *snap *snap *snap
Service, no matter how you spin it, can be made involuntary. And involuntary servitude is expressly prohibited by the US Constitution.
Them cons sure loves them wars.
Palin leaves open option of war with Russia
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20080911/ap_on_el_pr/palin_interview
"Palin told Charles Gibson of ABC News that she'd favor including Georgia and Ukraine, both former Soviet republics, in NATO despite opposition by Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin. Asked whether the United States would have to go to war with Russia if it invaded Georgia, and the country was part of NATO, Palin said: "Perhaps so."
"I mean, that is the agreement when you are a NATO ally, is if another country is attacked, you're going to be expected to be called upon and help," she said."
I don't know who is scarier. McCain or Palin? Palin. The woman is loco.
I thought it was a Half hour segment - I dread listening to him any longer
if govt is so bad why has mccain spent the past 26 years ...um....in the freaking government???!!!???
John in Mpls @ 56:
i know right, but obamas up next right?
John in Mpls @ 56:
Barack'll get an hour, as well. No worries.
K - Which is why I am still here
This old woman thinks McCain is an old fart.........
After 28 years of GOP bullshit...I don't believe a word they say.
Liars, charlatans and simply morally corrupt.
John in Mpls @ 60:
true dat
Obama's millions of Americans will send John McSame packing come November
Well, McCain IS running a different kind of campaign.
I've never seen a single candidate go so low in trying to smear his direct opposition. At least Bush let Cheney say that if you voted Democrat you'd die.
Just@61, How do your friends feel about McCain? I'm curious about what baby-boomers feel about McCain.
He didn't answer about the nastiness of the campaign
Well...tomorrow's another day...I only watched to see if he would lose bladder control.
It is important to focus on issues???
Better fire your PR guys if you want that to happen!
If John McCain is alive in 2042, I will be most impressed.
Elitist!
On the Candidate's Forum on Service, McCain just said:
"Listen, Mayors have the toughest job, I think, in America. Its easy for me to go to Washington and, frankly, be somewhat divorced from the day-to-day challenges people have. So, I admire Mayors."
This confirms Obama's theme that McCain just doesn't get it about the middle class, about working people, about people's day-to-day reality. And McCain said it himself. Obama should counter that he went to Washington to help people with their day-to-day problems, not be divorced from them.
Liberal AND Proud @ 68:
OMG LMAO
What did I just hear? He is proud of this country and wants to spread our 'freedoms' throughout the world?
I guess McCain's talking about our freedom to torture, our freedom for the government to spy on it's own citizens without a warrant and the freedom to bomb the hell out of those who don't see things our way because there just might be terrorists there. Yeah, that's something we can all be proud of.
/snark off
Get the hook.
Now that applause just dwarfed McSames
Is Lieberman and Graham standing in the wings in case he slips up?
did mccain just admit the american govt is hiring illegals?
I am watching this with my British husband here in London. You should have seen his face when McCain mentioned American exceptionalism. This old bastard has no place being president. Anyway, Obama is on now. I want to hear what a real service minded person has to say.
Palin asked about the Bush Doctrine... She doesn't know:
If Obama doesn't completely screw this up by saying "thumbs up to the draft" or something that is simply dumb beyond words, this could turn into Saddleback all over again.
Only, in reverse.
haha
me_over_here @ 78:
Didn't you know that Republicans universally feel that all Americans are exceptional - they own patriotism, service, torture, ...ooops.
If you caught this comment by Gov Palin. This will be no surprise.
But if you didn't catch this comment, It'll pop your eyes out.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/26664074
Yep! She's all for it!
Aaron S. Veenstra @ 40:
I tried to do the survey but when it asked me how many U.S. soldiers had been killed in Iraq the box would only take 3 numbers. I do believe the answer is at least 4,000.
cobsjo @ 79:
Pre-emptive strikes are defensive - didn't you know?
Barack Obama: I GOT THIS
me_over_here @ 78:
\
yeah sorry about that, america ferrera now she's an exceptional america
Orangutan. @ 86:
...I want that on a mug.
Orangutan. @ 86:
How about a t-shirt with that?
k @ 77:
Only to fight our war and if they have green cards, which means they're legal but not citizens. Apparently we're promising them a quicker path to citizenship if they'll enlist and fight our war for us.
As far as I know there is nothing firm on that, only hints, and a small number of legal aliens have enlisted in hopes of citizenship. I guess they have more faith in promises from Bush than I do.
Who screeched a minute ago?
ronhohn @ 91:
Cindy McCain
ronhohn @ 91:
Palin?
Is McCain drilling here, drilling now?
He is so on top of it - he announces the break!
John in Mpls @ 92:
Yeah, well whoever it was I hope they were punched in the throat. My dog won't stop barking at the damn TV now.
ronhohn @ 94:
TMI - thanks for the visual!
Yuuuuk
The Realist @ 96:
The bricklayers grip works more than the punch!
John in Mpls @ 98:
You speak truth, sir.
John in Mpls @ 95:
Hell yeah man.
Go unions!
Teachers need volunteers too!
Looks like the good old Gov from Alaska has a koolaid iv.
mainlining baby.
John in Mpls @ 98:
Any hard working class person can have a preety good grip. I know, I used mine on some necks before.
The Admirals grandson and son never worked for $12,000 a year - McSame is the real elitist!!!
After seeing all the posts here criticizing the McCain camp stretching the truth, I just read an AP story on Yahoo about how "the 'Straight Talk Express' has detoured into doublespeak."
"Even in a political culture accustomed to truth-stretching, McCain's skirting of facts has stood out this week. It has infuriated and flustered Obama's campaign, and campaign pros are watching to see how much voters disregard news reports noting factual holes in the claims."
Story on Yahoo's front page. Read, forward, and enjoy.
This is what I heard:
Growing up knowing one will have to "serve the nation" can have great benefits to the nation and to those facing service. There will be options in the service requirements beyond the existing options in military service (different branches). Perhaps service as a community organizer for several years (LMFAO), Peace Corps type service or WPA and CCC type endeavors that either benefits a group of citizens or provides training in a marketable skill. Young people will be encouraged to think about their options and have ample time examine the options they have.
Having begun this while McLame was on, Obama is now expressing my very thoughts. I yield to him.
Steve Jankowski @ 105:
Link: http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20080912/ap_on_el_pr/mccain_stretching_the_tr...
service is good, a job can be better, esp if youre unemployed
Steve Jankowski @ 105:
WASHINGTON - The "Straight Talk Express" has detoured into doublespeak.
I heard on the Peter B show today that the McCain camp is e-mailing people about absentee ballots.
Does anyone know anymore about this? Peter B wants people to get in touch with him if they've been e-mailed about this.
If you have received one of these SAVE IT!
k @ 87:
:) No need to apologize, I am an ex-pat American. However, I am doing my best to get Obama in office.
ronhohn @ 34:
That's because he's a Palindrone.
me_over_here @ 111:
how exceptional of you
Palin is a sicko (McCain too)
You see, the city of Wasilla, didn't want to "burden" taxpayers with having to support victims of rape. Yes, they were more interested in lowering taxes. It would have cost the city between $5,000 and $14,000 a year to pay for the rape victims' police medical exams. And if the City of Wasilla, circa the year 2000, wants to go there in terms of balancing rape vs, burdening taxpayers, you should know that each and every Alaskan gets a check from the state government each year, it contains their portion of that year's oil revenues.
Bloggers have been writing for a few days about reports that Sarah Palin's town charged rape victims for forensic exams when she was mayor. Now former Alaska Governor Tony Knowles has come out in support of the story. McClatchy reports:
USA Today has more:
And US News tells readers that, while Wasilla was the only town in Alaska with this foul policy, it isn't the only place in the U.S..
The Jed Report finds the connection to John McCain:
Joe Biden is truly for women
wow, givin into rotc recruiters
John in Mpls @ 85:
What the hell has Lieberman been doing?? I thought he was tutoring her. He was probably too busy looking at her "best credentials."
he should keep mentioning the gi bill on these military questions
mudshark @ 110:
This is going on in several of the swing states. If you get one, contact your local democrat office and possibly your local media.
The Realist @ 18:
if the students want the option of ROTC, they won't go to Columbia.
i am sure there are students who go to columbia and alum who contribute to columbia specifically because it does not permit rotc.
corps is the word, its got groove, its got feeling
Ron @ 118:
Will Do Ron.
Thank You.
woohoo, talking about investing in education always makes me feel warm and fuzzy inside, im sooooo a democrat
Absentee ballots are legal, and often recommended - at least here in the Golden State. We also have early voting, about a month before the official date.
I have done both
Charlie sounded offensive tonight and was interrupting Palin. What was Bush doctrine, Charlie? Or for that matter what was George Washington's doctrine or the FDRs?
It was always social, economical, or religious factors were involved.
I am not sure if Charlie was trying to be a snort or he might have been nervous with mixed emotions.
I thought Palin did well to say that we may have to go after Russia. Russia is a threat globally. Folks, be prepared to be drafted.
In addition, Palin stuck to her answer about Israel's self defense in times of war and Charlie had to swallow the hard pill.
Obama is very clear and on point and offer a plan. McCain offered nothing and had no vision for the future. McCain has nothing to offer this country. I hope people of this country wake up and see McCain is an empty suit.
Investing in education is all the investment we have left.
Good for Barack!
He would NOT say that McCain could serve in his cabinet!
SPEAKING TRUTH about the other guy! I love it!
Joe @ 125:
I swear that McCain sounded like he was going to have a stroke, confused, not completing sentances, and not staying on topic.
Ah does national service include "community organizers"?
EZ @ 124:
What makes you think Russia is a threat to the US?
As for Israel, I wish those folks would negotiate a peace with their neighbors . I'm sick and tired of all the trouble there.
Both parties are guilty. It's easy to hate.
ronhohn @ 123:
Yes, so do I use them, but the applications aren't being mailed to me by the GOP or McCain's campaign. There is lots of reasons not to mail it in to a return address provided by them.
I think 'community' infers 'local'
Answering in more than a few words...works at Saddleback where words are hard to understand and confusing, but works very well among the thinking people here.
#131 point taken. That I agree with. Should not be partisan
I'm for making government cool again, too!
One responsibility of citizenship is PAYING ATTENTION.
- Obama
"Part of being a citizen is paying attention" - Barack Obama
BRAVO!!!
MountainMan23 @ 136:
Hear hear!!!
John in Mpls @ 138:
And there.
ronhohn @ 139:
And everywhere in between.
Liberal AND Proud @ 137:
I don't think McCain and the rest of the GOP have been very good citizens then.
Idealism is GOOD.
Take THAT...Hannity, Limbaugh and Levin.
Done
Yowwser!
It sounds like they liked Obama's ideas better.
Ron @ 145:
Home field advantage had a bit to do with that - but I will take any advantage
Liberal AND Proud @ 137:
This is falling on deaf ears if he expects it from repugs.
Just watch the likes of O'Reilly and Hannity -- they NEVER listen, they just preach.
Obama made up for Saddleback, and then some.
perhaps its time to revive the hitler youth , siegh hiel right in our leaders face!
I cannot stand David Gregory! He apologizes for McCain and promotes McCain. Too bad his boss Griffin loves the guy.
Comments are closed on this entry