Obamacare Architect Says He Made A Mistake In 2012 Video That Wingnuts Are Freaking On

"I never heard any of them suggest subsidies would not be available in states where officials decided not to operate their own marketplaces." --Jonathan Gruber

Right wingers are up in a tizzy today after a video and a new audio surfaced by Jonathan Gruber, a main architect of the ACA, who they say backs up Boehner's lawsuit.

Brietbart: Obamacare Architect Jonathan Gruber Once Again Ties Subsidies to State-Based Exchanges

Daily Caller: Obamacare Architect Says AGAIN That Subsidies Were Only Supposed To Go To State Exchanges

Red State: Another 2012 Jonathan Gruber ‘speak-o,’ apparently.

Instapundit: WHO ARE YOU GOING TO BELIEVE — ME, OR YOUR LYING EARS?

The always great Jonathan Cohen interviewed Gruber to find out what happened:

Did the people who designed Obamacare intend to deprive millions of people of health insurance, just because officials in their states decided not to operate their own insurance marketplaces?

A lawsuit making its way through the federal judiciary, and perhaps on its way to the Supreme Court, claims the answer is yes. And while every federal official and member of Congress who worked on crafting the law in 2009 and 2010 disagrees, now there’s a video from 2012 in which one of the law’s best known advocates and architects—MIT economist Jonathan Gruber—makes the same basic argument that the lawsuit does.

Among those who say they are surprised by the statement is Gruber himself, whom I was able to reach by phone. "I honestly don’t remember why I said that," he said, attempting to reconstruct what he might have been thinking at the time. "I was speaking off-the-cuff. It was just a mistake." As evidence that it was not indicative of his beliefs, he noted that his projections of the law's impact have always assumed that all eligible people would get subsides, even though, he said, he did not assume all states would choose to run their own marketplaces.

If this was always the case I think we'd have heard about it long before now.

What do I think? As I’ve written before, I had literally hundreds of conversations with the people writing health care legislation in 2009 and 2010, including quite a few with Gruber. Like other journalists who were following the process closely, I never heard any of them suggest subsidies would not be available in states where officials decided not to operate their own marketplaces—a big deal that, surely, would have come up in conversation.


About John Amato

Comments

We welcome relevant, respectful comments. Please refer to our Terms of Service for information on our posting policy.