Has Obama's Post-Katrina Gulf Coast Recovery Plan Been Sufficient?
By dday Tuesday Sep 01, 2009 10:00amAs we live through another anniversary of the man-made disaster on the Gulf Coast and the shocking lack of a federal response that caused thousands to die needlessly, thoughts turn again to whether anybody remembers New Orleans and its environs, and whether the proper resources are being deployed to rehabilitate the region. If you listen to the President, of course, his Administration is doing a heckuva job down there. Lots of cabinet members have visited the region, to be followed by the President later this year. The White House has untangled some bureaucracy to allow for more federal assistance to reach the Gulf Coast, and the stimulus has enhanced recovery efforts. And even some local Republicans have praised his approach, particularly the renewed sense of confidence in FEMA.
But that's the White House's spin. And not everyone agrees with it. The Institute for Southern Studies has reported on coalition groups blasting the Army Corps of Engineers for their slow response to restoring the natural barriers - wetlands, marshes, and barrier islands - that could help prevent future hurricanes. New Orleans resident Harry Shearer has more on that. To their credit, the White House has created a federal task force to speed up coastal restoration projects. But on other issues, the ISS has given the Administration low marks.
The Institute of Southern Studies recently released a report that assesses how Washington has handled the storm's aftermath. The ISS asked 50 community leaders to grade the Obama administration's Katrina recovery efforts: Obama got a D+, and Bush was given a D-. If graded on an E for effort curve, Bush probably would have gotten the edge given his authorization of millions in Gulf Opportunity tax credits and bonds, and an extension of time under which developers could use them.
Meanwhile, Obama has done little in seven months beyond distributing $50 million in housing vouchers. Unfortunately, families either won't be able to use them because there aren't enough houses built yet, or the vouchers will be of little use because they only cover a fraction of rents, which have risen substantially since Katrina. He's also instituted a plan to sell FEMA mobile units to families for $1 or $5, but many of those trailers are toxic from formaldehyde leaks.
The American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) did little for recovery and reinvestment in the Gulf Coast area that needed it the most. Since calculations were made based off current population numbers -- many displaced people throughout the country are still waiting to return -- fewer ARRA dollars reached these congressional districts. ARRA's tax credit exchange program, which cashes in states' low income housing tax credits, also excluded the Go Zone tax credits, leaving over 17,000 housing units hanging in the balance.
The Lower Ninth Ward, already struggling prior to the flood, has been particularly slow to return to stability. Only 20% of its residents have returned full-time, and the area has lagged far behind the tourist spots and the Garden District.
The neglect of the Gulf both during and after the storm will not get turned around quickly or easily. I'm tempted to cut the White House a little slack on this one. But on the current trajectory, New Orleans is looking more and more in the post-Katrina period like a restored home for the rich and connected, and a nightmare for the voiceless. And given the moral outrage that the response to the storm correctly engendered, that is unacceptable. We have an obligation to those who were left to rot in the fetid waters, not just to give them a return to the same inequality, but a chance at a better life. Should Obama visit the city before the year ends, he shouldn't go to Bourbon Street, but the Lower Ninth, and he should not just tell them what he will do, but back it up.








Login or Register to post comments.
he sure has been laying low here recently.
He was on Vacation this last week. And is going to Camp David for another Vacation Wed.
Ooooootay
A Vacation from his Vacation I guess
Nice thread.
..after all, Obama has had only 7 1/2 months to do anything while w had three years to do nothing much at all.
http://d.yimg.com/a/p/ap/20090831/capt.7dfb2d...
W didn't get a fail cause his Daddy called the school.
the whole thing from the day that Katrina was headed for shore.
4 fucking years and it's still screwed up. unreal.
and the Republicans are mad because he's not cleaning up the mess they left him fast enough. "hurry up, boy and scrub them floors!"
But let me point your attention to one fact:
Bush caused the flooding of New Orleans. If Bush had not been so hell bent on giving tax breaks to his rich friends, and making up the shortfall by stealing the ACOE's levee repair money (cutting the funds to fix the levees by up to one fifth needed, and stopping repair work in progress) for three years, NOLA would not have flooded.
This is sickening. The rich got richer at the expense of an entire city and its unique culture. Thousand died so the super rich could have a little more money. Sick. Sick. Sick.
that the U.S. Government is nothing more than a vehicle for corporations, Wall Street, etc to control lawmakers, legislation, and military in a way that favor's their financial interest.
..that jeb bush was involved in selling funky, inadequate pumps.
Yeah...but he made lots of dough, avoided investigation or prosecution and lots of brown skinned people died.
Wow...he hit the Bush trifecta!!
Once we get the HC debate settled I hope Obama turns his attention towards NO. That city still needs massive help and after bailing out Wall Street and Detroit it's the least Obama should do.
I know this is off topic and advertisements on C+L have been discussed before, but how in the hell can there be an ad to support Republican HealthCare on this site. I understand advertisements generate revenue, but this is going beyond the norm in my opinion. The RNC, or there tainted money, shouldn't be allowed anywhere near C+L, nor should we accept it. Just because they have money doesn't mean we should take it. Thanks.
my question is, if any one here knows, is whether the right-wing blogs, etc have ads espouting liberal causes, and what is the reaction to them? I can't comment as if I went to one of those hate-filled sites, my head would explode. So if these sites don't carry these ads, then why does C&L carry right-wing ones?
The Gulf Coast is a most worthy candidate for more funds and attention. There are thousands of worthy candidates. After a reasonably good heath care bill is passed I would like to see some serious tax restoration. It is time to put the tax rate back to were it was before Reagan paid off the top 1%. All of the United State infrastructior is crumbling. Every year we pay more on intrest on the national debt than on everything thing except military and Social Security. It's time now to start to pay for what we need no matter what the corporations and the astroturf roots do.
First, thanks for the post. But when talking about this very important issue of Gulf Coast/New Orleans Recovery, it's especially important we get our facts right.
Case in point:
"The Lower Ninth Ward, already struggling prior to the flood, has been particularly slow to return to stability. Only 20% of its residents have returned full-time, and the area has lagged far behind the tourist spots and the Garden District."
Of course it's lagged far behind the French Quarter and Garden District...because the other areas WEREN'T flooded. You're comparing two totally different things.
The Ninth Ward gets a lot of attention (as it should), but we shouldn't compare it to areas of the city that did not flood. Try comparing it to Lakeview or Gentilly which had just as much water.
NO has the funds; NO has squandered funds; NO needs to get off their dead butts and get to work. They are too worried about a handout and who's going to do the work for them.
----------------------------------
I was a liberal until I learned to read, got a job and was mugged by weak-willed tax and spend politicians and their naive, Kool-Aid (tm) drinking acolytes.
Login or Register to post comments.