Did You Wonder Why 'Lord' Boustany Gave The Republican Rebuttal? Maybe Because He's Been Sued For Malpractice So Many Times.
By Susie Madrak Thursday Sep 10, 2009 5:00am
(John Amato: Wow, this might even top Bobby Jindal for lunacy.
His plan for reinvigorating the economy of his district is known as the Prescription for Prosperity. Rachel Maddow of MSNBC reports he attempted to purchase a "Lordship Title" from British scam artists.)
I think "Doctor" Boustany (as he prefers to be called) is an interesting choice for the GOP rebuttal. After all, not only does he seem to enjoy seeking legal redress for some colorful problems, he's also been the defendant in at least eight malpractice suits. From the DCCC:
Congressman Charles Boustany’s more colorful lawsuits suing con artists who told him he could become a British Lord and suing a construction company for “mental anguish” over a pool resurfacing job shouldn’t overshadow the fact that Boustany has been sued for medical malpractice by eight patients.
Boustany was found at fault by the Louisiana Medical Review Panel twice – including a two-year old child Boustany performed an unnecessary and debilitating heart operation on and a woman whose right leg was amputated as the result of complications from surgery – and patients were awarded damages totaling nearly $2 million.
Since 1992, Boustany has been sued for malpractice by eight separate patients. Boustany was found in fault by the state Medical Review Panel.
- Boustany was sued for medical malpractice for surgery performed on a child and found in fault by the state medical review board. The plaintiff received $600,000 in compensation as a result.
Melanie Malagarie sued Boustany for medical malpractice stemming from surgery performed on her young daughter, Leonette. When Leonette was an infant she underwent heart surgery for a condition called Tetrology of Falot. The surgery was described as being a “good result,” according to court documents. Shortly before Leonette turned three, Boustany recommended surgery described as a “complete repair of Tetrology of Falot.”
After surgery, Leonette was reported to have suffered multiple severe damages including acute renal failure, acute respiratory failure and evidence of post-operative infections.
In 1992, the court dismissed the case because Malagarie failed to file a complaint with the state’s medical board.
Two years later, she submitted the case to Medical Review Panel, which found in her favor. The case was later dismissed after the parties settled the matter, awarding Malagarie $600,000 in compensation. Boustany’s insurer offered her $100,000 on his behalf and the Louisiana Patient’s Compensation Fund provided the other $500,000. (Melanie Malagarie v. Dr. Charles Boustany, Dr. Shannon Turney, Dr. Geeta Dalal, Lafayette General Hospital et. al, Case No: 92-5260, 15th Judicial District Court Parish of Lafayette)
- Boustany was sued for medical malpractice after a cardiac operation he performed resulted in the patient requiring her leg to be amputated. According to the state medical review board, Boustany fell below the standard of care in treating the patient, who was later awarded more than $1.2 million in damages.
Carencro Sherriff Geraldine Arceneaux was admitted to the hospital for a planned bypass procedure by Boustany. According to court documents, Arceneaux had numerous complications from her surgery that required her right leg to be amputated. As a result of the amputation Sherriff Arceneaux could no longer hold her elected office. Prior to filing suit, Arceneaux filed a complaint before the Medical Review Panel, which found Boustany’s conduct to be below the acceptable standard of care. The court agreed and allowed Arceneaux to withdraw $1,212,106.87 in damages from the Louisiana Patient’s Compensation Fund for various needs. As of May 2004, Arceneaux reached a settlement with the Fund and the case was dismissed. (Geraldine Arceneaux v. Dr. Charles Boustany et. al., Docket No: 2000-2007, 15th Judicial District Court Parish of Lafayette)
- Boustany settled a medical malpractice case out of court.
Delila Hays sued Boustany for complications arising from surgery for coronary angioplasty. During the course of the operation, her aortic arch was torn and dissected causing temporary paralysis and damage to the patient’s vocal cords. The plaintiff returned to the operating room five days later for more surgery as a result of negligence and improper procedure during the prior surgery. After surgery, the patient was placed in the ICU, where her kidneys failed. The toes on her left foot had to be amputated. She sustained bowel problems, permanent ankle drop, and required speech therapy due to damage to her vocal cords. Ms. Hays underwent additional surgery approximately one month later for debridement of the right groin area; debridement of the right foot, with partial and full thickness skin loss; debridement of the left foot with full and partial skin loss; debridement of the left and lower leg; and the amputation of five of her toes. Ms. Hays alleged she was improperly monitored, appropriate steps were not undertaken by the staff, treatment was delayed and staff failed to provide the most basic level of care. The case was dismissed immediately because Ms. Hays did not receive the ruling of the Medical Review Panel prior to suing Boustany. In 2002, however, the case went into mediation and there was a complete settlement. (Delila Hays and Charles Hays v. Dr. David Baker, M.D., Lafayette General Medical Center, Dr. Guillory, Dr. Charles Boustany, Case Number: 95-0836, 15th Judicial District Court, Lafayette Parish, Louisiana) Boustany sued two con artists after paying them $18,500 to become a British noble and attend the Queen Mother’s birthday procession. In 1996, Congressman Boustany and his wife sued two British men and their fake company for an amount “in excess of $50,000.” According to their complaint, the couple had paid Stefanos Kollakis and Martin Lewis $18,500 on December 20, 1994 for a fraudulent title. In April 1995, Kollakis and Lewis had pleaded guilty to forgery in a London court for carrying out the con on several unsuspecting Americans. Using false passports, bogus companies, Latin mottos and a nonexistent “Institution of Heraldic Affairs,” they had promised to turn Americans into official lords and ladies. One of the promised rewards was an opportunity to ride in the Queen Mother’s annual birthday procession. (Boustany v. Kollakis, et al., Case No. 960325, 15th Judicial District Court, Lafayette Parish, Louisiana; Detroit Free Press, 4/28/95; Washington Times, 5/18/95) Boustany sued for “mental anguish” over an unsatisfactory pool resurfacing. Boustany sued a construction company for “mental anguish” over the loss of the use of his swimming pool. After the company had resurfaced the interior of his pool in April 1993, the surface blistered, cracked and discolored. (Boustany v. Louisiana Concrete Resurfacing, Case No. 931831, 15th Judicial District Court, Lafayette Parish, Louisiana) It is of note that the Boustanys’ home is worth nearly a half-million dollars, while the median home value in Louisiana’s Seventh Congressional district is $78,100. (U.S. Census Bureau)
Boustany was sued for a former partner for nonpayment of compensation.
Boustany was sued in 2001 by his former partner, Richard Dearman, for unpaid compensation owed to him from 1999 and 2000. Dearman also alleged that as a partner with 30 percent stock in the Charles W. Boustany, Jr., M.D., Ltd. medical practice, he was owed his unredeemed stock and portions of income from account receivables collected after Dearman withdrew from the medical practice. The case was settled out of court for an undisclosed amount. (Dearman, Richard, M.D. v. Charles W. Boustany, Jr., M.d.,Ltd and Charlses W. Boustany Jr. Case No. 2001-2776-G 15th Judicial Court, Lafayette Parish, Louisiana)








Login or Register to post comments.
In the free market he has a right to make a mistake.
The patient can simply go somewhere else for healthcare.
Besides, lawsuits are sooo unAmerican. Especially when they are directed at business...the engine of this great economy.
A lot of Republiklan party members act like such hypocrites. In family values matters and also in so called personal responsibility matters. The Republiklan party opposes people injured by doctors, corporations and others from getting into the court room. They preach personal responsibility but only for those other than doctors and corporations and other people who injure others. They don't care about personal responsibility for doctors, corporations and other professionals.
http://democratz.org
Many extreme right wingers, and many of whom are in Congress, believe in personal responsibility for EVERYONE ELSE. It's not supposed to apply to THEM. They seem to think they're the Privileged Ones and answer to no one. Typical narcissistic, sociopathic, and antisocial thinking.
What a friggin choad!
I didn't think ANYONE could do worse that Bombin boby jindal...guess I was wrong.
Goodness. Do the Republicans have anyone who isn't boring, racist, or fucking stupid?
but I liked Obama's speech.
yeah...right up to the part where he said.."Thank you, thank you very much"
He also walked off the podium very nicely.
I liked it too, but from what I read in last night's comments here we are in the tiny minority.
Can't win 'em all...
I prefer substance over style.
The message sucked, no matter how nicely it's delivered.
I guess we'll have to agree to disagree on that one L&P.
I'm ok with that.
When the insurance company sellout bill passes...oh...I'm sorry...healthcare reform bill passes...and costs go up even faster, I won't even say that I told you so.
I think L&P is disagreeing with everything today. He's not in his happy place right now. I think he needs a weekend to cool off and regain his sense of humor. He'll be back as good as new.
I am showing my sense of humor! I'm still here! ;o)
Funny, I watched him this morning on c-span and almost fell asleep. I had to change the channel to stay awake.
It might be on C-Span. I didn't catch where it will be, but there is a cast of familiar characters like DeMint who will be lying, I mean talking. Probably will be good for laughs, and perhaps some major outrage. Oh yeah, Boehner is one of the spouters, too.
The adulterers and the ones still in the closet?
.
official GOP rebuttal to Obama's speeches...
They really should get someone who...
A) doesn't look like a total neomaxyzoomdweebie
B) doesn't look like a deer in headlights.
C)doesn't have all the charisma of a pile of steamin hog poo
D)isn't a total neo-con lying scumbag POS...
ah wait...nevermind...they don't have anyone that fits those criteria.
HA!
Um, no, actually, they don't. They drove them all out of the party as RINOs.
have the same problem..They rolled out of medicine for a reason and it was NOT due to a call to 'civic duty'!
This one is not even articulate!
I resent Boustany breathing our air.
Yeah, I'm thinking it's better that this guy is in congress and out of a doc's office.
Jindal part II: Another strike out.
GOP'll have to look for some other national candidates: this guy is a sap.
Once again, LibNMod, I learn a new word from C&L!
It's one I can use in a lot of situations!
Thanks!
Lord Doctor sounds like a catchy title. He also is the perfect spokesperson for the republicans. I guess when you realize you suck as a doctor the only thing to do is get into republican politics.
..those that can't are republican'ts.
Maybe he thought he was god emperor of a desert planet or something.
a mass murderer.
Manson's in jail....
Dahmer's dead....
Instead of a serial killer, why not have ORLY TAITZ?
She's just what they need....shrill, the truth doesn't mean anything...
Sounds reasonable, yes?
Did you see a few days ago that Ms. Taitz once again was outed with a 2nd fake Obama birth certificate?
What a joke! Ha, ha, ha!!!!!
Not just the perfect GOP spokesman, the perfect US Congressman:
According to the nonpartisan Center for Responsive Politics, Rep. Boustany has received $1,256,056 from health and insurance interests since first being elected in 2004. The total counts for more than 20 percent of all of his fundraising.
"Rep. Boustany has taken more than $160,000 in campaign contributions from insurance and HMO interests alone. Do you think he'll disclose that to his national audience tonight?"
http://www.reuters.com/article/pressRelease/i...
with malpractice?
Malpractice AND mental anquish!
and now he and his party think he's a leader. Keep it up repubs. We are watching your party die on the vine!
At least his patients don't have to worry about him doing any more surgery while he's in Congress.
..if we're lucky, he'll be selling pencils on a street corner.
...I mean, another republican.
Wonder how Joe Wilson felt this morning when he woke up. You know when your mind kicks in and you realize what you did last night? He may need the Lord Doctor Boustany to help him to show his face in public today.
if its coming back in Bits and Pieces:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P975AVUAlN0
"The rule is perfect: in all matters of opinion our adversaries are insane."
Mark Twain (1835 - 1910), in Christian Science
Like any lifeless corpse, the Republican party is decomposing. It is rotting from within. Their language, their corruption, their unabashed disrespect for the President, the lunatic fringe. These are all elements of a dead carcass whose elements are becoming dismembered. The blue dogs are the only credible counterpoint to the progressives. RIP GOP.
Tort reform becomes "the cost of doing business". The only defense we have against wrongful and inept treatment is the threat of suing them. Otherwise, it becomes an allowable cost of doing business and is allotted that expense during budgeting. Republicans love to sue. They just don't want anyone else pursuing justice.
Why not eliminate the entire legal system!! Think of allll the savings that will be passed on to you...the customer...with the elimination of the legal system!
..I agree about frivolous lawsuits. They just stink up the joint. But there are cases that should be heard as not all of them are frivolous and petty.
I was sued because a child ran into the street and hit my STOPPED jeep. They said all kinds of things that weren't true and sued because they could. I did nothing wrong other than being in the wrong place at the wrong time. I did everything possible to not run over the child or allow anyone else to for that matter. Totally frivolous charges filed that I denied a father the company of his child; the child never left the household, the marriage was intact and I suffered traumatic stress syndrome, had problems with driving, saw a shrink. Who had the better right to sue? Truth is its everybody's right to sue but there are greedy, dishonest mother-f#$ers out there who will sue just to make a buck. The kid was OK, was playing in the yard the next day and I was a basket case. If I had disposable income, I would've counter-sued and allowed the case to go to the jury. Sorry, the system could be tweaked a bit to prevent this from happening but I wouldn't scrap the whole damn thing.
One has to wonder how much we could lower healthcare costs simply by removing this guy's license.
politicians. If they wanted an effective speaker they should have chosen Jason Stackhouse from Bon Temps, La. He gave a great speech last week defending the folk from Maenads.
intellectual giant thinks you can buy a title for only $18,500? Just because you can become a physician does not make you smart, I work with some pretty dumb ones.
Maybe that's how he got his license to become a doctor so he thought it might work to become a "Lord"
We get our titles for FREE. Serf.
he know he would have had to de(re?)nounce his US citizenship? Doubt it ...
1) Eliminate patient lawsuits.
2) Make instrument sterilization voluntary.
3) Eliminate surgical gloves and masks.
4) Reuse needles.
6) Create a Home Depot of Medicine, where people can purchase do it yourself kits for routine procedures like tonsillectomies, appendix removal, gastric bypass and liposuction.
The Home Depot of medicine would be a much better choice than the Walmart of medicine. You think you need an appendectomy, but Grampa Simpson has different ideas...
It is amazing how lame the Republican Party is. Jindal and them this cluck and Palin and Toes Morris and Beck and Limbaugh and Mike Wallace's son and O'Mousedick and Grassley and Bond and Sessions and Boehner and Canter and Greer and Mary Matlin and Cheney and Bush and Bush and Bush and...... Jeez the list could go on to next Tuesday. How can their followers follow them? It is retarded (no offense to retards mind you).
Does anyone else besides me notice Lord Boustany's physical resemblance to Dr. Enos Pork, MD, from Bud Grace's Piranha Club strip. When not getting drunk out of his mind, the good Dr. Pork, who is described as the only doctor who comes with a warning label from the Surgeon General, is frequently shown either misdiagnosing ailments or dodging malpractice suits. Hey, wow, another resemblance!
reform never addresses fraud, waste, malpractice, Pfizer's killer marketers, etc etc.
Maybe he's a quack doctor and deserved to be sued over his incompetency and deaths.
Yep, he's a birther. Watch this video, about 30 seconds in: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5gN-rxJFvJ8
Credit goes to the level headed cons at that site about green sports objects for pointing that one out.
said last night that would cause a fleeting (fellating) second's anxiety among the Health Insurance Parasites (HIP) as to the continued excess profitability of the 'industry.' Their stocks are rising quite nicely this morning...
As long as there's a profit incentive, there will be corruption. They will cheat us and fuck us, and rip us off, and leave us dying; they just don't give a fuck, as long as the money's there...
To the extent that the HIP 'can live' with any Congressional reform, that is the index of how far Obama and the Dims will shove CorpoRat profits up our asses...And laugh all the way to the polls...
See, this is my health insurance card. I receive the same high quality care as anyone else in this country. I'm no exception and there's no special privileges.
Blah blah
which for some reason or another they manage to keep them HIP honest.
What is even sadder is the performance of this GOP loon. Jesus tap dancing Christ on a pogo stick, and these are the assholes who can't find their very own ass in a room full of mirrors and are somehow managing to derail any meaningful health care reform. I weep for this country....
There was certainly enough to criticize in his response without resorting to ad hominem attacks. That's the typical Republican response and they just make you look petty and small.
care cost cutting is always tort reform. Having your rebuttal given by a doctor that has been sued for malpractice, with cause, is a dubious choice. Is the GOP that stupid or clueless?
... however, there is a lot of difference between "being sued for malpractice" and "being sentenced for malpractice."
Check out http://www.republicandirtytricks.com for a great picture of Lord Boustany
The set up for him was all wrong. The lighting was bad. It was almost like telling a spooky story in the dark while holding a flashlight below your face. His head looked too little and I think all the "gold" lighting was supposed to make him look warm and angelic. And is it me or did he look like something was holding him up?
His rebuttal was lame but generally they are from both sides but they made him look creepy while he was giving it. Did he even practice it before he did it?
But the whole comparison of him with Obama is dramatic. Including the presentation. And since he spoke for only 8 minutes, he only handcuffed in how many lies he could tell. To my count, only 4. And, of course, we got the GOP "response": tort reform!
contributes about 2% of the overall cost.
The other GOP toadies are focusing on the other 1%, illegal immigrants. Once they can figure out how to trip that 3% off, them happy days will be here again, I tell you!
It is this capacity to focus on the important stuff, what makes these GOPers such great and successful businessmen!
Elephant in the room. Here in Southern CA Illegal Immigrants account for far more then 1% of costs. It's the major drag on our system. I was just in the hospital last week. Guess what, they had to go FIND a person to speak English to me as I was sitting there throwing up my guts. It's pretty damn infuriating as an American no matter which side of the aisle you sit on.
Don't disagree with you about the pukes focusing on minutia and I am liberal and proud and all but this is a serious problem with our system and it needs to be addressed. I don't believe Senor Wilson for a sec but I am worried about whether or not Illegals really will be excluded in practice. I'm not willing to forgo reform cause of it that would be stupid but it needs to be addressed.
1% of costs I call bullshit on that one. Maybe in Indiana or something but not here in the Southwest.
... last year, illegals accounted for roughly $400 million dollars in medical cost in Southern California. Or roughly 20% of the $2 billion in unreimbursed care for SoCal hospitals.
The total tab is a few orders of magnitude larger (tens/hundreds of billion $$$), for both insured and uninsured citizens.
So indeed it is a drop in the proverbial bucket. There are bigger fishes to fry. And this is nothing but the proverbial desperate red herring trying to derail the debate.
In this country, we seem to think it is somehow reasonable to scrap something that would help millions if there is even the slightest possibility of a few people abusing the system. That is myopic to the extreme IMHO.
That we should scrap it just to spite illegals. That is like cutting off you nose to spite your face and like I said is stupid.
However, that being said I am extremely skeptical of the numbers. My lying eyes tell me one thing while budget reports say another. And sorry 20% is not a drop in the bucket by any standard. Earlier in the thread I was told it's 1%. See the problem with that?
bigger fishes to fry indeed, lets cut the pentagon budget 10% and pay for it all forever.
But come to my neighborhood which I have watched slowly turn into a gang infested shithole from a nice suburban mixed race community. We've been tolerant, we've been welcoming and they shit all over us for it.
My beef is not those who come here to work hard and be American taxpayers or servce in the service, thats fine even though it costs us jobs. It's the one's who think they can come here, use our services to have their multiple kids, commit felonies and then just bounce back across the border to evade punishment. Those fatherless kids then grow up to look for a father figure in a gang. Cycle repeated.
Plus the ones we do catch have been so institutionalized sending them to jail doesn't work, cause they are more then happy to go. It's a badge of honor. It makes it really hard for us law abiding citizens out here. I carry a gun now after being robbed in broad daylight on a busy street. Care to take a guess on who robbed me and where they went to avoid prosecution? Should I really have carry a gun to go buy milk?
If we as liberals don't address it, we just leave it to the Lou Dobbs's of the world and we are no better for it. This requires rational adult reasoning and pretending there is no problem is just going to lead to a Glenn Beck induced race war cause tempers are flaring out here.
.
Why did they even need a rebuttal? Obama gave in to almost everything they wanted.
Gee, I wonder. Did Jindal's acceptance of stimulus money include a requirement that only Louisiana Repubs give these responses? If so, another brilliant stroke by Obama.
We'll know if they go for the hat trick of inanity and after the State of the Union pick another one from Louisiana to give the response.
Listening to him has made me be teh stupid ........ must go read a book now to get over it.
Wish I would have known about this last night.
I sent this idiot a long email after his speech. On his web site, he asks for examples of our experiences with a "government-run" healthcare system.
So I sent him an email about my experiences in The Netherlands, which were quite good.
I would have asked him about those medical malpractice suits, had I known about them!
I hope this gets big coverage in the media out there. Think I'm going to send an email to Keith and Rachel, although they probably already know.
By the way, I like the way Susie says he likes to be called "Doctor Boustanay." I just called him "Sir" when I sent that email.
Besides being a liar, he is a quack and another really boring Reslug.
seperated at birth.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/19314030/
Burned me out when it comes to republicans and christian republicans.
I don't normally ask someones pollitical affiliation,but at this time I just cannot see myself dealing with these people on a daily basis.
I have lost all respect for these people. I used to think that they thought they were doing the right thing, I no longer believe.
I have watched so much dirty dealings, selfishness, greed, inhumanity, and evil, yes evil from people that profess to be follwing god. It leds me to the only possible answer left.
republicanism is a mental illness!
...but scum of the earth, disgraced doctors/politicians like this piece of shit certainly deserve nothing more than a spit in the wind.
Why did we ever win the Civil War? At times I think it would be better to offer amnesty to all those wishing to stay in the USA, and cut off the South with all these f*cktard politicians they nurture down there.
Shame of the South. Shame of our country.
1) We had a single payer system and
2) Malpractice was a CRIMINAL charge, the way it is in the UK.
Sure, they want liability reform... So when all those lawyers lose out on very tasty cases or those insurers no longer make a killing on malpractice premiums do either have a lobby on K street to turn to? I thought so..
Medical malpractice is made to appear much worse than it actually is so the thieving insurance companies can charge exorbitant fees from doctors for coverage, like $800,000.00 a year or more for some, like surgeons. It's another scam from insurance companies who need to be heavily regulated, and I mean heavily. If you think lawyers are a problem, if you ever get screwed over by someone or get in trouble with the law, then don't call one. Put the blame where it belongs, and that is not the doctors or the lawyers. And don't forget the sleazy and dishonest politicians who take the bribes. Without "bribees," bribers would have no one to work with. I feel much better now.
The public option is not "government run health care". Why do these assholes lie? It's like claiming automobiles are government run because they are driven on public roads. These shitheels are in serous need of a dressing down.
We've gone from Cat Killer Frist to Dr. Lord Boustany Mengele! Imagine those two in a dark room, drapes drawn with Bobby Jindal?
OMG! I need help loadin' the bong!
Were the folks he purchased it from the King and Duke? Did he meet them on riverboat? Was he floating down the river with an escaped slave when this happened? Because it all sounds familiar somehow.
At the heart of EVERY SINGLE POLICY is some selfish personal motivation.
This guy wanted the freedom to mangle people and not be held responsible.
Cheney wanted to rake in billions for his own personal stash.
Delay wanted to use hazardous toxic chemicals to kill bugs without government regulations.
They're such a bunch of selfish assholes.
I didn't have time to read the entire entry, but from what I glean,
here we have a Republican who is a poster child for frivolous lawsuits (emotional anguish? I've heard Republicans make fun of this all the time!) and medical malpractice (maybe that's why he wants to do tort reform, so that he's only liable for $250K each time he fucks up?).
Please, continue to aggrandize this man so the public learns this is the true face of the Republican party!
You'd think it was made up. Really! I seem to remember Dick Armey's wife sued because she opened a business and it didn't make money and she said the people who sold her on the location didn't tell her it sucked. There are probably hundreds of other tales in of people screaming "TORT REFORM" who have filed silly, silly suits.
Login or Register to post comments.