Hossein Derakhshan Missing, Believed Arrested, In Iran
Noted Iranian-Canadian blogger Hossein Derakhshan is believed to have been arrested in Iran. He recently went back to Iran on a visit and subsequently disappeared. Jerome at MyDD notes that "Hossein has been at the forefront of the huge Iranian-Persian blogosphere, advocating for the use of the internet as a means for social and political reform in Iran, but he's also made a lot of enemies on both sides, for his non-conformist viewpoints."
Josh Wingrove at the Globe and Mail writes:
...there has been no trace of him since Oct. 30. Iranian reports surfaced soon after that date, citing intelligence sources, saying he had been arrested and charged with spying on behalf of Israel.
Yesterday, through Toronto-based blogger and family friend Nazli Kamvari, Mr. Derakhshan's family said he had been arrested at his residence in Iran on Nov. 1. The family has spoken to him four times since then, each time in a phone call lasting less than one minute, Ms. Kamvari said. But family members haven't heard from Mr. Derakhshan for 13 days, and are now becoming worried.
"Every time he's been like, 'I'm okay,' " said Ms. Kamvari, 29. "They're very confused."
It's no more likely that Derakhsan is an Israeli spy than that I am. Mark MacKinnon writes:
I met Hossein once, and yes it was in Jerusalem. But he walked the streets proudly wearing an "I Love Tehran" T-shirt (probably the first one ever worn in Israel) in an over-the-top effort to challenge stereotypes and tackle the misconceptions that exist in both Tel Aviv and Tehran.
Yes, he was a critic of Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmedinejad. Yes, he openly admired the Israel and the West. But he was also fiercely proud of his Iranian heritage, and called Iran the freest country in the Middle East after Israel. Though himself an atheist, he expressed admiration for Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini.
I heartily endorse MacKinnon's call for Derakhsan's release.
On a more personal note; I've written a lot about the false narratives surrounding Western debate over Iran's nuclear program and other accusations designed to inflame Western opinion towards armed intervention there. But occasions like this make me more aware that I am a reluctant apologist for a truly odious regime on the subject. It's a theocracy disguised with some democratic trappings, even the moderates aren't moderate at all by my usual standards and it violently represses it's own people in their free expressions of greivance or dissent. None of which are sufficient reasons to go to war with Iran rather than any number of other similiar regimes. The anti-Iran narrative in the West which centers around its nuclear ambitions is circumstantial at best and often entirely fabricated by groups who want the US to change the Iranian regime by force for their own selfish reasons. Some so that they themselves can be the new dictators, others for the even less palatable reason of ideology. I can't sit idly by and watch such a push for war with Iran on false pretenses even if I do find the Iranian regime odious. Two wrongs really don't make a moral right.
Crossposted from Newshoggers
What are the rules in Iran?
Is it like the United States where you can be held indefinitely as an enemy combatant without a trial?
And I hope they don't torture him like the U.S. allows.
I hope I never get tortured. I have such a low threshold of pain that I would confess to anything.
t's a theocracy disguised with some democratic trappings ...
Oh, you mean like the White Christian States of America that evangelicals and the GOP seem think we live in?
The sad thing is, whenever you cast aspersions on them, you're basically told, "You have free speech! Now shut the f--- up!"
The Bush Policy of torture/rape/murder might be the new Law of the World. As other countries see their citizens kidnapped held without charge and tortured. The US can no longer call for action from the United Nations. Iran can always say we are following the Law of the United States Govenment. Next we'll hear Americans are being kidnapped and help without charge forever. We allow our Presidential Dictator to bring this Policy to action for 8 years, even Obama/Biden can't change history.
To travel to Iran and openly criticize the Iranian government in their own country is just asking for it. It's a suicide mission at best.
Even if he beats the spying rap, I can't imagine his future looking too bright, atheistic beliefs and whatnot.
Don't try to confuse the issue with half-truths and gorilla dust.
I hope he's well and is released soon.
I really doubt he's an Israeli spy, but that whole bit about Israel being the freest country in the Middle East is absolute hogwash. Sure, it's free for anyone who happens to be Jewish.
I've been hoping for regime change in the USA for 8 years now. I never suggested starting a war with you to change it, even if you do break international laws, actually use nuclear weapons (Japan), and torture people, like the people (some of) you cast aspersions on.
far left loon >.<
It sucks when the U.S. abducts a Canadian and renditions him to Syria, and it sucks when Iran abducts a Canadian.
It sucks even worse that we can't claim much moral high ground in this sort of case. When we're only slightly better than THAT??
Did I mention it sucks?
They'll probably tie his ass up to the nuclear facility that the Israelies are going to destroy. Great lesson Rumsfeld's buddy, Husseinm, taught them.
Bada bing, bada boom!
Counting the days till 1/20/09
"Your lips move but I can't hear what you're saying..."-------Roger Waters, "Comfortably Numb"
I find that I use this statement a lot in life. But, it fits perfectly to this situation. I hope Derakhshan is well and will be released. Can you imagine how the families of the people that we've renditioned must feel? America has no moral high ground to tell other countries what is right or wrong.
> saying he had been arrested and charged
> with spying on behalf of Israel
LOL! I can't imagine that there's anything left in any of the Christian terrorist occupied State that is worth being spied upon. Still, Israeli terrorism is a serious treat.
Comments are closed on this entry