Moon Over Alabama

Moon Over Alabama Constitutional law applies to the states -- even Alabama The question of whether states can ignore Supreme Court rulings was decide

Moon Over Alabama

Constitutional law applies to the states -- even Alabama The question of whether states can ignore Supreme Court rulings was decided a long time ago. Unfortunately, four leading right-wing judicial candidates running for Alabama's Supreme Court are still confused.

In a debate with powerful echoes of the turbulent civil rights era, four Republicans running for Alabama's Supreme Court are making an argument legal scholars thought was settled in the 1800s: that state courts are not bound by U.S. Supreme Court precedents. The Constitution says federal law trumps state laws, and legal experts say there is general agreement that state courts must defer to the U.S. Supreme Court on matters of federal law. Yet Justice Tom Parker, who is running for chief justice, argues that state judges should refuse to follow U.S. Supreme Court precedents they believe to be erroneous. Three other GOP candidates in Tuesday's primary have made nearly identical arguments.

First Roy Moore, now this. Forget Kansas, what's the matter with Alabama?

-- Guest Post by Steve Benen, The Carpetbagger Report


About John Amato

Comments

We welcome relevant, respectful comments. Please refer to our Terms of Service for information on our posting policy.