Go Home

David Brooks 'Jayson Blair' Restoration Project

David Brooks is one of the most dishonest conservative columnists going. He's not an idiot, but he can take events that have occurred and craft them into complete nonsense. That does take real talent. Only it's a despicable one. In his latest column in the NY Times, he writes one of the most perfidious pieces of excrement imaginable.

Charles Pierce has an excellent debunking of Brooks' latest travesty in Esquire: David Brooks Does Not Get the Moral Norm of Being Broke

He notices that poor people are having fewer babies, which makes him sad. But, things are looking up! People have stopped using their "bank-issued" credit cards as much. (These would be the cards they used so as to support the overstuffed suburban lifestyle that David Brooks so celebrated in his earlier, funnier work.) This means, to Brooks, "Quietly but decisively, Americans are trying to restore the moral norms that undergird our economic system."

Jesus H. Christ in a fking Volvo, no, it doesn't. It means people are broke. People are broke because the end product of 30 years of economic theorizing and political action that you supported has resulted in a shattered middle-class. People are broke because the Wall Street casino that your politics created and celebrated and enabled finally broke the entire country and took the rest of us down with it. People are broke because you and the rest of your "conservative" pals latched onto a crackpot scheme called supply-side economics, married it to a deregulatory frenzy and free trade, and then pitched it to the Bobos as economic liberty. You got rich. You got important. Now people are not using their credit cards because they can't afford to buy the overpriced, Chinese-made crap that you once proposed as the new staple of American society. That is not a conscious mass moral choice. You've got to be on mushrooms to believe that.
We continue.

"Second, Americans are trying to re-establish the link between effort and reward. This was the link that was severed on Wall Street, where so many made so much for work that served no productive purpose. This was the link that was frayed by the bailouts, when people who broke the rules still got rewarded."

Oh, really? What tipped you off, Sherlock? Got two sources for that insight? Have no fear, though. Brooks has lingered as long as he cares to in the general vicinity of the fact that the people his politics enabled and celebrated were grievously amoral in almost everything they did for a decade. He's got workers to bash.

"The auto bailouts mostly worked, but they are unpopular even in the Midwestern states that directly benefited because those who failed in the market still got the gold. Public sector unions are unpopular because of the perception that benefit packages are out of balance."

The prosecution would like an offer of proof on that first sentence, Your Honor. As to the second, and the ironclad "perception" on which it depends, I guess Brooks was watching the Amanda Knox trial and missed all those people standing around on the lawn in Madison last winter, and he's still missing all those folks in Ohio who are kicking John Kasich's nuts through the roof of his mouth.

Ah, but the real brilliance is yet to come.

"The third norm is that loyalty matters. A few years ago there was a celebration of Free Agent Nation. But now most people, even most young people, would rather work long-term for one company than move around in search of freedom and opportunity."

Yes, you idiot, they would. Everyone would. Unfortunately, and I hate to keep bringing this up, Dave, but 30 years of dumb Republican economics and even dumber Republican politics, both of which you made your bones celebrating, have sort of made that impossible. (A couple of decades of bipartisan "free-trade" agreements haven't helped, either.) Who was it that was cheering on "Free Agent Nation"? It was the politicians and the pundits who were declaring the golden age of the global economy, in which we'd all have two or three jobs before we retired, fat and happy, on the 401k's that the miracle of Wall Street by then would have inflated beyond our wildest dreams. Anyone who meekly suggested that, maybe, he'd like to put in 20 years at his job and collect a pension at the end of it that he could live on, was dismissed as a whiny relic of a past age, or as a state employee. And, in any case, part of the miracle of Wall Street was devising new and complicated financial instruments by which private pension plans could be pillaged for private profit. If David Brooks was concerned about this prior to 2008, when the people who go to dinner with him and who pay his honoraria nearly blew up the world, he kept devilishly quiet about it.

What American capitalism knows about "moral norms" is that they are for other people. The people who did all the real damage are not in any way interested in "repairing the economic moral fabric" that "is the essential national task right now." They are interested in keeping the money they stole and in stealing as much more of it as they can. But David Brooks is far more concerned with some guy, sitting around his kitchen table, bills up to his elbows, who decides that, in the interest of the "economic moral fabric" of the country, he won't take the kids to Chuck E. Cheese tonight on the family MasterCard. Congratulations, good and faithful servant, says David Brooks, and orders another brandy.

Pierce reminds us of this take down by Sasha Issenberg back in 2004 that should have had him booted out of the occupation of masquerading as an intellectual writer of non-fiction.

(h/t Atrios)

Share This Post

Link To This Post


9 Comments
Captain Kangaroo's picture

People have stopped using their "bank-issued" credit cards as much because the cards are either maxed out or they don't want to pay the 30% interest rate because their credit is so poor because they are broke. Why do these Republicans act like total turds?

MaryK's picture

This was brought home to me when I got my first paycheck from subbing a little while ago. The pay for substitutes has been cut by $10/day, while the schoolday has been extended by 1/2 hour. Maybe I should be happy that I'm working at all!


"Courtesy is owed. Respect is earned. Love is given." --Unknown author, found in Guide to Texas Etiquette by Kinky Friedman

Hazel-Rah's picture

I only regret that Pierce did not have the chance to say this to Brooks face to face on national TV or whatever medium available that I could watch.

I stopped reading any of his stuff or watching him on PBS years ago.
I wonder what he'll have to say about the reasons for the next crash - which will likely happen in the not -to-distant future?

Does he know what is happening in Europe...specifically Greece and Spain? Does he know that the Bank of America is acting on the "Fourth Norm" .....continue to perpetrate fraud while you still can get away with it...as they're trying to move debt from a failing part to a subsidiary insured by the FDIC. This must be David's "Fifth Norm" - let BoA off the hook and make the taxpayers continue to pay while the criminals get million dollar bonuses.

And, does David have any clue about what might happen when the $600 Trillion in OTC derivatives market floating around the globe (in the asteroid belt, no doubt) blows up or crashes down...or whatever it will do??

"When will all the poor, unemployed Americans wise -up," says David, "and start spending again - preferably on my books?"


"Egotism is the anesthetic that dulls the pain of Stupidity" - Frank Leahy

dasqf's picture

absolutly LOVES david brooks......pretty fucking funny...check out his site.


....the fools do not realize,a population that can ,..... not paticipate .............in the 'economy'...,can not keep it viable!..........."we are listening,.......and we're not blind.,......this is your life....this is your time."

Daddio478's picture

every day dasqf, he is spot on. " Hey, I'm an Adjective! ". If Brooks had his head any further up his ass about the real pulse of this nation, he would be crowned as "king of disconnect".


"No man is so foolish but he may sometimes give another good counsel, and no man so wise that he may not easily err if he takes no other counsel than his own. He that is taught only by himself has a fool for a master." - Hunter S. Thompson

Phylter's picture

Are spending as much as possible on paying down credit card debt and cutting them up as soon as they are paid off. We have knocked off about 15K in two years, most of which was for her dental work, implants don't come cheap, but of course, if there was really affordable health care, we wouldn't have been in this position.

Amitola's picture

I've mentioned this before. As I have no dental insurance either, my dentist told me about 'Care Credit' (a subsidiary of GE Bank). They provide no interest financing for dental, medical, chiro, vision, etc., for up to 24 months. Your provider has to be signed-up with their program (there's a provider directory on their site), and you need to supply very basic financial info to get approved.

I've used the service for about 2 years for dental work and it works as advertised....You might want to check it out for future use....I think the website is just carecredit.com.


"Egotism is the anesthetic that dulls the pain of Stupidity" - Frank Leahy

barkleyg's picture

Charles Pierce had this to say, and I agree 100% !

The GOP Is Not Giving Up 50 Years of Bigotry for This Guy

Read more: http://www.esquire.com/blogs/p.....z1bWmp8Eaq

Pierce writes like I speak: REAL words, real feelings, no “nice” words when REAL words work!

Comments are closed on this entry