WH Claims Executive Privilege Over Tillman Documents

pattillman.jpg And the disgraceful Pat Tillman saga continues.. How's this for "supporting the troops" and respecting their families?

Seattle Times:

The White House has refused to give Congress documents about the death of former NFL player Pat Tillman, with White House counsel Fred Fielding saying that certain papers relating to discussion of the friendly-fire shooting "implicate Executive Branch confidentiality interests."

Reps. Henry Waxman, D-Calif., and Tom Davis R-Va., the leading members of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, objected to the refusal Friday in letters to the White House and the Defense Department.

White House and Pentagon officials have turned over about 10,000 pages of material, but Waxman and Davis said those papers lack critical documents that would show communications between senior administration officials and top military officers shortly after Tillman was killed in Afghanistan in 2004.

Is there anything this administration is not secretive about? And why would they want to conceal their role in the cover-up informing of the Tillman family?



Login or Register to post comments.

133 comments

This is how they support our troops.

:)

:)

Because it would expose this administration for what it truly is " a fantabulous marketing adventure".

Their deepest fear is that the American public is no longer buying what they are selling.

And their craven marketing of the Tillman's families personal misfortune would expose them for the beasts that they are.

Did the family get any documentation from the Whitehouse?

Let's tell them how we really feel.

http://myfightfordemocracy.blogspot.com/2007/07/new-declaration-of-indep...

Impeach. Convict. Imprison.

Make an example of these bastards.

Another White House cover up.
Pat Tillman's clothes, bulletproof vest, and personal diary were burned.
Destroying evidence and withholding facts here and everywhere, Libby, Iraq Lies, Energy Task Force.

This could be IT, folks.

Call the Generals in fer testimony. One of them who knows this affair inside and out is bound to give up the administration- the administration that shits on the military at every turn!

Andy K @ 8:

This could be IT, folks.

Call the Generals in fer testimony. One of them who knows this affair inside and out is bound to give up the administration- the administration that shits on the military at every turn!

What generals? I thought Bush fired them all.

Does the FOIA cover this? Assuming they haven't classified the Tillman affair?

If we Dems had a brain, we would send a second request to W and have it delivered by members of the Tillman family. Show the nation how W and Cheney treat vets and their families.

In my dreams,

This is stunning news.

And, the country moves yet another step toward military dictatorship.

If Congress learns what those documents include the terrorists have won.

Tillman's mother will go justifiably beserk. If there is going to be a straw, this is it, for God's sake. What more will it take?!

“implicate Executive Branch confidentiality interests.”

In other words, from the highest levels they gleefully and shamelessly used Tilman's death to fabricate a propaganda blitz. Just ask Jessica Lynch: That's what it implies, right?

smchris @ 16:

“implicate Executive Branch confidentiality interests.”

In other words, from the highest levels they gleefully and shamelessly used Tilman's death to fabricate a propaganda blitz. Just ask Jessica Lynch: That's what it implies, right?

You sir are correct

Gee what a surprise! What harm could it do to give the family some peace. They could have given the family the details without us even knowing about it. I'm sure the Democrats would have respected that. The pain will never go away for the family but I really think these neocon assholes enjoy the extra pain they inflict on this family. Neocons wage war with other families sons and daughters. It's like a chess game to them. A chess game. Think about it. They lie about going to war and do not care at all what it means. George Bush worries about his legacy? What a dick. The brave soldiers who have died have no legacy. They are dead. No legacy George, they are dead. Dead. Dead.

I can only imagine kkkarl's fingerprints all over this one...most likely rummies too. With the implication that shooter and chimpy listened in via teleconference. The worst part is the loss by the Tillman family. That means nothing to these maniacs.

Investigate, Indict and Impeach

Our beloved executive criminals.

Pssssssst....

WE are letting this happen.

It is up to WE THE PEOPLE is it not?

Be not afraid to stand up,

Fear remaining seated.

If you stand up and are stricken you die on your feet and not your ass. How shall a man die on his ass and remain a man? Oh that's right...never was one then.

JimmyK

Everyday I can't help but draw comparisons between this administration locked up with their White House and the portrayal of Hitler in Downfall locked up in his bunker. Especially the part where he refused to let the people out of Berlin while it was being sieged because they didn't matter one little bit. It's just so very sad.

JimmyK As a wheel chair bound individual I resent your last remark. You are one callous SOB.

Ron @ 9:

Andy K @ 8:

This could be IT, folks.

Call the Generals in fer testimony. One of them who knows this affair inside and out is bound to give up the administration- the administration that shits on the military at every turn!

What generals? I thought Bush fired them all.

Even better. They'll be in the mood to talk.

Bruce Fine, a right winger who was active in the impeachment of Bill Clinton, was on Bill Moyer's Journal tonight on PBS.

He was eloquent in his advocating the impeachment of Bush--Cheney. A few more like him, and they are history.

What the.....!?

Executive privilege over an issue like this!? It is just disgrace......makes me sick. A soldier's family must know how their son/daughter died fighting for their country. A basic right……damn it.

Then maybe Pat will have died for a good reason if this causes the further destruction of over-reaching powers in this administration.

Pat did die for a good cause. Friendly fire deaths are a part of war. All this post-death game playing and deception doesnt change that.

IMPEACH NOW!
For cryin' out loud.

"implicate"? you dont say.

these repubs want to track and trace every aspect of our lives while letting corporations have no regulation and while they claim Executive Privilege over everything and stonewall FOIA requests

fedupwithhypocrisy @ 15:

Tillman's mother will go justifiably beserk. If there is going to be a straw, this is it, for God's sake. What more will it take?!

Could not have said it better.

cheney/bush'es abuse of 'executive priviledge' and anything else they can get away with will continue and get worse until they are impeached or worse. If the law meant anything to them they would have stopped a long time ago.

And the bu$h Cartel can take it's executive priviledge and shove it up their collective asses!!!!!

bubba @ 28:

Pat did die for a good cause. Friendly fire deaths are a part of war. All this post-death game playing and deception doesnt change that.

That is the most fucked up comment I've seen in a while.

does this finally stab in the heart the idea that Republicans are better to the military? I mean I know that not giving them the supplies they need or a plan for what to do after they arrived in Baghdad is showing the utmost support for our soldiers, but will this finally lay to rest the bullshit idea that the conservatives spew like a broken record?

I mean the Republicans have shown they have no respect for American, the American Military or the American System of Justice...so what exactly makes them better for America? Go ahead you sorry ass lurkers, explane to me, becuase I don't get it, you all just look like America Haters to me, but what do I know huh, I'm just a liberal how doesn't believe our troops should be sent into battle without body armor and proper equipment and I don't believe our soldiers should have to be put along side mercinaries who are getting paid 4 and 5 times as much to do the same jobs. I don't believe in no-bid contracts and I certainly don't believe Dubya is anything more then they greatest enemy America has ever faced.

Andy K @ 8:

This could be IT, folks.

Call the Generals in fer testimony. One of them who knows this affair inside and out is bound to give up the administration- the administration that shits on the military at every turn!

I agree - I think this is it - the moment we've been waiting for - when the light bulb could go on for the remaining 25%.

There is something so unbelievably FOUL in the Whitehouse treatment of this tragic incident - I cannot believe every American doesn't see it.

You have to wonder how something so egregious could happen in this country - what kind of people are these?
*

I don't imagine Mrs. Tillman will be as easy to swiftboat as Cindy Sheehan was.

But they'll try. Hell, if they can go after 9/11 widows, there's no limit.

How can the administration even pretend this is covered under E.P.? This is getting real bad. Like Amway salesmen have taken over the universe.

Pat @ 23:

JimmyK As a wheel chair bound individual I resent your last remark. You are one callous SOB.

Well, whereas I feel bad for your plight, it does not likely affect your mind. I know you are aware of what I was saying and it had nothing to do with the physical but the mental and the willingness to stand for the truth and our children.

If you feel you cannot do that, don't blame it on the condition you have forced upon you, but rather that which you allow.

exit7a @ 17:

smchris @ 16:

“implicate Executive Branch confidentiality interests.”
In other words, from the highest levels they gleefully and shamelessly used Tilman's death to fabricate a propaganda blitz. Just ask Jessica Lynch: That's what it implies, right?

You sir are correct

Sadam's statue being pulled down: faked
Weapons of Mass Destruction: lie
Sadam's Capture: faked
[Conspiracy theories edited. Really tinfoil hat stuff in the middle of an otherwise great list-Sitemonitor]
Heathrow Shampoo Bombers: a joke
Al Kida: Boogey Man
Condi Rice: Stateman
Elections: Rigged
Drug Importation: Jeb
Savings & Loan: Neil
Good Shepher: Dad
They are laughing at us! Couldn't we have just a smidgeon of justice?

Shared Humanity @ 3:

Because it would expose this administration for what it truly is " a fantabulous marketing adventure".

Their deepest fear is that the American public is no longer buying what they are selling.

I think we are way beyond that. What torments me is how Bush and Cheney deserve IMPEACHMENT since 2 years ago at least and this guy keeps getting away with breaking the law, defying his oath of office and dragging this nation into disgrace.

How is he getting away with it? No other presidents got away with so much, why this guy?

SwingJay: The only answer to why he gets away with it as I see it is the Dem. candidates are drooling at having such power (of course the Bushies in the courts won't let them)

Why not get some football players who knew Pat Tillman come out of the closet and do educational ads, via YouTube, about impeachment as absolutely necessary at this stage. No more game playing. Get professional football players out politically active about ending this insane war and this insane murderous traitorous regime of anti-American thugs.

Dems, write to Republican Congress members, not just to fellow Dems. Make 'em believe their base is turning on them!

Ya know, at every turn, I joke about the bunglings and even the imperial actions of this presidential administration. I make fun of them, I laugh at them, and I say stupid stuff about them. All of it is in good fun. Truthful, but still in good fun.

But I cannot, CANNOT, sit here and humor this horrendous, despicable bullshit "executive privilege" excuse pertaining to the death of an AMERICAN SOLDIER. A man who gave his life to protect us, and who was killed by friendly fire, and now, we, the Americans he fought to protect, can't know how much the people who work for US knew about this whole thing. This President will, truly, go down in history as the WORST president in the long, rich history of this great country. And he deserves every damn thing he gets. As the son of a Marine, I salute Pat Tillman, and his bravery and courage to go forth and protect this nation. And as for this President, I have a salute for him, too, but it might get me landed in Gitmo.

After this, I can pretty much guaran-damn-tee that there will be a special place in hell reserved just for those in the Bush Administration, and George W. Bush and Richard Cheney will get the best seats in the house.

The Champ is out.

Why would there be critical documents between senior administration and top military officers shortly after Tillman was killed? What's there to hide?

Abu Ghraib
   Got public attention beginning 2004. Trials ended by September 2005
Pat Tillman
   KIA - April 22, 2004

A Hero makes a good distraction...

What are WE going to with Emperor George 43? This will turn out to be the most corrupt and imperous administrations in US history.

(202) 224-3121 tell your Rep. to support H.Res. 333.
Most Americans support impeachment of Cheney, nearly half of Bush. Why don't their Representatives?

IMPEACH

These are the same bastards that electrocuted my uncle in the VA because he had shell-shock after WW II.

BASTARDS. ENOUGH.

Well, if the White House wants to conceal documents, they probably point out that the White House orchestrated the lies about the Tillman death.

miss_kitty @ 35:

bubba @ 28:

Pat did die for a good cause. Friendly fire deaths are a part of war. All this post-death game playing and deception doesnt change that.

That is the most fucked up comment I've seen in a while.

I had to read her post twice to be sure I was reading correctly and bubba I second what you said.

The Champ @ 46:

Ya know, at every turn, I joke about the bunglings and even the imperial actions of this presidential administration. I make fun of them, I laugh at them, and I say stupid stuff about them. All of it is in good fun. Truthful, but still in good fun.

But I cannot, CANNOT, sit here and humor this horrendous, despicable bullshit "executive privilege" excuse pertaining to the death of an AMERICAN SOLDIER. A man who gave his life to protect us, and who was killed by friendly fire, and now, we, the Americans he fought to protect, can't know how much the people who work for US knew about this whole thing. This President will, truly, go down in history as the WORST president in the long, rich history of this great country. And he deserves every damn thing he gets. As the son of a Marine, I salute Pat Tillman, and his bravery and courage to go forth and protect this nation. And as for this President, I have a salute for him, too, but it might get me landed in Gitmo.

After this, I can pretty much guaran-damn-tee that there will be a special place in hell reserved just for those in the Bush Administration, and George W. Bush and Richard Cheney will get the best seats in the house.

The Champ is out.

(applauds with enthusiasm) Damn, if I had tried I could not have said it better.

carol @ 52:

miss_kitty @ 35:

bubba @ 28:

Pat did die for a good cause. Friendly fire deaths are a part of war. All this post-death game playing and deception doesnt change that.

That is the most fucked up comment I've seen in a while.

I had to read her post twice to be sure I was reading correctly and bubba I second what you said.

The second most fucked up comment.

Andy K @ 8:

This could be IT, folks.

Call the Generals in fer testimony. One of them who knows this affair inside and out is bound to give up the administration- the administration that shits on the military at every turn!

Could be! Wait... that's just Disneyland going off.

No mother; indeed no parent should endure this, furthermore; no parent should sit idly by. Corporal Pat Tillman deserves that mothers and fathers of America rally in support of his mother's quest for truth. Corporal Tillman's mother, and his family, deserve the admiration and vocal support of every parent out there.
But for the grace of God, that could be your child. Close your eyes to this and you forfeit any claims to the life and death of your children.

spit take @ 38:

I don't imagine Mrs. Tillman will be as easy to swiftboat as Cindy Sheehan was.

But they'll try. Hell, if they can go after 9/11 widows, there's no limit.

And they love going after the women ~
*

So basically this is an admission of guilt that the President was personally involved in the cover up of Pat Tillman's death and the surrounding propaganda campaign.

Sounds like have another Cindy Sheehan in the brewing.

This is apparently the Rovian strategy for Bush and the repigs with the elections coming up next year.

Bush and Cheney are abusing their power as they stonewall oversite hearings, obstruct justice, while the repig senators filabuster all bills.

It's to try and give the appearance that the dem majority are the ones wasting time on hearings and not getting any legislation passed.

Of course you also have Bush and Cheney blatantly flipping off all American citizens. Since nothing will come from all these hearings why don't they just put impeachment back on the table.

They may not have enough votes for it to work but they would still have the opportunity to expose all of the corruption and abuse of power.

The repigs always play politics with the war and claim these hearings are just "show trials" well come dem's grow some f**king balls and give them one hell of a show trial!

Hey Bubba at 28, why don't you enlist and put your pathetic life on the line if you think it's for such a good cause you ignorant, delusional, foolish bastard you!

American Psycho @ 60:

Hey Bubba at 28, why don't you enlist and put your pathetic life on the line if you think it's for such a good cause you ignorant, delusional, foolish bastard you!

Take carol @ 52 with you

I think I'm starting to come down with a lethal case of Bush fatigue! :( Will this nightmare ever end?

E in Md @ 58:

So basically this is an admission of guilt that the President was personally involved in the cover up of Pat Tillman's death and the surrounding propaganda campaign.

Sounds like have another Cindy Sheehan in the brewing.

Why the Executive Privilege then?

Why not just tell us the entire truth regarding the matter?

These are quotes from republicans when Clinton committed troops to Bosnia. Where is all of their concern today with 3400+ US soldiers dead, over 20,000 wounded, billions of dollars wasted, the death of 50,000-650,000 innocent Iraqi citizens , no victory or exit strategy, more chaos and no end in sight??

"You can support the troops but not the president."
-Rep-Tom Delay (R-TX)

"Well I just think it's a bad idea. Whats going to happen is they're going to be over there for 10, 15 maybe 20 years."
-Joe Scarborough (R-FL)

"Explain to the mothers and fathers of American servicemen that may come home in body bags, why their son or daughter have to give up their life?"
-Sean Hannity (Fox News, 4/6/99)

"Victory means exit strategy and it is important for the President to explain to us what that exit strategy is."
-Governor George W. Bush (R-TX)

"I had my doubts about the bombing campaign from the begining...I don't think we had done enough in the diplomatic area."
-Trent Lott (R-MS)

"If we are going to committ American troops, we must be certain they have a clear mission, an achievable goal and an exit strategy."
-Karen Hughes, speaking on behalf of Governor George W. Bush (R-TX)

The bastard (George Bush) didn't claim executive privilege when he came out and lied about how this young man died. He was happy to spew the garbage of this young man being a hero so that he could bate others to join this scam of a so called war.

It is only after we learn the truth that he is now claiming this so called executive privilege that is simply another illegal cheap shot in the face of the American people.

This guy and his entire administration needs to be removed from office before they start a mutiny in this country and he better be dame happy I am not the mom of this young man.

While we are at it, we also need to remove this disgusting media that is contributing to many of the problems for American people.

We should never let up off the FCC, to force them to provide a progressive view on our radio stations all over this country. They should not be allowed to get away with this sick game they play about this so called liberal media that none of us have heard sense but stole office, both times

These people are obligated to provide a progressive voice to counter this right wing bull shit they force on us as they clog up all this free radio air waves with the daily trash they are feeding American people .

The information they are hiding is creating a huge mess and they know it, which is why they continue to do it and never believe that Bush and Karl Row is not behind it like they are everything else that is evil in this country, including 9/11.

Aide: Mr. President, the United States is under attack.

Bush: uh.....uh......

Hey whatever happened to the old regulars like Sphinx, E-man, Mirth and Nate? Do they still comment here anymore?

Bush needs to be kicked out of office. Impeach the whole rotten lot of them. They're daring us to do it.

I will be volunteering at The LA Impeachment Center tomorrow. I am done with this crap!

So Al Qaeda is known to be training and operating in Pakistan now. Hmm didn't Bush once threaten military action against any country that is known to harbor terrorists?

I guess that only counts for countries who do not have nuclear weapons. No wonder why Iran wants nuclear weapons.

JimmyK @ 40

Well, whereas I feel bad for your plight, it does not likely affect your mind. I know you are aware of what I was saying and it had nothing to do with the physical but the mental and the willingness to stand for the truth and our children.

If you feel you cannot do that, don't blame it on the condition you have forced upon you, but rather that which you allow.

I was just fucking with you JimmyK...I'm an able bodied retired military guy. You were talking about what it takes to be a man. I'd like to hear your qualifications? And hey...keyboard warrior doesn't count.

[Deleted. Please consult the commenting policy-Sitemonitor]

that was supposed to be for bubba@28. My bad.

Sitemonitor: I urge you to check comments 60 and 61. They are every bit as bad or worse than my last comment. The one that was deleted.Talk about flame bait.
[Actually your comment was pretty vicious. And your claims were off base and inaccurate. Then you said you directed it at bubba, whose same comment you said you agreed with earlier-Sitemonitor]

Tillman was murdered, it was no accident.

"But the true threats to stability and peace are these nations that are not very transparent, that hide behind the - that don't let people in to take a look and see what they're up to. They're very kind of authoritarian regimes."

George W. Bush, in a media roundtable discussion, March 13, 2001

The fact that the White House is claiming executive privilege over what would ordinarily be just a military matter shows (1) the White House is involved in spinning military actions (who wudda thunk?) and (2) the Bush administration will stop at NOTHING to advance its political goals, and regardless of the cost to the military and the families involved.

Had enough, folks? What more do we need to impeach the SOBS??

Tillman sure could defend against the deep pass but, not frag from his own teammates. Did anyone see his flag draped coffin at DAFB? Or, was this also blacked out?

carol @ 52:

miss_kitty @ 35:

bubba @ 28:

Pat did die for a good cause. Friendly fire deaths are a part of war. All this post-death game playing and deception doesnt change that.

That is the most fucked up comment I've seen in a while.

I had to read her post twice to be sure I was reading correctly and bubba I second what you said.

Just what is fucked up about Miss Kitty's comment if you have studied any military history?

Friendly fire goes back a long way.

Own up to it as well as to the manipulations regarding the story and move on. The executive privilege routine is getting pretty old as a tactic in trying to cover up mistakes, possible crimes, and errors instead of just owning up to them. What are we, back in the days of President Grant again?

Would the chickenshit Republicans start joining the military. Instead of attending your Ivy League colleges, pass up that opportunity and serve your country. Pat Tillman gave up millions of dollars because he thought serving his country was the noble thing to do. I am tired of these shitheads calling everybody a coward that wants to leave Irag. Be the tough guy you claim you are and enlist.

uh santa-I said the comment of Bubba's was fucked up. We shouldn't have been there in the first place. So the fact that anyone has died fighting for CheneyBushCo has not died 'for a good cause.' And saying so made it a fucked up comment. JMHO

As for executive privilege, it simply does not apply in this case.

StCyrlyMe @ 65:

While we are at it, we also need to remove this disgusting media that is contributing to many of the problems for American people.

We should never let up off the FCC, to force them to provide a progressive view on our radio stations all over this country. They should not be allowed to get away with this sick game they play about this so called liberal media that none of us have heard sense but stole office, both times

These people are obligated to provide a progressive voice to counter this right wing bull shit they force on us as they clog up all this free radio air waves with the daily trash they are feeding American people .

Were you old enough to remember when the fairness doctrine was supposedly in effect? It was ineffective, hence why it went in the dust bin.

The radio marketplace pretty fairly determines what gets or stays on the airwaves. In NY we don't have an FM country music station because very few listened to it.

Air America's ratings are dwarfed by conservative radio. Alan Colmes syndicated radio show is pretty much dwarfed by competition.

You can't force people in the marketplace of ideas to listen to your message. You have to be able, like a Michael Moore, to coat your message in honey so that you are not only preaching to the choir, but also influencing the fence sitters as well as the opposition.

If progressive hosts figured out a formula that was similar and enticing to the public, the ratings would jump. If you mandate that they be on stations as counterpoints to Rush, Hannity, etc., you will just hear a lot of clicks of the dial if it is not entertaining.

What will you do my American friends , when george manufactures a "national emergency" as a result of "intelligence" recieved. He will then suspend the electoral process until such time as the emergency is over and claim excutive privilege.

miss_kitty @ 81:

uh santa-I said the comment of Bubba's was fucked up. We shouldn't have been there in the first place. So the fact that anyone has died fighting for CheneyBushCo has not died 'for a good cause.' And saying so made it a fucked up comment. JMHO

As for executive privilege, it simply does not apply in this case.

Sorry, I was confused by the thread. While I disagree with your viewpoint on Afghanistan as far as being their in the first place, I do agree with you with regards to the cover-up & executive privilege.

Yeah-No matter how he died-the cover up was totally disrespectful to his service, his life, his sacrifice.

This isn't the first or only instance when this administration has been involved in a cover-up:

A video showing how a British soldier was killed by American warplanes in Iraq was finally released by the US last night - four years after the fatal attack, and only after it had been leaked to the media. It will be used as evidence in the inquest on L/Cpl Matty Hull, 25, whose family had been told that the footage did not exist...

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qn4158/is_20070207/ai_n17201988

The killing of Lance Corporal Matty Hull in an American air strike in Iraq was a "criminal, unlawful act" by pilots who opened fire "with disregard for the rules of engagement", a coroner ruled yesterday.

Oxfordshire Assistant Deputy Coroner Andrew Walker also scathingly criticised the US authorities for their lack of co-operation which had caused so much "pain and suffering" to L/Cpl Hull's family. The failure to hand over important documents has meant that "the full facts have not yet come to light".

L/Cpl Hull, 25, died when his convoy came under attack from two A-10 "Tankbuster" warplanes despite the British vehicles showing orange markings to signify allied forces.

http://news.independent.co.uk/uk/legal/article2366536.ece

Not that any protest made a difference:

A diplomatic row erupted between London and Washington ght over George Bush's bid to cover up the way bungling US soldiers killed British servicemen in Iraq.

The President's envoy in the UK has been summoned to a humiliating dressing down in Whitehall tomorrow because of a White House refusal to make American troops answer in British courts for their mistakes on the battlefield...

...The provocative action of Ms Harman is supported by Oxfordshire Coroner Andrew Walker, who has conducted most of the inquests into British soldiers killed in Iraq. He has privately voiced his anger with the Americans, accusing them of making it hard to do his job properly.

Ms Harman has been in talks with the Americans for nearly six months in an unsuccessful attempt to resolve the dispute. They refused to change their stance even after she guaranteed no risk of criminal prosecution or compensation.

She decided to go public after they rejected demands to send US service personnel to two recent friendly-fire inquests conducted by Mr Walker. Earlier this month he ruled the deaths of two RAF Tornado pilots, Flight Lieutenants Kevin Main and Dave Williams, were 'entirely avoidable'. The fliers were shot down by an American Patriot missile.

And last month he criticised US Marines blamed for the 'unlawful killing' of ITN reporter Terry Lloyd after the invasion of Iraq in 2003.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/news.html?in_article...

If the British couldn't get any straight answers out of the Bush administration for all these unlawful deaths, the Tillmans stand no chance.

Disgraceful. And criminal.

miss_kitty @ 54:

carol @ 52:

miss_kitty @ 35:

bubba @ 28:

That is the most fucked up comment I've seen in a while.

I had to read her post twice to be sure I was reading correctly and bubba I second what you said.

The second most fucked up comment.

Hmm, I even recall reading an article about this in a norwegian magazine a couple of months back.

If I recall correctly, he got three (three) bullets in the face, while the rest of the patrol he led sustained not a single injury. Apparently, he had lost faith in the US war effort, and was appalled at the behaviour of US forces in Afghanistan. His diary, which he had faithfully written in since he was a kid, was burned, and his family lied to, mere weeks before he was to return to the US, possibly to go public with what happens.

Friendly fire? Well....

The biggest threat to the Bush Administration is an informed public. I wrote that two years ago, and not much has changed when it comes to this corrupt administration trying to cover up their crimes.

Look, Americans stood silent and allowed the disgracefull actions of the Swiftboat Veterans for Truth in 2004 to slander and defame the service of John Kerry. Their actions and the silence of the "Commander in Chief", the Secretary of Defense, the Secretary of the Navy, and every other honorable veteran in defending John Kerrys service to his country stands in stark testimony to the attitudes of everyone who allowed these lies to be blasted across the airwaves of America. This insult rendered my awards, medals, and citations totally worthless, for if John Kerry did not actually deserve his purple heart and silver star, then my awards are also worthless and undeserved. Why would we think therefore that these so called patriots in the republican party would do anything other than cover up Pat Tillmans death and disrespect his service? Hell, as I recall, the Republican Convention even made a mockery of John Kerry's purple heart! They can be so proud of themselves, most most likely HAD OTHER PRIORITIES when it came to military service to their country anyway ... in all honesty, most most likely are cowards plain and simple! Executive privilege my ass ... they are nothing short of liars, cowards, and traitors to our country and deserve the contempt of us all!

Norse @ 87:

miss_kitty @ 54:

carol @ 52:

miss_kitty @ 35:
I had to read her post twice to be sure I was reading correctly and bubba I second what you said.

The second most fucked up comment.

Hmm, I even recall reading an article about this in a norwegian magazine a couple of months back.

If I recall correctly, he got three (three) bullets in the face, while the rest of the patrol he led sustained not a single injury. Apparently, he had lost faith in the US war effort, and was appalled at the behaviour of US forces in Afghanistan. His diary, which he had faithfully written in since he was a kid, was burned, and his family lied to, mere weeks before he was to return to the US, possibly to go public with what happens.

Friendly fire? Well....

Cheney/Rummy ordered the murder of Pat Tillman because Pat's charisma could no longer serve the neocon/fascist lies. Let's stop beating around the bushslut and try cheneybushrummycondicolonrover for TREASON and MASS MURDER. And let's start with their assasination of Pat Tillman, a leader and patriot.

One more outrage from the Bush administration. How they can possibly justify executive privilege over this matter is beyond me? But, then again, how they've managed to get away with everything else they do is beyond me. I would really love to know what they're hiding.

I think people should just start openly talking about this as the ordered assassination of Pat Tillman rather than his death by friendly fire. When I first heard he was strongly against the Iraq war and then they found a certain number of bullets in his forehead, it was pretty clear it was a deliberate hit. There is no other reason I can come up with as to why the White House would claim "executive privilege" for this. Let's start calling it what it was: Political assassination. If they want to deny it, they can prove it!

This administration could easily commit murder or any number of heinous crimes and get away with it by claiming executive privilege. You do have to wonder why they're so secretive.

Contact your Senator and Congress critter and demand the "impeachment" of these criminals.

call congress to pass conyer's h.r.333, the impeachment of cheney, h.r.111, the impeachment of bush, h.r.222, the impeachment of gonzales, h.r.444, the impeachment of rice, h.r.555, the impeachment of rumsfeld and roll it into h.r.666, which renames guantanamo to spandau and replaces there the enemies foreign with the enemies domestic

Executive Privilege = We're lying our asses off over and you can't do crap about it so NAH NAH NAH!

650, 000 dead Iraqi civilions and no one cares

Shared Humanity @ 3:

Because it would expose this administration for what it truly is " a fantabulous marketing adventure".

Their deepest fear is that the American public is no longer buying what they are selling.

though the block of believers and followers is truly shrinking, they still are the loudest. and because they are, it would appear that they are the largest and the strongest. the rest of american must speak in unison and send the one-toothed wonders and snake handlers back to their holes. but to do that, the head must first be severed. impeach now.

We have all the proof we need to realize this Administration is completely corrupt.
Impeachment will take too long. The Democrats are doing the right thing, Just keep these inquiries going and they will keep exposing just how corrupt and evil they are. Eventually they will only be able to convince the 28%'rs of idiotic American who never will admit that the Administration is wrong about just about everything. The Republican Party is crumbling and will continue as long as we keep asking the hard questions.

Thing Fish @ 47:

Why would there be critical documents between senior administration and top military officers shortly after Tillman was killed? What's there to hide?

Abu Ghraib
   Got public attention beginning 2004. Trials ended by September 2005
Pat Tillman
   KIA - April 22, 2004

A Hero makes a good distraction...

Bingo

Karl Rove's only concern is maintaining the narrative.

But, #76, you'll notice that he didn't say that was a BAD thing.

Shelly @ 92:

I think people should just start openly talking about this as the ordered assassination of Pat Tillman rather than his death by friendly fire. When I first heard he was strongly against the Iraq war and then they found a certain number of bullets in his forehead, it was pretty clear it was a deliberate hit. There is no other reason I can come up with as to why the White House would claim "executive privilege" for this. Let's start calling it what it was: Political assassination. If they want to deny it, they can prove it!

After his death . . . I was watching the NFL Arizona Cardinals on TV . . . . they had a huge "jumbotron" kitsch filled tribute video at halftime mythanizing the American Hero "Pat Tillman" . . . President Bush segment starts and the entire stadium starts booing . . . they prematurely cut away to General Myers in the sportcasters booth who talks about progress in Iraq . . . segment ends and they transition to commercial playing Green Day's "American Idiot".

My jaw dropped to the floor. Major cognitive disonnance bomb or just capitalistic nihilism run amok?

This is a true story dear readers.

I was just fucking with you JimmyK...I'm an able bodied retired military guy. You were talking about what it takes to be a man. I'd like to hear your qualifications? And hey...keyboard warrior doesn't count.

1) Am glad you are able bodied.

2) Am grateful for your service to our country.

3) Agree "Keyboard Warriors" are generally all talk and no substance.

One who feels the need to list what he considers as his "qualifications" for being a man is probably is less secure in the fact of being one than he lets on.

Thanks

They're hiding the fact that they probably used Tillman as target practice.

American Psycho @ 70:

So Al Qaeda is known to be training and operating in Pakistan now. Hmm didn't Bush once threaten military action against any country that is known to harbor terrorists?

I guess that only counts for countries who do not have nuclear weapons. No wonder why Iran wants nuclear weapons.

Do you honestly believe that our military has the capacity to do anything in Pakistan that wouldn't kill huge numbers of civilians in the process?

This is one of the tragedies of Bush's folly in Iraq: the opportunity cost of not being able to do other things that really need to be done.

Enough is enough already.

IMPEACH NOW!!!!!

Was Tillman ordered to be taking out? because he was unhappy about being in Iraq?

What are they hiding, that we already don't know? If he was ordered to be hit or killed by the Blackwater unit, or the 2 thing they probably would hide from public.

Someone or ones in the white house either ordered or at least signed off on the friendly fire tradgedy reversal for recruiting purposes, and put a gag order on the fact that Tillman was against the war in Iraq and a non-godbot.

It seems there WAS an atheist in the foxhole after all. RIP Pat, you were a true American.

ticktock @ 63:

E in Md @ 58:

So basically this is an admission of guilt that the President was personally involved in the cover up of Pat Tillman's death and the surrounding propaganda campaign.

Sounds like have another Cindy Sheehan in the brewing.

Why the Executive Privilege then?

Why not just tell us the entire truth regarding the matter?

Maybe bush had him wacked!

This makes me insane. My heart and soul ache for his family. His brother, Kevin, especially. God, it must take a mountain of restraint on his part to maintain a level head.

Pat Tillman's family knows, as do informed Americans, that Pat was A MAN IN FULL.........stunning on the outside, and rightous to the core. On the other hand, there's bu$h's track record. There is nothing else to say.

I hold the Tillman family, and their incredible son, in my heart and they inspire me every day to stay cool in spite of the evil underbelly of the slouching beasts that occupy our White House.

Now it is clear clear that our constitutions can breed dictators because this current administration is obviously a dictatorship. And it is really funny how this current dictatorship can get away with alot of things claiming executive privilege. It makes it worse that my fellow republicans have decided to put their party first before the nation. I wonder what is going on in their heads. Who is going to deliver us from this mess?

If this does not stir the family's of our troops we have no hope in this country.The army brass have been spinning and lying about a young man who volunteered and lost his life.No higher-ups were court marshaled in the torture cases at Abu Ghriab only enlisted men.Bush and the WH knew this story about Cpl. Tilman was BS but they went along.Now they are stonewalling against the family of this dead boy.Outrage.Outrage.Every newspaper should have this story on page one.Wake-up

The White House is noted for releasing negative /newscomment/info/announcements etc on Friday in hopes of not giving it legs. Why did Waxman choose Friday to comment on Tillman document quest ?

Yes it is true that republicans have decided to put party above the nation. It makes the United States a dying giant.

I have completely fogotten what the true Republican party stood for. Today it is the Grand Obnoxious Party

1) The party of Division
2) The Party of Hypocrates
3) The party of Traitors
4) The party of Propaganda
5) The party of wolves in sheep clothing
6) The party of pedophiles
7) The party of fearmongers
8) The party of Hitler
9) The Party of Hate
10) A collection of selfish Children

You know what i know that people like Rudy Guillani, Fred Thompson, Mike Huckabee, Sen John Mccain, Mitt Romney, Sen Brownback will only continue the same path. Infact no body in the republican party is fit to run this country except Ron Paul. He speaks truth to power.

doubting_terrance @ 76:

"But the true threats to stability and peace are these nations that are not very transparent, that hide behind the - that don't let people in to take a look and see what they're up to. They're very kind of authoritarian regimes."

George W. Bush, in a media roundtable discussion, March 13, 2001

Georgette Orwell @ 101:

But, #76, you'll notice that he didn't say that was a BAD thing.

You're right. Stability and peace isn't what Georgie "The War President" wanted.

AMERICA NEEDS TO GET A SPINE,.... IMPEACH THE TRAITORS NOW !!!

Enough! This administration is practically DARING Congress to impeach Bush and Cheney. If the Dems have no stomach for it, I'm done forever with the party.

Tom (Not Tom) @ 119:

Enough! This administration is practically DARING Congress to impeach Bush and Cheney. If the Dems have no stomach for it, I'm done forever with the party.

Senator Wellstone had a plane accident and Senator Leahy was sent anthrax produced at a US military installation.

[Deleted. 9/11 fantasies-Sitemonitor]

hey, #120, wellstone's plane crash was no "accident". they rubbed him out. read james fetzer's book on the subject and you'll see. no doubt about it.

Tillman was an athiest. Do you think that had anything to do with the friendly fire?
Don't jump to conclusions about what I am saying, I'm an agnostic.

This current White House administration is a disgrace. I encourage every American to write Congress, write the Senate, and write the news media concerning the wrongful way this nation is being managed. The lies, the deceit, the autocracy are unbelievable. Here is my letter to Pelosi, you bloggers may do better, but at least I quickly got one sent. Please do the same.

Dear Speaker Pelosi,
I encourage Congress to file simultaneous impeachment proceedings against Mr. George W. Bush, Dick Cheney, and Alberto Gonzales immediately. At the same time indict Harriet Meiers for her failure to appear at hearings. She is not above the legal mandates issued by congress.

It is clear that the President, et al, are not behaving rationally concerning the wars in the middle east, Iraq and Afghanistan. There is more than enough evidence to bring a case for impeachment against each of them. By bringing simultaneous impeachment charges it will call attention to the extent of the corruption and the illegal practices of this White House administration.

The majority of Americans comprehend what Congress seems to fail to understand. That this sitting president behaves like a spoiled child.

Why do you, a Mother, and leader, choose to indulge this dangerous child, who wears the mantle of president of the United States. This same spoiled child that alone has the power to press a nuclear button that can create holocaust throughout the world. I do not understand your failure to immediately press for removal of such a person as Mr. Bush. Please start impeachment proceedings. You were elected to do what was necessary to change the direction of this nation. There is no other recourse at this point.

Avoiding the impeachment process implies that the democrats in congress are as interested as the republicans in keeping the war money flowing into their districts. No matter how many die for the political contributions and profits garnered by the war. Simple logic indicates that the reason democrats have not moved for impeachment is because they, too, have sold their integrity to the lobbiests and war profiteering corporations in order to benefit personal campaign interests.

There is no sane reason to allow this president and his entourage to continue the destruction of America, as well as the ruin other nations it deems unfit to govern their own affairs.

We need to get out of Iraq and Afghanistan. We need to discontinue threats against Iran. And, we need to mind our own business. (caveat: provide food, medicines, and education to those in need).

The guy shoulda gone into acting instead of the service. He looks like either Flash Gordon or Superman.

Now we have Toby Maguire and Brendon Routh who look like they enjoy wearing tights too much.

ORCON rules prohibit classification or suppression of embarassing information.

WHo classified this information?

Once the decision -- to mislead -- was made, the post-decision deliberations are not protected by privileged.

Not surprising. They capitalized on a "friendly fire" incident they knew would create support for the war. They destroyed/are keeping the evidence.

Sounds almost carefully planned...

Its Karl's TV program . . . that's all its ever been . . . Karl controls the tube and the good shepherds loot the bank while the sheep salute the flag (which is made in China).

This really makes me sick to my stomach. This poor family. This country owes them more than this....we owe them the truth. Is there something set up for people to do to put pressure on Bush? I have already written my congresswoman. Any kind of website that anyone is aware of?

[...] Tillman story is still being hidden by the White House.  Isn’t this just [...]

Death 2 Tyrants!

Anybody happen to get when Fielding cited executive privilege? Was it Friday? Just wanted to know if the Repugs were "staying on course" with their tactics...you know, releasing bad news on a Friday, hoping that no one would notice.

[...] Crooks and Liars [...]

133 comments

Login or Register to post comments.