Go Home

Yahooooo----Congratulations to Senator Dodd for showing what a little backbone can do. Harry Reid tabled the FISA bill just a few minutes ago. Thanks to the many C&Lers and the entire Progressive blogosphere for all the emails, comments and phone calls that helped put the pressure on when it was needed most.

icon Download | play icon Download | play

Matt Browner-Hamlin writes:

Without Senator Dodd's leadership today, it is safe to assume that retroactive immunity would have passed. This is a great victory for the American people. His outspoken opposition to retroactive immunity and the Intelligence Committee's FISA bill made it impossible to move forward now...read on

Logan Murphy made the vids and says:

In his closing speech Dodd vowed to filibuster again in January if telecom amnesty is still part of the FISA legislation. This speech should be watched by every student, every member of Congress as well as all Americans who value their civil liberties. No matter which presidential candidate you support, you can’t get around the fact that this is what REAL, American leadership looks like. Bravo Senator Dodd, BRAVO!

Share This Post

Link To This Post


272 Comments
kathleen's picture

Thank you Senator Dodd. Senator Kennedy you ripped up the carpet. We are right behind you.

giving us hope

Dahgrostab'ph-r-i's picture

Great!!! this is the best news this week! I love it!

I guess it's one for the American Citizens!

Dahgrostab'ph-r-i's picture

also I saw the headline question on yahoo news: Should news media withhold identity of mass killers?

does this mean they are not going to mention George Bush or Dick Cheney in the news anymore?

adkls;f's picture

the power of one... out of, what, 228 or so?? all the more important demonstration why we need such democratic numbers against corruption.

JasonS's picture

Thank you, Senator Dodd. Thank you.

DUDE's picture

Frist!

I am relieved. Thanks to Chris Dodd, Joe Biden, Harry Ried and Arlen Spector for not allowing this inane bill to pass. Looks like our civil rights are still intact..... for now.

Jason B's picture

THANK YOU DODD! I cannot say this any more sincerely - you have saved my belief in this country. You still have an uphill battle next month, but thank you!

RobertD's picture

No sh*t???? A Democrat with spine? Show this guy some love and send his campaign a few dollars. If Ron Paul can raise $5 mil in a day for doing nothing, Chris Dodd is certainly worthy of a grass roots groundswell of financial support for this.

ShouldBeWorking's picture

I don't get it...I really don't. Reid sold out his credibility as a liberal...and for what? Tabling the bill as is only shows that he's spineless in all capacities, not just when he thinks nobody is watching. Well guess what Harry, we're watching and we'll be watching all the more closely and ever closer every time you stab Americans in the back. I hope your integrity and the respect of your constituency was worth the thousands or possibly hundreds of thousands that you sold it for. I spit on you.

rmf's picture

Great to know there are people like Dodd around.

But, won't the twerp-in-chief just veto it if it's passed? What happens then?

Slabo's picture

Bravo Sen. Dodd.

Quotes

"Liberals got women the right to vote. Liberals got African-Americans the right to vote.
Liberals created Social Security and lifted millions of elderly people out of poverty.
Liberals ended segregation. Liberals passed the Civil Rights Act, the Voting Rights Act.
Liberals created Medicare. Liberals passed the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act.

What did Conservatives do? They opposed them on every one of those things ? every one.
So when you try to hurl that label at my feet, 'Liberal,' as if it were something to be ashamed of,
something dirty, something to run away from, it won't work, Senator, because I will pick up
that label and I will wear it as a badge of honor."
-- Matt Santos

Kay's picture

Imagine that. The Republicans have been using the threat of a filibuster to table sensible legislation for years. It took someone on the other side of the aisle this long to figure out that it could work for them as well. I don't know if I should be excited or dumbfounded, but in either case I am glad Dodd showed some backbone here.

Jimmy B's picture

I'm confused...http://www.reuters.com/article/newsOne/idUSN1741430720071218

CatAtomic's picture

Reid's spinelessness works in OUR favor for once- hooray!

Jimmy B's picture

Actually this story...http://www.reuters.com/article/newsOne/idUSN1741430720071218 ...makes it look like there is a lot of weasel room.

L.A. Confidential's picture

I wouldn't start celebrating yet. But it's a start.

mudshark's picture

msnbc says their going to bring it back after the holidays..???what is going on?

Newbie's picture

I'm reminded of that moment at the end of the first Star Wars when the Tie Fighter gets clipped, Vader spins away and Han yells, "Wahoooo!"

Rock on Chris Dodd. Rock %$@#ing on!!!

LibertyLover's picture

This is good news. I'm cautiously optimistic. Thank you Senator Dodd, for standing for the Constitution and not Big Business!

Tequila's picture

He might win my vote yet, but only if he impeaches next.

L.A. Confidential's picture

mudshark @ 17:

msnbc says their going to bring it back after the holidays..???what is going on?

Insanity

L.A. Confidential's picture

mudshark @ 17:

msnbc says their going to bring it back after the holidays..???what is going on?

You tell me.

Bush's phone immunity bill wins Senate vote
Reuters - 1 hour, 15 minutes ago

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - President George W. Bush's demand for immunity for telephone companies that participated in his warrantless domestic spying program won an initial victory on Monday in the U.S. Senate.

mudshark's picture

http://www.reuters.com/article/newsOne/idUSN1741430720071218 WTF!!!!!Would someone explain what the F is going on....

VietVet8666's picture

Reid is weak.

Dodd reveals it.

NONsequitur's picture

OOOPS..."Bush's phone immunity bill wins Senate vote" Washington Post

Bitty's picture

Yessssssss!

I just gave his campaign $25 (all I can afford for now). Please go and give him what you can as a thank you for standing up for us.

Shared Humanity's picture

Senator Dodd and Senator Kennedy demonstrate what real leadership is about.

L.A. Confidential's picture

mudshark @ 23:

http://www.reuters.com/article/newsOne/idUSN1741430720071218 WTF!!!!!Would someone explain what the F is going on....

Spin, lies, manipulation, corruption. Welcome to the New World Disorder.

Dan's picture

He's one of the real leaders in the Senate and not one of the suits with the official title.

mudshark's picture

L.A. Confidential @ 22:

mudshark @ 17:

msnbc says their going to bring it back after the holidays..???what is going on?

You tell me.

Bush's phone immunity bill wins Senate vote
Reuters - 1 hour, 15 minutes ago

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - President George W. Bush's demand for immunity for telephone companies that participated in his warrantless domestic spying program won an initial victory on Monday in the U.S. Senate.

gulp!....help.............................................

Miles Tougeaux's picture

This is the candidate that should be the Democratic front runner. He's showing integrity while the others cautiously voice support, poll on the issue and vote "present".

ashton's picture

At least someone has some balls in this government. I have never heard of granting immunity to a)corporations and b)corporations who claim to have done nothing wrong.

BabushkaBlue's picture

I am so proud of Senator Dodd! Kennedy's speech was fantastic too. Feingold has always impressed me. Obama? Clinton? Where in the hell WERE you? I won't forget that you weren't there.

CalGeorge's picture

Awesome!

They called us "leftist" and "irrational" but they can't beat the passionate commitment of Americans to the Rule of Law.

On to the fight in January!

Mark's picture

Congrats to Chris Dodd, and congrats to America!

mudshark's picture

L.A. Confidential @ 28:

mudshark @ 23:

http://www.reuters.com/article/newsOne/idUSN1741430720071218 WTF!!!!!Would someone explain what the F is going on....

Spin, lies, manipulation, corruption. Welcome to the New World Disorder.

if this is what's happening......those fuckers are psychotic nutcases................yeah I know,I know.

Thing Fish's picture

The earlier 76-10 vote was to move the act forward and end debate on the measure. It wasn't a vote to approve bill 2248.

carefulwiththatAXEeugene's picture

Thank You Senator Chris Dodd! YOU ROCK!!!!

on another note:
wonder why the network$ aren't reporting this?

Slabo's picture

Thank you Sen. Dodd

This is why I Am A Liberal And A Progressive And A Democrat

I am a liberal because it is the political philosophy of freedom and equality.(of Opportunity,of Justice, of Genders,of Races,etc.etc. see Jefferson and Lincoln’s words) And I am a progressive because it is the political path to a better future. And I am a Democrat because it is the political party that believes in freedom, equality and progress. Oh yeah, and because our liberal revolutionary Founders like Paine & Jefferson were liberals who fought against conservative Loyalists like the godfather of conservatism Edmund Burke. ( see the debate between Liberal Thomas Paine’s RIGHTS OF MAN and conservative Edmund Burke’s drivel supporting autocracy)

Till this day, conservatives revile Paine as a commie/pinko. Typical con ingrates and hypocrites

Congratulations America for waking up in 2006 and throwing the corrupt conservatives out of congress for another 40+ years in the wilderness!

"Liberalism is trust of the people tempered by prudence. Conservatism is distrust of the people tempered by fear."
William Gladstone, 4-time Prime Minister of Great Britain.

"Long ago, there was a noble word, liberal, which derives from the word free. Now a strange thing happened to that word. A man named Hitler made it a term of abuse, a matter of suspicion, because those who were not with him were against him, and liberals had no use for Hitler. And then another man named McCarthy cast the same opprobrium on the word...We must cherish and honor the word free or it will cease to apply to us."

Eleanor Roosevelt

“The liberty of a democracy is not safe if the people tolerate the growth of private power to a point where it becomes stronger than their democratic State itself”

President Franklin D. Roosevelt (father of modern American liberalism and greatest president of 20th century)—according to 99% of historians!

"No question that Authoritarianism in modern Conservatism is Proto-Fascism."
John Dean---former Nixon aide and also a personal friend and confidant of Barry Goldwater and author of
CONSERVATIVES WITHOUT CONSCIENCE.

Liberalism is our salvation, we must commit ourselves to the principle of Liberty and distributed power or conservatism will destroy civilization.---Me

“If Liberals Hated America, We'd Vote Republican !”--anonymous

Impeach cheney and bush's picture

Slabo @ 11:

Bravo Sen. Dodd.

Quotes

"Liberals got women the right to vote. Liberals got African-Americans the right to vote.
Liberals created Social Security and lifted millions of elderly people out of poverty.
Liberals ended segregation. Liberals passed the Civil Rights Act, the Voting Rights Act.
Liberals created Medicare. Liberals passed the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act.

What did Conservatives do? They opposed them on every one of those things ? every one.
So when you try to hurl that label at my feet, 'Liberal,' as if it were something to be ashamed of,
something dirty, something to run away from, it won't work, Senator, because I will pick up
that label and I will wear it as a badge of honor."
-- Matt Santos

mudshark's picture

Thing Fish @ 37:

The earlier 76-10 vote was to move the act forward and end debate on the measure. It wasn't a vote to approve bill 2248.

ok,ok I get it now.......Whewwww!

getalife's picture

Watched it all day.

Great job Senator Dodd.

ashton's picture

mudshark @ 36:

L.A. Confidential @ 28:

mudshark @ 23:

http://www.reuters.com/article/newsOne/idUSN1741430720071218 WTF!!!!!Would someone explain what the F is going on....

Spin, lies, manipulation, corruption. Welcome to the New World Disorder.

if this is what's happening......those fuckers are psychotic nutcases................yeah I know,I know.

Actually it is not entirely wrong. Earlier there was a vote on cloture (sp?) and it did pass that to make it to the floor. Somebody appears to not understand the difference between the cloture vote and the actual vote for the bill. Sad, but apparently true.

apple pie's picture

What was that picture I am reminded of....Truman smiling and holding up the newspaper: "Dewey Wins!"

Seems like the media has already written the news on this one.

Ron's picture

Now if they will show some spine on impeachment.

L.A. Confidential's picture

mudshark @ 36:

L.A. Confidential @ 28:

mudshark @ 23:

http://www.reuters.com/article/newsOne/idUSN1741430720071218 WTF!!!!!Would someone explain what the F is going on....

Spin, lies, manipulation, corruption. Welcome to the New World Disorder.

if this is what's happening......those fuckers are psychotic nutcases................yeah I know,I know.

Former Bush insider in 2001

The first thing the Bush Administration said was we're going to go out and make new friends in this world. No, we're not. That was a lie. We're going to make new enemies as a precursor to increase global tension, which in turn is a precursor to turn back the clock to a world that they understand, a world where the old cabal works, a world where it is the waste, fraud, abuse, graft, corruption, and malfeasance of yesterday that the Bushonian faction of the military-industrial complex understands. It is a world where things can remain hidden under "National Security."

carol's picture

Chris Dodd is the man!

hope's picture

The Reuters headline bites. Are they actively trying to convince people this fight is over so no one will be bothering the politicians with emails and phone calls on this issue. Dodd and those who stood with him deserve the glory. Glad C&L can provide it for them anyway.

Thank you, Senator Dodd. Bravo, indeed!

Rasputin's picture

Big Big Kudos To Dodd... (note to self... write check to Dodd if he runs for the Senate again!).

2nd note to self... write every damn Dem in the Senate to demand Reid's resignation and then get Dodd to be Majority Leader!

3rd not to self... keep watching because you know that these mother F***s will wait until the national distraction is on something else and will try to push this through again, probably a closed door session or something. Harumph... the price of liberty is constant vigilance.

Edwin's picture

Hurray and congratulations Senator Dodd. Today you restored some of my faith in America-- that you are a law-abiding nation-- and garnered a great deal of my respect for your foresight and perseverance! Well done. Now, I hope some other politicians and presidential candidates take note.

(Now, remind me again, why were the Dems --Harry Reid-- so afraid of a filibuster. That's democracy at work.)

99's picture

I was watching... I thought they said Reid just put it over till January? That's not exactly a victory... just a postponement of defeat. I hope I'm wrong...?

ronhohn's picture

Isn't the Reuters article what they wrote about Reid bringing up the bill, which in turn got Sen. Dodd busy?

pc's picture

FINALLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Some actual clarity, and on the floor of the Senate, no less!

Did I just witness leadership, finally, in the Democratic Party? AND experience? AND new ideas? AND change? AND cajones? All wrapped up into one person, who just happens to be running for President??

I'm revisiting Senator Dodd..

liberalista's picture

This is great news. Thank you Senator Dodd.

Guitar Playing Bastard's picture

I just gave money to the Dodd campaign. I don't think he has a chance in hell, but he made a stand of conscience today, and so far, he's the only guy in the field who's done so.

It takes a big set to do that in this day and age. Dodd is the very first Dem in the past seven years to stand up to Bush and say "NO! Come to think of it, FUCK NO!"

This kind of action is needed on the part of people from all walks of life - those who will stand up to republicans and say "NO! Come to think of it, FUCK NO!" Those who will stand up to Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, Joe Lieberman and the other Blue Dogs (they ARE Blue dogs) and say "GROW A SPINE! STOP CAVING! STOP BACKING DOWN!

I am proud of Senator Dodd. I wish I could vote for him in CT but it's too friggin cold there.

Well done, Senator Dodd. Salud!

mudshark's picture

Reid has to go......I'v been very patient and quiet on Reid and Pelosi...REID HAS TO GO.....and Nancy.....get a clue...................if it's not too late already

hope's picture

ronhohn @ 52:

Isn't the Reuters article what they wrote about Reid bringing up the bill, which in turn got Sen. Dodd busy?

Um, no. It was written today and released at 7:50 EST.

I Am A Banana's picture

Wow, my faith in the process has returned every so slightly.

You see how it's done Democrats? You stand up for principles: now stop caving and follow Dodds lead for goodness sake!

MamaMia's picture

Thank you Senator Dodd, for doing what Reid should have done in the begining. Sen Reid take a good look at how a real patriot stands up for his people, you can learn a lot.

Avilyn's picture

Chalk one up for the good guys! Way to go, Sen. Dodd!

I notice there's nary a peep of this on CNN... so much for the 'liberal' media...

FOX is State Sponsored TV's picture

w00t!

athospaco's picture

Crooks and Liars I could kiss you! Way to champion a man with principles.
The blogosphere actualy works. You bet this victory is 100% blogs...and 0% Mainstream bootlicking media.

Hold your heads up high proudly tonight, Dodd and Crooks and Liars, you deserve it.

StirFry's picture

Dodd, you da man.

L.A. Confidential's picture

99 @ 51:

I was watching... I thought they said Reid just put it over till January? That's not exactly a victory... just a postponement of defeat. I hope I'm wrong...?

It will probably become buried and forgotten in the Dems heap of unfinished business and broken promises.

donkee's picture

GREAT JOB!

plebius's picture

My first thought was that this is just more theatre and that retroactive immunity will eventually be passed.

budda's picture

Congrats Sen. Dodd

I have a newfound respect for this man!

LibertyLover's picture

carefulwiththatAXEeugene @ 38:

Thank You Senator Chris Dodd! YOU ROCK!!!!

on another note:
wonder why the network$ aren't reporting this?

Where have you been? We lost our 4th estate long ago...

squiggs's picture

Thank you Mr. Dodd. You're a damn good man. Now will you please start proceedings to remove Harry Reid?

watercarrier4diogenes's picture

Hopefully, this will give Dodd, Kennedy, Wyden, et al, time to digest yesterday's NY Times story on how this spying started within three weeks of Dumbya taking office and involves WAY more than terrorists. Once digested, I hope they stuff it up the rest of Congress's noses and make it perfectly clear that by election day in November, every damn one of us is going to know exactly what's been going on and they won't be able to mischaracterize this the way some of the rethugs' speeches today did.

Patrick's picture

Now that's what I call Democracy in action. This gives me a little more hope. Thanks you Senator Dodd. Let's see if this sparks a fire under the rest of the Democratic MAJORITY.

aNGRYaMERICAN's picture

We expect senators to be corrupt hypocrites, but when you’re taking no-interest loans from banks you’re supposed to be regulating, and over a hundred grand in campaign cash from AIG while you just happen to exempt them from your bonus crackdown, it doesn’t help to pose as a crusading man of the people, fighting those big mean bankers. Chris Dodd, fuck you. Fuck you for fooling so many nice, if naïve, people into thinking you were on the level. Fuck you for saying “here” all the time like it’s a damn comma. But most of all, fuck you for being you, just another phony, entitled senator on the take.
Exhibit A: Dodd’s dad was a Senator too—and he was censured for pilfering $100,000 from his campaign funds in 1967.(excerpted from the BuffaloBeast.com,page 1645)

OliverDreams's picture

Thank you Senator Dodd, for standing up for America.

Dodd is the only Democratic candidate showing true leadership in the Senate.
Dennis Kucinich is the only Democratic candidate showing true leadership in the house.

We need the courage and leadership that they both have shown.
Dodd/Kucinich Kucinich/Dodd
Either combo works for me

JJohnson's picture

Mr. Dodd - you sir are a bonafide BADASS.

Good job man!

Straight Shooter's picture

A couple months ago, when I finally decided on a candidate, I chose Christopher Dodd. Looks like my political instincts are correct. :)

Remember that Dodd said he would support the Democratic candidate in Connecticut, and when all the other Dems abandoned Lamont to kiss Lieberman's a**, Dodd was right out there supporting Lamont.

Christopher Dodd is showing America what it means to be a Democrat, even if he did have to sacrifice time in Iowa. Some people may say, well, so what, he's trailing all the other candidates, but in my book, that means his sacrifice was greater, because he was taking precious time to promote We The People instead of his own campaign.

Substance matters.

Thing Fish's picture

99 @ 51:

I was watching... I thought they said Reid just put it over till January? That's not exactly a victory... just a postponement of defeat. I hope I'm wrong...?

I think next comes debate on any amendments to the bill. Read that Dodd plans to team up with Feingold to offer an amendment that would strip the entire immunity provision, which means pending suits would not be immediately tossed. C/Net

Feinstein is also supposed to have an amendment that grants immunity if executives were acting legally or in "good faith", or weren't involved at all. The "good faith" clause sounds more like a loop hole to make it sound like something was done while nothing exists in reality (which sounds like typical Feinstein).

Logan Murphy's picture

carefulwiththatAXEeugene @ 38:

Thank You Senator Chris Dodd! YOU ROCK!!!!

on another note:
wonder why the network$ aren't reporting this?

Countdown covered it tonight, we'll have that segment soon.

JJohnson's picture

OliverDreams @ 72:

Thank you Senator Dodd, for standing up for America.

Dodd is the only Democratic candidate showing true leadership in the Senate.
Dennis Kucinich is the only Democratic candidate showing true leadership in the house.

We need the courage and leadership that they both have shown.
Dodd/Kucinich Kucinich/Dodd
Either combo works for me

Hell yes.

That's what we call a sweet sweet dream ticket right there.

RMac's picture

Many thanks to Senator Dodd and those that stood with him all day long today.

I watched CSPAN all day and found it immensely refreshing to see those with a backbone make themselves heard.

May I ask those who have their backbone please try and find some leftover backbones around Washington D.C. (you know, from all the skeletons in those proverbial closets) and give one to another member who may have already lost theirs.

gdkzen's picture

Thank you Senator Dodd! On a day when Lieberman makes me disgusted, you restore my pride in being a Connecticut Yankee!

thoughts's picture

Ring, ring... telecom calling. Ring, ring... America calling... Thank you for picking up the right phone!

If need be, you were willing to lose your voice to make our voice heard! Thank you, Mr Dodd...Thank you for standing up; thank you for your principled stand; thank you for using your platform for good in this Country. Sadly, rapacious self-serving greed is a disease infecting the majority of our 'leaders' ... thank you for reminding Americans what leadership can be! Know that millions stand behind you and that you are not alone... Americans are hoarse - screaming for leadership... Thank you!

Preacher Boob's picture

Too bad Reid and Pelosi aren't Dodds.

Paul in LA's picture

And another one bites the dust:

REPUBLICAN SecState of Colorado bans all ES&S machines:

All voting systems made by Election Systems & Software, Inc. (ES&S), both paper-based optical-scan and DREs, were completely decertified. Their op-scan systems tested, according to Coffman, "both failed because of an inability to determine if the devices work correctly and an inability to complete the testing threshold of 10,000 ballots due to vendor programming errors." Their ubiqutous, and fatally flawed iVotronic DRE system "failed because it is easily disabled by voters activating the device interface, and the system lacks an audit trail to detect security violations."

Paper-based optical-scan systems made by Sequoia Voting Systems were conditionally certified, while their DRE systems were completely decertified for use, as they "failed due to a variety of security risk factors, including that the system is not password protected, has exposed controls potentially giving voters unauthorized access, and lacks an audit trail to detect security violations."

Paper-based optical-scan systems made by Hart Intercivic were decertified "because test results showed that they could not accurately count ballots"(!), while their DRE voting system was conditionally certified.

And finally, both optical-scan and DRE voting systems made by Diebold/Premier were conditionally certified for use in Colorado.

http://www.bradblog.com/?p=5451

L.A. Confidential's picture

plebius @ 66:

My first thought was that this is just more theatre and that retroactive immunity will eventually be passed.

Associated Press 55 minutes ago

WASHINGTON - The Senate late Monday delayed its consideration of a vote on a new government eavesdropping bill until January.

Jim's picture

The news networks are useless! Thank God for the internet, or I wouldn't have know about this great news!

Newbie's picture

JJohnson @ 77:

OliverDreams @ 72:

Thank you Senator Dodd, for standing up for America.

Dodd is the only Democratic candidate showing true leadership in the Senate.
Dennis Kucinich is the only Democratic candidate showing true leadership in the house.

We need the courage and leadership that they both have shown.
Dodd/Kucinich Kucinich/Dodd
Either combo works for me

Hell yes.

That's what we call a sweet sweet dream ticket right there.

That is the only Dem combo I would ever consider, although Edwards is not too too bad. It's a shame Ron Paul is just a bit too loco, because at the very least, he is totally honest.

chrisp's picture

Thank you Senator Chris Dodd. It is sad that you have to talk for 8 hours or so just to make sure this Administration can't spy on us. I loved Sen. Kennedy's speech; however I find it curious that he spoke of Bush breaking the law, "If Congress immunizes the telecoms for past violations of the law, it will send the message that Congress approves what the Administration did. We would be aiding and abetting the President in his illegal actions his contempt for the rule of law, and his attempt to hide his lawbreaking from the American people". If he feels so strongly about this then why has he not called for Impeachment? I know impeachment starts in the House but he could at least speak out about it if he believes Bush broke the law.

L.A. Confidential's picture

plebius @ 66:

My first thought was that this is just more theatre and that retroactive immunity will eventually be passed.

Mine to. Both sides are playing some serious mind games with the public.

Media Concepts's picture

This is amazing! What a roller coaster of a day. Dodd deserves our applause and respect for being so courageous.

Meanwhile, Dodd was being more than generous in complimenting Harry Reid. Don't forget that Reid did at least two things to let things get this far: (1) he chose to bring the Senate Intelligence Committee version of the bill (which contains telecom immunity) to bring up for a vote, rather than the Judiciary Committee version (which does not contain immunity); and (2) he denied Dodd the courtesy of putting a "hold" on the bill, a courtesy that Reid routinely grants to Republicans, so that a filibuster would not have been necessary. Reid has caved into Bush and the telecoms at every turn. I think that makes him look weak, compared to people like Dodd who stand on their priniciples. What principle is Reid standing on?

Lindy's picture

Did you see the look on Dick Cheney's face? Priceless!

bobnchristy's picture

Probably won't vote for him but I just gave him $25 dollars and note telling him why he deserves it. Go Dodd, Kennedy and Feingold!

The Truthiness Hurts's picture

Whats that.. someone in the senate... Grew a pair?!

Esteban's picture
Booker's picture

It's a step in the right direction.

LookyHere's picture

I know some of you here think the article in the link below is a mistake, but deep down I think they're trying to rewrite history!

http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20071218/pl_nm/usa_security_phones_dc

I feel something terrible will happen either before this year is up, or on New Years. God help us all!

Andrew's picture

Bravo Senator Dodd. We the American people now have a louder voice because of your efforts, and one can only hope that others running for elected office both now and in the future will come to understand that it is WE THE PEOPLE, all of us, right, center and left that can never let the flames of justice, liberty and freedom which our country was founded on, ever be extinguished. For should that day ever come, we will cease to be a nation of laws while falling under the rule of a dictatorship. It is also gratifying to know, that through e-mails, phone calls, faxe's and any other form of communication that was required, we the people were able to make a difference.

numfar's picture

WTG Senator Dodd.

You're now number 1 on my list for President. I'm spreading the word.

Thank you, sir.

14All's picture

Now THAT's leadership!

Spicegal's picture

Thank-you Senator Dodd for defending the rule of law and our Constitution. It's kind of interesting how we keep hearing from a number of congressman that the Bush administration broke the law, yet nothing is done about it. Someone please explain.

mudshark's picture

Paul in LA @ 82:

And another one bites the dust:

REPUBLICAN SecState of Colorado bans all ES&S machines:

All voting systems made by Election Systems & Software, Inc. (ES&S), both paper-based optical-scan and DREs, were completely decertified. Their op-scan systems tested, according to Coffman, "both failed because of an inability to determine if the devices work correctly and an inability to complete the testing threshold of 10,000 ballots due to vendor programming errors." Their ubiqutous, and fatally flawed iVotronic DRE system "failed because it is easily disabled by voters activating the device interface, and the system lacks an audit trail to detect security violations."

Paper-based optical-scan systems made by Sequoia Voting Systems were conditionally certified, while their DRE systems were completely decertified for use, as they "failed due to a variety of security risk factors, including that the system is not password protected, has exposed controls potentially giving voters unauthorized access, and lacks an audit trail to detect security violations."

Paper-based optical-scan systems made by Hart Intercivic were decertified "because test results showed that they could not accurately count ballots"(!), while their DRE voting system was conditionally certified.

And finally, both optical-scan and DRE voting systems made by Diebold/Premier were conditionally certified for use in Colorado.

http://www.bradblog.com/?p=5451

excellant find Paul in LA.....you keep up the good work too......maybe hit Hermosa Pier ...or the strand this fri night.

getalife's picture

Dodd vowed to do it again in January.

FunMe's picture

Wow, while not a outright victory, it is a step in the right direction.

Oh trust me, after the Christmas & the holidays, we in the blogsphere will be more than recharged to fight the real bill. We will be free from shopping and parties and focus on actually gain a VICTORY for our democracy.

2008 is the year for ALL candidates and representatives. Either you are for the US Constitution i.e. WE THE PEOPLE, or you are against it. We will remember in November 2008.

And thank you Senator Dodd for standing up for us!

Onward to victory!

Paul in LA's picture

Newbie @ 84:

It's a shame Ron Paul is just a bit too loco, because at the very least, he is totally honest.

No one who holds views like he does can afford to be 'totally honest.'

Did he TELL you he was in favor of further coal and nuclear power? What? Didn't come up?

Did he TELL you he authored an amendment to ATTACK HOLLAND if the International Criminal Court tried to arrest our warcriminals? Did he tell you that he opposes the Geneva Conventions JUST LIKE BUSH?

No, he's as honest as a Ron Paul dollar is currency. He lies, covers over his radical ideas in things he knows the public wants, and harbors white supremacists with his 'states' rights' MALARKY.

bmw 528's picture

Thank you Sen Dodd.

"One man with courage makes a majority."
Andrew Jackson

hope's picture

Lindy @ 88:

Did you see the look on Dick Cheney's face? Priceless!

Where'd you see Cheney? I thought maybe he was in his bunker decorating for Christmas.

oldgringo's picture

Senators Dodd, Kennedy and Feirngold now stand as beacons of bright and glorious light shinning into the abysmal darkness of the fell place into which the BUSH/CHENEY/LIEBERMAN FASCIST CABAL, aided by their "BLUEDOG enablers calling themselves "DEMOCRATS" have coerced, cheated and lied us into from the beginning.
Let us now see if we. the people, can unseat Ball-less Harry Reid and Faithless Nancy Pelosi and their BLUE DOG fellow travelers from their possitions of power and then out of government entirely right along with the BUSHIST BASTARDS!

Ron England's picture

It is great to see a Demcrat with a set of balls and the spine to stand up for Defending the Constitution.

nsr's picture

You know how many minutes NBC Evening News gave this story tonight? Zero. It was crowded out by Ann Curry bungee-jumping, keeping pets safe, and introducing some actor as their new announcer.

Fine with me. If they want to make their show some kind of irrelevant alternate-universe version of the news, there's plenty of other places to find out what's going on.

Ron's picture

Ron England @ 106:

It is great to see a Demcrat with a set of balls and the spine to stand up for Defending the Constitution.

It's great to see an American stand up to this administration.

Donald's picture

We all owe a great deal of thanks to Senator Dodd for his leadership on this issue. I just donated $100 to his campaign. But, despite Dodd's leadership and fight on this issue, this still does not absolve Senator Reid and the people who supported him of their malfeasance. We have a real problem with the Democratic leadership. It needs to be dealt with. If we don't wake up and deal with it, we have no one to blame but ourselves for the continued giving away of our rights and civil liberties, and the further selling out of the American people. If someone would tell this story, without identifying the country, of all the corrupt policies, violations of Americans rights and civil liberties, and other democracy threatening activities promoted by our government, you would think we were talking about the USSR. But no it is the United States of America. What the hell has happened to our nation!

Anthology's picture

A democrat actually did something.
Dodd has my vote.

Thing Fish's picture

Reid Statement On FISA Bill

“Under regular order, and the rules of the Senate governing sequential referral, I will move to proceed to S. 2248 – the bill reported by each committee. When that motion to proceed is adopted, the work of both committees will be before the Senate. Because of the order in which they considered the bill, the Intelligence Committee version will be the base text, and the Judiciary Committee version will be automatically pending as a substitute amendment.
...
“In my view, that will make the final product stronger. There is one issue that cannot be resolved through informal negotiation. As some are aware, the Intelligence Committee’s bill provides the telephone companies with retroactive immunity from lawsuits filed by their customers for privacy violations. Many members, myself included, believe that such a grant of immunity is unwise. I expect there will be a full debate on this subject next week.

“Senators Specter, Feinstein, Whitehouse and others are working to craft a compromise that might give the phone companies some relief – but allow the lawsuits to go forward in a manner that would preserve accountability. In one way or another, we must ensure that President Bush is held accountable for his actions.

It sounds like this drama was fairly well planned out. Don't agree with the Feinstein compromise. It just allows telecoms off the hook as long as Bush is held accountable.

John's picture

THat was great to watch on cspan, the only repub that got up was orin hatch, what a dinosaur that guy is. I am so glad they finally put something up there. His closing comments suggested that they were still going to use this as a political tool instead of actually going against the administrations illegal activities though. I would not be suprised.

still, if you are in the bush admin and/or leading a telecom company you gotta be pretty pissed off.

Mark Richards's picture

Congratulations to us and to Senator Dodd. Nice to finally see some leadership.

It was pretty disgusting watching that emaciated stick of a man Reid state on the Senate floor this morning that he agreed with Dodd's objection, yet had to push the immunity version of the bill forward so that other important legislation wouldn't be held up. Give 'em Hell? No, Harry, this time it was handed to you.

Reid and Pelosi need a new job.

Hey, in the spirit of Mike Gravel, stick them both on the "Buildings and Grounds" committee.

Joe H's picture

If Dodd can make it to California, he's got my vote.

sharkcellar's picture

Fuck yeah! Small blessings.

Preacher Boob's picture

My last email to Pelosi expressed regret she 'hadn't yet grown a pair of cohones and a swinging pene'.

No reply yet.

Scytherius's picture

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I give you an American Hero. I know you probably didn't recognize it at first as it has been way too long and they are too few and far between. But along with Kucinich, Feingold and a few others, there is leadership and courage still left in this country.

THANK YOU SENATOR DODD!!!!!!!

sjay's picture

Backbone Dodd!

VietVet8666 @ 24:

Reid is weak.

Dodd reveals it.

And that's why Reid pulled this bill from the floor.

I'm just wondering if Bush has pictures of Reid, Pelosi, et al, of them having carnal knowledge of barnyard animals. It's the only explanation of their cowardly capitulation - they can always get money elsewhere...

chlorocardium's picture

Dodd's stock rises. America gasps another breath.

Now how does the Repug FCC screw the dying victim tomorrow? (drumroll....)

BobM's picture

What can I say...Chris Dodd is my hero!!

Orangutan.'s picture

Tell 'em what you think...

www.ChrisDodd.com
www.WexlerWantsHearings.com

mudshark's picture

while Senator Dodd is near ,if not on top of my list now......lets not forget.....he has some questions to answer....web search his voting record...........He needs to be asked a few questions...and answered with honest answers.....but again.......he is near ,if not the top of my list

bmw 528's picture

nsr @ 107:

You know how many minutes NBC Evening News gave this story tonight? Zero. It was crowded out by Ann Curry bungee-jumping, keeping pets safe, and introducing some actor as their new announcer.

Fine with me. If they want to make their show some kind of irrelevant alternate-universe version of the news, there's plenty of other places to find out what's going on.

Agreed. I don't watch the insipid farce that is called "news" by NBC, ABC, or CBS. All of these are little more than propaganda outlets for their corporate masters at GE, etc. Their form of "journalism" is an insult to people like Edward Murrow and Walter Cronkite who valued integrity before being a corporate panderer. And to think that once, these conservative hacks hated Pravda---they have become what they despised.

nsr's picture

Reid: "the Intelligence Committee’s bill provides the telephone companies with retroactive immunity from lawsuits filed by their customers for privacy violations. Many members, myself included, believe that such a grant of immunity is unwise."

Sorry, Harry. Your little game is up.

The News Hour's not talking about this story either. AT&T is one of their sponsors.

Cowboy Bob in Austin's picture

mmm... Democrats weilding political power! I like it.

foolme1ns's picture

Ron Paul has been breaking fundraising records on the internet. Perhaps it's time we showed Dodd a little love

Bobby's picture

Hasn't anyone thought about why this nutjob, Lieberman, was the vice-presidential candidate with Gore in 2000? Was he the back-up plan, should Bush-Cheney not have been able to steal the election?

Al & Joe win, "something" happens to Al, Joe brings on Cheney to shows he's "fair & balanced" and we still get the '01 Energy meeting, 9/11, and war in Iraq. Lieberman was a very odd, last-minute choice for VP; Not Al's choice.

Maybe Gore was lucky enough to have "lost" the 2000 election afterall? Hey, let's all go shopping, no worries.

E in MD's picture

Dodd just got my vote. I was leaning more towards Gravel since he reminds me of what I'll be when i'm seventy something. But he doesn't stand a chance in hell.

I refuse to vote for Hillary because I don't trust her, she won't end the Iraq war and we need new blood in the White House. ( and note that I voted for Bill twice and would vote for him again )

I won't vote for Obama just because I think if we're going to have a youngin like him you need someone with some passion. I don't see Obama threatening a filibuster to protect the rights of Americans. He's done shit as far as I can tell.

Edwards still needs to explain why he voted AYE to invade Iraq despite the fact that he was on the Senate Intelligence Committee along with my Senator Mikulski. Mikulski voted no because the Yellowcake memo was known to be false. Why didn't Edwards?

Dodd however has been out there moving to protect the little guy even at potential cost to himself. I don't see Giuliani or Ron Paul or any of those other Republican tools doing that. They all see the election as a power grab. So Dodd will be getting my vote in the Primary. If it comes down to someone other than Dodd vs a Republican I will vote against the Republican.

Damian Duff's picture

Chris Dodd is not telegenic or articulate. He is no JFK, RFK or WJC but I can't help thinking that I would sleep a lot better at night if he were President.

Steve Charb's picture

Reid should step down. Durbin should become Majority Leader, and Dodd should become Majority Whip.

Hekyll's picture

At last - someone with courage who is willing to stand up for principle. Maybe Dodd can give Reid and the other blockheads lessons on how to grow a spine.

Robin's picture

A skeptic.
While I applaud Chris Dodd, I can't help feeling this was a contrived filibuster by the democrats in part because CD actually thanks Harry Reid in this video for not impeding him?
He wouldn't have needed to filibuster were it not for Harry Reid!

So many things should have been filibustered but were not. I have to ask myself if this was purely for show.

jwazzz's picture

Thank you Chris Dodd - fuck you, Harry Reid.

enigma4ever's picture

thank you at C&L or covering this and allowing us to help fight back...and help Dodd...thank you and thank you Senator Dodd....and also Senator Kennedy and to all that helped keep this battle alive.

LongTooth's picture

Dodd (as quoted) said: "And hopefully between then and January a suggestion can be made to compromise without granting full immunity..".

Not "full" immunity, not partial, not any goddamn immunity whatsoever should be the rallying cry.

If those people want a Truth Commission convened, make them beg for it.

wesisbest's picture

I don't know if Dodd has my vote, but I just gave him some money. I feel that he deserves my donation for missing out in Iowa right now, while all of the other candidates are still campaigning.

I'm proud of Sen. Dodd!

Rob's picture

unflippingbelievable!! make that man president

tyree's picture

Paul in LA @ 102:

Newbie @ 84:

It's a shame Ron Paul is just a bit too loco, because at the very least, he is totally honest.

No one who holds views like he does can afford to be 'totally honest.'

Did he TELL you he was in favor of further coal and nuclear power? What? Didn't come up?

Did he TELL you he authored an amendment to ATTACK HOLLAND if the International Criminal Court tried to arrest our warcriminals? Did he tell you that he opposes the Geneva Conventions JUST LIKE BUSH?

No, he's as honest as a Ron Paul dollar is currency. He lies, covers over his radical ideas in things he knows the public wants, and harbors white supremacists with his 'states' rights' MALARKY.

yeah and the nuts are sending him big bucks go figure!

ticktock's picture

“Chris Dodd Does It. Reid pulls Telecom Immunity bill off the table”

A genuine hero of the people...

bmw 528's picture

nsr @ 125:

Reid: "the Intelligence Committee’s bill provides the telephone companies with retroactive immunity from lawsuits filed by their customers for privacy violations. Many members, myself included, believe that such a grant of immunity is unwise."

Sorry, Harry. Your little game is up.

The News Hour's not talking about this story either. AT&T is one of their sponsors.

I think PBS is great, but hate it when they have to suck up to toxic waste like AT&T. I canceled my services with them last year.

Karen's picture

rmf @ 10:

Great to know there are people like Dodd around.

But, won't the twerp-in-chief just veto it if it's passed? What happens then?

You mean if the FISA bill is eventually passed without retroactive immunity for the telecoms companies? Sure, it's highly possible that he'll veto it.

But then, he doesn't get any kind of FISA, which would put him in a worse position than he wants to be in. It's possible that he could sign it, and then push for retroactive immunity in a separate bill.

Frankly, though, it doesn't matter what authority Bush has or doesn't have de jure. He does what he feels like doing, the law be damned.

thegris's picture

woo-hoo! this is great news. I'm sure it's not over, but I'm surprised that Reid capitulated so fast. Oh, wait... it's Harry Reid. I guess a quick capitulation should be expected.

Note to other Democrats: Try leading. It's easy if you have principles.

CoIntelPro's picture

why does harry reid force a democrat to filibuster, but won't force the repugs to filibuster?

why does harry reid permit a republican to put a 'hold' on a bill but won't honor a 'hold' by a democrat?

reid is like having LIEberman as the majority leader. speaking of which, why is LIEberman supporting a repug and not feeling any consequences?

nevermind!

wmholt's picture

Bobby @ 128:

Hasn't anyone thought about why this nutjob, Lieberman, was the vice-presidential candidate with Gore in 2000? Was he the back-up plan, should Bush-Cheney not have been able to steal the election?

Maybe Gore was lucky enough to have "lost" the 2000 election after all? Hey, let's all go shopping, no worries.

It's strange that you would write this today. After I heard that Lieberman endorsed McCain this morning, mostly for his foreign policy stance, I had that exact same thought.

Meanwhile, it's too bad that we don't have a virtual locker room to pour champagne on the heads of all the participants in today's impressive win over Telecom amnesty. Congratulations to Chris Dodd, Crooks and Liars, Glenn Greenwald, FireDogLake, Russ Feingold, Ted Kennedy, just to name a few, and of course, the progressive activists that made all this possible.

It seems that Harry Reid isn't deaf after all! I would have loved to see Chris Dodd's expression when Harry Reid announced this.

Please don't forget to contribute something to Senator Dodd's Campaign if you can.

Marc's picture

The whole scandal of retroactive immunity is far from over, but this is a major battle won.

I have to admit, when I read the news headline elsewhere, it's the first time I can EVER remember pumping my fist and saying a quiet "Yes." in response to a news report, much less one about politics.

bmw 528's picture

There was a really nice attaboy on the Dodd website for C&L, FDL, and Huffpo acknowledging our efforts in helping to promote Sen. Dodd's filibuster.

The efforts of a small group of determined people to change the world cannot be underestimated. To paraphrase Winston Churchill---"We shall never surrender."

CoIntelPro's picture

warning about the fisa in either form:

it gives boosh unlimited surveillance powers wither way!

ROM Spaceknight's picture

senator dodd did his job. it's not like he deserves a pay raise.

and if he authorized iraq he certainly doesn't earn my vote in the democratic primary.

Comments are closed on this entry