Medved
By John Amato Sunday Mar 23, 2008 3:01pm Howard Kurtz uses Michael Medved on CNN yesterday to analyze Obama's speech from Tuesday and to give his most expert and serious opinion on the situation.
Yes, I think it was a courageous speech in some ways, and yes -- but it was also an attempt to change the subject. Because the truth is that people responded indignantly to Reverend Wright not because he's black. It's not about race, it's not because of the racial outlook of the church, which very specifically defines itself as an afrocentric church and emphasizes blackness, blackness, blackness.
They didn't respond to it that way. If a white pastor had made the comments that Jeremiah Wright had made, people would have been equally indignant.
Race had no part in this discussion in Medved's eyes. Hmmm, how did he draw that conclusion? I don't know about you, but it would seem he has a somewhat confused and warped view on slavery. I guess this op-ed makes him a right wing expert for Reliable Sources though:
So Michael Medved, semi-famous movie reviewer and radio host, who has of late morphed into a weird “Hollywood vs. America” right-wing concern troll, has published an op-ed at Townhall that says that slavery in America just wasn’t as bad as all that. No, seriously
1. Slavery was an ancient and universal institution, not a distinctively American innovation.
2. Slavery existed only briefly, and in limited locales, in the history of the republic - involving only a tiny percentage of the ancestors of today’s Americans.
3. Though brutal, slavery wasn’t genocidal: live slaves were valuable but dead captives brought no profit.
4. It’s not true that the U.S. became a wealthy nation through the abuse of slave labor: the most prosperous states in the country were those that first freed their slaves.
5. While America deserves no unique blame for the existence of slavery, the United States merits special credit for its rapid abolition.
6. There is no reason to believe that today’s African Americans would be better off if their ancestors had remained behind in Africa.
You see it's not so bad. Blacks have had it soooo good in this country...And that other very nice and unbiased man from the Nixon White House, <snark>Pat Buchanan thinks so too.








Login or Register to post comments.
Yikes.
First?
Anyway, yikes.
You have to give the man some credit for having one of the dorkiest mustaches in the history of modern civilization...
Check it out - your MSM hard at work, discussing the important issues of the day (and giving the Cheney some ideas at the same time...)
http://www.time.com/time/arts/article/0,8599,1725102,00.html?cnn=yes
Medved is such a creep. He should've stuck to his crappy film reviews.
-AF
This guy sounds like an A1 asshole to me...
Michael Medved...always, always, always sees things from a knee-jerk conservative's point of view. Dumbass.
Howie Kurtz is the thumb on the hand of the Rightwing Reacharound Robot.
-GSD
Kevin @ 4:
looks like one too.
The point he may be trying to make with his 6 points is that slavery in the US could have been worse: that is true but so what?
Tell Medved I want my mustache back.
-Ron Jeremy
Just another typical uneducated, biggoted, Reslug gnat.
Rapid abolition?
Really? Over 200 years is RAPID?
This guy is beyond stupid.
I can never get tired of posting this article, "Why can't Seattle's foremost movie critic get any respect?" But I do disagree with the descriptive, 'foremost.'
Not only is he an A1 asshole, he's a big effin' whiner as well.
This wasn't nearly as bad as Kenneth Blackwell's comments on the speech on Hardball the other day. I guess he was there to give the Uncle Tom perspective on it all.
I'm sure all of his gay Reslug friends love his ugly mustach though.
"3. Though brutal, slavery wasn’t genocidal: live slaves were valuable but dead captives brought no profit."
From the viewpoint of a slave owner:
Slave-$200. Lynching rope-$5. Lesson taught-Priceless
Bud @ 2:
I have a Cousin that looks like a cross between Medved and Richard Benjamin. and he is a dorkis as well. maybe it's the mustache? I couldn't see Medved or Howie Kurtz holdin anyones mud!
I truly beleive we have fallen into the abyss. Our media is not to be trusted. The manipulation of MSM is rampant. everything favors Big business and big money. Meanwhile the dumbing down celebrity bull shit is numbing. We have a nation of no-nothing, selfish people.
"3. Though brutal, slavery wasn’t genocidal: live slaves were valuable but dead captives brought no profit."
They were treated only a little better than LIVESTOCK!!!
Just another irrelevant sack of shit with an ignorant opinion that no one gives a rats ass about .....
There just isn't enough Raid in the entire world to get rid of the complete infestation of gnats in the media.
Has this man never read the writings of people that felt morally called to free their slaves?
chattle slavery is an abomination.
The Brits outlawed slavery in their own country in 1774, and in all their territories in 1833 with the Abolition of Slavery Act.
I'm sure all this will make them feel better. god...
Here ya go:
http://www.panzers.co.uk/i/sauce-image.jpg
I guess the racial outlook that the white man gave black people aids.. had 'nothing' to do with it..
It seems that we have been forced to limit the discourse to what is acceptable for a pastor to say to their congregation. This issue is about political correctness. Rightwing America has successfully defined for the American public what is acceptable free speech.
For those who are offended by Reverand Wright, when will the public-at-large formally reject and denounce the daily hate spewed by the rightwingers on radio and Fox Noise? Aren't these preachers of hate reaching far more people than the few thousand people in south Chicago? How dare our rightwingers expose their children to this hateful rhetoric? Will America hold John McCain accountable for cozying up to these Preachers Of Hate?
Bet he'd never say this to a black person's face.
He'd have to meet one first.
as an adult white man, i am embarrassed that assholes
like this are even given a voice when it's so apparent
how brain-dead they are and how insensitive to pain and
suffering the slaves endured under fucking greedy whites.
no one can walk in the shoes of another person and no
one can ever understand the true hardship slaves suffered
when these experiences are so personal.
Again I am stuck in the circular world of the pundit belief system. I have a real hard time believing that they believe 95% of the crap that spews from their collective mouths. If they do believe what they say then have a completely different understanding of reality than I am familiar with. If they don't believe what they say how can they live with them selves.
Not that this needs to be repeated for this crowd, but: of course, white pastors have made this kind of comment -- nationally, on TV, not a home movie someone dug up and posted on YouTube -- and the people screaming about Wright were not equally indignant. (Buchanan, Falwell, et al., saying that America's sins has turned God against us.)
Nahhh it wasn't so bad... even the sail over to the New World was like a luxury cruise!!
From PBS :
And that was just the first leg of the Middle Passage... it only got better and better after that!! Woo hoo!
African Americans are so grateful their ancestors were brought over here in such luxury and comfort by such a caring crew of white folks. I'm sure Michael Medved is related to those who ran the slave ships.
Here is Rachel Maddow commenting on the Wingnut 'Values Voter Debate' held in Fort Lauderdale last fall. At the forum the question was put: 'what would you do to counteract the homosexual agenda'.
Ms Maddow illustrates the double standards between the right and the left.
Featured at the event was a choir singing the original song; 'Why should god bless America'.
Ms Maddow goes on to presage what a firestorm there would be should someone from the left turn lyrics around in such a manner.
Does that sound at all familiar to you, it does to me.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K0IvNydHFhQ&NR=1
Rachel Maddow for President (after Obama's second term).
The average American is getting disgusted by MSM. Faux News and CNN(Faux News Lite) are becoming parodies of true media. Endless pundits, fluff pieces and failing to report on real issues. The disparity of the rich and middle class. Iraq and Afghanistan. Wall Street manipulation. And all out greed. I will be in my garden all this summer. I can't take it anymore.
Mikelx @ 26:
I think FOX is the most hateful network in the free world. If any one was patriotic they would try to bring people together. Imagine a political party having their own news network.
I'll take it as a given that Kurtz didn't bring up Robertson, Falwell, or Hagee and the whole "catholics/gays/chocolate ice cream" brought down God's anger on us in the form of AIDS, 9/11, katrina, and so on.
"Liberal media" at work.
spinn @ 31:
Its the media baby!!
Think Medved should read this book before spouting off again.
http://www.stltoday.com/stltoday/entertainment/reviews.nsf/book/story/52...
So, being a mediocre movie critic qualifies you to be a credible political pundit. Nice.
He wrote an op-ed for the opinionjournal.com about ten years ago that blamed the level of gun violence in America on Hollywood's glorification of violence.
Not on the number of guns on the street. It never dawned on him that everybody having guns could result in gun deaths. It's liberal Hollywood's fault, of course!
He's a fucking doooooooooooochebag, and his douchebaggery is nothing new. He' a conservative Catholic hack masquerading as a film critic.
People with handlebar mustaches are gay. It is one of the things that the gay community does so that they can recognize each other. Sorry to out you mike; but, your a d@uchebag and deserve to be outed.
Even if he believes what he is saying why the hell is he stupid enough to say it? What he is saying makes him sound like a man who is totally out of touch with the history of our country.
Trying to make slavery look less awful than it was is not the kind of talk Obama was speaking of when he said we need to talk about race and resentments on each side.
Besides, who died and made this movie critic an expert on the subject of slavery?
"Don't think of them as chains. Think of them as early, crude bling."
Sadly there are many more Medveds other here than we care to admit. They either clean up the truth about our history(lie) or they hide from it as if it didn't happen so they don't have to take in consideration any down line social or economic ramifications.
medved also mentioned that those brought over on the slave ships were treated to a free ocean cruise.
in reality, medved has put himself atop the list of neoslavers, good job medved! it is a lonely, racist and pathetic position, and i couldn't think of a better leader.
Who gives a better mustache ride, Stossel, or Medved?
if anyone has seen 'the yesmen' you might notice the similarities between the yesmen's satire and medved's sincerity.
medved, i'm sure, would argue that, given time, market forces would have ended slavery without the need for the civil war. again, see the yesmen. brilliant, imho.
as for the revulsion level: i'd be shocked but i have gotten used to the subtle and not so subtle racism emanating from the rightwing.
mean steve @ 46:
I really thought they were the same person for awhile. lol
Of all the people they could have come on and opined, they pick this embarassment? As an average shmoo I could care less what this cretin has to say.
casper46 @ 48:
NO one is a hollywood jackass and the other is a little bitch that'll run away crying if you slap him twice.
Pawsie @ 25:
In a country that has the proud achievement of EXPERIMENTING on Black men by WITHHOLDING treatment for syphilis, which did not stop until nineteen seventy-two --that's well into the modern age and long past the alleged attainment of civil rights, in case one of you tries to say it was so long ago-- I'd say any misgivings people may have about the origins of AIDS is well-founded. It was called the Tuskegee Experiment.
But, while we're on the subject, Bill Cosby, many white Americans favorite heckler of the Black poor, said something similar in the 90s during an interview on CNN. Be a scout and check it out for yourself.
So thank you for your unthoughtful dismissal of a reasonable suspicion among a group that used historical referencesto come to their conclusions.
"They didn’t respond to it that way. If a white pastor had made the comments that Jeremiah Wright had made, people would have been equally indignant." Medved
"Horseshit" yellow dog
Here in the midwest, many people are having buyers remorse for voting for Obama. People don't want to be preached to. Nor do they want a President that they can not disagree with without being called a racist.
Obama seems to surround himself with bigots. That's not cool. No matter how you slice or dice it.
Sadly, this outrage will create an environment that will help John McCain become the next President.
While people on the east or west coast might understand the nuance of the Obama speech, many others do not.
Liberal AND Proud @ 39:
In rightwing world, he is over qualified.
What a friggin' ugly mug that bastard has. Ugh.
I've heard his program before, and he sounds like a typical a whiny, pansy-ass republican who is scared of his own shadow of change and progress.
It's so hard to sit through five minutes of his program.
Who decided Medved's opinions were worth airtime?
Typical Gay White Person @ 53:
So what your saying is that all the people in the Midwest are backward stupid country folk that have a hard time understanding anything more than grunts and burps??
Typical Gay White Person @ 53:
That's because MOST people didn't even hear (or have the sense to research ) the speech. All they will hear is what MSM tells the sheeple.
Typical Gay White Person @ 53:
I know I didn't feel preached to. I learned a lot from Obama's race speech.
Medved was the worst movie critic in the world. I didn't think he could sink any lower, but of course he proved me wrong. He is actually quite good at being the asslick dog of the GOP noise machine.
1. Racial slavery was, pretty much, an American institution. America as in the continents, not the USA.
2. Half the history of this nation is hardly brief. Half the states in the nation is hardly limited and 13% is hardly tiny.
3. So what? They're lucky we didn't just kill them?
4. The most prosperous states in the nation didn't lose a massive war? Color me unsurprised.
5. Only Brazil continued the institution of slavery longer than we did.
6. Because us whiteys really, really fucked Africa up.
RayC Hussein @ 57:
There's no shortage of that type anywhere. The good news is they were all voting repug from the get go so there's no loss there.
What a wheelbarrow full of knee-jerk crap. Sorry, but American blacks do not have the patent on the horrific institution called slavery. I think empires like Rome and Greece did a pretty good job enslaving millions of whites too. As Marcus Rediker points out in arguably the finest book every written "The Slave Ship A Human History", the brutal enslavement of Africans to the Americas by specifically the English and the Dutch, would have been impossible to carry out if it were not for the complicity and participation of Africans themselves. Various warrior like tribes such as the Udu kidnapped, murdered and raped their own people to sell and bring them personally to the English and Dutch Commanders anchored off the coast of West Africa. In many cases the sailors of these ships were treated worse than the slaves themselves by the brutal and murderous slave Captains. I think that the nearly 700,000 Americans who died in our Civil War and the sacrifice of their families demonstrated that not all Americans would tolerate such a barbaric institution. Let's move on.
RayC Hussein @ 57:
Hahahahahahahahaha......damn! Warn me next time!! Coffee is hot!
casper46 @ 58:
True. Anybody who listened to the speech would not think that they "cannot disagree with [him] without being called a racist."
pitman @ 63:
Sound argument. "But, but, but, other people did it too!!"
This closeted religious turd should go back to reviewing family films- poorly.
At least in that setting, no one expects anything other than vapid, thinly disguised racism.
pitman @ 63:
Interesting post. Most slavery apologists do not think the Civil War was about slavery.
Is it me or do I have a deja vu moment? I've seen those six statements before, possibly on C&L.
P.D. @ 17:
That is why it is no longer the MSM, there is nothing mainstream about this monster. Just like you said they represent the corporations/big business not the mainstream. It is the corporate media all the time and any other opinions don't apply.
And yes, a nation of no nothing selfish people that also want everything for next to nothing. We have become a nation of drones.
Republican party, R.I.P.
See why CNN is the most trusted name in news?
They give equal time to both sides, Republicans and racists.
Wow. Let me write that again...
Wow.
I am especially stunned by -
While America deserves no unique blame for the existence of slavery, the United States merits special credit for its rapid abolition.
Um, rapid abolition???? What???
It took a hundred years and well over 600,000 lives. Even Lincoln initially even sought to prolong it so long as the Union was preserved.
I thought this guy was just a wierd nut living in his own Rockwellian world, but now...? He's clearly INSANE.
jimbo92107 @ 71:
lol- nice one
I wonder what this fruitcake thinks about the Holocaust...
There is not one point in Medved's screed which isn;t complete and utter bull$hit.
It is so irresponsible for CNN to allow this uneducated fool to comment on such a complicated subject. As a counter they should have had Dr. Harry Edwards or Dr. Cornell West in the discussion to eat this dumb fucker alive.
Reminds me of the same brilliant mindset of Barbara Bush when she made a comment re Katrina victims:
"This is working very well for them."
http://www.editorandpublisher.com/eandp/news/article_display.jsp?vnu_con...
That list is so stupid. The states that were more prosperous could afford to free their slaves because they weren't needed - other industries were available.
You have to be a brain-dead idiot to follow that logic.
it's not about race, it's about blackness...huh?! what a tool.
Another excellent candidate for agressive pancreatic cancer, and yet it will strike somebody else far less deserving.
Wow. I don't know where to start. This guy is grasping to maintain his state of denial.
The only thing I can think of that wasn't already commented on is this:
4. It’s not true that the U.S. became a wealthy nation through the abuse of slave labor: the most prosperous states in the country were those that first freed their slaves.
If they weren't making money off Slavery in the South, then why did they spend so much money on slaves?
Enough of his facial hair and wishing he had cancer, stop embarrassing yourselves. And the fact remains, points 1, 2 and 3 (of his, on slavery) are in fact true statements. Anyone who denies that is as big a fool as anyone who tries to defend points 4, 5 or 6!
Jack @ 74:
So true. When Jewish people get bat crazy at Holocaust deniers maybe they can imagine how we black folk feel when unqualified assholes like Medved spout off this mythical racist dumb shit.
This is really disturbing. If you want to make a decent comparison, you should compare the experiences of Africans to the experiences of the Jews. Both groups were persecuted across a wide range of nations and over many years. Both groups have been the target of racial and ethnic hatred. Both groups have sought redress for their grievances.
Nodoby would dare to tell a Holocaust Survivor to "just get over it." No matter how secure Jewish people are today in the United States and Europe, nobody has a right to tell them to forget about the past. The Holocaust was simply too terrible and evil. The entire country of Germany has dedicated itself to making up for the Holocaust. They have paid back the money they stole. They have abolished their national anthem. And, all German kids are forced to study tolerance.
But what about black people in this country. How many were killed? Put into ghettoes? Starved? And systematically destroyed? Nobody knows for sure.
And though the situation has improved for black people in this country, people like Rev. Wright ought to be considered with the similar respect and deferrence that we give to Holocaust survivors. Not the exact same, because the Holocaust seems worse. But we should cut Rev. Wright some slack. He lived through segregation. He lived through race riots. He lived through the assassinations of black leaders. He lived through lynchings and the KKK. He lived through the ghetto.
The mistreatment of African-Americans in this country, while it might not be the same as the Holocaust, it is our mark of shame. And if we cannot make up for it by honoring our historical promise to pay black people for the work they did while in bondage, the least we can do is try to understand why someone who grew up in the previous generation would feel the way that they feel.
1. Slavery was an ancient and universal institution, not a distinctively American innovation.
In 1860 approximately 15% (4 million) of the inhabitants of the U.S. were slaves, a number surpassed only by the Roman Empire.
2. Slavery existed only briefly, and in limited locales, in the history of
the republic - involving only a tiny percentage of the ancestors of today’s Americans.
The first slaves arrived in Virginia in 1619. The overwhelming majority of African Americans and Africans living anywhere in the Americas are the descendants of slaves.
3. Though brutal, slavery wasn’t genocidal: live slaves were valuable but dead captives brought no profit.
Slave trader accounts and records assert that approximately 20% of kidnapped Africans (a number near 2 million) did not survive the Middle Passage voyage to the Americas.
4. it’s not true that the U.S. became a wealthy nation through the abuse of slave labor: the most prosperous states in the country were those that first freed their slaves.
American slavery predominately served to create wealth for the nation’s plantation aristocracy, tying up their capital and retarding the development of other economic activity. The South's insistence on spreading this inefficient form of economic feudalism to the West was the primary cause of the Civil War.
5. While America deserves no unique blame for the existence of slavery, the United States merits special credit for its rapid abolition.
The dates from 1619-1865 encompass 146 years plus 100 more years of Jim Crow.
6. There is no reason to believe that today’s African Americans would be better off if their ancestors had remained behind in Africa.
Nor is their reason to believe they wouldn’t be better off. Between 9 and 12 million people were kidnapped from their homes in Africa and shipped to the Americas between the 16th to the 19th Centuries. Neither they nor the ones they left behind were better off for it.
1. Cultural genocide was an ancient and universal institution, not a distinctively Nazi Party innovation.
2. The extermination of Jewish families across Europe existed only a few years, and in just a few countries, in the history of the World - involving only a tiny percentage of the ancestors of today’s Europeans.
3. Though brutal, the Holocaust wasn’t necessarily genocidal: Jews were kept alive in labor camps to promote the war effort - that is until the Final Solution.
4. It’s not true that Germany became a wealthy nation through the abuse of Jewish labor: the most prosperous country in Europe was the one that surrendered to the Allies.
5. While Germany deserves no unique blame for the existence of genocide, Germany merits special credit for its rapid surrender.
6. There is no reason to believe that today’s Jews would be better off if their ancestors had remained behind in the ghettos they were confined too.
This clown sounds exactly like that Racist Dinesh D'souza.
Michael Medved is so, so, wrong. The fact that he can utter such nonsense without getting skewered for it only proves the deadly aspect of the state of journalism. Gore Vidal said it best:
From "Gore Vidal Speaks Seriously Ill of the Dead" (his eulogy of Bill Buckley):
"The habit of lying is now a national style that started with "news" magazines that was further developed by pathological liars that proved to be "good" Entertainment on TV. But a diet of poison that has done none of us any good.
I speak ex cathedra [as if i'm the Pope] now, ad urbe et orbe, (to Rome and the world) with a warning that no society so marinated in falsity can long survive in a real world."
http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/20080320_gore_vidal_speaks_seriously...
Andrew @ 77:
So true...this woman is filled with hatred. George W. is truly his mother's son.
Hey, Medved, let's conduct a thought experiment:
Let's say we live under a system where I own you, your wife, and your kids.
Just for profit, I decide to sell off your kids to some farm 100 miles away. You won't see them again.
Oh, and I've decided to keep your wife as my "house maid."
Mouth off about it, and I'll horsewhip you until you go into shock.
Imagine a few generations of this...
How you like it now?
John Tulin @ 82:
Sorry Dad.
Africans sold THEIR OWN to the Dutch into slavery. The White Europeans brought them to America. America ended slavery, at least in this country.
I've heard the same kind of remarks made by toothless meth addicts.
Left&Left @ 76:
My man Cornell.
They do not (in the Right wing) have any intellectuals, just these knuckledragging fools.
Makes me wonder can this be for real, or just a way to divide the middle class?
Someone out to tear this man down and put up a human being...
Too bad there aren't any American Indians here to speak up about the genocide point... hmmm, Where are they?
pitman @ 63:
I haven't read the rest of the comments but I guess we'll see "off with his" for daring to offer a different perspective.
John, you should respell your name: Toolin
Cheers,
-GSD
You can't get any closer to genocide than slavery. Just take a look at the life expectancy statistics for a slave. Disease, caused by slavery, wiped out so many people...it might as well be called genocide.
Even if 1,2, and 3 are absoutely true, that doesn't justify slavery in the slightest. And it certainly doesn't make it insignificant in the history of things. How silly.
abarts @ 92:
yeah i never hear anyone condem the black kings for sellng thier own race into slavery for profit!!! mostly bugs!
Medved's viewpoint on black slavery in the US has historical validity. Black Americans enjoy annual spending power of $700 billion. If Blacks in America were a separate nation they would be one of the world's richest and by far the wealthiest black nation on earth. The forced Diaspora of slaves to the United States turned out to be fortuitous for the generations of their black descendants. American Blacks current standard of living is light-years beyond that of their counterparts on the African continent. Black Africans are desperate to emigrate to the US.
abarts @ 92:
Good to know we're better than the Dutch of the old world. I guess your kind will be one notch up on the 9 circles of hell.
Can you blame the slave owners? They were just afraid. A Brief History of the USA.
Slavery wasn't so bad? I beg to differ. I recently learned from a Ken Burns documentary on Lewis & Clark's discovery of the Pacific Northwest that Capt. I was saddened to learn Clark (who had a large number of slaves) had refused freedom to a particularly important slave who had accompanied him on his voyage west. Everyone who had accompanied Capt. Clark on his voyage was awarded 350 acres of land by President Jefferson. The slave was rewarded with a safe return back to being a slave for Capt. Clark. Capt. Clark complained to Merriweather Lewis that this slave had become insolent and angry, acting high and mighty, believing that he was entitled to special treatment for his courage and bravery for accompanying him out west.
So, that's not mis-treatment of a slave?
abob @ 102:
What kind of a rationale is this? It's akin to saying...be thankful for the holocaust or there wouldn't be a state of Israel. Any interpretation of slavery that minimizes the horror that it was, is just hateful & racist.
abob @ 102:
How ridiculous. It's like saying, "Well, thank God I got hit by that truck that killed my family last year, otherwise I wouldn't have been able to sue for millions of dollars; and look where that's gotten me! Woohoo! I'm rich! My family may be obliterated, but at least I'm doing better than the guy next to me still driving an'84 Volvo! Haha."
pitman @ 63:
So, its OK because other people did it too....Uh....alrighty then...NEXT!
I remember watching this guy on the tube a few years back, debating another guy about how Hollywood is just so darned politically correct, going out of its way not to depict all terrorists as Arabs. And I thought to myself, he really should brush up on his history of the origins of Middle East terrorism/the founding of Israel, you know, Irgun, Stern Gang, the King David Hotel bombing, Deir Yassin, etc. Or, for that matter, the facts surrounding the 1993 WTC attack (FBI’s proven involvement), Oklahoma City, and—well, can’t talk about that one here.
But now I see he’s also a fountain of disformation on slavery. I wanted to link a Google video of a lecture by a South African historian tracing the roots of slavery to Judaic sacred texts, but—well, look!—it’s not there anymore.
I'm not getting how Wright is being twisted into some black separatist/nationalist. I'll quote a friend who attends Trinity:
Why all of the outrage over the Afrocentric one?
Once again another white guy(Pat Buck also in that boat) pontificating on minorities issues. If I ever see Medved I will punch him in the face. No correction I have seen him speak I will probably slap the sissy.
Limp-Dick Blimpaugh @ 14:
that dude is ugly. really, really ugly
The historical timeline of Black progress in America is muti-faceted and can be interpreted from many angles. For example: My wife is pretty annoying at times. Would I welcome the prospect of her getting killed by a rich drunk driver who ended up paying me tens of millions in compensation to settle a civil suit? I'm thinking. I'm thinking. OK, maybe not; but it aint a cut & dried decision.
"1. Slavery... not a distinctively American institution." thanks Mike, for so bravely denying something that no one has ever, ever asserted. But we had a whole, whole lot of slaves and had a national economy and culture in which slavery played a major role.
"2. Slavery existed only briefly, and in limited locales, in the history of the republic - involving only a tiny percentage of the ancestor's of today's Americans." What a dishonest creep! The tyranny of slavery predates the republic, and the tyranny of Jim Crow and Segregation extend long past emancipation, yet Medved wants to take 350 years of evil and turn it into a 75 year blip. The percentage of white Americans descended from slaveholders is probably not large, though I would doubt it's tiny either. The percentage of black Americans descended from slaves, however, probably approaches 100%. Isn't it so very telling which group of Americans Medved identifies with.
"3. Though brutal, slavery wasn't genocidal: live slaves were valuable but dead captives brought no profit." Well yes, but the Nazi's used slave labor too. All kinds of people survived WW2 slave labor because they were seen as valuable to the Nazi war effort, does that make it a bowl of cherries? I'm surprised Medved doesn't refer the rapists of female slaves as "pioneers in bridging the racial divide."
<..and the beat goes on. they continue to sing the same song, same lyrics, the black as well as other minorities in this country have had it so good for so long. what the heck are they complaining about. they just need to pull themselves up by the bootstraps just like the rest of us. all we need now is the story of "my grandfather came over at the turn of the century with no english and no money and look at us today. They can do the same." right! time to start calling them what they are. I used to give them the benefit of the doubt because they must be educated. But i've found that just because a person has schooling, it doesn't make him wise. conservatives know only one thing: personal wealth. everyone else can go to he double l.
I love Medved because he is consistent. He is sick and tired of Blacks harping on slavery and he is equally disgusted with his fellow Jews who keep dwelling on the Holocaust, Medved insists it is high time that both ethnic groups move on and stop re-living the past. The progress of Jews and Blacks in the United States, the greatest country on God's green earth, has been nothing short of spectacular. It serves no purpose for misery pimps to keep pretending we are still stuck in the 1930s. Medved is a Mench,
The part of his piece that I do agree with is that Obama's speech was a let's change the subject speech. There have been plenty of opportunities for Obama to give a speech like the one he gave, but he didn't. It was another cover Obama's butt moment.
thank you for finally getting onto medved....how he is an expert at anything beyond hyping really bad movies is beyond me
last week, medved went on and on about how the church has classes in swahili, but there are no classes with anything to do about america
someone please ask the alledgedly religious medved to show them one synagoge that teaches americana or english
oh, and im sorry, but this mans mentor is a scam artist....google rabbi daniel lapin and see how he laundered money for abramoff, and was ahead of the curve when it comes to housing scams, as he ripped off his former community of venice california
if a rabbi in the jewish community had any balls...both of these aholes would be put into cherem (excomunication) and that would destroy lapin and medved's children from finding suitable matches and thereby stopping their ability to procreate and allowing their perverse bloodlines to continue
thats right....i went there
Ok,for the record I HATE michael medved; but bigots like this sucker get their foot in the door using bits of history that get no exposure. The Rev Wright's anger of the history is warrented, but he gives only part of the story. Fact: The 13 orginial colonies took in and sold slaves as did the United States did later; indentured servants were also taken in with some tragic stories also. But South America and Central America took in more slaves than North America. This is no way excuses the history of what happened here. Second, more enslaved Africans were marched east to Muslim countries that sailed the Atlantic. Also North African slavers captured millions of Europeans from Italy to Ireland; these were from sea side villages and sailors. Thomas Jefferson sent the Marines to kick butt at Tripoli to prevent American sailors from being grabbed and sold into slavery. America will always have to keep paying a high price for her sins; but America did not invent the practice. The Rev Wrights of the world give asses like Medved traction in their arguments, cause the larger story is not told. The Rev Wright had the Romans enslaving the Jewish people(therefore white folk); when it was actually the North African Egyptians that enslaved the Jewish people; Rome merely conquered and ruled them. History is not our enemy; but distortion can be.
What would Zeus do? @ 8:
We lost how many people in the Civil war to end slavery? 600K or something...NO, it was that bad.
abob @ 117:
that mensch aligns himself with daniel (the pig) lapin
nice of medved to say that jews should get over the holocaust and blacks should get over slavery
how many of his family died in the holocaust?
and every year, he and other jews relive the slavery of egypt....we still havent gotten over it....nor are we allowed to...it is what makes us the jewish people
his thoughts on religion are perverse...which makes sense, because it seems that the only person he has ever learned with is daniel (the pig) lapin
note that lapin never speaks to jewish groups...they wont have him....but christians love that pig
Medved couldn't make it as a third-rate movie critic.
That's all I needed to know about the guy.
Next.
Michael Meved has a long list of prominent Blacks who endorse, co-sign, validate and agree with his political and social viewpoints. Among his many Black defenders are Shelby Steele, Larry Elder, Niger Ennis, Roy Ennis, Ward Connerly, Ken Hamblin, Walter E. Williams, Rod Paige, J.C. Watts, Angela McGlowan, Thomas Sowell, Sophia A. Nelson, Deroy Murdock, Lynn Swann and Ezola Foster. Medved enjoys street cred in the conservative black community.
"It’s not about race!" said the stupid, fucking white man. Yeah, that would be convenient for YOU, Medved. Please stop acting like you speak for the rest of us pasties, ok?
Who cares what he thinks, anyway? Even his whiny movie reviews suck. This guy couldn't find the hairy end of a dog with two hands and a professional groomer doing an assist and we need to hear his opinion on this topic? Feh! Double-feh!!
Hmm, Medved, Kurtz running down Barack HUSSEIN Obama. Who'da thought?
I could very easily make a case that Medved is retarded.
5. While America deserves no unique blame for the existence of slavery, the United States merits special credit for its rapid abolition.
the USA freed slaves when? 1865? and mexico when? 1814? okay, just checkin'.
not to mention his agenda is disgusting.
Barack has to answer vis-a-vis Wright. Then get back on track. And by the way that's a preacher or Minister, not a Reverend. What about Insane John McCain? Why has the media failed to get their hands on some of the lunacy from Hagee and that slick piece of shit Rod Parlsely? Another pass for the senile ole former flyboy?
abob @ 124:
"Street cred in the conservative black community"?? You make it sound like these people are the Wu Tang Clan. I grant you, some of them could be considered old, dirty bastards...
Captain Hussein Kangaroo @ 127:
What offense have retarded people committed against you that you would so insult them?
abob @ 124:
medved has street cred with alot of self hating blacks, who if it was possible would wipe the black off their skin
as an aside, the reason the southern states signed onto the declaration of independence was due to the fact that britain was aboloshing slavery
it took over 100 years from the founding of this country to the civil war....that may be swift in universal time....but 100 years is a long time for many a man
Medved is so full of shite.
His absurd comment #5 that the U.S of A. brought about a swift end to slavery will not go unchallenged here.
The Fugitive Slave Law in 1793 revised in 1850 allowed Southern slave owners to recapture their "property" and return that "property" to the slave owners custody. We need to give Canada much deserved credit for allowing Fugitive Slaves into their territory. The U.S. did not abolish the Fugitive Slave law until June 1864. We need to acknowledge Canada for their help in ending slavery as well as Methodist and Unitarians Liberals in Massachusetts for helping those Fugitive Slaves escape the hell of human bondage.
Former Slaves were not allowed citizenship until the 14th Amendment in 1868, and it was not until 1870 that the 15th Amendment gave former slaves the right to vote. Unfortunately it was not until the Voting Rights Act of 1965 that the last of the Jim Crow discrimination laws were abolished.....only 43 years ago.
Certainly even a dickweed like Medved should recognize that market forces drove the exportation of slaves out of Africa to the British Colonies. As long as North Americans were buying the exports would continue. WE drove the market, Medved, you can't just casually disregard that fact.
In order to buy into this guilt free version of American Exceptionalism you have to disregard so many historical facts that you have to disregard history itself.
Oh come on, it's been like what, 150 years? Who even remembers who owned who?
(h/t to Jon Stewart).
Medved is not trying to justify, rationalize or mitigate slavery. Medved is simply putting slavery into historical perspective. Slavery is not uniquely American. The history of mankind is the history of slavery. Black slavery in the United States ended at the cost of 600,00 lives. Almost all of the dead were white men. Black slavery exists today in Africa; almost 150 years after it ended in the United States. Slavery is not a uniquely white institution. The brutality, savagery and merciless atrocities blacks have historically inflicted on each other makes white oppression look like a stroll through Disneyland.
I know its wrong to wish disease on people, even a creep like Medved, but I'd kind of like to see it just so the Dr. could say "and now Michael, 6 reasons why your terminal cancer really isn't so bad!"
abob @ 103:
And all it took was the rape of their women. The enslavement and humiliation of men. The stealing and sale of their children. The brutality, torture, disease, and murder of generations.
Not to mention the fact that a slave could get killed for READING. There were lynchings, hangings, whippings and worse done black men and women.
Only an evil man would think that it's a good thing that was done to them.
Maybe it should be done to your family. Then you can tell us how you feel.
You're an animal. A subhuman. Someone like you should be rejected from the human race.
abob @ 137:
Now that's an outright lie.
Last time I looked, there blacks weren't publicly hanging one another, whipping each other to death, raping generations of women, or selling each others children into slavery.
I don't know what kind of madhouse they let you out from, but fella... you're insane.
Medved, being a conservative, can't help being odious. But I would advise liberals to temper the uniform revulsion they feel for all conservatives. Having listened to Medved, he more frequently than any other radio host, generally draws callers back to facts, he allows opposition calls, and if I recall correctly he just said positive stuff in defense of Obama last week. He also has Conspiracy Day on his show, where you can call in and voice any suspicion that the governement is secrety working against us.
Another conservative radio host Mike Gallagher or Dennis Praeger warned his listeners, last week, not to gloat or play holier-than thou about Elliot Spitzer because as he said, he had 6 words fo his listeners to consider, "Larry Craig, David Vitter, Mark Foley." Even Bill O'Reilley, douchebag extraodinaire, has moments of moderation (on his radio show, not on TV). Conservatives are actively destroying this country, but occasionally they say moderate things.
Save your real vitriol for unredeemable assholes like Ann Coulter, Michael Reagan, Michael Savage. And most of it for Bush and Cheney.
All these media guys are just corporate paid prostitutes. paid huge sums of money to spout the corporate line no matter how badly they have to lie they feel the money they make makes everything allright!
Though brutal, slavery wasn’t genocidal: live slaves were valuable but dead captives brought no profit.”
Has this idiot ever heard of slave ships, with their mortality rate of one third of their passengers? How many hundreds of thousands died while being captured and transported to their cruel destinations. When you make such a stupid assertion about a topic like this, you add to the cruelty of slavery. Well done sir!
As a black man this puts it all in perspective for me. I mean who gives a shit that someone had the unmitigated gall, hubris and temerity to think that my ancestors were no better than pack animals that could bought and sold, beaten and bloodied as if they were barely (if at all) human? Who gives a shit that the concept behind it was utterly repugnant and stood in complete antithesis to everything the founding fathers said the country was supposed to stand for? It only lasted a couple of centuries, what's the big deal?
F*cking idiot.
In the 20th Century alone:
Gen Yakubu Gowon massacres in Biafra...1 million
Hutu massacre of Tutsi in Rwanda...1.3 million
Idi Amin massacre of Ugandans...500,000
Somalia massacres...400,000
The death toll is tripled when you add all the wholesale slaughter of blacks by blacks in liberia, zambia, angola, luanda, darfur, eritria, ethiopia, mozambique and congo. Perspective and historical context is crucial for those who seek the truth.
Amen Bro. Thats fuckin rediculous. Its very sad that there are ignorant mother fuckers like that in this country. Ignorance is contagious. Fortunately so is Knowlege. Slavery is the ultimate evil no man should ever be subservient to another man.
abob @ 145:
Go back and read Medveds dumb ass article, then tell me what your post has to do with this thread.
Hey, since it wasn't so bad, lets enslave all the white guys who wimped out on joining the military in the 60's and we'll use them to regain our status as a once great country. And then we'll release them, quickly, even quicker than the US in the 1800's. So how bout it big guys?
abob @ 117:
Reliving past tragedies & death is only annoying when it reminds the dominant culture that neither they, nor their ancestors ARE as innocent as they want to believe.
Slavery wasn't isolated in this country! The Laws of Manumission were enacted by the government nationwide and very few refused to disobey the law and many more profited. Freed Africans in the North were brutally and deceitfully shipped to the south even if they'd never been slaves because some Northern Yankee could make a buck from a Southern slave bounty hunter, get rid of business competition or take over land.
Insurance companies profited from the insured 'cargo' that were living, breathing, kidnapped Africans.
Ship buildiers & sail makers prospered handsomely from making the necessary equipment to bring the live 'cargo' into the states.
The White House was partly built using slave labor. The majority of America participated in slavery; it was sanctioned by this nation of laws.
Not only that, after slavery was abolished, my ancestors were forced into a not so different bondage that legally allowed white people to physically 'punish' them for any arbitrary transgression on the job. Then there was the practically fruitless effort of sharecropping that saw most cheated out of their rightful wages! Oh' and later there were the many incidents of white mobs lynching men & even pregnant women to run Blacks out of their town. Try reading the James Loewen book, Sundown Towns: A Hidden Dimension of Racism. You might live in one of those towns, which would explain your incredible pride in being so ignorant.
You're only convincing yourself of your lies. Other people know better.
abob @ 137:
Just like Medved, ignorant white fucks like you Abob have zero right or credibility to discuss our issues. In fact, if race relations required a grade, stupid ass crackers like you Abob would get a fucking "f-" you idiotic mother fucker!
[ Left&Left....it's getting tiresome.Stop with the racial slurs,and stop being abusive. Site Monitor]
Left&Left @ 149:
When I hear totally unqualified, uneducated white cocksuckers like your dumb ass trying to explain the "black man's plight from your white perspective, I want to vomit. You don't know shit Abob. So STFU!!
[Stop with the racial slurs....and stop being so abusive...Site Monitor.]
Login or Register to post comments.