Go Home

DNC Launches First General Election Ad: Better Off?

Statistics showing that McCain's claims are not fact-based below the fold.

Anderson Cooper Voiceover: "Senator McCain, are Americans better off than they were 8 years ago?" [CNN Republican Primary Debate, 1/30/2008]

John McCain: "I think you could argue that Americans overall are better off - because we have had a pretty good prosperous time…" [CNN Republican Primary Debate, 1/30/2008]

CG: "Household Income Down $1,000"
Median Household Income:

2000: $49,192
2006: $48,023

[Joint Economic Committee Fact Sheet , 8/29/2007]

McCain: "With low unemployment…"

CG: "Unemployment Up"
Unemployment Rate

January 2001: 4.2 percent
March 2008: 5.1 percent

[Bureau of Labor Statistics, The Employment Situation, March 2008]

McCain: "Low inflation..."

CG: "Highest Inflation in 17 Years"

Annual Inflation Rate
1990 6.1
1991 3.1
1992 2.9
1993 2.7
1994 2.7
1995 2.5
1996 3.3
1997 1.7
1998 1.6
1999 2.7
2000 3.4
2001 1.6
2002 2.4
2003 1.9
2004 3.3
2005 3.4
2006 2.5
2007 4.1
[Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI-U Historical Data]

McCain: "A lot of good things have happened."

CG: "Gas Prices Up 200%"
Retail Price Per Gallon:

Jan 1, 2001: 141.6
Apr 14, 2008 339.7

[Weekly U.S. Retail Gasoline Prices , Energy Information Administration]

McCain: "A lot of jobs have been created…"

CG: "1.8 Million Jobs Lost"

January 2001: 6.0 million unemployed
March 2008: 7.8 million unemployed

[Bureau of Labor Statistics The Employment Situation, March 2008]

Statistics provided courtesy of the Democratic National Committee

About Nicole Belle
Nicole Belle's picture
Mom, Wife, Media Critic/Political Analyst, Blogger, Austen Fanatic, Unapologetic Liberal NicoleBelle@crooksandliars.com
Share This Post

Link To This Post


67 Comments
sofla's picture

What an elitist old fool.

anneyhussein's picture

It's an excellent ad!

All the Democrats need to do is keep pointing out the strong connection between McCain and Bush, as well as keep McCain's lurching proclamations that change every day and his volatile temper before the voters, and McCain becomes pitiable, not presidential.

motorfingaz's picture

The only way to defeat this right wing wacko is to destroy his character.

The DNC has not realized this tactic yet but notice the right wing uses it each and every election cycle.

Its time to stop playing nice with the conservatives!!

breakspear's picture

Today one of McCain's lapdogs stated that Obama is a new politician with old ideas. that's odd, as McCain is the consummate washington experienced insider, and also old. so, lapdog, if there's anyone this country doesn't need is more of the confirmed 'same old same old. for you know with McCain, everything old is still old. and that includes ideas.

Maldoror's picture

Can someone explain to me how the last statistic compares to population growth? Does the number of jobs lost appear smaller when compared to a larger population?

Furious's picture

Ever since Ronald Reagan famously asked Americans in 1980 if they were better off now than four years ago, answering the question has been a pre-requisite for aspiring White House hopefuls. This week, Republican nominee John McCain twice tried to supply a response when asked about the eight years of the Bush economy. His changing answers of "yes" and "no" on consecutive days set a new flip-flopping record, even for John McCain.

For the details, see:
"McCain's 24 Hour Flip-Flop on the Bush Economy."

hood's picture

This sinile old fart better not pack, he ain't going near the White House. I see the glass half full; America won't f**k this up again, and the only scenario (from hell by the way) that this person becomes president would be if they cheat again or SCOTUS "divinely" appoint him.

General_Rennenkampf's picture

Wingnut cap on/

Facts?!!! Logic?!!! Only sissy weenie boys use that!!!

/Wingnut cap off.

I agree with Motorfingaz in post #3, it's the only way to beat the Repub attack machine.

beltman713's picture

That seems to be McCain's line, "some people argue" or "you could argue." It's sort of a way to flip flop out of what you say. You could later say, "I didn't that the economy is good, I said you could argue that it is."

ConcernedCanuck's picture

I have a question perhaps someone on here could answer. Um, the US government is bailing out it's banks. England is bailing out it's banks. Nations involved with Iraqi invasion are in financial turmoil. Yet, government leaders from these nations all say the same thing---- that it is not "war" related......well, then is this just some sheer coinkydink that every nation involved in this fiasco just happens to all have banks with the exact same bad judgements? I smell a big ass rich corporate rat.

Mark @ News Corpse's picture

This ad is only half finished.

As Furious (is that you Jon?) notes above, McCain more recently answered the "better off" question saying that "Americans are not better off than they were eight years ago."

Tack that quote onto the end of this ad and you've got something really powerful.

News Corpse, The Internet's Chronicle Of Media Decay.

Alice (formerly Hussein)'s picture

It looks good to me, but you're preaching to the choir here.

The Democrats are going to want to remind the people who still have their homes how much value they have lost.

It is about 25% around Detroit.

If that doesn't float some Democrat's boats then they should go into a different line of work, if they can find it.

motorfingaz's picture

Oil prices are expected to continue their upward march. It recently crossed the $100/barrel threshold that energy analysts have predicted. Their next prediction: "Black gold" could reach price points up near $200 within 12 months.

http://www.moneymorning.com/ppc/oil_2008_je9.html?gclid=CMz_y8zo6pICFQFq...

B.'s picture

Wow...I like this one. Hopefully it's one in long string of others...SOMETHING has to counter the positive media attention the man gets. I don't understand why / how people view him as an outsider...we need to show them reality.

Yellowbird's picture

When you add up the inflation figures, which by the way, do NOT account for FOOD or FUEL, The amount of inflation since 1990 is 105%.

I want to know how many workers have had a 105% increase in wages to keep up with that?

Not counting food and fuel.

As far as I can tell our pay has been cut in half since then. I don't know many people who make 61K a year anymore. The talking heads call that MEDIUM income right now.

Any observations?

McCain the Liar's picture

I'd love to see his first wife interviewed. It would end it for him.

Hussein Hussein's picture

Best strategy to beat McCain is to make him speak before the country without a teleprompter for 20 minutes. Oh, and we'd have to gag the press, since they'd all clamour to defend his "insight", "experience", and "legacy". Puke.

Left&Left's picture

My cousin Aaron is better off....he just got released after ten years in the Illinois State Pen.

Orangutan.'s picture

Howard Dean's Fifty State Strategy and Barack's message of Hope is really going to help come this fall. Some things are coming together that could provide for a more peaceful and optimistic future.

b's picture

word!

scylla's picture

These points are worth making and worth remembering, but if I hadn't read them first in your commentary, I wouldn't have gotten them all from the ad, because the first few points flashed on and off the screen so fast I could barely take it in. The other thing is that in a short ad like this, McCain's words can be heard, but the main information, what you want people to remember and maybe even repeat! is only in text flashing on the screen. What's wrong with this picture? That's freaking risky, because a lot of people are often listening to the TV but not looking directly at the screen. Which turns this into free promotion for McCain...do these folks have any professional producers working with them?

bullfrog's picture

you know what america really oughta do? we oughta give this guy a nuclear arsenal!

bullfrog's picture

TED BUNDY, EAT YOUR HEART OUT!

The Smiths's picture

To alert the american people the ad can also be tweaked to slam certain media outlets
and pundits that spew disinformation and lies.

.... and put the ad right in the middle of "those certain pundit's shows".

Orangutan. @ 19:

Howard Dean's Fifty State Strategy and Barack's message of Hope is really going to help come this fall. Some things are coming together that could provide for a more peaceful and optimistic future.

and hopefully, an end to the DLC.

EliteLemming's picture

Bullfrog wtf? Maybe Tim McVey?

Anderson Cooper Voiceover: “Senator McCain, are Americans better off than they were 8 years ago?” [CNN Republican Primary Debate, 1/30/2008]

John McCain: “I think you could argue that Americans overall are better off - because we have had a pretty good prosperous time…” [CNN Republican Primary Debate, 1/30/2008]

apparently, you're NOT an american if you're not doing better. I guess the number of americans is dropping steadily.

P.D.'s picture

Anyone who votes for McCain is a glutten for punishment.

hood's picture

What teh Dems should do is recycle some of the crap the Bush Repigs used in 2000. I know it's dirty but damn it, we can't allow that man near the White House. Some has said and it's true, that we are one wacko away in the supreme court from moving decades backwards.

bullfrog @ 23:

TED BUNDY, EAT YOUR HEART OUT!

truly! no one can ring up a death toll like a repug president. bidding starts at 300,000.

P.D. @ 28:

Anyone who votes for McCain is a glutten for punishment.

or glutton...

Maldoror @ 5:

Can someone explain to me how the last statistic compares to population growth? Does the number of jobs lost appear smaller when compared to a larger population?

population grew about 6% in that period from about 280M to 300M
unemployment (in people) went up 30%

The Smiths's picture

Every state and DNC should also do some investigating....

"...the question isn't whether or not ABC set out to lynch Obama..

....No, the only question is for whom the network was performing the deed? "
http://www.progressivedailybeacon.com/?p=807

bullfrog's picture

anyone want to join me in hell for some bbq?

satan's fixin' up some ribs o' hagee, everyone's invited.

YUM!

Fil Hussein Oaks's picture

motorfingaz @ 3:

The only way to defeat this right wing wacko is to destroy his character.

The DNC has not realized this tactic yet but notice the right wing uses it each and every election cycle.

Its time to stop playing nice with the conservatives!!

You are correct. Here is everything needed to do that.
http://www.wcltam.com/news/special/articledetail.cfm?articleid=23261

Roket's picture

Excuse me, but none of McLiar’s claims are based on fact. What comes out of his mouth is determined by who he is speaking to at the moment. Facts, and even truth, have nothing to do with it.

Shared Humanity's picture

Out of touch.

ROBERT H. GRAHAM's picture

THIS MAN IS DREAMING, WHILE WE ARE IN A NIGHTMEAR!!!!, DON'T LET IT GO ON, STOP HIS DREAMING, NOW!!!!.

Atilla the Hungry's picture

They should have McCheatunHeart's first wife do the voice over.

Otay's picture

He's out of touch with the ordinary American. No wonder, with his 100 million dollar household income. Oh well, what can one expect from the elites but elitism?

Rasputin's picture

They needed to add food prices up 40% to 70%... and food riots in 33 countries... we're next!

bullfrog's picture

BaScOmBe against Bitter Elitist Bullshit @ 30:

bullfrog @ 23:

TED BUNDY, EAT YOUR HEART OUT!

truly! no one can ring up a death toll like a repug president. bidding starts at 300,000.

lbj, tricky dick & hank kissinger managed to team up and get 58,000 of our boys killed for absolutely no reason.

chimpy's got a ways to go, although who knows what glory could be fulfilled in mccain's century of armageddon?

dropkick's picture

"I have a question perhaps someone on here could answer. Um, the US government is bailing out it’s banks. England is bailing out it’s banks. Nations involved with Iraqi invasion are in financial turmoil. Yet, government leaders from these nations all say the same thing—- that it is not “war” related……well, then is this just some sheer coinkydink that every nation involved in this fiasco just happens to all have banks with the exact same bad judgements? I smell a big ass rich corporate rat."
It is related. Consider the twin deficiets, trade and US budget. We are 9 trillion dollars in debet and climbing. Borrowing half a trillion dollars a year to carry on this illegal war. We have printed so many dollars the world is awash in dollars. Foriegn central banks are sitting on trillions because they are trying to keep the dollar strong (theirs weak) for the trade advantage and buying more of our debet even as the dollar drops faster in value. Things may start to come apart when one of these countries decides it's no longer going to take the loss and start bailing out of the dollar. That may start the race for the bottom. We already see the oil producing countries begining to sell there oil for other currencies. We have in the past demanded that these countries sell the oil for dollars an artificial prop for the dollar (other countries must buy dollars on the open market to buy oil).
Even the drug lords are begining to demand Euros. That should be a wake up call.
This house of cards is about to collapse.

chris's picture

Typical Dem ad, talking about issues the president does not control.

chuck's picture

Senator McCain is not wearing an American Flag lapel pin.

Shame... shame... shame...

dropkick's picture

Ron Paul was right. Get rid of the FED and the CIA.

RevJeff's picture

The DNC should run a commercial explaining that with our military in the shape that it is now, if we stay in Iraq much longer we are going to have to have a draft. There is no way around it. McCain in the White House in 2009, draft by 2010.

Lisa Williamson's picture

RevJeff @ 47:

The DNC should run a commercial explaining that with our military in the shape that it is now, if we stay in Iraq much longer we are going to have to have a draft. There is no way around it. McCain in the White House in 2009, draft by 2010.

"You say you want a revolution..." - John Lennon

Annual Inflation Rate
1990 6.1
1991 3.1
1992 2.9
1993 2.7
1994 2.7
1995 2.5
1996 3.3
1997 1.7
1998 1.6
1999 2.7
2000 3.4
2001 1.6
2002 2.4
2003 1.9
2004 3.3
2005 3.4
2006 2.5
2007 4.1
[Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI-U Historical Data]

my raises over that period exceeded inflation 4 times. guess which years?!

the munz's picture

Err, sorry, just a senior moment. What was the question?

Otay's picture

chris @ 44:

Typical Dem ad, talking about issues the president does not control.

ROFL!

If you're talking about war, I'd agree that this president certainly hasn't seemed to be controlling things...

but he did enable spending money on this fiasco, and pretends to control it.

Carol's picture

Go to: www.democrats.org and show Howard some support!

Carol's picture

Please fund the ad: www.democrats.org

Thank kew

JJohnson's picture

Otay @ 51:

chris @ 44:

Typical Dem ad, talking about issues the president does not control.

Typical Republican, all bluster, but no understanding of what the issues even are.

JJohnson's picture

*edit*

Sorry Otay; my quote got mingled with your's somehow!

VegasRage's picture

The democrats hold the power of the purse, why haven't they ended the war? What were the mid-term elections about again? Why should we listen to these clowns regarding the economy when they have been just as complicit in helping the economy slide as the Repuglicans who have asked for the billions of dollars they continue shell out for this ill conceived illegal war? Neither party deserve our vote or trust.

ferrofluid's picture

Alice (formerly Hussein) @ 12:

It looks good to me, but you're preaching to the choir here.

The Democrats are going to want to remind the people who still have their homes how much value they have lost.

It is about 25% around Detroit.

If that doesn't float some Democrat's boats then they should go into a different line of work, if they can find it.

One thing that puzzles me when comparing British party politics to American is...

The Democrat party seems to be rudderless or gives out that impression, where is the strong visible leadership of the Congressional people.
I know there is a massive separation between the pop star President role and the mundane Congressional jobs.
In the UK the Prime Minister is the leader of the party and also the top party dog in the House of Commons.
British party leaders both the in power and opposition both appear on TV and give interviews and promote policy and action.
Here in the US, the party leadership seems or tries to be invisible and toothless.

ferrofluid's picture

VegasRage @ 56:

The democrats hold the power of the purse, why haven't they ended the war? What were the mid-term elections about again? Why should we listen to these clowns regarding the economy when they have been just as complicit in helping the economy slide as the Repuglicans who have asked for the billions of dollars they continue shell out for this ill conceived illegal war? Neither party deserve our vote or trust.

16 months of mostly leaderless inaction apart from a handful of dedicated committee types.
time to pull the rug out and stop funding bad Republican policys.

ferrofluid's picture

chris @ 44:

Typical Dem ad, talking about issues the president does not control.

hey chris was that you doing that Faux ambush interview earlier !
certainly sounded like a crackly voiced teenygopper.
dont forget you have to be in bed by 9pm so up in time for school tomorrow.

Spicegal's picture

McCain is blatantly lying. And you can bet the interviewer didn't bother to challenge him on any of those points. Are Americas really that gullible? I feel like we're living in Oz with the Wizard standing behind the curtain pulling his little levers blowing smoke up everyone's behinds. Yes everything is wonderful, peachy kin, and pay no attention to that mind behind the curtain and all those facts that suggest otherwise.

Spicegal's picture

# 44 says.."Typical Dem ad, talking about issues the president does not control."

I always find it of interesting how when the Dems are in control and the economy goes to crap, it's the Dems fault. On the other hand, when the REthugs are in control and the economy goes to crap, which it inevitably does, it's not their fault. And of course, the economy was great under Clinton (a Democrat), and he gets no credit, and in fact is blamed for the problems that ensued once he left office. So, not only do the Dems get blamed when they're in control, they get blamed when they're not. It's truly amazing. Republicans are such hypocrites.

Idiotland's picture

chris Says: Typical Dem ad, talking about issues the president does not control.

hahahahaha!

You fascists must really enjoy making asses out of yourselves.

DR-TV's picture

Amen to those demanding the dems take off the kid gloves and slap this grump old hasbeen in from off all to see. McCain may have been an American hero as a young man, but those days are long gone. Since the war, he's cheated on his wife with an heiress he's referred to as a c--t, married into her 100 million dollar family, and like to vote against financial aid for our current veterans. Some hero.

SnowCritter's picture

While the ad attempts to compare and contrast McCain's "reality" with the world as it is, all you hear are McCain's words. Anyone not watching the ad (just listening to it while doing something else) could easily assume that the ad was pro-McCain. Try it. Close your eyes and just listen to the ad. It's only at the end where the question is asked "Do you feel better off?"

The DNC ran these types of ads in the last two election cycles. They're lousy - they put forth the other sides positions better than our own.

Harm's picture

Worst disclaimer ever! "The Democratic National Committee is responsible for the content of this advertisement." NOT! Should have ended, "The Bush administration is RESPONSIBLE for the content of this advertisement. The DNRC just paid for the air time!"

Harm's picture

correction, "DNC".

Bob Rogers's picture

McCain's nickname in Vietnam "Songbird"

Comments are closed on this entry