Go Home

The Right-Wing War on the AARP

Back in 2003, Republican leaders praised the AARP for its support of President Bush's unfunded and deeply flawed Medicare prescription benefit. But now that the 40 million member organization has endorsed the House Democrats' health care reform bill, the GOP is declaring war on its one-time ally. Helping lead the attack is an array of industry-funded front groups and their reactionary has-been spokesmen like Pat Boone.

Last week, Republican Congressmen Dave Reichert (R-WA) and Mike Pence (R-IN) implied the nation's leading organization for seniors was in for the ACORN treatment from the GOP and its media allies. Despite the thorough debunking of right-wing claims that Democratic health care reform proposals would slash Medicare benefits for46 million American elderly:

Pence and Reichert suggested that support was the result of corruption inside the AARP and not based on the interests of its membership.

"What you've got here is a backroom deal," Pence said of reform measures expected to be introduced by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid this afternoon. "Democrats are protecting the salaries of the heads of groups like AARP while cutting Medicare"...

The GOP is using more than just rhetoric to go after the group. Rep. Dave Reichert (R-WA) claims to have launched an investigation into AARP in his home state. Reichert says his "ongoing" investigation focuses on whether AARP should be classified as an insurance company because of its revenue from royalties the group gets from licensing its brand for insurance products.

Sounding the clarion call for conservatives is aging singer turned World Net Daily regular Pat Boone. Boone, who in recent months branded Barack Obama a "president without a country" who is "waterboarding America" over "socialistic health care and a host of other ultraliberal causes," is also the celebrity mouthpiece for the 60 Plus Association.

When Pat Boone isn't proposing the metaphorical gassing of "all manner of parasites, vermin, roaches, rats, worms and termites" of President Obama and his team in the White House, he's leading the charge for the self-proclaimed right-wing alternative to the AARP:

The 60 Plus Association is a non-partisan seniors advocacy group with a free enterprise, less government, less taxes approach to seniors issues. 60 Plus has set ending the federal estate tax and saving Social Security for the young as its top priorities. 60 Plus is often viewed as the conservative alternative to the American Association of Retired Persons (AARP).

Of course, the 60 Plus Association is non-partisan in much the same way that bricks float. As SourceWatch, Rachel Maddow and FireDogLake all documented, "60 Plus has been a front group for the pharmaceutical industry since its inception." As Greg Sargent detailed, Boone's group, led by president and long-time Bush supporter Jim Martin, in 2005 backed Social Security privatization. Now, the 60 Plus Association with $2 million in funding from Big Pharma is producing ads and distributing direct mail with fabricated health care reform horror stories designed to scare the bejesus out of America's seniors.

As Maddow and FDL related, 60 Plus is tightly integrated into the usual suspects of right-wing astro-turfing, including FreedomWorks, the Tea Party movement, Bonner & Associates and even Jack Abramoff. And virtually all of its political skullduggery is funded by its friends in pharmaceutical lobby:

In 2002, 60 Plus received 91% of its total revenue - $11 million dollars - from one undisclosed donor, which the Washington Post reported lined up perfectly with "an unrestricted educational grant" to 60 Plus from PhRMa, the drugmaker lobby group. Jim Martin, the 60 Plus President, has acknowledged in interviews that it received money from pharmaceuticals, saying "I wish it was more."

As it turns out, Pat Boone and the 60 Plus Association aren't the only ones doing the Republican Party's dirty work in trying to kill health care reform. The American Seniors Association (ASA) and former Hollywood Squares host Peter Marshall, another group with another D-List celebrity front man, is trying to do the same thing.

The ASA garnered the spotlight in August when CBS News highlighted the organization in a fawning segment titled, "Thousands Quit AARP over Health Care Reform." But while noting ASA's aspiration to be the "conservative alternative" to the AARP, CBS' Sharyl Attkisson did nothing to research either the group's background or its claims.

While parroting the ASA's claim that the Obama plan "calls for $313 billion dollars in Medicare cuts over ten years," CBS provided neither context nor fact-checking. As Politifact examined in detail, President Obama is proposing $177 billion in savings from the private Medicare Advantage program, which "costs taxpayers on average of 14 percent more than the traditional Medicare plan." As Marc Steinberg of Families USA noted, "The core benefits of Medicare won't change." Just as important, Obama has pledged to reduce the notorious - and financially devastating - "donut hole" in the Bush Medicare drug plan.

Which is why the AARP is not falling for the Republicans' scare tactics. The organization's vice president for social impact noted, "AARP has not endorsed any plan at this point." As CBS reported:

Yet the AARP's Cheryl Matheis couldn't find anything to quibble with, including the Medicare cuts which she says will not affect benefits.

Of course, the CBS story wasn't really about health care. Instead, it was about the reactionary free-market conservative agenda and Republican scorched earth opposition to Barack Obama at all costs.

A little digging into Stuart Barton's 60,000 member American Seniors Association would have made that clear. Founded in 2005 by Barton's father Jerry as the National Association for Senior Concerns (NASCON), the group targeted the "radical agenda" of the AARP. Topping its program is Social Security privatization, hard-line opposition to immigration reform, and an overhaul of Medicare, which Barton deemed "the most abused and wasteful of all federal programs that could be bankrupt even before Social Security." As its press page shows, the ASA is a right-wing talking point regurgitation machine:

"On page 425 of the bill, a person must go to counseling every five years to basically learn how to die," Barton says. "As I read this and hear about no preventative care, it dawned on me that Obama's plan is to let all these baby boomers die quicker so we don't have to care for them in old age."

The ASA's "Four Pillars," also extolled by former Hollywood Squares game show host and honorary chairman Peter Marshall, are a hardliner's dream and a senior citizen's nightmare:

  1. Medicare Reform: This most abused and wasteful of all federal programs could be bankrupt before the Social Security System runs dry!
  2. Social Security Reform: Voluntary personal accounts safe from government meddling must be approved providing senior citizens options and keeping the system solvent.
  3. Illegal Aliens: Lawbreakers do not deserve Social Security payments intended for you and your family who are citizens.
  4. Tax Reform: An easily understood and simplified tax code in the form of the Fair Tax.

As that laundry list makes clear, the American Seniors Association like the 60 Plus Association cares less about the needs of America's elderly and more about the agenda of the right-wing of the Republican Party.

Meanwhile to President Obama's obvious delight in Washington, AARP CEO A. Barry Rand announced his group's backing of Democratic health care reform:

"AARP is proud to endorse the Affordable Health Care for America Act. We urge members of the House to pass this critical bill this year so our healthcare system can work for all of us."

No doubt, Pat Boone and his reactionary backers won't be happy. It's only a question of time before he calls for the "tenting" of the AARP.

(This piece also appears at Perrspectives.)

Share This Post

Link To This Post


63 Comments
curtilingus's picture

Twitter!

Evet's picture

Chirp

majii's picture

The 60 Plus Association is for rich elderly persons only.

Nangleator's picture

Playing with fire, they are.

Peter G's picture

and they may oppose the evolution of health care reform towards that end. Unless it looks like it will work. In the meantime it's better to have them on side then not.


Hasa Diga Eebowai

Seems like a red herring. I don't like the bill, at least what I know about it. I haven't seen the final bill, and I doubt that we'll see it before the vote.

Peter G's picture

Why indeed? It will make it that much harder to woo the AARP back into the fold later when public health care expands. They're behaving as if they were a child having a tantrum and threatening to take their ball and go home. I can't see any sense to this strategy. If they had any sense they'd be ignoring or playing down these sort of endorsements.


Hasa Diga Eebowai

savannah43's picture

the moderate GOP, and 60 Plus represents the wing nuts. I love it when they eat their own.

NoBuddy's picture

It might have a chance in a Democracy. However, the Senate is not a Democratic institution.

And the House and White House seems compromised by corporate lobbying/bribery.

And take a look at the corporate media. The government could only take single payer off the table because the mass media cooperated.

They have gone off the deep end and it doesn't look like they no how to swim. Well I say drown. Let these idiots go under and don't even attempt to help one of these morons. We will be better off without these idiots messing up the gene pool.
republicanism/conservatism is a mental illness that is killing America.

ChrisRobbins's picture

Even though they often seem guano crazy and unreasonable to the point of not being able to compromise, any long-term positive change we make to our nation, world, and species will probably have to come from bipartisanship. That means we'll at least have to tolerate the idiocy and come ready to play hardball.

therefore you cannot tolerate the idiocy of groups that will not put their proposals out on the table to bargain with. Positive change should not be based on bipartisanship.

Was the change effective? Did the change improve the current situation or make it worse? Cause and effect

curtilingus's picture

You know, it may not seem to have anything to do with the AARP and Obama, but I think the fact that a bird dropped a baguette on the Hadron collider and shut the whole thing down is proof that some one from the future is trying to prevent us from starting it up and destroying the planet.

You'd be surprised the conclusions you can draw from six pints.

but I am hoping it might move all the crazies into another "dimension"!


"Egotism is the anesthetic that dulls the pain of Stupidity" - Frank Leahy

The Sailor's picture

"In a theory reminiscent of the time travelling film Back to the Future, the theoretical physicists Holger Nielsen, from Denmark, and Masao Ninomiya, from Japan, have concluded that its discoveries could be so "abhorrent to nature" that they are coming back to stop their own creation. "

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/science-ne...

Peter G's picture

how foolish this would be? Taking on a lobby as powerful and well funded as AARP is daylight madness. Who are they going to try to take to the woodshed next? Veterans?


Hasa Diga Eebowai

J M Ashby's picture

The GoP already craps all over veterans. They go on TV and claim to be supporting the troops, but in the chambers of congress they constantly shit on servicemen and women.

Tax the Rich's picture

When you are an irrational kneejerk reactionary idealogue lunatic, you just can't help yourself. Especially when your I.Q. is lower than whale shit.

Taking on a group of 40,000,000 old folks, 100% of whom vote, and pissing them off. I like where this is going.


If I were a psychopath, I would join the republican party, and get in on the gravy train taking the Teabircher morons to the cleaners.

Terrible's picture

everyone, veteran or not, should sign the petition from VoteVets to Sen. Coburn telling him to stop blocking the veterans legislation that covers issues like caregiver assistance, Military Sexual Trauma, women-specific health care matters, and newborn health issues.

Kuyper's picture

Pat Boone is NOT a has-been. He's a never-was.

ysbaddaden's picture

...ooohhh...

...excuse me...


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

savannah43's picture

In deference to you, I used an ivory instead of a black. Regretting that now.
This still does not make a shitty bill good. The infighting is making me dizzy. I'm going to start a scorecard.

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

I may use white candles

But wear a black robe,

And when I have my Yuletide beard (all white)

With the silver hair at my temples and the back of my head

It makes for an interesting effect

Namely noticeable dandruff.


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

around her back yard naked under a full moon. The moon was her downfall, because a neighbor saw her and called the police. First, they took her to a hospital where she was given Thorazine, then taken to the county jail. She had long red curly hair, and she was on the chunky side. She probably put flowers in her hair, too, but I'm just speculating about that part. One of my favorite stories.

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

I was mooning the full moon last November 2nd.


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

with your beard mooning the moon. I hope your neighbors aren't too close.
Meanwhile, AARP is one of the biggest enemies of single payer. Is all suddenly forgiven? They make most of their money shilling for insurance companies. I have this strong sense that reverse psychology is in play here. You?

ron's picture

United Healthcare's Medicare advantage plans which are not an advantage at all. I dropped my membership with AARP.

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

I thought I read they were supporting Obama's plan now, and the goppies are attacking them for it.


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

ron's picture

playing both sides.

savannah43's picture

to me. He never does anything without a specific reason lurking in the background. They're up to something.

savannah43's picture

may be. But that is because of the mandatory coverage. They are in the business of selling insurance, contrary to what some people believe. They are not a lobbying group for seniors. Did you know that the mandatory coverage was a trade off for covering people with preexisting illnesses? Figures.

Last year, AARP collected $222 million in royalties from UnitedHealthcare, which provides most of the health insurance marketed under the AARP brand. That figure is almost as much as AARP collected in dues from its members.

I am not quite sure how I feel about AARP overall. I do not like the fact that AARP would offer anything related to Medicare Advantage Disadvantage. However, one can simply choose not to buy that plan. There are many other products and services AARP provides that do help and benefit its members. Because of its large membership and clout in the health industry lobby game, the positives of having its support for some type of reform far outweigh the negatives.

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

Thu, 11/05/2009 - 18:15 — savannah43
__________________________________________________________

Eh...politics is all about alliances at the moment.

Like shards of color glass in a kaleidascope.

I'd probably support nadir if he made a serious and viable attempt to restore American civil rights.

I'm still trying to figure out what the deal was between the alliance between Andrea Dworkin and jerry falwell of the moral majority.


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

Hi )0(,

Dworkin never, ever worked with Falwell. It's a myth, one among many circulating the web. Please help put it to rest.

Thanks.

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

Of course I celebrate Samhain/Halloween for the whole month of October until Hecate night on November 16th.


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

project's picture
Wow

I just went to the RGA site to see what it was and found that Amazon is giving 15% of your purchase money to the RGA. I went to the amazon site and used the contact info to tell them that I will buy nothing else from them if they support lying, ignorant, murdering, republicans.
Maybe if we all do this we could send thema message!

plastic. I always use money orders, and they stopped taking them. So I stopped buying from them.

Kate's picture

... what's RGA? Is Amazon giving them 15% of whatever you spend on anything, or only on specific products? I've clicked links here on C&L to buy certain books at Amazon where C&L codes the link so that Amazon gives a bit of money to C&L. Is this the same thing? Site monitor?

Amitola's picture

near the top with the smiling faces of Christie and McDonnell - RGA is the Repug Governor's Association.


"Egotism is the anesthetic that dulls the pain of Stupidity" - Frank Leahy

But it stops tonight!

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

Yecch,

No risk of that.

Besides it looks like Wayne Boring's work

When I prefer Joe Schuster and later Kurt Schaffenberger.


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

Tyler Durden's picture

... we should encourage them to go against the AARP.

constituent's picture

i want the GOP to tell AARP they're on the wrong side. i want the AARP (at least at this point) to voice their side and rationale. hey are you the zero hedge dude. if you are i digg your info. i read the fannie mae rental strategy article today.

Evet's picture
[Comment Deleted By Administration For Violation Of Terms Of Service]
Kreskin's picture

You bet Tyler , go after the AARP you dumb ass lunatics ! Please ! Right wing / Republican cannibalism and self sabotage ... who could ask for more ?


Insanity , it is what it is , there is no understanding it .

Liberalicious's picture

the right-wing goes after the nasty liberal NRA!

Kreskin's picture

Whoops , I should have left that part out .


Insanity , it is what it is , there is no understanding it .

Terrible's picture

did endorse the "liberal" Republican in the NY23 election. Considering that I'm surprised they haven't gone after them already.

But just wait til they start attacking NASCAR!

Liberalicious's picture

rumors like this into the RW blogs and make sure that catch on, and stand back and watch the implosion.

Terrible's picture
Terrible's picture

And check out the comments at that link! The teabagger contingent IS indeed attacking the NRA over it!! Too funny watching them implode! Thanks Rush, Malkin, Bachmann and Beck!

NoBuddy's picture

"After carefully monitoring developments in Washington and studying the various legislative proposals, AARP’s all-volunteer Board of Directors — made up of working and retired doctors, nurses, business people, and teachers — has decided to endorse the Affordable Health Care for America Act (H.R. 3962/H.R. 3961) because it delivers on key priorities we’ve been fighting for."

http://www.aarp.org/health/insurance/hcr_event/

The House could vote on this as early as tomorrow. Then it's off to the Senate. Andrew Sullivan was on the Colbert show this week, and said that the "reconciliation" process could be used to get the legislation through the Senate on 51 votes, this 60 vote thing isn't necessary. So, this placating of Snowe and Lieberman is just a bit more of the charade.

blue553's picture

Catholic Charities got 100 million in August. Just asking--bribe too, they say they support HC reform stand to make millions, yet Bishops last week had pastors use flyers to kill the bill, re: abortion, Lots of money from the Catholics in Maine too against gay marriage. When do you cross the line of "substantial" lobbying by a tax-exempt church? Personally, I trust the AARP more than than the Catholics.

bmw 528's picture

Get off my yard!

Oh and BTW, Pat Boone, go ahead and join your fellow senile morons at the 60 Pus Ass. and Free DumbJerks.


"We will find fulfillment not in the goods that we have, but in the good we can do for each other."

Robert F. Kennedy

Soulman's picture

are there a lot of Repuke ads on this website. I feel some kinda strange subliminal messaging thats goin on that totally hurts my brain.
"Well this article and every other article on this website including my own common sense tells me conservatives are evil. But those ads for Palin's new book and the RGA 2 victory sweep ad are in my face with their upbeatism that I just can't help but stare... its like the intelligence has been neutralized by the stupidity and all I'm left with is a blank stare and drool on my face."

Soulman's picture

that is a creepy video... makes me worry about the people who ask for judgement day...
Although... it'd almost be worth it to have it come and go up to pat boone and say- "haha- it was Native Americans who had it right... god really hates angry privileged white men!"

bushputz's picture

The far right has gone after
Democrats
Liberals
Gays
Minorities
The middle class
Progressives
Moderates
Independents
Moderate Republicans
Not-so moderate Republicans
Republicans who used to be considered left of Ghenghis Khan
They got away with all that - but taking on the blue-hairs?
Now THAT'S just fricken' crazy....

nemo's picture

And the Rethug dogs's fleas carry The Plague.

The bit about Medicare wasn't the only craven thing AARP did: the AARP leadership even deep-sixed a controversial poll on medicinal cannabis to curry favor with the Bush Too Regime, purely for political purposes. And now they're in Rethug gun-sights after having carried their water.

Typical, so typical.

Limp-Dick Blimpaugh's picture

Reslugs are nothing but sad, hatefilled, angry, bullying, ignorant liars, but intelligent, educated Americans can see through their over the top antics, habitual lies and acting like drunkin lunatics.

jmmartin's picture

It is ironic that the far right wingnuts attack AARP on the insurance reform. AARP chose to partner with United Healthcare in offering members supplemental health insurance. United Healthcare is usually cited by the left as the Number One Offender in taking massive profits and providing low quality health insurance benefits. How many pols who attack AARP also get campaign contributions from the health industry and United?


"Respect for the rights of others is peace." --Benito Juarez

Comments are closed on this entry