Go Home

Workin' on a tax farm

HuffPo's Investigative Fund has come up with a sharp story on the ever-expanding tax lien investment market, which you'll be surprised to know is just another way for Wall Street to gouge American taxpayers. Here are the relevant parts:

Nearly a dozen major banks and hedge funds, anticipating quick profits from homeowners who fall behind on property taxes, are quietly plowing hundreds of millions of dollars into businesses that collect the debts, tack on escalating fees and threaten to foreclose on the homes of those who fail to pay.

The Wall Street investors, which include Bank of America and JPMorgan Chase & Co., have purchased from local governments the right to collect delinquent taxes on several hundred thousand properties, many in distressed housing markets, the Huffington Post Investigative Fund has found. [...]

Some states allow the investors to tack on as much as 18 percent interest and a passel of legal fees and other charges. When property owners fail to make full payment, the investors can sue to foreclose - in some states within as little as six months. [...]

Years ago, the big banks left the buying of tax liens largely to local real estate specialists and small-time investors. These days, banks and hedge funds, stung by the failure of many speculative investments, see tax liens as a relatively safe option that can yield returns of around 7 percent.

Some banks also are packaging tax liens as securities - in a similar way to how unpaid home loans are securitized - and selling them to investors.

So broke local governments, instead of taking the time to collect taxes properly, are essentially forking over people behind on their taxes to Wall Street, where they'll have the lovely choice of paying off their taxes at usurious interest rates or losing their house to the banks that bought their tax liens. This is a great investment for banks since, even in this horrible real estate market, they can make a significant profit from selling someone's home for the relatively low price of paying off one year's worth of property taxes to the government. Either way, it's KA-CHING, KA-CHING, KA-CHING!

For those interested in learning more about how to become a financial vulture, I found this swell how-to video posted by the National Association of Tax Lien Investors. Note the sociopathic disregard for human suffering throughout it:

My favorite line comes at the 5:15 mark: "You can... purchase some great investments and take over property for a fraction of the value!"

If you're a student of history, you know that these sorts of practices aren't, in fact, new. During the time of the Roman Empire (and before and after), this sort of thing was known as tax farming:

Tax farmers (Publicani) were used to collect these taxes from the provincials. Rome, in eliminating its own burden for this process, would put the collection of taxes up for auction every few years. The Publicani would bid for the right to collect in particular regions, and pay the state in advance of this collection. These payments were, in effect, loans to the state and Rome was required to pay interest back to the Publicani. As an offset, the Publicani had the individual responsibility of converting properties and goods collected into coinage, alleviating this hardship from the treasury. In the end, the collectors would keep anything in excess of what they bid plus the interest due from the treasury; with the risk being that they might not collect as much as they originally bid.

Tax farming proved to be an incredibly profitable enterprise and served to increase the treasury, as well as line the pockets of the Publicani. However, the process was ripe with corruption and scheming. For example, with the profits collected, tax farmers could collude with local magistrates or farmers to buy large quantities of grain at low rates and hold it in reserve until times of shortage. These Publicani were also money lenders, or the bankers of the ancient world, and would lend cash to hard-pressed provincials at the exorbitant rates of 4% per month or more.

In the late 1st century BC, and after considerably more Roman expansion, Augustus essentially put an end to tax farming.

So there you have it. In the 21st Century United States, our government is allowing tax-collection practices that even the Roman Bleepin' Empire eventually outlawed because they imposed too much financial hardship on their citizens. But hey, at least we're not alone since free-market paradises such as Bangladesh have also revitalized tax farming. Hooray for freedom!

Share This Post

Link To This Post


22 Comments
ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

Diabolus est Deus Inversus

Krona's picture
heh

Perfect link.

Stupid Git's picture

What could possibly go wrong? I mean, they've been so upfront and transparent in the whole foreclosure thing I'm assuming they'll be just as reliable in this venture as well.

Seriously, what is our country not privatizing? Tax collection, war, schools, police... hell, they're even privatizing "public libraries".

We're literally pawning off our country.

Phoenix Justice's picture

Its the Shock Doctrine put into affect. They have been waiting and wanting this for a very long time. Their time has come and they are stripping the State of all its riches and getting paid to do it!


Election 2012: Be Educated! Be Active! Vote!

www.PhoenixJustice.com

Abbybwood's picture

'splains everything very clearly:

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-5153...


"The US has an army of 90,000 soldiers in Afghanistan and is spending $100bn a year, but has still been unable to defeat 20,000-25,000 Taliban who receive no pay at all." - Patrick Cockburn

Rich H's picture

was foreclosed on and had to move. Obviously he has no title to the house. Yet, BofA is billing him (and sending him to collections) for the homes upkeep (landscaping etc,,,) until they manage to sell it.

Unbelievable, except it's BofA so it's par for the course.

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

I used to work for Bank of America, originally with Republic. My retirement is largely tied to them.

But after 14.5 years I was fired; they made it sound for cause.

But coincidentally enough, I only just realized, it was after bank meeting where the president was talking about this new "paradigm" where they would be selling stock to customers as part of their business. When he asked for questions I asked how the Glass Steagall act would affect this policy (gramm/leach/bliley wouldn't be passed for another two years).

He feigned ignorance of Glass Steagall. Six months later I was gone.


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

Rich H's picture

being upstaged by someone smarter and ethical. I've seen that type before. BofA has got to be the Worst Bank Ever.

ikalbertus's picture

First of all, even if a homeowner is behind on payments, as long as there is sufficient money in the escrow account isn't the lender compelled to make the tax payment? If the escrow account is exhausted the homeowner is likely soon to be in foreclusure. If the bank that buys the tax lien is not the same as the bank that holds the note then the lien holder gets a property for practically nothing. UNLESS there is a backroom deal with the holder of the note where the lienholder makes a quick 18% interest on back taxes for some paperwork and the lender gets a quick foreclosure. OR the noteholder and the lienholder are one and the same.

Phoenix Justice's picture

A homeowner can be making payments to a mortgage company that doesn't actually hold the title, so therefore the actual title holder isn't getting the money to pay the property taxes and the homeowner doesn't even know about it until they are foreclosed on and evicted.


Election 2012: Be Educated! Be Active! Vote!

www.PhoenixJustice.com

my taxes. So, concievably, they could stop paying the taxes, I wouldn't be informed, then they could foreclose and take my home from me?

Ferrofluid's picture

and the start of that American meme of banks seizing farms and houses.

That meme lingered in the American culture up until the 80s, Dukes of Hazard anybody !?

But along came Raygunomics and the national memory cleansing.

Excelsior's picture

It's beyond me how anyone could even consider making money this way. Horrifying.


There's always free cheddar in the mousetrap, baby. - Tom Waits

Powkat's picture

they go to church on Sunday and proclaim their piety? There has to be karmic balance coming along - this kind of obscenity can't go on forever.

Edwin's picture

Real Oil Can Harry stuff. (remember him? Mighty Mouse.)

http://johnkstuff.blogspot.com/2009/04/mighty...


far left loon >.<

DamOTclese's picture

Fucking Republican traitors. This is what these rightarded piles of shit want for us, the actual workers, all while making themselves rich at our expense.

Bustednuckles's picture

These people make Al Queada look like benevolent school marms.
At least they just want to kill you outright instead of bleeding you to death like a fucking leech.


The rantings of a left wing liberal.

mhenley's picture

This article makes sound a little worse than it is. When someone is forclosed on for say a tax lien of 5000, they can add fees to that maybe 10,000. Now if they sell the property for 100,000 and you owed 50000 to the bank, the math would be 100,000 -50,000 (bank) - 5000 (lien amount) - 10,000 (fees) = 35,000 that the former owner would walk away with. The foreclosing party does not get to keep the extra money.. what they do is jack the fees up as much as possible. If you are underwater, you could still owe them money (no clue on who gets money first assume its the tax lien).

My info is based on Texas law as explained by my bf who taught real estate law courses so of course, I may have misunderstood or the law in your state could be totally different.

baffles me. People need to stick together and fight these thieves.


Republicans are liars and simply cannot be trusted.

Paul's picture

here at C&L, because it's way passed time for pitchforks and torches at the hands of the serf class. These banksters are never going to stop committing their serial crimes against society unless compelled to do so.

gtomkins's picture

Christ famously was willing to dine with even publicans and sinners, but even He would draw the line at Re-Publicans -- people so bent on evil folly that they repeat offend despite the lessons of history.

Speaking of the lessons of history, this piece neglects mention of the tax farm as practiced in France before the Revolution. That event had many causes and triggers, and attibruting it to popular outrage at the excesses and abusive practices of the ancien regime is probably overblown. But admitting that, the tax farm clearly was the most resented abusive practice of the ancien regime. People associated with the tax farm were much more likely to face revolutionary reprisals than people who were merely aristocrats or monarchists.

Cyke's picture

I need to look into this. I'm not getting it. So what prevents me from purchasing the house of my dreams. Then deliberately not pay my taxes. I acquire the lien as an investment. In time this wipes out the mortgage and I now own the home for a fraction of the original cost?

Comments are closed on this entry