Go Home

NY Daily News columnist Bill Gall offers up an interesting comparison between the way Babe Ruth rescued the game of baseball after it was found not to be trusted after the infamous Black Sox scandal of 1919.

The Chicago White Sox were pitted against the Cincinnati Reds. Every baseball fan and newspaper reporter knew the White Sox should be a cinch to win the Series. But, what nobody knew, not even the Cincinnati club, was that the Sox were already in the tank.

Well, so much happened in that Series that appeared suspicious, that tongues in the stands began to wag saying that there was something rotten in Denmark. The Sox were losing games they should not have lost!

In the end, the favored Sox lost the Series, five games to three (they played best-of-nine in those days).

The chant "fix" started to emerge and it lasted until 1920 when the rumors were finally confronted. After a lengthy investigation, members of the Sox admitted being a part of the dive, and those involved with the racketeers were banned from baseball for life. They included Shoeless Joe Jackson, then considered the greatest hitter in the game.

Was anybody going to trust this once-pure game ever again? Of course not! Baseball was forever tainted! Who, if anyone, could possibly patch up all the broken pieces? Was there such a person in this country to do it? There was. And he came into the picture just in time to not only cure baseball, but to change it. As if sent from heaven, along came a burly, confident young man named George Herman Ruth.

The Babe came on the scene to change baseball from a singles game to the more exciting and appealing home run game. While Ruth was starting as a pitcher and sometimes outfielder for the Boston Red Sox, his esteem as a player was looming larger and larger. By the time he came to the Yankees in 1920, Ruth would sell out any ballpark.

The Sultan of Swat, with his prowess on the field and his happy and ever-popular personality, was capturing the fans. And without realizing it, Babe was also winning back the fans' trust.

One man saved a wonderful American game that desperately needed saving through change and honest indulgence. I use this as just one example to show how, in our country, there is always someone who comes along at the opportune time.

President Obama, America has faith in you, and even for the little we know you, we don't see you ever letting us down. Our view of you from television is that of an intelligent individual who is honest to the core, and one who can deliver the goods. So, there you are up at the plate, Mr. President...read on...

Will Barack Obama be able to restore the public trust in our government after the disastrous tenure of George Bush? If a Babe Ruth was able to come along at the right time and restore the dignity to a sport that had been destroyed, then there is some real hope that perhaps Obama can do the same in the world of politics.

Share This Post

Link To This Post


74 Comments
ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

Baseball metaphors ain't cricket.


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

Liberal AND Proud's picture

now we're gonna equate G W Bush with Shoeless Joe Jackson.

Shoeless Joe may have tanked the Series...but he had REAL talent.

George Bush was doing his BEST. That is what is so tragic.


"Anyone that makes less than $150K in this country, has no business voting Republican."

Paraphrasing a line from Harry Caray's HOF induction speech, "No man is above the game". This was in regards to the then ongoing Pete Rose gambling scandal. This holds true with not only Rose, but also Shoeless Joe Jackson, Babe Ruth and other greats of the past and the Derek Jeters and Alex Rodriguezes of the present. These players have and do advance the game, but without the game, what are they?
I'm all for Barack Obama. I feel he has the potential to be one of our greatest presidents. Certainly, George Bush thought he was above the Constitution and our country suffered under his administration just as baseball suffered during the 1919 Black Sox scandal and Rose's own gambling problems.
So the analogy is that Obama is Babe Ruth, Okay, I can accept that. Maybe I'm just a little sore at Shoeless Joe being compared to George Bush. Or maybe it's the massive hangover I have today after all the celebrating last night.
Let's just keep things in perspective.

tyke's picture

gives way to clueless George ...

... and my lady friends assure me that Barack is truly a babe!

"Will Barack Obama be able to restore the public trust in our government after the disastrous tenure of George Bush?"

That question is capable of making this deeply unreligious man pray: "Please, God, let it be so!"

That America could produce such a man, and then recognize that he is the one to lead us, that gives me hope that we can redeem ourselves from our lazy thinking and self indulgence.

upchuck's picture

I see pictures of Coulter everywhere on this webpage. They lead to some conservative underground propaghanda site.

They're not on my screen. But hey that "underground propaganda site" isn't Politico is it? I made the mistake of going there today via RawStory. Not pretty!

That Mick Piobr's picture

appears twice on the page.

But I suppose it's okay as I'm trying to lose weight.

eccccch

Allows you to block individual scripts, effectively silencing ads. I'm Coulter-free.


"Parachutes are allowed in checked or carry-on baggage, but may not be worn in flight."

---Southwest Airlines

Serious question.

Do you make money if I click on the Ann Coulter ad?

And if so does this mean Ann Coulter pays you?

And does Ann Coulter make money if I click on the ad?

Why for the love of God would ANYONE click on an Ann Coulter ad?

ricky's picture

"I mean Romney is the most conservative on illegal immigration and I don't think Ronald Reagan could get elected in California today."
Ann "Clipped" Coulter

To make money for Crooks and Liars. And if it costs Ann Coulter money even better.

That's all.

SKdeA_Miss1929's picture

They pop up randomly, usually you can choose keywords or geographic match to the IP address of the viewer or both.

However, it is a service that her handlers or she has to pay for advertising, so cover your eyes, click through, then use the back button!

enchanting505's picture

It is a very masterful depiction of the White Sox (Black Sox) scandal. An awesome period piece on par with The Sting.

ConcernedCanuck's picture

is earned. Not blindly given. I hope he does what he said he would in order to get elected. Given the economic climate, he will have to be Houdini to restore public trust. Doesn't matter who is Prez, the next few years are going to be extremely painful.

Shadowgm's picture

... what Obama does/doesn't do and the moments where we find out the true depths of Bush's perfidy.

ConcernedCanuck's picture

Why? I'm confused, let's put it that way. Every Prez in the US, has a mass media and supporter frenzy of "what they will do". How they will implement their ideas, etc. I thought the US Prez couldn't even introduce legislature? Am I wrong? Then who exactly is going to do his bidding? CONgress has their own ideals. Without them, there really isn't a Prez because nothing would be made into law. So I guess what I'd like to know is, how is it that Americans as a whole feel like the election of a new Prez is going to really make much difference, unless there has been elections of new CONgress critters? Last time I looked, most are the same people that have been in there since Moses was still alive.

ricky's picture

you guys kept the queen. Go ahead and keep the name.
And the US did not start until roughly 4800 in creation years.
Moses was gone before Jesus 2009 years ago and God dosn't make us to last as long anymore, so no, the Droolin Bonzos over in the Dome haven't been around since Moses. The Burnin Bush and George Bush are no relation.


"I mean Romney is the most conservative on illegal immigration and I don't think Ronald Reagan could get elected in California today."
Ann "Clipped" Coulter

Shadowgm's picture

We need to know that our elected leaders can do the right thing. The 'it's okay to break some laws to do x' argument is a Republican fiction that was never part of my Catholic upbringing.

At the same time, just like Babe Ruth or any other player, we're going to see our share of whiffs and strikeouts. Teams play on regardless, knowing that the season is more than a single game.

But right now, I feel like Obama just hit a walk-off grand slam.

ricky's picture

Bad analogy.

The Black Sox were players and they were good. They took bribes to play bad.

Bush was inb the owners box, picking his nose and trading Sammy Sosa to those same named Sox.


"I mean Romney is the most conservative on illegal immigration and I don't think Ronald Reagan could get elected in California today."
Ann "Clipped" Coulter

ron's picture

it's what we do to make our country a better place.

ConcernedCanuck's picture

we better all hope the rich people were listening to Prez Obama's speech as well. Unless it's a violent upheavel, 95% of a nation can attempt to change, but if that top of the ladder won't, nothing will.

fastfeat's picture

I'm getting my bat out and practicing my swing...


"Parachutes are allowed in checked or carry-on baggage, but may not be worn in flight."

---Southwest Airlines

ConcernedCanuck's picture

If things keep going the way they are, I suspect bats will be useful. Banks, auto industry, and basically everyone, is already floating their begging in the media once again.

fastfeat's picture

.


"Parachutes are allowed in checked or carry-on baggage, but may not be worn in flight."

---Southwest Airlines

ConcernedCanuck's picture

*went over my head*....I'm having a very bad day

Gotta run to piss in a cup...


"Parachutes are allowed in checked or carry-on baggage, but may not be worn in flight."

---Southwest Airlines

ConcernedCanuck's picture

Doubt it, but thanks for the thought before running to do your business.

Hechicera's picture

1 . Mom, nice mom from Kansas no less, check.

2. Baseball, he's the second coming of Babe Ruth, check.

I now await his (or his wife's) famous apple pie recipe, for the complete trifecta!

Or, maybe I just want pie.

ricky's picture

fat and ugly. So was Ms. Ruth and if you believe Billy Crystal, she guarded his legacy like Nancy does Ronnie Rayguns.


"I mean Romney is the most conservative on illegal immigration and I don't think Ronald Reagan could get elected in California today."
Ann "Clipped" Coulter

fastfeat's picture

and boozed heavily but was still able to 'getter done'...


"Parachutes are allowed in checked or carry-on baggage, but may not be worn in flight."

---Southwest Airlines

Shadowgm's picture

... it's a sure bet it won't be something copied off of the Food Network website by an unpaid intern.

Hechicera's picture
Ha.

Yes. That was a good one.

Samson-'s picture

In the first hours of his presidency, President Obama directed an immediate halt to the Bush administration’s military commissions system for prosecuting detainees at the detention center at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.

that move was babe(ruth)-alicious.

that was a fucking great opening move to help restore this guy's trust...

ricky's picture

We need that military commissions system when they send George and Dick down to GITMO, don't we? I am confused.


"I mean Romney is the most conservative on illegal immigration and I don't think Ronald Reagan could get elected in California today."
Ann "Clipped" Coulter

SKdeA_Miss1929's picture

to prosecute them for war crimes, also we can impeach for internal stuff, and I don't think we'll need the MCA for that either.

since you mentioned it first, where will obama move these prisoners to? and where are the prisoners we sent to other countrys ? and will they allso be moved? and to where?

dosido's picture

when do we get to ban anyone from the bush admin from participating in public "service" ever again?

Savagewinston's picture

Ban the Coulters and Rushes and the Billos from going anywhere near a mic, computer and/or TV camera ever again..

My apologies for going off-topic, but I couldn't resist..

ohkay's picture

"...an intelligent individual who is honest to the core, and one who can deliver the goods."

If we can't make these qualities an absolutely required qualification for all future presidents, we deserve more like George Bush and Dick Cheney.

SKdeA_Miss1929's picture

but if a baseball analogy makes it interesting to people who find politics boring, it's OK by me.

But this is our country and the world we're talking about, not a GAME.

Shadowgm's picture

... sports used to teach the principles of good sportsmanship and the importance of doing one's best. You don't shine your coach on and then say, "Hey, I did what I thought was right!"

Truth_Critic's picture

The "Cincinnati Reds" are linked in more ways then one I'm afraid...


Study the symptoms not the virus...

Sec_Humanist's picture

Why the reference to what is essentially a children's game in order to provide a framework for a serious question? The Popular Media can only deal with very simplistic descriptions and analyses of national and world events and, not surprisingly, gravitate toward 30 second sound bites, one-liners and "what is hot". All reflect an adolescent perspective. The truth of the matter is that it is Congress and not the President who are the representatives of the people and it is they and not the individual who occupies the White House who should be "righting the ship" after the disastrous and criminal Bush administration. Unfortunately, they have abdicated their constitutional responsibilities and have become indifferent, complacent and likely corrupt in many cases. The fawning over the new President and the expectation that he and he alone will "make things right again" is a return to the age-old tendency of primates to look to a father figure. The priest, the shaman, the feudal lord, the king, the saviour . . . It's more a religious delusion in secular form and an unsettling desire to return to the European modle of the monarchy and the ever-present courtiers/aristocrats/corporatists. That is, it's a shift of power from the citizens and their representatives to a small group of elites. "Hope" or "Change" isn't the solution. A strong congress working within the framework of the constitution is the more enlightened way. Besides, almost anything that Obama can do Congress could do also.


"Secular humanism -- a fearless, realistic world view replete with doubt and scepticism that attempts to attain an unachievable state of equilibrium between and among the human qualities of reason, intuition, imagination, memory, ethics and common sense.

Shadowgm's picture

A game which has rules, umpires, team managers, and sportscasters/color commentary has absolutely nothing to do with our political reality that has laws, judges, elected officials, and the media?

And Congress can't sign its own laws. They can, if sufficiently motivated, overturn a veto.

Hechicera's picture

You're right. Popular Media has ever not been dumbed own? Yes, congress has to do the heavy lifting here.

Images still have use, and metaphorical historical figures can convey meaning and power quickly. Rituals provide comfort, but also can quickly give us a framework and place to start. This analogy simply gives Obama one more card to play in his dominance game with Congress. We are still primates with complex dominance rituals. A team still works best with a nominal leader.

If you worry about religious intersection with the start of a presidency, the whole inauguration ritual looked like an elaborate religious ritual. Whether you believe it was or not, we as a species still like our rituals. They matter to us somewhere in our wiring. Can you not say that most of the world now perceives Obama as more legitimate as the President now he completed the appropriate complex ritual with its religious overtones?

Shadowgm's picture

... that even in baseball, George W. Bush made a muddle of things, not only trading away Sammy Sosa, but voting against other team owners in instituting the current playoff/wildcard system.

Bush insisted that history would prove him right.

Truth_Critic's picture

Study the symptoms not the virus...

Cjohnson's picture

Utterly unrelated to the article itself, but why am I seeing ads for Ann Coulter, of all people, here on C&L?

tubesox's picture

that the site has no control over

these guys really have to work on their programming skills

ive been to wingnut sites and the same company has ads for progessive authors pop up

ricky's picture

to put her on browsers which are Israeli or porn friendly.


"I mean Romney is the most conservative on illegal immigration and I don't think Ronald Reagan could get elected in California today."
Ann "Clipped" Coulter

tubesox's picture

dont quit your day job

ricky's picture

Did anyone see where Tubesox left my day job? I know its gotta be around here somewhere.


"I mean Romney is the most conservative on illegal immigration and I don't think Ronald Reagan could get elected in California today."
Ann "Clipped" Coulter

tubesox's picture

there are baseball scholars who til today still argue that the sox really didnt throw the series

in fact, the reds won more games during the season then the sox did...and caminski was known for abusing his players, to the point that they may very well have run out of steam by series time

furthermore, the babe only saved the game, because the press, who was merciless in dealing with the sox, gave the babe a total pass

refusing to report on his womanizing, neglecting to tell anyone about his "trick bat" (the rule against corking a bat came about because of the babe)

let us hope the press does not give obama a pass if he effs up...that kinda stuff helped lead us into an immoral and illegal war

woody's picture

There was probably not a vice to which the Babe did NOT invest his substantial energies.

The analogy is labored, at best. Good catch...

ricky's picture

I hope Mr. O has a bat corked up to its ass.


"I mean Romney is the most conservative on illegal immigration and I don't think Ronald Reagan could get elected in California today."
Ann "Clipped" Coulter

woody's picture

iirc

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

Is that the sound of a hanging noose tightening?


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

ConcernedCanuck's picture

in this picture, what I think it is? Caught on camera again, Bush drinking!
http://www.thedailybeast.com/blogs-and-storie...

Shadowgm's picture

His daughter sitting in his lap? Ewwwwwww.

Seriously, that could be anything from a diet coke to an iced tea, but it's definitely being served in a bar glass.

ricky's picture

was able to give him a cigar before he left.


"I mean Romney is the most conservative on illegal immigration and I don't think Ronald Reagan could get elected in California today."
Ann "Clipped" Coulter

More my speed:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=52scMVXF2mc

And I'll cry if I want to.


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

John Amato's picture
Hi

I got a bad cold so I'm out of it today, but I'm not analyzing every detail, but saying we need a Babe Ruth hitter to get us our of this mess....
The ads come and go...

ConcernedCanuck's picture

you had a blast John! Hope you feel better.

ricky's picture

as to point out Josh Gibson hit more home runs and was considered one crazy.... Well at least not until now.


"I mean Romney is the most conservative on illegal immigration and I don't think Ronald Reagan could get elected in California today."
Ann "Clipped" Coulter

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

I'm coming down with something. Texas weather's gone haywire the past month. It jumps between lows in the 20's, highs in the 70's. Tommorrow will be between 35-80.


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

ricky's picture

"I mean Romney is the most conservative on illegal immigration and I don't think Ronald Reagan could get elected in California today."
Ann "Clipped" Coulter

tekjannsen76's picture

Good lord what's wrong with people. How can this even be remotely considered anintelligent thought or reflection? There is so much that had to happen for the Babe to make baseball relevant again and some of that effort was mirrored by the last administration. Some of the commentors have touched upon the many vices that Ruth had. They are right, these were glossed over. I am not positive about the corked bat but sure, maybe that happened and that only adds to the fact that Ruth was a figment of the press's imagination and not who really existed. Sounds familiar doesn't it? Jesus anyone? Along with rule changes that did make for more offense in the game the press took it upon themselves to invent a persona for the "jolly big man" that essentially did not exist. These were people that i guess cared about the game (more their livelihood) and used this imagery to help play up a game that had been sorely tarnished by the scandal. Not unlike the hero myths we are accustomed to from the past or even the endless stories recounted as fact about many if not all of our saints and other holy individuals of note.

Is this what you want for the President? Again this was actually attempted and is still being attempted by the folks who just left the office. They look at the so called positives from his administration and try to construct a legacy for the future that other's might deem a lot more successful than we would recall. Obama will need his failures and struggles visible and we pray that they are not as significant as the past President's. People need to stop attaching such reverance to this post. It calls for a healthy amount of respect already, the rest is earned.

Lastly, a lot of people had to reinvest in the game back when Ruth was around. They had to put their faith in the game, that it was worth the devotion of their time. They made Ruth. While they trumpeted some of the less than honest accounts of his image, they also rebuilt the game through their dedication. This is the task ahead of America. The staggering image I have of the last year is not of the man, but the movement. He may have inspired it, but it was built as he so clearly said on the backs of Americans who believed what he believes and can only continue to exist with the assistance of everyday Americans. It's all of your responsibility to restore the lost lustre and respect for America that has been lost not just one man. He can help lay the groundwork but ultimately whether you succeed or fail is up to all of you.

22dividedby7's picture

I think Ty Cobb or Tris Speaker would disagree with that assessment.
I know I do.
Though all 3 do share one thing in common, fixed games in 1919.

The Cobb-Speaker Scandal.
http://www.questia.com/googleScholar.qst?docI...

Career stats-
Tris Speaker:
http://www.baseball-reference.com/s/speaktr01...

Ty Cobb:
http://www.baseball-reference.com/c/cobbty01....

Joe Jackson:
http://www.baseball-reference.com/j/jacksjo01...

Auximinus's picture

Joe Jackson played that series by the book. He was framed. They destroyed his career. It's one of the greatest travesties in baseball history.

Andy K's picture

In the bottom of the 4th inning of game 1, the Reds pitcher hit a ball to left that Jackson misplayed into a 2 RBI triple. There were a few other triples hit to left field by the Reds in the series (7 triples, total, for Cincy in the Series). It was said of Jackson's glove that it was the place, "where triples go to die." Must have been usin' the wrong glove in that Series.

And the fact that he hit terribly in the 5 losses, with only 1 RBI- the solo homer in game 8, when the Reds already led 5-0- only lends creedence to the case against Jackson.

But, I've gotta say that if I were in the shoes of Jackson, Cicotte, and the other five fellas in on the fix (Buck "The Ginger Kid" Weaver should have his name cleared, imo), the money- and a chance to piss off Charlie Comiskey- would have been mighty tempting.

Andy K's picture

The Reds hit 2 triples to left in the Series, the second being in the bottom of the 4th in game 2, by the shorstop, Kopf, scoring 1 run. That's 3 runs right there (when you count the 2 from above) in the two games that no one argues were being thrown.

appnzllr's picture

And baseball ruined the sport with the strike and with steroids.

Comments are closed on this entry