mccain_keating5_1705c.JPG
Back in 1999, John McCain acknowledged his role in the 1980's Keating Five savings and loan scandal that rightly stained his career. "The fact is," he said, "it was the wrong thing to do, and it will be on my tombstone and deservedly so." But again facing withering criticism as a second financial crisis grips the United States, his campaign today instead claimed McCain's intervention 20 years ago with federal regulators on behalf of future convicted felon Charles Keating was merely "a political smear job."

As AmericaBlog and Politico reported, the campaign deployed McCain's lawyer John Dowd to rewrite history on his client's behalf during a conference call Monday:

McCain lawyer John Dowd described McCain's "former relationship with Charles Keating as 'social friends,'" and called the situation a "classic political smear job on John."

Sadly for McCain, Dowd's yarn matches neither the facts nor McCain's self-proclaimed resurrection as a reformer in the wake of his near-death experience in the Keating Five imbroglio.

Earlier this year, the Boston Globe summarized McCain's close relationship with Keating and his decision to intervene with federal regulators on his behalf:

McCain met Keating in 1982, during McCain's successful run for Congress, and soon began accepting offers from Keating to fly McCain's family on a corporate plane to Keating's house in the Bahamas. McCain did not pay for most of the trips until years later, when the matter became public.

Keating, meanwhile, complained regularly to McCain that a proposed regulation would hurt his business. Known as the "direct investment" rule, it limited the amount that savings-and-loan institutions could invest from their assets. In 1985, after having "heard frequently from Charlie on the matter," McCain decided that Keating's complaints "were sound enough to warrant our assistance." He cosponsored a resolution sought by Keating, but it failed to postpone the regulation, McCain wrote in his autobiography.

By then, Keating was one of McCain's most important benefactors; McCain received $112,000 in campaign donations from Keating and his Lincoln associates, mostly between 1982 and 1986.

It was in April 1987 that McCain fatefully joined four other senators in meeting with Edwin Gray, chairman of the Federal Home Loan Bank Board in Washington. After that meeting, Gray told his associate William K. Black that he was "very upset" that the senators were trying to pressure him.

Ultimately, a Senate ethics panel agreed with that assessment. California Democrat Alan Cranston was censured for "an impermissible pattern of conduct," while Senators DeConcini (D-AZ) and Riegle (D-MI) were criticized for actions which "gave the appearance of being improper." As for McCain, he and John Glenn (D-OH) were admonished for exercising "poor judgment."

McCain, who had told the Ethics Committee that his role in support of Keating was "to help constituents in a proper fashion," reacted to the panel's findings in 1991, "I am, of course, relieved that I have been exonerated."

And so it was that John McCain survived the Keating Five and S&L scandals with his career, if not his reputation, intact. As the New York Times recounted this past February:

When Lincoln went bankrupt in 1989 - one of the biggest collapses of the savings and loan crisis, costing taxpayers $3.4 billion - the Keating Five became infamous. The scandal sent Mr. Keating to prison and ended the careers of three senators, who were rebuked by the Senate Ethics Committee in 1991 for intervening. Mr. McCain, who had been a less aggressive advocate for Mr. Keating than the others, was reprimanded only for "poor judgment" and was re-elected the next year.

Some people involved think Mr. McCain got off too lightly. William Black, one of the banking regulators the senator met with, argued that Mrs. McCain's investment with Mr. Keating created an obvious conflict of interest for her husband. (Mr. McCain had said a prenuptial agreement divided the couple's assets.) He should not be able to "put this behind him," Mr. Black said. "It sullied his integrity."

For his part, John McCain has acknowledged the blight on his record, if not his sense of his own honor. As Senator McCain put it in December 1999, the taint of his Keating Five role is permanent:

"The fact is, it was the wrong thing to do, and it will be on my tombstone and deservedly so."

But McCain's seemingly humble admission of guilt could not erase the temper tantrums the Arizona Senator displayed at the height of the crisis. As has been documented so many times since, John McCain in 1989 exploded at the press when it dared to questioned his behavior.

While McCain was ultimately admonished by a Senate ethics panel only for "poor judgment," his behavior in response to the white hot press spotlight raises troubling questions about his fitness to lead. As the Arizona Republic recalled in March 2007:

On Oct. 8, 1989, The Arizona Republic revealed that McCain's wife and her father had invested $359,100 in a Keating shopping center in April 1986, a year before McCain met with the regulators.

The paper also reported that the McCains, sometimes accompanied by their daughter and baby-sitter, had made at least nine trips at Keating's expense, sometimes aboard the American Continental jet. Three of the trips were made during vacations to Keating's opulent Bahamas retreat at Cat Cay.

McCain also did not pay Keating for some of the trips until years after they were taken, after he learned that Keating was in trouble over Lincoln. Total cost: $13,433.

When the story broke, McCain did nothing to help himself.

"You're a liar," McCain said when a Republic reporter asked him about the business relationship between his wife and Keating.

"That's the spouse's involvement, you idiot," McCain said later in the same conversation. "You do understand English, don't you?"

He also belittled reporters when they asked about his wife's ties to Keating.

"It's up to you to find that out, kids."

Ultimately, the paper ran the story. After it broke, McCain held a news conference with his rage in check and calmly answered questions for 90 minutes. (In a preview of the 2008 campaign, McCain's defense was that his wife's finances - and extreme wealth - were separate from his own.)

But McCain's response also revealed another disturbing pattern that continues to this day. After launching a furious tirade against the media, McCain sought to forgiveness after the fact. As the Boston Globe described the episode:

When reporters questioned the investment, John McCain wrote in his autobiography, he "shouted at them, cursed them, and eventually slammed the phone down on them. It was ridiculously immature behavior."

In that same 2002 book, McCain pondered, "I don't know how (The Republic journalists) would have reported the story had I been more civil and understanding or just more of a professional during the interview."

Twenty years later, Americans are watching history repeat itself. John McCain's closest aides and advisors, including campaign manager Rick Davis, chief of staff Mark Buse and transition manager William Timmons, garnered huge paydays from their work on behalf of failed Wall Street firms, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. And with his pendulum-like response to the financial meltdown and his bitter attacks against Barack Obama, John McCain is again lashing out at those rightly criticizing his poor judgment.

The truth, the old saying goes, will set you free. But not if you're John McCain. Then it's just called "a smear."



Login or Register to post comments.

69 comments

I can't say I'm hopeful that Brokaw will bring this up unless he refers to it as a smear himself. I hope Obama's got his game on tomorrow night--we could be in for a sandbagging.

Tuesday's New York Times features a profile of Tom Brokaw ahead of the October 7 presidential debate being hosted by the veteran NBC newsman. The Times reveals that Brokaw has "played a pivotal role out of public view, both within NBC and in its dealings with the campaign of John McCain in particular."

The story's on HuffPo:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/09/30/tom-...

They kill me with this revisionist history.

Yeah I might feel bad for him... if he wasn't such a bag about being a maverick and honorable... neither of which he is. He's a fucktard and this is all about what goes around, comes around. People need to know his part in this scandal and if he chooses to run regardless, then he and his campaign need to STFU about slagging Obama. Plain and simple... if you dish it out, you'd better be able to take it coming back at you!

Forget the Keating Five for a second. Why isn't Obama responding to the "Bill Ayers" attacks from Palin with a good schooling about Palin's own ties to the Alaskan Independence Party who's mission is "the complete repatriation of the public lands, held by the federal government, to the state and people of Alaska".

Isn't that unpatriotic and treasonous?

Because she's irrelevant at this point, having already peaked as a threat. The goal now is to wound McCain prior to the next debate.

Good answer!

However, if they want to take a shot at her later, this is more than fair game, being factual and all.

there's still plenty of October left.

They're pouring history on me and I'm melting....make them take the nasty history away.

John McCain in his interpretation of the Wicked Witch of the West

McCain is going to go down in history as an asshole that was heroic.

Even his "heroism" is in question, IMO. He lost several planes during his military career. The only act of heroism and bravery on his part was when he reportedly refused to be sent home early from captivity.

Other than that, he's a incompetent scumbag.

I wonder if anyone else confirms this "refuse to be sent home" story?
Wouldn't he,on his return, be arrested and tried for treason "giving aid and comfort to the enemy" by his written confessions and condemnation of America while a POW?
Was the demand for the release of all of the camp's prisoners made by his father Commander? Was it refused by the captors during negotiations?
Isn't the captor always in charge of where a prisoner goes?
I don't believe McHero would have had any choice in the matter.
It smells fishy!

It's time to purge the greed, the lies, the sludge, the corrupt out of our America.

Let's get busy

I thought Obama shouldn't bring up Keating 5 because McCain's defense ("I learned a big lesson and I've changed") would take too many news cycles to plow through. But McCain's campaign is too inept to even use his own dodge and is instead adding another easily-provable lie to the big pile.

I wouldn't have believed it, but it's actually possible to make a lie transparent enough for the media to catch.

man talk about out of sync with REALITY.

AP - Mon Oct 6

WASHINGTON - Three days after providing a $700 billion bailout for Wall Street, Congress is holding its first hearing into what caused the nation's financial markets to collapse last month.

Last month? Uhh hello? Did you guys notice anything unusual today?

Oh man

With the Repukes, even if it's true it's a smear when it is against them. But stating that Obama hangs with terrorist when Ayers was never convicted of such is ok.
That being said, wouldn't Ayers have a case for a libel suit against Palin if there was no conviction.

Republicans think they are immune to facts and can spew anything if they think it will help them win in the court of public opinion (and elsewhere.) Republicans are the first to scream that their first amendment rights are being violated, but are also the first to deny those rights to anyone and everyone else and label valid criticism as "smear" tactics.

They are a sad, pathetic bunch of immature, self-serving bloviators.

A political smear on himself by himself? Now that one's a good ones for the Annals of Psychiatric Disease.

This gang of desperados don't know if they're coming or going....with Troopergate about to blow up in their faces at week's end....and McCain now lawyering up due to blowback between the parallels of Keating 5 and his personal senate complicity with the deregulation movement which landed us in our current economic crisis, I think McCain's heading for a full-blown, very ugly nervous breakdown.

My predication is that his melanoma has metastasized sufficiently into his brain stem and what we're seeing in terms of instability every day happens to be the evidence of this progressed disease.

RELEASE THE MEDICAL RECORDS NOW!

RELEASE CINDY'S TAX RETURNS NOW SO WE CAN SEE HOW CHARLES KEATING CONTINUES TO FACTOR INTO THIS ECONOMIC DEBACLE. I SUSPECT THAT IT'S THE VERY SAME 'CAST OF THUGS AND CHARACTERS' AT THE BOTTOM OF THIS STINKING CORPSE CALLED WALL STREET.

when, on the same evidence, you can deduce corruption or malevolence.

McC(umst)ain's dirty, through & through.

Has always been. Always will be.

Unprincipled, bullying, dishonorable.

Tomorrow evening we will either see:
1) a heavily and obviously sedated McCain who can't talk his way out of a paper bag - or -

2)a man on the verge of a nervous breakdown - whose fuse will be ignited on stage.

Either way - McCain will lose the debate - again!

Once he loses this one, his "toilet bowl express" will have swirled for the second time and find itself heading south for good.

if he thought he could campaign for the presidency and avoid the spotlight on his role as one of the Keating Five.

Much could be forgiven McCain if he had truly been regretful realizing that his efforts cost millions their life savings and he changed his ways. He says he did, but he voted time and time again to further deregulate the banks and financial institutions so that no one was watching or prosecuting their criminal activity. This is like deja vu. And on top of everything else, he's a terrible whiner, isn't he?

Karma is a funny thing, isn't it? Just when you think you've pulled one over on karma, it bites you in the behind. How timely karma placed this gift on Obama's political plate - to be used as a parallel to what's transpiring today as this country heads into self-destruction.

As they say: Karma's a b*tch, isn't it, Johnny Boy?

I heard a recording today online of McPerv's seedy laugh over and over as he boasted about Miss "winkie" Hoodwink's ability to defraud the public. Don't know about anyone else but that winky, sleazy stuff she stooped low enough to plaster on the american public made her look like a cheap hooker from the south side of Seedyland....then McLecher's sleazy laugh....compounded the impression as either pimp and prostitute or something more incestuous....ewwww......there is something very unsavory and perverse when you look at the two of them together, isn't there?

Jesus. I'm fighting my way through this blog site.

My comment:

Vote for Dems, if you wish. They are going to screw you.

And the $15 thousand dollars Keating paid for McCain's vacations in the Bahamas was just play money?

Submitted for your consideration: McCain in the membrane goes insane.

Please, by all means let's stop the smearing and get back to talking about the important topics, like blowjobs.

Blowjobs got us into a very SEVERE problem of TRILLIONS of dollars in SURPLUS. It took REPUBLICANS hard work, planning, and fraud to eliminate that unacceptable condition.

REPUBLICANS are the terrorists, hiding in one of their many multi-million dollar homes they completely lost track of. Not in a cave or spiderhole.

The biggest blow job (as in totally blowing it) has been on the American people during the reign of King George and his Cohort, Darth Cheney.

Let's not forget about Todd's card-carrying membership in the Alaska Secessionist Movement and Sarah's video message delivered to this group's annual meeting in 2006 saying "keep up the good work". Secessionists?? Anti-US Government type secessionists?

Some nerve to suggest that a 7 year old palled around with a terrorist during the vietnam war when everyone would be considered a terrorist by their anti-Vietnam war views.....interesting how they both seem "hell bent" on destroying themselves by mentioning the very thing for which the people have prima facie evidence of them being involved in....very self-sabotaging if you ask me.

Blowjobs have also cost us thousands of American lives and hundreds of thousands of Iraqi lives, thanks to Bill Clinton.

Say it ain't so Joe! Trying to tie Bill Clinton in, there you go again, doggone it, dude! Get your head out of a decade ago and deal with reality, please.

If only Grandpa McCain could get a blowjob, then maybe he'd lighten up a bit. Of course, that would be if there is a woman on Earth who would touch him.

It wasn't Bill Clinton that was to blame. The blame goes to the mentally challenged who allowed the sanctimonious reichwingnut extremists to focus on that so much we got a total moron and his fascist running mate in the white house the next eight years. I personally will not begrudge a blowjob although, if I were POTUS I could get something better than Monica.

Pffft! All I know is that this country was in far better shape for the eight years than The Clenus was in office than it was for the 12 before and the 8 after. BLOW JOBS FOR ALL, if that's the magic wand (pun intended).

Cripes, but people can't see past their own repressed little fears, can they? Anybody who is still obsessing over The Clenus and Monica's talents probably needs a knob-polishing or muffin-buttering of their own.

I can't believe it's not butter!

According to National Enquirer she had an affair with her husband's business partner. Maybe she should get laid now instead of acting so stupid. Tina Fey is more qualified than she is and that is a testament to John McSame and his mental facilities. Cancer and senility are eating him up.

McCain is so mavericky he tells the truth about himself and then turns around and calls the truth a "smear job"

Paraphrasing Gollum and the Daily show

We loves the truth
We hates the truth
loves the truth
hates the truth

McCain's schizoid persona and campaign is scrambling around so much that they don't know what they're saying.....their total instability is acutely obvious.

Now he says he's repentent for the Keating Five?? Would that be so that the people go easy on him for his deregulation of Wall Street? I'd say that a cadre of the best lawyers in the country can't save McKeating from the avalanche of personal involvement in this crisis which is about to fall upon his chrome dome right now.

It'd be hell to be Mr. John McCain right now! He's damned if he does/damned if he doesn't.

Keating 5 has put him into a corner from which there is absolutely NO exit.

The Bush/McCain/GOP economy:

NBC News tonight says the stock market has wiped out the gains from the past decade but the silver lining is gas is down to $350 gallon! That's oughly 3 x what is was during the Clinton years.

With "silver linings" like that who needs bad news?

Obama doesn't need to counter McCain's nasty campaign tactics with more sleaziness. Instead, it would be a better strategy to save it all for the next debate and expose his position on all this shit then and there while everyone is watching. McCain deserves nothing less.

They can try to revise history all they want but the archives are there with what was being written at the time. Take a look at this article about the connection of McSame to the scandal written in 1989.

http://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/1989-11-29/new....

When will the Dems learn the rules of the game? It's only a smear if they do it. If the Cons do it, it's just informing the public. Geez!!

Why get all wrapped up in historical facts, when you can just change them as you please?

You want to see Crash McCain lose it. Bring up the LATimes story about his plane crashes and the Rolling Stone story about his military record. http://www.latimes.com/news/politics/la-na-av...
http://www.rollingstone.com/news/coverstory/m...
Obama should demand that McCain release his military records to clear up the issues raised by these articles.

stipulation that one must be batshit crazy to run for office? For crying out loud, if this doesn't take the cake, I don't know what the hell does.

It's good to see that some of the Keating 5 have come over to support Obama:

http://blogs.abcnews.com/politicalpunch/2008/...

"You don't get introduced by John Glenn every day," Bruce Springsteen said yesterday at an Obama get-out-the-vote rally at Ohio State University, as reported by the Columbus Dispatch.

Former Sen. John Glenn, D-Ohio, was -- along with Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz. -- one of the Keating Five, the handful of senators who met with federal regulators to urge them to ease up on the savings and loan owned by contributor Charles Keating.

Hours after Glenn introduced the Boss at the Obama rally, the Obama campaign launched a campaign attacking McCain for his Keating Five activities. They made no mention of Mr. Glenn.

other than McSame are not running for POTUS and lying their asses off. McSame is lying and still doing harm to the economy with his Phil Gramm economic philosophy. We as a nation even forgave Richard Nixon before he died. If someone pays the price for their wrongdoing, you forgive them. If they refuse to admit they were wrong and continue the same behavior, you do not forgive them or trust them in any fashion.

http://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/1989-11-29/new...

Obama doesn't mind a little support from Keating 5 members.
They are A-OK in his book.
Bruce Springsteen hates Keating 5 members, except the ones that are his friends.

Sarah Palin is that you?

Second straight time i've gone to a new thread and found the comments closed?

Is this a glitch or a feature?

[We built that in just for you-Sitemonitor]

That's "my" senator from Arizona. He is nothing if not an opportunist. He is banking on the hunch that Americans don't care about "ancient" history and on the fact that the next debate moderator is a partisan Republican short on ethics.

Hello Is this one the McCain residences? No? But you know him right? Well this is Westside Memorials calling. Could you let him know that his tombstone is ready for pickup.

Tell me it ain't so Joe....there you go again changing your mind....I swear you change your mind about as often as your change your Depends, McSenile!

Here's a link to info on their involvement:
http://www.thenation.com/blogs/campaignmatter...

US Federal Reserve , and claim to authorities afterwards that it's all just a "smear"............

doggone it - those material facts, aka "truth", just keeps stacking up against her. Here's more which confirms her attendance at their meeting in 1994. Also confirmation that Todd was a card-carrying member until 2002...Good look with your terrorist meme, sarah!

http://blogs.abcnews.com/politicalpunch/2008/...

Actually, I have always wondered about the "refused to be released early from captivity" thing. How is that supposed to work? The big guy opens the door and says "follow me" and you argue with him until he reassures you that you are just going to be tortured, not released?

The military did its best to spin what was a catastrophic disaster (the capture of the privileged son of the leader of our forces in Vietnam) into as much of a propaganda victory as possible. That propaganda has endured to this day in the shape of McCain's political career. There is no doubt that he was patriotic, risked his life and suffered terribly in captivity. All of the other stuff seems a bit, um, contrived in a "Reader's Digest" sort of way. We have tapes of the guy reading anti-American propaganda, after all. Wouldn't it have been better for him to accept release (which I doubt even was offered) than to help the enemy's propaganda machine to that extent?

Of course, to even question the war stories is to bring on wrath parallel to that brought down upon those who doubt Mary's virginity.

"Back in 1999, John McCain acknowledged his role in the 1980's Keating Five savings and loan scandal that rightly stained his career. "The fact is," he said, "it was the wrong thing to do, and it will be on my tombstone and deservedly so." But again facing withering criticism as a second financial crisis grips the United States, his campaign today instead claimed..."

Yeah, but you've got it all wrong. The above soul searching quotes were from McSame's evil twin, Straight Talk McCain. Don't expect to see him again until after the election, if ever.

"It's a wrong appearance when a group of senators appear in a meeting with a group of regulators because it conveys the impression of undue and improper influence." "I was judged eventually, after three years, of using, quote, poor judgment, and I agree with that assessment."
--John McCain

So McCain admits that it was wrong and that he used poor judgment, but it's a smear? How is bringing up facts and a case that directly relate to the current financial crisis and the perils of deregulation a smear?

No one made McCain do wrong back then; no one made him champion deregulation for all those years; and no one made him pick Phil Gramm, the king of deregulation to be his chief economic advisor. So much for taking responsibility, but look at whose footsteps he's trying to follow. No ethics whatsover.

All Palin does in her smear campaign against Obama is repeat the same script in every city about Obama and Ayers. WORD FOR WORD! Does this woman have a mind of her own in this campaign

Here's a deal for the McCain campaign. Stop trying to smear Obama, and he'll stop bringing up the Keating 5.

What's that you say? Then you'd have to run on your plans for the economy and you'd surely lose?

Well, them's the breaks. Your choice.

Obama has my vote if during the next debate he knocks the old man over, drops his drawers, straddles the geezers face and says, "Old Man, I'm about to do to you what you and your party have done to the country for the last 30 years."
Then take a healthy shit on gramps face.
For an encore Obama then gives McShitty a mookie scoot for the ages.

{Deleted, Disgusting. SiteMonitor}

The difference between Ayers & Keating was, Ayers protested to save lives and became a terrorist, while Keating took the life savings of 21,000 people (mostly seniors). To me this is terrorism because of the fear and doubt these old folks were placed in for the rest of their lives. But alas...John McCain is a hero.
Only in America.

by the same people who brought you Ronald Reagan, deregulation, Iran Contra, John McSame, Phil Gramm, Dick Armey, Ken Lay, Dubya Bush and Dick Cheney. Now can you believe that he is really a hero?

by the same people who brought you Ronald Reagan, deregulation, Iran Contra, John McSame, Phil Gramm, Dick Armey, Ken Lay, Dubya Bush and Dick Cheney. Now can you believe that he is really a hero?

Memo To Barack Obama:

The Breakfast Of Champions is NOT a Creal....It's The OPPOSITION!!!

You can count on McCain being there. $400 million spent on a campaign......he ain't quitting.

GET TOUGH! But be professional.

Daytona Beach has earned the dubious honor of becoming one of the most corrupt cities in the United States. Corruption is so ingrained and so well organized that even the people in charge of prosecuting it are under control of the people benefiting from it.

From the purchase of overpriced land from political cronies, to the sale of the personal residency of a city commissioner to the city by over twice its just value, to the financing of personal hobbies and indulgences of tycoons at taxpayer expense, Daytona Beach has turned into Capone's Chicago.

The end result is a city in despair, high unemployment, low morale, rampant crime, homeless roaming the streets and an overworked police force that can't keep up.

Learn more about this poor city in badly need of Federal intervention http://www.DaytonaPost.com

69 comments

Login or Register to post comments.