Go Home

Mitt Romney, a Profile in Cowardice

For months, likely Republican presidential nominee Mitt Romney has made Barack Obama's supposed "failure of leadership" a centerpiece of his campaign. But like his ill-advised comparison of President Obama to Marie Antoinette, Romney's sound bite could well boomerang. After all, when Multiple Choice Mitt isn't comically reversing his stands, he's too afraid to take any at all.

That cowardice starts with his tax returns. While John Kerry and John McCain at least presented a summary of their (and their well-to-do wives') payments to Uncle Sam, the $250 million Mitt has so far refused to do so. Despite his famous demand in the 1994 Senate race that Ted Kennedy release his tax returns to show he has "nothing to hide," Romney reiterated his own paperwork would not be forthcoming. "We don't have any current plans to release tax returns, but never say never," Romney said, adding:

"I can tell you we follow the tax laws, and if there's an opportunity to save taxes, we like anybody else in this country will follow that opportunity."

Or as he put it to CNN's Wolf Blitzer last week (at around the 6:40 mark):

"I don't put out which tooth paste I use either. It's not that I have something to hide."

That's one interpretation. Another is that Mitt Romney is desperate to avoid the horrible political optics his tax returns would inevitably produce. After all, because Romney's continuing millions in annual income from Bain Capital (a company the Los Angeles Times recently explained "often maximized profits in part by firing workers") are taxed at the 15 percent capital gains rate, Mitt already pays a much lower share to Uncle Sam than most middle class families.

Romney's pusillanimity extends to his own tax proposals as well. Unlike virtually all of his GOP rivals, Romney has held back on endorsing either a flat-tax or the complete elimination of the capital gains tax. As he seemed to suggest to the Wall Street Journal, discretion is the better part of valor when it comes to telling voters about the massive windfall the Romneys would reap under the tax policies that dare not speak their name:

What about his reform principles? Mr. Romney talks only in general terms. "Moving to a consumption-based system is something which is very attractive to me philosophically, but I've not been able to sufficiently model it out to jump on board a consumption-based tax. A flat tax, a true flat tax is also attractive to me. What I like--I mean, I like the simplification of a flat tax. I also like removing the distortion in our tax code for certain classes of investment. And the advantage of a flat tax is getting rid of some of those distortions"...

Amid such generalities, it's hard not to conclude that the candidate is trying to avoid offering any details that might become a political target. And he all but admits as much. "I happen to also recognize," he says, "that if you go out with a tax proposal which conforms to your philosophy but it hasn't been thoroughly analyzed, vetted, put through models and calculated in detail, that you're gonna get hit by the demagogues in the general election."

Mitt Romney's fear of getting hit was also on display during the debt ceiling debate this summer. As the GOP's brinksmanship over defaulting on the U.S. debt reached its climax in late July, Romney turned his tail and fled. As MSNBC reported at the time:

NBC's Garrett Haake reported that Mitt Romney told reporters in Ohio yesterday that he would not comment on the debt negotiations in Washington. And so far, he has refused to either endorse Boehner's legislation (as Huntsman has done) or oppose it (as Pawlenty and Bachman have done). Our question: How does someone who wants to be the leader of the Republican Party not have a position on one of the biggest issues facing Washington, especially after the dueling primetime speeches by Obama and Boehner? It's actually quite surprising; this isn't just another Washington fight. Is the lack of a position proof of how fragile Team Romney believes its front-runner status is right now?

(Ultimately, Romney used Facebook to announce his support of the Boehner bill, but only after it passed the GOP House.)

As it turns out, Ohio was the scene of another of Mitt Romney's moments in cowardice.

After visiting a Republican phone bank calling voters about the state's controversial Issue 2 curbing public unions, Romney amazingly refused to take a position:

"I'm not saying anything one way or the other about the two ballot issues."

Embarrassed by his obvious lack of backbone, Romney endorsed the measure the next day. Ohio voters, who handily defeated the Republican measure, won't soon forget Romney said goodbye to his spine in Columbus.

Romney's vertebra similarly went missing on immigration and abortion, two issues near and dear to the Republican primary voter's heart. As Steve Benen recounted, Mitt's campaign simply would not answer Joe Klein question about what President Romney would do about the 12 million illegal immigrants already in the country:

The evasion wasn't exactly graceful. Klein asked what Romney would do with the undocumented immigrants who are already here, and Fehrnstrom replied, "He would not grant them amnesty." Right, Klein said, but instead of amnesty, what would Romney do with these people? "He would not grant them amnesty," Fehrnstrom answered. Got it, Klein said, but what, specifically, would Romney do? "I just told you, he's not going to grant them amnesty," the campaign spokesperson said. When Klein then explained that this isn't actually an answer, Fehrnstrom, once again, said, "He would not grant them amnesty."

The Romney camp built a similar stonewall after their man seemingly came out in support of the soon-to-be defeated "personhood" initiative in Mississippi. But the day after the ballot measure went down to crushing defeat, Team Romney insisted "he's being falsely characterized as supporting a proposed amendment to define a fertilized egg as a 'person.'"

On matters small and large, duck and cover is Mitt Romney's posture. Afraid to admit that he has obviously been running for President without interruption since his failed campaign four years ago, Romney's wife claimed his 2012 run was all her idea. As Ann Romney told Wolf Blitzer last week (starting around the 2:30 mark in the video above):

BLITZER: Is it true that you had to talk to Mitt into running again?

ANN ROMNEY. ROMNEY: It is true...after the last campaign, it was kind of ironic that I was the one that said I'd never do this again, and now, this time around, I'm saying, you know what, Mitt, you've got to do this again.

But in Mitt's telling, his latest White House bid is all due to Barack Obama. As he told the Wall Street Journal just days ago, Mitt was content to hang out in his $12 million, soon-to-be doubled-in-size California beach side home:

The Republican presidential candidate says he never intended to run for office again after 2008--"I went back and bought a home which was far too expensive and grandiose for the purposes of another campaign," he jokes. He was drawn back into public life amid Mr. Obama's bid to "fundamentally transform" the country, to use the president's own words, into "an entitlement society," to use Mr. Romney's.

Given his Boston area townhouse and lakeside mansion with man-made beach in New Hampshire, a third palatial retreat would have seemed excessive for a candidate Romney. After all, Mitt Romney's running for office as a "man of the people"; he can't have mansions, for Pete's sake.

"If it seems like this keeps coming up with the former governor," Benen concluded, "it's not your imagination."

Romney refused to take a stand on Paul Ryan's budget. Romney refused to take a stand when asked about voters booing a U.S. soldier serving in Iraq during a Republican debate. Romney refused to take a stand when Rick Perry dabbled in Birtherism. Romney initially refused to take a stand on Ohio's campaign to undermine collective-bargaining rights, and then sheepishly backpedaled when the right complained.

There's going to come a point next year when the Obama campaign is likely to say, "Mitt Romney lacks the courage and the character to be a leader." And the criticism will sting because it's based in fact.

And so it goes for the man George Will rightly described as a "recidivist reviser of his principles." On the issues where he doesn't change his mind, Mitt Romney - the man who would be leader of the Free World - lacks "the courage of his absence of convictions."

(This piece also appears at Perrspectives.)

Share This Post

Link To This Post


22 Comments
MaryK's picture

1. As head of the investment company Bain Capital, Mitt Romney laid off thousands of workers.
2. Mitt Romney's advice on the foreclosure crisis: "Don't try and stop the foreclosure process."
3. The former Bain Capital managing director said of Mitt Romney's tenure: "We had a scheme where the rich got richer."
4. Mitt Romney set up shell companies in the Cayman Islands and Bermuda to avoid U.S. taxes.
5. Mitt Romney's plan for a "middle class tax cut" would provide zero benefits to 73.9 percent of the middle class.
6. Under Mitt Romney's leadership, Massachusetts ranked 47th among the 50 states in job creation.
7. Mitt Romney has proposed tax cuts for the rich and corporations that would cost $7.8 trillion over 10 years.
8. Mitt Romney's top economic adviser Greg Mankiw said the "offshoring" of American jobs was a good thing.
9. Mitt Romney called for taxes on the poor, saying low-income Americans having no income tax liability is "a problem" that will "kill the country."
10. Mitt Romney would repeal the Dodd-Frank bill, which regulates the risky practices that led to the 2008 crisis.
11. Mitt Romney: "Corporations are people, my friend."
12. In 1996, Mitt Romney called the flat tax a "tax cut for fat cats." In 2011, Romney said "I love a flat tax."
13. Mitt Romney supports privatizing Social Security.
14. Mitt Romney defended his belief that we "should consider a higher retirement age" for Social Security and Medicare to preserve tax breaks for corporations.
15. As governor, Mitt Romney vetoed a minimum wage increase to $8 an hour.
16. Mitt Romney said he "cannot see that a Cabinet position would be justified" for an American Muslim.
17. Mitt Romney opposes troop withdrawal from Iraq.
18. Mitt Romney vowed to increase the size of the military by 100,000 troops.
19. Mitt Romney wanted "bombardment" of Iran.
20. Mitt Romney advocated doubling the size of Guantanamo.
21. Mitt Romney won't say whether he thinks waterboarding is torture.
22. Mitt Romney supports drilling for oil in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge.
23. Mitt Romney considers liquid coal a "clean" technology, though it emits more greenhouse gasses than oil.
24. Today, Mitt Romney says a cap and trade program would have "devastating results for people across the planet." In 2005, Romney said he was "convinced" that cap and trade was "good business."
25. Mitt Romney supports penalties for doctors who perform an abortion.
26. Mitt Romney wants to see Roe v. Wade overturned.
27. Mitt Romney used to say he was pro-choice, and now he's "avidly pro-life."
28. Mitt Romney would "absolutely" support a state constitutional amendment to define life as beginning at conception, which would restrict women's right to an abortion.
29. Mitt Romney has signed the National Organization for Marriage anti-gay campaign pledge, calling for a federal amendment outlawing same-sex marriage.
30. Mitt Romney reversed his campaign position, enacting abstinence-only sex education in schools.
31. As of October 2011, Mitt Romney has raised more than five times as much money from Wall St. employees as Obama, raising $1.5 million.
32. Mitt Romney said he finds "it hard to disagree with Rush Limbaugh on topics."

Source: The Slaughterhouse Informer, a newsletter from www.tbrnews.org


"Courtesy is owed. Respect is earned. Love is given." --Unknown author, found in Guide to Texas Etiquette by Kinky Friedman

Rich H's picture

What a list. It's safe to say whoever wins will be Wall Street's best friend.

blu-n-red utah's picture

for your very complete list, Mary; Plastic-Fantastic Mittens presided over the most expensive Olympic games ever. He, along with help from Utah repubes like Whorring Orrin Hatch and Robert Bennet, sucked over 1.5 BILLION $$ out of US taxpayers pockets to stage the 2002 Salt Lake Winter Olympics. Many of their wealthy cronies reaped huge beneifits after all was said and done.
Somehow, I don't think your average Teabagger would agree this was a wise way to spend their tax dollars.

ixnay's picture

cyborgs like iRomney are unable to "experience" human emotions, like cowardice or shame.


CTHULHU 2012 "Why vote for a lesser evil?"

flag_bible_gun's picture

he did squeeze out santorum in Iowa.. lol


Can I teach evolution in the Sunday school at your tax-free Church? No?!
Can you use taxpayer money to impose your religious beliefs on others? NO!
Separation of church and state is a wall, not a one-way door.

docb's picture

It is being reported that the vote count was 20 votes off to romneys favor! Santorum may have won ...

dixie blood's picture

Can anyone name a Mormoron with a spine, 2 balls and a set of guts?


Reader, suppose you were an idiot. And suppose you were a member of Congress. But I repeat myself.

TheSavage's picture

Roy Halladay.


"I could give a flying crap about the political process.... We're an entertainment company."
- Glenn Beck - Forbes interview; April 26, 2010

dixie blood's picture

He and his wife were raised as members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, although they are now non-practicing


Reader, suppose you were an idiot. And suppose you were a member of Congress. But I repeat myself.

Paul the Sax Guy's picture

Actually I can, though his name and writings would mean little to anyone unfamiliar with Scottish Rite Freemasonry, Illustrious Art de Hoyos, 33rd Degree, Supreme Grand Historian at the House of the Temple in DC and member of the Supreme Grand Council.

It's Art that updated and annotated Morals and Dogma and wrote A Bridge To Light, an exploration of the 4th-32nd degrees of the Southern Jurisdiction Scottish Rite.

I've corresponded with him, occasionally, and have read him for years; a more thoroughly decent, upright and good man does not exist, and, yes, he and his family for generations before him are LDS.

I don't happen to share that faith, but it's as nasty and uncalled-for to insult LDS practitioners for the failings of some of their more public and hypocritical adherents as it is to consider all atheists to be murdering assholes like Lenin and Stalin.


In the marketplace of ideas, too many people shop in the bargain basement.
-- Thunder BlueRose

Why, yes, I am a card-carrying member of the ACLU
http://saxman.bravepages.com

Paul the Sax Guy's picture

Oh, and I might add, he's funny as hell, too... unlike the subject of this thread.


In the marketplace of ideas, too many people shop in the bargain basement.
-- Thunder BlueRose

Why, yes, I am a card-carrying member of the ACLU
http://saxman.bravepages.com

NavSpecWarVet's picture

I had a C.O. in the Navy, full captain. He was a mormon. He had an outstanding combat record in three wars, WWII, Korea and Viet Nam. Unfortunately, he was also the biggest prick I ever met. Hated blacks and all other minorities, Treated enlisted men like servants. To top it off he was on his "Sunset Cruise." He had been passed over for admiral and was really pissed off about it. And took it out on all of us. This was in the early 70's.

dixie blood's picture

Doesn't sound like much of a momoron to me....


Reader, suppose you were an idiot. And suppose you were a member of Congress. But I repeat myself.

docb's picture

Has most of those!

NavSpecWarVet's picture

Little known fact about Romney. Although at the time he was a resident of Utah, he got a deferment from his father, who was governor of Michigan, as a divinity student from the draft. This despite the fact that Mormons don't have divinity students. Fuckin' Chickenhawk now supports all wars, is against troop withdrawals, has no sons in uniform and wants to bomb Iran, among other places. I despise people like him. I would spit on him if I ever happened to face him.

angryspittle's picture

Romney a coward? No, a coward would not be so brash as to do what he has done. Shameless, yes, b ut it takes real guts to be such a fucking hyopocrite.

Obama is the real coward.

LeftandLeft's picture

Even most of the most ignorant Confederate party member would disagree with your bullshit assessment...they hate Shitt too. Everyone(but you) knows that Willard is a soulless gutless forever lying stack of shit.

"it takes guts to be such a fucking hypocrite" Great value system you've got going. I sure hope that you haven't/can't procreate.

Ape-Man's picture

Willard Romney = Fired Workers


"Government by organized money is just as dangerous as Government by organized mob"
-= Franklin Delano Roosevelt =-

g-man's picture

His wealth estimate of $250 million makes him part of the .001%. Americans love their oligarchs cause most don't know who they are or what they have done to the country that shelters them.

He is a man who, despite his professions of piety, demonstrates no possession of a functioning conscience, is an irremdial predatory opportunist, is a habitual and pathological liar, is essentially amoral and anethical, gives no evidence of possessing a capacity to experience shame or remorse and demonstrates not only a complete incapacity to experience empathy or compassion but seems also to contemptuously disdain the very concepts, to name but a few of the salient features of his personality. The man is corrupt beyond any hope of rehabilitation. His supreme reality, from what I can see, is Mitt Romney. I strongly suspect that all others, including those who are closest to him, do not actually possess any meningful measure of objective reality in his eyes or mind; all others are just objects in his environment who are presnt to be used or manipulated as suits his desires...beings of zero actual consequence.

It seems amazing to me how a person can make professions of being a good and godly person who is well socialized, based upon a mere claim of adherance to some set of religious moral principles, and how - despite overwhelming and long term behavioral evidence that runs contrary to that claim, masses of gullible and shallow people will always flock to his or her banner. A carefully crafted public personna, a mere pretense with abosolutely nothing to back it up seems to be all that it takes to lure in and endless supply of prey creatures. That is the principal skill of a sociopathic predator and Romney has perfected that skill. He reminds me of a Ted Bundy with money.