Educational-Industrial Complex, Idaho-Style
[h/t Heather]
Meet Tom Luna, Idaho's Republican Superintendent of of Public Education, architect of the gutting of Idaho public schools, massive teacher layoffs, and union-buster. Tom Luna is an interesting character. He's a good, solid Republican, 2-year veteran of the Bush Administration's Department of Education, and doesn't really have any educational qualifications for the office he now holds. No, seriously. He doesn't. Here's his resume in a nutshell:
Education:
Classes at Boise State and Ricks College, Bachelor of Art (2002) in Weights and Measures from Thomas Edison State College, a non-accredited on-line degree factory supposedly based in New Jersey.
[Commenters have pointed out that TESC is indeed accredited, so the person I quoted above is wrong about that. Even so, there is nothing about a degree in weights and measures that qualifies Luna for the office he holds.] Also, he owns a scale company whose largest account is an Idaho corporation owned by Frank Vandersloot -- Melaleuca. Remember that name. I'll be talking about him later.
Tom Luna's Amazing Fundraising Abilities
Now, Tom Luna had one of the best-financed 2010 re-election campaigns I've seen for an office that oversees about 280,000 students. (For perspective, California employs more teachers than Idaho's total number of students.) But to get Tom Luna elected in a Republican state in 2010 when the Tea Party was full of hubris and madness, donors gave $212,000 to his campaign, of which $132,000 was spent as of November 18, 2010. This is not counting PACs, or independent expenditures. That's direct campaign donations. With the exception of the Governor and Lieutenant Governor, no other candidate for state office came anywhere near the campaign donations that Luna received.
Those donors didn't give because they were feeling generous and loved Tom Luna. They loved Tom Luna's plans for the state's public education system, though.
If Luna’s “Students Come First” proposal passes the Legislature, online education will be mandated in Idaho and a laptop will be available to every high school student. That means 115 school districts, with 82,000 high school students, will be in the market for computers, software and online courses.
Well, lookee there. And look at who Tom Luna's top 2010 donors were:
- K12 Inc. of Virginia, an online company with 81,000 students and operator of the Idaho Virtual Academy. In Idaho, IVA enrolls 2,930 students and received $12.8 million from the state in fiscal 2010. K12, its employees and major stockholders spent about $44,000 supporting Luna; $25,000 of that was funneled to an Idaho interest group for independent advertising on Luna’s behalf. I should also mention that K12, Inc was started by Bill Bennett, Education Secretary under Ronald Reagan. Yes, *that* Bill Bennett.
- - Apollo Group of Phoenix, the parent company of the University of Phoenix, an online university with more than 400,000 students. Luna’s plan would allow high school students to earn college credits at state expense once they complete high school requirements. Apollo Group gave Luna $5,500.
- - Executives of Scantron Corp., a Minnesota-based leader in testing technology that is aggressively expanding into online education. Scantron employees and family contributed $7,450.
Other corporate education contributors: Apangea Learning, Inc. (online math courses) $1,000; Education Networks of America (educational video/network technology) $5,500; Madison Education Group (education consulting and advocacy) $5,000, and yes, Frank Vandersloot, who not only picked up the tab for thousands in independent expenditures, but also donated $10,000 to Luna's campaign. But don't take my word for it. Here's a whole huge list with all the tentacles listed.
For-profit educators, GOP privatization organizations, marry at the IBCEE
Frank Vandersloot is a wealthy affiliate marketer in Idaho who is also connected with the Education Alliance of Idaho, an affiliate of the Idaho Business Coalition for Education Excellence (IBCEE), a non-profit organization (which hasn't filed any Federal disclosure forms that I can find) comprised of CEOs and company presidents. The Education Alliance membership is comprised of the following:
Members include J.A. and Kathryn Albertson Foundation and representatives from the Idaho Education Association, Idaho Association of School Administrators, Idaho School Boards Association, Idaho Parent Teacher Association, Idaho Digital Learning Academy, State Board of Education, State Department of Education and the State Division of Professional- Technical Education.
According to the "fact sheet (PDF)" they publish it has a mission:
The Education Alliance of Idaho is a coalition of key stakeholders in the Idaho education system. The core purpose of the Education Alliance is one of advocacy and advice. The Education Alliance does not have authority in statute, nor does it control policymakers. Instead, the organization’s influence on the future of the education system in Idaho comes from that of its members.
Indeed. In 2005 (the only annual report (PDF) I could find), the JA and Kathryn Albertson Foundation funded 20 charter schools, including the Idaho Distance Education Academy, the Idaho Virtual Academy and INSPIRE Charter school, all online schools. The foundation has also given a large grant (in connection with the Micron Foundation, another Luna donor) to the Boise school District for the first "brick-and-mortar web enabled elementary schools using K12 Inc. curriculum."
But it's not only the Albertson grocery family. Others participate in the "influence on the future of the education system in Idaho." Others, like Bill Hansen, co-founder of Big Luna Donor Madison Education Group and now President and CEO of Scantron have some influence, too. Hansen was an adviser to the 2008 Romney campaign, too. And Michael Milken, who owns 24% of K12, Inc.
I've given you all of this detail on Idaho because it's a small enough state that the money flow really stands out like a sore thumb. Despite Luna's insistence that he's not beholden to those who bought his re-election, his "reform proposals" say otherwise.
But it's not just Idaho. It's Michigan. It's Pennsylvania. It's Arizona. Florida. Ohio. Indiana. The names are different but the model's the same. In Michigan, it's the DeVos family who funds charter schools and "influences policy". The corporate education firms have different names but the goal is the same: To break unions, get rid of as many teachers as possible, and force students into online learning courses which teach to a test but don't necessarily educate students. This particular model assumes students are commodities with identical learning styles and abilities. Profit centers, amortized over 12 years.
Cronyism Strikes Deep
Idaho's high school students understand what's at stake. It's why they walked out in support of their teachers earlier this month. And some of Idaho's citizens get it too. In fact, one retired secretary is beginning a recall effort against Luna. Her reasons echo the same reasons Wisconsin and Michigan citizens have for undertaking their own recall efforts.
Berto has attended protests against Luna’s three big education reform bills with “Stop the Lunacy” and “Save Our Schools” signs. Despite overwhelming public testimony against the plan backed by Luna and GOP Gov. Butch Otter, two of the three bills are expected to get final legislative approval in the House Tuesday. The third bill is stalled in the Senate.
Berto disputes Luna’s claim of a mandate for change — including larger class sizes, required online classes and a computer for every high school student — because neither he nor Otter mentioned the ideas in the 2010 campaign.
I would only say this to Mrs. Berto: Follow the money during the campaign and it will tell you what they're really planning to do after they're elected. Luna's campaign was so heavily and well-financed that it was clear from early on that the goal was exactly what they've now done.
Tom Luna lives the GOP creed: Cronies Come First.




Great piece of work!
I am impressed.
*high fives*
"President and CEO of Scantron"
Of course - Scantron is used to count ballots. Nothing funny about that.
"I know that there are people who do not love their fellow
man, and I hate people like that! " ~ Tom Lehrer (1928 - )
Yeah-sure you are-we all know how much you care about the "kids." They are just potential money to be made in your "Charter schools" profit seeking plunder.
Each kid is like a heifer in a feed lot-worth only so much per pound.
We love those kid$$$$.
Hummmm....wonder if he's related to Jeroen van der Sloot?
TESC is accredited. You can read about it here:
TESC doesn't merely hand out useless pieces of paper that pass for diplomas, either.
Now it sounds like this guy in Idaho is a tool, but there's no reason to incorrectly characterize TESC to make that point.
I noticed that as well. TESC is geared towards working adults, but it's a completely real and accredited school.
Heck, just last year Gov. Christie was talking about merging it with Rutgers!
And even if it is accredited and Luna received the very finest weights and measures education and attendant degree, it does not qualify him as some kind of educational policy expert.
I realized it was a quote, it's just that it has a glaring factual error and that the "nutshell" relies on this quote without any clarification or correction. I get the overall point about his qualifications (and agree with your conclusion).
But if you quote someone, and the central point of that quote is based on an error (especially a big one!)...if you don't correct that error, you take ownership of the quote as well (at least to a certain degree) - particularly if you use it to support your own argument.
That said, you're totally right: it still doesn't mean Luna has any real qualifications for his job.
There's a note in brackets.
Ah, now I'm seeing why every Republican Presdiential candidate from that frothing Santorum, to you can't spell 'Pawlenty' without the 'yawn', to Boss Hogg Barbour are bitching about public schools, which once made us the wealthiest, most educated country in the world.
If you privatize education, your cronies have guaranteed income for 12 years, and your kickback will be a lobbying job for 7 figures a years later.
What a racket!!!
'Leave no child's pockets with anything in them.'
And their parent's, too.
Goddamn...this country SUCKS.
I really feel like abandoning ship...we're going down quicker than the Titanic.
Just 'Cos You Got the Power...THAT DON'T MEAN YOU GOT THE RIGHT!
like we should. It has to be this long drawn out slow motion thing so it's completely impossible to start over,
Tom Luna's reelection was just one more example of the bait and switch tactics we have seen in so many states. During his first election he was seen as a radical Con-servative bent on the destruction of education. He managed to win the office in spite of that viewpoint and spent his first term softening that perception. He then ran for reelection as a "proven" moderate. None of his proposals were released and the state media ignored any question of his financial backing. It was only after the election, at the beginning of the legislative session, that his radical proposals came to light.
At this point your presentation of his backers is the best I have seen. Local media have only recently and grudgingly published the Vandersloot and Scott (Albertson Foundation) connections. In fact, the Idaho State Journal in an editorial, mildly criticized Vandersloot's motives after publishing a series of full page ads from Vandersloot (and Albertson Foundation) supporting Luna's actions. Money first... then the facts.
The actions of Scott have tarnished the reputation of his grandparents foundation. His grandmother Kathryn built a reservoir of goodwill and integrity that no longer exists.
While Vandersloot has his hands in a lot of Idaho politics, his primary goal is the destruction of unions. That and the preservation of his privilege ie He has pretty much single handedly stopped a wind farm development near his recreational property because it would interfere with his privacy.
It sounds an awful lot like Wisconsin - without the protests.
are in London today.
Windows smashed and shops targeted in Oxford Street
and would rather die through peaceful protest than fight back against the people who are killing them.
Humpty Dumpty was pushed.
This goes right along with my posting the other day, The War on Public Education.
Election 2012: Be Educated! Be Active! Vote!
www.phoenixjustice.com
It's really a terrible situation. I think there's more than just the moral cons behind it though. There's value to some in simply keeping the workforce ignorant and dependent.
that "Take every last dime from them and them kill them when they're worthless" was going to be such a successfull business strategy, I'd have been a republican politician.
It's a gawd-damned war and real people are dying, but nobody's allowed to mention the V-word. Well, just die. Leave your money on the dresser.
Humpty Dumpty was pushed.
This is something I think public schools should be replicating.
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/need-to-know/uncatego...
"In 1998, when Massachusetts first implemented new standardized testing that was required for graduation, administrators at Brockton High School learned that more than 75 percent of their 4,000 students would fail to graduate.
But over the last decade a small group of dedicated teachers have changed the way every class is taught. They began a schoolwide literacy program to reinforce literacy skills in every class, including math, science and even gym. The transformation at Brockton has been remarkable: Failure rates for that state test have dropped to 6 percent for English, ...." --Clip 13 min, 09 secs.
This is an example with data that proves that the approach works. And the thing that will preserve the public school approach is adapting processes that work. So long as the public schools fail to provide a good result, the public will be receptive to alternate approaches.
and to quote you these programs "don't necessarily educate students", I think that is being far too generous.
Students that I worked with who used virtual learning programs (granted, they were ordered by the juvenile court to participate in the program because they had to be removed from the general school population, but I found them to be no different from "regular" students that I had worked with for the most part) generally "copied and pasted" text from lessons or the web into the areas where they were to provide answer on history, social studies, language arts, and science lessons.
The only subject area where they were not able to do this was with math, which was where I came in as a tutor, then they just waited until I provided an answer, or would play the "lottery" by selecting from A, B, C, or D multiple choice answers. They learned nothing from these programs, they would finish lessons as quickly and with as little thought as possible, and then begin to play games online.
Your post proves Mr. Luna does not meet the statutory requirements to be Superintendent of Public Instruction. I expect action to be taken to remove him forthwith.
Unless, of course, your post containins false or erroneous information.
TFR
is an elected position in Idaho. The only requirement is to fool enough rubes to be elected.
karoli's post says he does not meet them. He should be removed from office.
TFR
statement of opinion is one that is shared by a great many people - but it has nothing to do with the statutory requirements for the office. She is correct that Mr. Luna has no traditional "... educational qualifications for the office he now holds."
The only Statutory requirements are:
that he be elected by the qualified electors of the state
reside at the seat of government
perform such duties as are prescribed by the constitution and laws of the state
take and subscribe to the oath prescribed by the constitution
shall be bonded to the state of Idaho
This is not a Constitutional position in Idaho. It was established by the legislature in 1973.
Someone is Incorrect here Ricky, but I don't believe it's me (or Karoli).
So I may be found guilty of quoting someone else who is in error, but it quite clearly a quote.
I clarified it for you.
Thanks for the clarification. As you will note from the citation I am about to insert, with the highlight by yours truly, if your quote was accurate, he did not meet the statutory qualifications as I found them posted by the Idaho Legislature.
http://www.legislature.idaho.gov/idstat/Title...
But even with the clarification there is a problem. There is no such thing as a Bachelor of Art (sic?) degree in Weights and Measures at Thomas Edison State College. In fact, there are not even courses in such a topic. Of course, Luna has never claimed such a degree. But there are not even courses in what Wiki claims his degree is in.
I smell fraud. But then Thomas Edison apparently allows you design your own course of study.
TFR
what a well informed, well spoken, intelligent young man................It makes one wonder what chance there is of many more like him emerging if the re-pukes have their way.
The first casualty of republicanism is the truth.
Party politics are not only undemocratic, they are antidemocratic.
has Republicans slamming their laws and measures down the throats of its citizens before the backlash. They want to redistrict to stop voting backlash. They want to pass laws that are going to be hard to change because we'll be busy fixing everything they broke. They are creating havoc.
Jeanne
http://voices.idahostatesman.com/2011/02/22/i...
Read the comments.
"No man is so foolish but he may sometimes give another good counsel, and no man so wise that he may not easily err if he takes no other counsel than his own. He that is taught only by himself has a fool for a master." - Hunter S. Thompson
Education privatizers are also in Chicago, NJ, TN, NYCity, Texas and spreading thanks to a bottomless pit of Gates foundation PR and Arne Duncan's Race to the Top sellout. The myth that public schools are failures is now axiomatic and the only way to save them from the teachers unions is to turn over management to our Wall Street overloards. Corporate investors are sucking up consulting fees and contracts from public education funds faster than Goldman shorted mortgages. Every state has a Tom Luna and multiple influence peddling philanthropists.
But it's for the kids...
"Got Dough? How Billionaires Rule our Schools"
http://dissentmagazine.org/article/?article=3781
http://www.schoolsmatter.info/2011/03/bit-o-b...
http://nycpublicschoolparents.blogspot.com/20...
http://jerseyjazzman.blogspot.com/2011/03/gat...
http://www.schoolsmatter.info/2010/12/to-star...
http://charterschoolscandals.blogspot.com/
This issue really deserves much more attention. And yes, Race to the top is a huge part of the problem.
Comments are closed on this entry