The Shock Doctrine
By Nicole Belle Tuesday Sep 11, 2007 12:16pm
Naomi Klein has written a must-read book, The Shock Doctrine, and teamed with Children of Man's director Alfonso Cuarón to make a film on the state of shock that has subjected us to accept disaster capitalism.
This film and book discuss the CIA's experimentation with using electric shock to break people down. Yet, the more important point of these works is that a broader "shock" to the systems of a people as a whole, like say 9/11, can have the kind of impact the CIA was searching for in their tests, one that breaks down a whole society and makes them so fearful they are open to nefarious suggestions.
I am sure none of this sound familiar, does it? This is very powerful stuff that can explain how a traumatized society may act, and may just explain to you why a certain former Mayor of New York mentions 9/11 4.75 times per sentence. Read on...








Login or Register to post comments.
9/11: The gift that keeps on giving to George W Bush
If you haven't read Naomi Klein's No Logo, read it. I'm sure The Shock Doctrine is great as well.
Naomi Klein's last book, No Logo, was one of the most powerful books that I have ever read. I even got to meet Naomi Klein last year to tell her what an amazing analysis she has done. Her new book is bound to send a shock wave of its own through the foundations of our sordid economic system.
Another good book to read is Ecology of Fear, which was written a couple of years before 9/11. It talks about how the local climate and ecology of Los Angeles often got in the way of making easy money, and because of this, the land boom of the 1950's turned So. Cal. into the Hellhole that it is today. Needless to say, the naturally chaotic ecology of the LA basin crept into the imagination of Hollywood, which produced a large number of disaster movies, most of which take place in So. Cal.
"This is very powerful stuff that can explain how a traumatized society may act"
and this just reinforces how wrong the Iraq war is. If 9/11 causes this much trauma, imagine the trauma faced by Iraqis every day. It's wrong. Keep petitioning your congressman and senators to end the unjust occupation.
Fascinating. I'm seeing this.
Shock and Awe
Harlan Ullman
James Wade
Terrorism
Terror
Fear
Submission
Neo Cons
Hegemony
Massacre
Orphan
Firefighter
Abu Ghraib
Skyscraper
Oil Fields
Lebanon
Victims
Blitz
Babies
Civilians
Richard Perle
Fear
Fear
Shock & Awe
Shock
9/11 inside job. if it wasn't, these guys are too dumb to run a lemonade stand.
The book is brilliant. I've been recommending it all over the place since I got it last week.
I hope it doesn't get buried by the mainstream press.
She really takes an axe to Milton Friedman and his disciples.
From Machiavelli to Orwell, it's been recognized, despots and
their supporters know a terrified population is a docile population.
The Republic party has nothing left to sell but fear...
Of Terrorists
Of Muslims
Of Immigrants
Of Gays
Of ANYTHING that isn't white, christian, and living in the Midwest or the south....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EYCnNb5Iyak
Though I haven't read it yet, this sounds very much so like the CIA's experiments with MKUltra and Project Monarch, and if that's the case, then we are, as a whole, in deep shit.
Others fighting over Oil too.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eG768hhPwSE
This all sounds a little too much like a tin-foil-hat ranting.
utopiate @ 11:
She makes specific reference to the CIA and MKUltra in the first section dealing with EST.
12 ysbaddaden Says:
That was for the thread below.
Bill Norton @ 14:
Why? How?
Cuaron is brilliant. While P.D. James' book had a specific message, he took Children of Men further with the film adaptation, showing us what could happen in the near future if things keep going the way they are. Ray Bradbury, Orwell and Huxley's works ring true today.
kudos to Naomi Klein for always speaking truth to power
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1W3AdD6CFF0
Bill Norton @ 14:
And what would happen if you put your little tin hat in the microwave?
[Sorry. The spam filter has od'd on steroids today-Sitemonitor]
Naomi Klein is brilliant.
Grab some popcorn. Pipe down. Listen.
Part I
Part II
Part III
Part IV
Part V
Part VI
Bill Norton @ 14:
I remember when the Patriot Act first got leaked onto the internet in 1999. It was dismissed as tin-foil-hat ranting. But in the days right after 9/11, it was rammed through Congress fast. The people who voted for it, didn't read it.
Correction!
It should read "and teamed with Children of Men director Alfonso Cuarón"
That Film is too important to get the name wrong.
Peace Love
Osama got it all backwards didnt he! ...What a dummie!
I guess he never knew that the 9/11 attacks would make the very people he wanted to hurt...even richer and more powerful (and more agressive) than before.
Osama....yeah right.
The Shock Doctrine
http://www.shockdoctrine.com
Digg It... http://digg.com/politics/The_Shock_Doctrine_3
ysbaddaden @ 21:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g8huXkSaL7o
Here's another natural disaster for ya:
http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y54/hfiend/race6.jpg
Why hasn't she ever been photographed with:
http://www.popeyespoopdeck.com/img/cast/ovalback.haggy.jpg
?
I've several reviews of this book and I thought that this one was the best: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/LAC.20070908.BKKLEIN08/TPStory/?query=shock+doctrine
Naomi Klein is great, a treasure for whose work we should all be grateful.
She also supports organized labor. AMAZON does not.
Support labor: buy from unionized stores.
Children Of Men was the best film of 2006, bar none. Very interested in this.
Read these recommendations. I read it, and I think it may be the most important book of our time.
"Klein tracks the forced imposition of economic privatization, rife with multinational corporate parasites, on areas and nations weakened by war, civil strife or natural disasters….pointing an alarmed finger at a global “corporatocracy” that combines the worst features of big business and small government…. Klein’s book incorporates an amount of due diligence, logical structure and statistical evidence that others lack….[P]persuasive…Provocative…. Required reading for anyone trying to pierce the complexities of globalization."
—Starred Kirkus review
"Impassioned, hugely informative, wonderfully controversial, and scary as hell."
—John le Carre
"Naomi Klein is one of the most important new voices in American journalism today, as this book make clear. She has turned globalism inside out, and in so doing given all of us a new way of looking at our seemingly unending disaster in Iraq, and a new way of understanding why we got there."
—Seymour M. Hersh, Pulitzer prize winning investigative journalist for The New Yorker
"This beautifully written, very readable book will change the disgusting history it so calmly chronicles"
—Peter Carey, author of Oscar and Lucinda and Theft: A Love Story
"Her argument is well-documented, logical, riveting, and convincing."
—Jane Smiley, author of A Thousand Acres and Ten Days in the Hills
"This masterful book is a measured but furious call to arms. Naomi Klein is Antigone before the King, the antidote to the feeling of inevitability that says that we must accept murder as a legitimate economic policy… A spectacular triumph."
—John Cusack, actor/filmmaker
"The Shock Doctrine is, simply put, a book without peer, an epic and riveting work whose message must be heard. With the persistence of a journalist, in the best sense of the word, and the rigor of a scholar, in its truest incarnation, Naomi Klein offers nothing short of a new paradigm for understanding politics…. Her book is honest, urgent and necessary to read. Through its eloquent writing, searing analysis and remarkable breadth, we confront the hubris and zealotry of envisioning a blank slate and being left, time and again, with a scorched earth. The Shock Doctrine is an essential book; only Klein could write it."
—Anthony Shadid, Pulitzer Prize winning Iraq correspondent for The Washington Post
"Naomi Klein is in the best tradition of I.F. Stone and Upton Sinclair, a muckraker who digs in where others accept the surface. I love her stuff and as a 20th Century man, I salute a 21st Century woman."
—Studs Terkel, historian and author of Working
"A revelation! With unparalleled courage and clarity Naomi Klein has written the most important and necessary book of her generation. In it she exposes liars, murderers and thieves, ripping the lid off the Chicago School economic policy and its connection to the chaos and bloodshed around the world. The Shock Doctrine is so important and so revelatory a book that it could very well prove a catalyst, a watershed, a tipping point in the movement for economic and social justice."
—Tim Robbins
"Naomi Klein is an investigative reporter like no other. She roams the continents with eyes wide open and her brain operating at full speed, finding connections we never thought of, and patterns which eluded us. She shows us, in clear and elegant language, how catastrophes -- natural ones like Katrina, unnatural ones like war -- become opportunities for a savage capitalism, calling itself “the free market,” to privatize everything in sight, bringing huge profits to some, misery for others. To ensure the safety of such a system, it becomes necessary to constrict freedom, to assault human rights. The torture chambers for some then match the torturing of the larger society. This is a brilliant book, one of the most important I have read in a long time."
—Howard Zinn, author of A People’s History of the United State
"Naomi Klein has written a brilliant, brave and terrifying book. It''s nothing less than the secret history of what we call the ''Free Market''. It should be compulsory reading."
—Arundhati Roy, author of The God of Small Things
"Naomi Klein as a writer is an accusing angel. This life-saving book, packed with thinking dynamite, provokes and instills a calm. It reveals a striking parallel between CIA prisoner interrogation technique and the blackmailing technique of the World Bank and I.M.F. for imposing disaster capitalism across the world; both want to induce by shocks a loss of identity. Hence calm is a form of resistance. A book to be read everywhere."
—John Berger, author of G, winner of the Booker Prize, and Ways of Seeing
"Naomi Klein''s exposé is certain to be sensational…. She rips away the ''free trade'' and globalization ideologies that disguise a conspiracy to privatize war and disaster and grab public property for the rich few. She is brilliant on the malevolent influence of Milton Friedman and the University of Chicago''s Economics Department in promoting global privatization. She offers an excellent explanation for the failure to repair New Orleans after Katrina. Hers is a long-needed analysis of our headlong flight back to feudalism under the guise of social science and ''freedom.''"
—Chalmers Johnson, author of The Blowback Trilogy.
I love the part with the wispering person spreading the truth. I think Cuaron is very mindful of the futility revolution (futility means it won't work).
Children of Men really paints revolutionaries as misguided zealots. I wonder though, if you had a guy in front of you who willingly bombed thousands of children for nothing, like Bush did, would you not CUT HIS HEAD OFF?
Fun to ponder, if you are at all human, that is.
Bill Norton - idiot!
Angelo - no killing is wrong,. make them live with the shame of their actions,. tattoo 'traitor to humanity' on they forheads,. lock them up in gitmo! put them on video 24/7 and let real people visit with them every day to 'talk' to them,. perhaps they can be saved,. but at least they will be kept form hurting the rest of us,. leave the killing to the non-human beings,. like the neo-con madmen that pulled 9/11! Fascism is on the rise becouse of this shock trick they have learned,. tell everone not to fall for FEAR!
Naomi Klein!
Clearly articulates the progressive message and attendant solutions.
...
this series of documentaries is worth a look:
http://www.archive.org/details/ThePowerOfNightmares
1st ep. synopsis:
"Both [the Islamists and Neoconservatives] were idealists who were born out of the failure of the liberal dream to build a better world. And both had a very similar explanation for what caused that failure. These two groups have changed the world, but not in the way that either intended. Together, they created todayÃÂÃÂs nightmare vision of a secret, organized evil that threatens the world. A fantasy that politicians then found restored their power and authority in a disillusioned age. And those with the darkest fears became the most powerful."
Not impressed. Politicians and leaders have now this for hundreds of years. Just look at the burning of the German Parliament (Weistag sp?) in 1930s Germany. So sorry, your idea is not new. Look at how the US reacted to Pearl Harbor. Humans, by their nature, do not act on anything until it is glaringly obvious that there is a problem. No one wants to disrupt the stasis quo unless they are forced to. Your idea is not special, but very glitzy in its presentation.
Login or Register to post comments.