October 04, 2007 11:30 PM
Open Thread
ADVISORY: This video has some graphic war images.
Usually we've posted funny videos on the Open Thread but this one isn't funny. It's sad, and should be required viewing in every big-box Bush-voting church in America.
UPDATE: This video was sent in by Raginggurrl who deserves more than a belated hat tip. Give 'er a click.




Great video exposing the mouth-breathing useful idiots
Hey....
There is plenty of KILLING left to do!
scarey shit
Dear Lord:
Please send some common sense into the hearts and minds of these fools...
These images are tough to look at, especially the babies...
Just a real sense of sadness for the people hurt by this war and the mass of Americans who are too dull to understand that George Bush's prayers are sending us in the wrong direction.
My passion has been zapped by this continual war.
GOD save us from the Christians
I read somewhere once that more people have died in the name of one religion or another than have died in all other wars.
That makes it really SPECIAL when our Asshole-In-Chief and his sidekick Darth Cheney tell me how Christian they are.
Just makes me want to puke.
Genius. Pure genius. I just realized that these people prove that evolution is true. They are not fully evolved human beings. Only a still forming intelligence can come up with responses like that.
As a Christian, all I ask is that:
Those guys haven't thought a lot about any of what they're professing.
On Fox News today, a guest managed in less than four minutes to say that Barack Obama and Democrats in general are:
- Domestic insurgents,
- Domestic enemies,
- Equating loving the flag with being a pervert,
- Good allies of the foreign enemies of this country,
- Not demonstrating their patriotism,
- Badmouthing the country,
- Demoralizing the troops,
- Undermining the nation,
- Throwing flags into the gutter,
- Wanting a cloth flag and a match, and
- Opposing everything this country was founded on!
Apparently this man is the love-child of Ann Coulter and an auctioneer.
I think we're missing the point. The people in the video are not stupid, and they're not horrible. They are, I suspect, decent, sincere people who care passionately about the things they have been taught are important. They've been trained to fear a God who will damn them if they do not bring others to his cause, which is so strongly aligned with the abortion issue that they can't see the importance of other moral issues. These are the people created by the culture of "Jesus Camp." If you want to attack someone, attack the cynical manipulators who made them what they are.
...Anyone think we should of payed more attention to him when he was alive?
He nailed them for what they have grown into today...
The prophet Bill Hicks.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mHey5g56CIs&mode=related&search=
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-qmglGWMsdk
I think its the arsenic in the water and the mercury vapors from the power plants.
Soooooooo....
When are all these blogs going to join together and plan some major protest?
Iran is getting closer.
Too bad all these popular blogs never jumped on board for the general strike Strike911.org planned for last month.
Why was the Jena 6 protests so easily organised?
If the major blogs only knew how much power they hold.
I asked a fundamentalist Christian the other day if he was ready yet to retract his 04 vote, and this is someone who is otherwise intelligent and who voted for Gore in 2000. (He voted for Bush for religious reasons I'm certain. I told him point blank the neocons have always played the religious right for fools, that they aint Christians and they have done Satan's work, if any religious force is their guide. And then he says "I agree, we have not fought this war right"
Hello? Are you overlooking the fact that there is no "right" way to invade another country and commit cause a humanitarian disaster and cause ethnic cleansing by arming both sides in a guerilla war? (This I should have said and didnt)
He then decided it was time to go, and before he left he said something like "Well, he does do some good things, I agree with his Supreme Court choices" and drove away.
The church installs reality disconnects in these people, it shows that the mind can be programmed. The churches of the United States have failed miserably in speaking out against war. They have proven themselves fraudulent on so many levels.
Jesus loves me yes I know.
The priest who raped me told me so.
Nuns and priests cannot have sex.
When giving head they strain their necks.
Once they had a holy war.
They killed Jews and Muslims door to door.
They killed some "witches" back in Salem.
They hung the bitches, way to save them.
They have ten rules that they obey.
How many will they kill today?
The gates of heaven may let me in,
but not my neighbor, he likes men.
They buy the myth of original sin.
Those evil babies are at it again.
Hahaha!
I thought you said that video wasn't funny,... those brain washed idiots are funnier than all the Jim Carey movies combined,...
"Duuuuuhhhhhh,.... I didn't think about THHHAAATTTT,... guh-huh-guh-huh,..."
REAL Christians like CS Lewis & GK Chesterton are spewing right now, looking down on these Forest Gump wannabes,...
"[Bush is] a man of character, a man of honesty."
How can one person be so utterly full of crap?
Do these assholes realize that up to a million people have been killed by Bush? Oh, that's right: Brown people don't count (they won't say that, but that's what they mean).
It's just so easy for people like this, isn't it? Faith makes everything so simple. Why is that guy not fighting Bush's war in Iraq? God hasn't called him to do that. Instead, god has called him to vote for the person ordering the deaths in Iraq, while limiting the freedom of those at home. No retort works when someone can simply assert, "Ehh, god wants me doing what I'm doing."
Oh, and who were those Christians he mentioned?
George Washington? Hmm, let's ask historian Barry Schwartz.
Better yet, let's ask another of the Christians he mentioned, Thomas Jefferson:
And as for Jefferson himself?
By the way, Jefferson sought a "god of nature." He believed that if there were a god, god would be found by studying nature and the universe scientifically. Since he wrote the Declaration of Independence, he slipped in a reference to "Nature's God," sort of satisfying those Christians around him in the Continental Congress who wanted a more religious document.
Oh, and video dude mentioned Abraham Lincoln, right? Heh, that one's just too easy. No historical interpretation necessary:
Finally, Mr. John Adams. I'll give video dude that one. Adams was, largely, a Christian, though had bouts of agnosticism. Mostly, he lamented the way Christians behaved though.
Fa la la.
these people are exactly why when someone tells me they are christian, i run for my life.
blind insipid obedience to theology. they will shout in your face for the rights of
an embryo and then they will kill anyone who disagrees with their point of view.
to them it's save the embryos=delusional death penalty for adults.
too many wars have devastated humanity because of these ignorant bastards. i am an egnostic, but if i were to give my all to a faith, it would not be what these assinine
"new born" fuckups think is god's word. i have read one version of the st. james bible and today's "christians" would murder jesus if he dared stand in their way of hate.
What the hell holds these guys ears apart or their heads from caving in?
It's blind loyalty to Bush. They need the Daddy figure.
Dear Lord,
Please let those who believe in you know you do not exist.
first three presidents were christian eh? doesnt surprise me that somebody as deluded as he is wouldnt know much about history either.
EJG @ 20:
The mind eating virus leaves behind what could be called cellular trash-piles of genetic material within the nucleus of each individual brain cell. Thus, they can technically be called shit-heads.
Chris @ 10:
I think you're correct that, by and large, people like this are not stupid or evil. They've been indoctrinated. I imagine as well that even the people who run Jesus Camp think they're doing the right thing. They were indoctrinated also, after all. Likewise for the 9/11 hijackers. I'd bet they truly believed they were doing god's bidding, and would be rewarded for it.
Certainly some "cynical manipulators" exist, and do the indoctrinating. But I think overall, all of society needs to take a long hard look at itself and question whether "faith" is a virtue at all. Even so many secular people "believe in belief," to use Dan Dennett's term -- that is, they think that even though they have no belief themselves, they nevertheless maintain that faith is a useful and virtuous attribute. I disagree, and do so openly.
JohnnyThief @ 16:
Real Christians? I dunno. I'm not so sure the people in this video aren't the "real" Christians. In my experience, those who profess to be the "true Christians" are the ones who have their own internal sense of morality, and disregard the tenets of Christianity they don't like. Then they simply claim that their version of Christianity is the right one.
It always makes me quite curious how someone defines "Christian," when s/he makes such a claim.
Karen,
Here is a good one for your quiver:
"The day will come when the mystical generation of Jesus, by the Supreme Being as his father, in the womb of a virgin, will be classed with the fable of the generation of Minerva in the brain of Jupiter."
-- Thomas Jefferson, letter to John Adams, April 11, 1823
Chris @ 10:
Fuck them! These idiots know EXACTLY what they're saying. I have absolutely ZERO respect for their beliefs. Bunch of hypocrites the entire friggin' lot of them.
This video demonstrates something more than the idiocy of Christianity. (There is no such thing as "intelligent" or "liberal" Christianity - something that should be obvious to anyone with enough common sense to understand that virgins cannot have babies and dead people cannot come back to life.)
It demonstrates that human beings, in general, are idiots. Religion is evil, and it will insure that the wars and bloody idiocy will continue. Sooner or later (perhaps under the banner of Christianity vs. Islam) humanity will destroy itself - and in the long run, the rest of the world will be better off for it.
Homo sapiens is a junk species, harmful to every other species save its cohabiting brothers (cockroaches, rats, shit-pigeons, etc). Homo sapiens is doomed because, despite the presence of a few admirable individuals, it is collectively too stupid to save itself.
God has called on me to disbelieve...and so i don't...i don't believe in God...it is His will and i must obey it.
these christofachist bastards are batshit crazy, batshit crazy , god wants them to kill men women and children, the cocksuckers took my brother from me hes fucking brain dead with that shit him and that whole pack of rat bastards that are praying for the rapture should get it tonite this minute this second ,fuck them all the way to the hell they make for others,
underdog @ 26:
Hee hee, yes, I do like that one too. I avoided it, though, since, without the surrounding context, it is arguable that Jefferson is lamenting his prediction. :)
gene214 @ 27:
I have zero respect for their beliefs as well. But I can separate respecting a person from respecting his beliefs. Not that I have much respect for the people in this clip, but I do agree that they're not evil per se. Most likely, they have indeed been indoctrinated into their religion from early childhood.
This video shows a very good representation of your average Bush/Christer voter.
In other words, complete dipshits, divorced from reality.
All I can say after watching that is holy sheet...wow.
Karen @ 32:
The guy in the dark glasses looked like he was making some connections. People of faith are not bad people out of hand, some of them come to some very bad conclusions when they decide to stop thinking for themselves and let someone lead them and use them. I have known many people who have done a lot of good things because they believed in God. All of us have seen many who have done a lot of destructive things with the same faith but a lack of understanding of what faith entails.
xoites defends Constitution @ 29:
Xoites, your comments make me smile in the same way I do when I see an M.C. Escher painting. :)
These naive men in the video should take five minutes to read this :
http://www.repentamerica.com/bushrevealed/
It's not too late to seek the truth, for the truth will set you free .
you should have seen bill moyers show tonight if you think this vedo shows what fucking morans christians are his is worse ,i first wanted to puke then wanted to kick thier ass then i got to where i just hated the dam brain dead assholes!
Karen @ 36:
Thank you. Even though the statement turns around on itself it is meant to turn the "logic" of faith around on those who misuse it.
"The guy in the dark glasses looked like he was making some connections."
I think he was just regretting having eaten that third roadside-vendor hotdog with chili.
underdog @ 40:
Yes, it is hard to understand the ways Christ can choose to move one.
xoites defends Constitution @ 35:
Hmmm. I realize that many people understand religion in this way. It can inspire good; it can inspire bad, though the bad is often a misinterpretation. I'm not so sure.
I have my suspicions that the good works of the faithful manifest themselves in ways congruent with their respective faiths. However, I suspect that their moral impulses are simply hardwired into them; they'd have done them anyway. In other words, instead of doing things because they believe in god, their natural moral instincts drive them to be good, and they consult their religions for guidance.
On the other hand, many of the evil deeds of the faithful are entirely compatible with the tenets of their faiths. As Sam Harris says, those who supported slavery in the South, and justified it with Biblical passages were on the winning side of a theological argument.
Karen @ 18:
Better yet, let's ask another of the Christians he mentioned, Thomas Jefferson:
And as for Jefferson himself?
By the way, Jefferson sought a "god of nature." He believed that if there were a god, god would be found by studying nature and the universe scientifically. Since he wrote the Declaration of Independence, he slipped in a reference to "Nature's God," sort of satisfying those Christians around him in the Continental Congress who wanted a more religious document.
Oh, and video dude mentioned Abraham Lincoln, right? Heh, that one's just too easy. No historical interpretation necessary:
Finally, Mr. John Adams. I'll give video dude that one. Adams was, largely, a Christian, though had bouts of agnosticism. Mostly, he lamented the way Christians behaved though.
Fa la la.
Isn't it nice to know you're in good company? At the same time, I get this overwhelming feeling that this was the high point of American history....we be on the downslide from here, honeychild.
These right wing nutzoid kooks scare the bejesus out of me!
Even if you showed this to them, they wouldn't get it. They would see as some sort of propaganda piece trying to lead them away from the true path. Yes, folks, they are that brainwashed. They wouldn't acknowledge the truth if it bit them on the ass.
tyree @ 38:
You COULD always change your name to something like Oral, or Pat, or Jerry and make your living off of their gullibility, but you'd have to look at yourself in the mirror every day and not throw-up.
underdog @ 46:
Are Oral and Anal Roberts still alive?
xoites defends Constitution @ 47:
Xoites, there's a diary over at Daily Kos regarding Oral and his son, would you be so kind as to link to it and to give us the lowdown? I promise you'll LOVE IT!
Strawberry @ 43:
:)
James Madison argued passionately for the separation of church and state by telling its detractors that both religion and government would both exist in "greater purity" the less they were mixed together. Indeed, you're correct about the "downslide" from that generation onward. I'm not too sure what Madison meant by "greater purity," but it is certainly fascinating how faith flourished in the United States, while it wained in countries with established religions. It's sickeningly paradoxical: Populations subjected to established religions (but otherwise liberal, western forms of government) tend to reject faith far more than in our country, where we have a "free market," so to speak, of religions.
Karen @ 42:
To be serious (just for a moment) it is hard wired into us to save a drowning human, defend a victim, and help each other. When we start creating belief systems we get into trouble. I have been listening on and off to NPR's "This, I believe" series and it occured to me today that it may well be that our desire and propensity to "believe" in things is truly at the root of our problems.
Come on...the dude says he supports the chimp cause he "prays"......wtf ?
This is a bible thumping adult that is void of logic unable to think for one self....in other words a sheep...I grew up catholic and got married in a Lutheran church and I found this video frightening. This is sick and scary stuff....
I would be glad to, but could you post a direct link? My eyes are old. :)
ecotopian @ 45:
Yep. Recently, Richard Dawkins debated a theistic mathematician on the existence of god. Both professors recognized, and openly supported Darwinian evolution. The debate (such as it was) centered simply on the existence of god. I would have thought it painfully obvious to anyone listening, but on some Christian blogs, many posters heralded the great blows to Darwinism rendered by the mathematician. Somehow, people hear what they want to hear.
xoites defends Constitution @ 41:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DIhv26Lh460
It's in poor taste, but totally applicable.
Found it! :)
Breaking: Oral Roberts U. Sex (and more) Scandal
by gobacktotexas
Fri Oct 05, 2007 at 09:14:34 PM PDT
Oral Roberts' adult daughter-in-law used university funds to purchase tens of thousands of dollars in clothing. Whilst sending a bunch of text messages to underage males. And Oral Roberts' son used university resources to fund political campaigns in violation of state and federal campaign laws....These are the allegations raised in a lawsuit against the university by three professors who say they were fired for trying to bring the wrongdoing to light.
I actually heard this on NPR today. Sounds like the usual Bible thumping to me. Well, ok, underage male thumping in this case.
Jesus jumped up and wept.
I "stopped" going to church because of the religious right and it happened last Christmas eve in the pastors sermon which I walked out of........I do still believe in an all forgiving God.....just not the one this loon in the video is talking about....
This pastor gave a sermon about the fact that Jews, Muslims, and Arabs all going to hell because they were not Christians and he lost me....can anyone explain to me how the people who died in the Holocaust..the families...the"Children" are now in hell next to the evil that burned and starved them to death ? Or the bombs we dropped on Iraqi families and children we see "in this video"...are they burning in hell for eternity ?
This is what the bat sheet wing nut right thinks....it's not right.
peachkfc @ 56:
somebody probably goosed him in his ass
xoites defends Constitution @ 50:
I do think you're onto something. While evolution has hardwired a moral sense into our brains, it has also given us a survival instinct. I suspect that we have an emotional attachment to our beliefs partly because of that survival instinct.
Our parents tell us not to play in the street, that the cars driving by will hurt us. As children, we'd best not be too skeptical. We just believe.
And having our beliefs challenged just might feel threatening to our very survival.
I'm not so sure that it's "belief systems" that are the problem. What we need to learn is a method of evaluation, a means by which to analyze evidence, and determine whether to adopt belief. Science is, first and foremost, a method for evaluating empirical claims, and it works better than anything else we have. Mathematics enables us to evaluate analytical truths. For normative and metaphysical claims, all we have is philosophical discourse, which is just fine. :)
xoites defends Constitution @ 55:
"Nothing will do it." - 87%
Sadly, that was my vote as well.
You have to feel sorry for these people, but fear them in the same instance.
It's obvious that if the guy is willing to profess that "the first three President(s) of the
United States were Christians," then he's also willing to repeat anything else he's told in the name of God. These types have a mental meltdown when told that most of the framers of our constitution despised Christianity as a despotic, hypocritical ruse based in ancient mythology and pagan sun worship. But how do you tell that to someone with the "thousand yard stare" of apocalyptic theology, someone who's been so convinced, so brainwashed by the Cult of Christ?
If Christianity provides a framework by which people lead responsible, ethical lives, it is a good thing. When it is used as a justification for killing, torture, shame, and division, it is no longer a religion, but a cult, and this is precisely the fear expressed by the very three presidents this man makes reference to.
Andy @ 57:
May I ask why? I'm genuinely curious, and since you're putting your beliefs out there for us to read, I'd like to know why.
How did you come to believe in the god in which you now believe, and why did you reject the one about which your pastor spoke? It seems that you simply didn't like what the pastor was saying, so you decided it wasn't true. Am I wrong?
I'm not trying to be rude or disrespectful. Just asking.
xoites defends Constitution @ 52:
Xoites, every time I try to link on this new computor, it says I must register the product...I swear, I've tried every product number I could find, to no avail, I can't even send e-mail yet. Look, it was a gift, OK? And I don't even own a cell phone. YES, FINE, I'M AN IDIOT, I ADMIT IT. TECHNOLOGY BITES!
OneTrickPony @ 61:
Brilliant comment. Politics and religion is toxic.
i wonder what room they used at abugrab prison to hold church services in ?
OneTrickPony @ 61:
I have made a concious decision a long time ago not to fear, but you make a good point. You can not reason with the unreasonable, but if we get our act together (they managed to back in 1776 somehow) we can get and keep these people out of power.
Scandal Brewing at Oral Roberts U.
Ignorance is bliss. Just say it's in the name of God. Put God's name behind everything you justify whether it's right or wrong and it will be okay.
Although leftists already have their scapegoat and need look no further, WE ARE BLOWING THE BIGGEST POLITICAL ISSUE OF THIS YEAR, which is the upcoming rubberstamp of arch-neocon Mukasey as Attorney General.
Mukasey has already said that he will not support the naming of special prosecutors.
We should be blocking Mukasey and DEMANDING special prosecutors. Call or write Chairman Leahy and these Senators:
Edward Kennedy Massachusetts
Joseph R. Biden, Jr. Delaware
Herb Kohl Wisconsin
Dianne Feinstein California
Russ Feingold Wisconsin
Chuck Schumer New York
Richard Durbin Illinois
Benjamin Cardin Maryland
Sheldon Whitehouse Rhode Island
Minority
Arlen Specter, Ranking Member Pennsylvania
Orrin Hatch Utah
Chuck Grassley Iowa
Jon Kyl Arizona
Jeff Sessions Alabama
Lindsey Graham South Carolina
John Cornyn Texas
Sam Brownback Kansas
Tom Coburn Oklahoma
(With the rightwing complaining about Mukasey also, it might be worth contacting the minority to complain as well).
Strawberry @ 63:
Do you have the software for your operating system? (Such as Windows?)
RobertPaul @ 5:
I'm a Christian and I abhor what these 'Christians' are believing and doing. Just as there are many different sects within a particular religion, Christians come in all different types. These Christians in the clip, including the likes of Bush, Cheney, Falwell, Robertson, etc are what I call American Fundamentalist Christians. They are a terrifying lot and I am not one of that kind of Christian.
The Gospel of Jesus Christ is about Love, Tolerance/Long-suffering, Mercy, Forgiveness and Grace. Anything other than this is false and descends into the depths of judgement, condemnation, intolerance, hate and destruction. If more 'christians' spent more time in earnest prayer contemplating the love of God and being consumed with Mercy and Grace, everything would be different.
Somewhere these American Fundamentalist Christians got seduced into believing they were God's right hand-men and didn't realize they were shaking hands with the devil. Now their fruits, shrouded in Pharisitical arrogance, are judgement, hate, intolerance and destruction. The harvest is truly frightening.
Karen @ 62:
very simple...I can not believe that God would send innocent people "of faith"...whatever that faith may be ...to hell...Now you tell me ....do "you" think that the children burned in Hitlers ovens and the children who died in Iraq from cluster bombs are in hell if they had faith no matter what it was ?
It's whats in your heart that gets you into heaven. Your life...your works.
Thing Fish @ 67:
Ach und himmel...where were you, like 15 minutes ago. You could have saved me a shit load of humiliation.
(But if you complain to the Republicans, do it in THEIR terms, obviously. Why can't they chose a real Christian, and not a New York liberal, for Attorney General?)
xoites defends Constitution @ 70:
It came preloaded...WAHHHHHHHH!
Strawberry: "Ach und himmel"
The phrase is Gott im Himmel (God in Heaven), FWIW.
You are sking me to believe in American Democracy. Hell, i don't even believe in Gid!
Or God* for that matter. :)
Strawberry @ 75:
its swell its a dell
Strawberry @ 73:
Sorry, just got finished watching the first half of Lawrence of Arabia.
75 Strawberry
Email me, i may be able to help.
Thing Fish @ 80:
Good movie. Too bad it is only 16 hours long. :)
Andy @ 72:
Right. But my question was why you can't believe that. I know that you don't believe it. I'm just wondering why. Is it just because you would morally disagree with such an action? Couldn't god be evil, or someone with whom you disagree morally? It just seems to me as though you decided it wasn't true simply because you don't like the idea that it is true. It's unpleasant and morally upsetting to you. To me, and again, I'm not trying to be disrespectful to you, that seems like a faulty way to determining truth, that's all. So, if you'll permit me, I'll ask again. Why do you not believe that god sends innocent non-Christians to hell?
Me? No. I do not believe that anyone murdered at the hands of Hitler or Bush are in hell. Because I don't believe in hell. Or heaven. Or god. I have not seen convincing evidence that such places or such an entity actually exists.
Why do you believe that?
My mom died in 1994. She came back to tell me there is no afterlife.
Paul in LA @ 76:
Funny, I never heard the Gott part...but then again when my muttie used that phrase, her german/english got kinda' mushed...maybe 'cause she was too busy swingin' that Gott awful wooden spoon.
God gave us free will. It is up to us in which direction we take our free will. Calling yourself a Christian is not the only answer.
xoites defends Constitution @ 50:
This I Believe:
That in his frail attempt to rationalize an often irrational world, to give meaning to his existence and assuage his knowledge that one day, he too will be dead, humans since the primordial have developed cognitive structures by which they give meaning to their otherwise powerless and meaningless paths from the womb to the grave. The faculties of imagination and abstract thought beget myths that eventually become belief systems. Religions are products of fear in its most basic form. They are the fitful denials that one will never know from whence we came and whence we go. The old saying, "You won't get out of this world alive," sums it up the agony nicely.
Karen.. I really want to know...do you think your God would condemn children to hell who were not "Christians" or just happened to be born "non Christians."...
God is all forgiving...there is a God in my heart that accepts everyone into heaven whose heart and soul is good....what that pastor said, on Christmas Eve no less, was evil as far as I am concerned....He took a time of hope and turned it into guilt.
The American Indians were probably one of the most culturally religious people on the face of the earth...are they all in hell after we slaughtered them and took their land ?
I can still read the Bible and believe in God's word and pray...now because I don't conform to what "you" think is what God says and does..I now am going to hell ?
God gave me free will but i gave it back. I told him i did not want him making any decisions for me.
tyree @ 79:
How'd ya guess?!
the supreme imbeciles of creation, reductio ad absurdum
Andy @ 88:
I guess you missed my previous answer to your questions @ 83? :) No worries. Head back up there, and continue the discussion. :)
Karen..you answered my question....I do think there is a higher power though...a God. An Afterlife. I have seen death and people die and I believe the soul lives on.
xoites defends Constitution @ 89:
That is the free will he gave you, to make your own decisions. There was nothing you could give back to him in your case, except love.
Andy @ 93:
Right. I know that you believe in such things. My question is why you do.
Ron @ 94:
I may not believe in God, but i am convinced you do.
I respect that.
Karen: "And as for Jefferson himself?
"
This selective quotation is misleading. The reason why Jefferson says this caveat is because this was the cover letter (to Van der Kemp) to the mailing of the Jefferson Bible (redacted gospels with all miracles removed), which Jefferson spent his last years working on. In more accurate context, note that Jefferson also said this:
"Notwithstanding these disadvantages, a system of morals is presented to us, which, if filled up in the true style and spirit of the rich fragments he left us, would be the most perfect and sublime that had ever been taught by man." (lettter to Priestly, 1805)
xoites defends Constitution @ 96:
Thank you.
xoites defends Constitution @ 77:
No, I'm asking you to get off your fat ass and actually DO something to change the future.
Paul in LA @ 99:
Paul, I know for a fact, xoites does more than most.
And to follow up on your last comment "again" as to why do I believe what I do ?
Because my Faith is that God accepts everyone and is forgiving of all sins. Does the color of my skin or my nationality change
that ?
I know the Christian pitch...it is the word and the only way to heaven. I don't agree basically because I don't know.
Ron, I think you are a fine example of someone who believes in God and does his best by his fellow humans. People who behave as you do don't worry me in the least. It is the people who misinterpret the reason the Bible was pieced together in the first place (a guide for a segment of the human race to survive and get beyond savage self interest) who worry me. They have turned the Bible upside down so they can use it as a way to promote their savage self interest.
Paul in LA @ 99:
Actually, i am really fucking skinny.
Strawberry @ 85:
There once was this great Effigies song which started with Kezdy(?) yelling Gott im Himmel a couple of times, and then laughing hysterically.
Ron: "Paul, I know for a fact, xoites does more than most."
Well, in any case, it isn't a matter of belief. This is PRAGMATISM.
Special prosecutors or bust.
Even our scooters don't work!
Rudy thinks spending
is why Americans have had it with Republiscum.
xoites defends Constitution @ 102:
I agree, I'm not a member of any church but it doesn't affect my faith.
Andy @ 101:
Hey, Andy. Please continue to understand I mean no disrespect towards you. You seem a decent person, and I'm only hoping to engage in polite discussion. In the above sentences, though, from my perspective, it sounds like you're saying, "I believe it because I believe it." Which isn't really an answer.
I suppose you could just say, "I have faith that this is true. It is not evidence-based. I just believe it." And hey, I respect your right to such beliefs. Personally, though, I do not understand them.
Ok, now I'm a little confused. :) Are you saying that you can't know whether one religion or another marks the only way to heaven, and thus you refrain from adopting such a belief? Cuz I would totally agree with that. That's basic skepticism.
Though for me, it goes further. I don't know how the universe came about, and haven't seen evidence for an intelligent being who created it. So, I refrain from adopting belief in one. Perhaps through our scientific studies, we'll find good evidence for such a being. But until then, I don't believe in such a being.
Basic perspective of a skeptical atheist. ;)
Paul in LA @ 106:
Oh, now i see what you are upset with me about. Ok, i will yell in a few deaf ears and see if they wince. :)
ill tell you what i believe ,i believe religion was invented by some perverted asshole so thier would be jobs for dickheads that really didnt want to do an honest days work , so they made them preachers then some other asshole needed fools to follow him to make him feel like a bigshit, then they had the fools pass the plate around so the lazy bastard preacher could buy his wife a nice fur coat and feed the little preacher bastards they produced so they could show off how well thier kids believed all the bullshit pappa beat into thier heads , and finally they invented religion to keep all these fools from killing each other , but it didnt work out so they just decided to use religion to kill anyone who doesnt believe thier fairytale shit and who dont look like them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Brian De Palma said: "The pictures are what will stop the war"
Thank you to BlueGal for posting the video. I made it over a year ago, because I strongly feel there's a disconnect between what war supporters believe and reality. The networks refuses to show us what our tax dollars are paying for in Iraq. If they would broadcast the mangled bodies of innocent dead children and our dead soldiers, this war would be over and companies like Cheney's Halliburton would lose money. Corporate media shuts its eyes and ours, while they are making a killing.
karen......I watched my wife's sister die 3 years ago from breast cancer at 31...when she took her last breath her body, her looks changed...her soul left her and went somewhere else...she was not a "Christian" and i believe she went to heaven... my wife was carrying my 3 year old son then.
I watched my father die..as I was sitting at his bedside he took his last breath and then was a shell....Didn't even look like himself....he was not religious....I believe he is in heaven because he was a good man....
What do "you want me to say" ? Does Jesus Christ accept jews, muslims and those of other faiths into heaven....
My answer is..yes.
xoites defends Constitution @ 112: Ok, i will yell in a few deaf ears and see if they wince. :)
Stamp on their toes, twist their noses, mock their poses,
and kick them when they dozes.
Democracy is like dancing. Over an abyss.
Andy @ 115:
What about atheists? (aka, sin against the Holy Spirit)
Karen and Andy,
Here is the problem in a nutshell: I was listening to a talk show last year. There was a Priest, a Rabai and an Imamm on. (No, this is not the lead in to a joke.) They were discussing their commonalities and their differences.
One thing they all have in common is that their religion is THE ONE TRUE FAITH!
Two of them, by definition MUST be wrong.
In my opinion they all were.
Andy @ 115:
I'm very sorry to learn of your losses. And I extend my condolences to your wife.
If I'm not making my queries clear, I apologize. No worries. There isn't anything in particular I "want you to say." As someone who doesn't believe in souls, heaven, hell or god in the first place, I was just curious as to why you did believe in such things. That's all.
Thanks for the conversation. :)
karen...I have no disrespect at you being an atheist...I'm probably an agnostic now.
very simply put...I look around me every day and can not believe the beautiful earth we live was spawned from an atom...and if it did...where did the atom come form to begin the evolution process....
Thus I believe in God.
Obviously, this is not the place to discuss religion, or maybe it is.
Paul in LA @ 116:
Stamp on their toes, twist their noses, mock their poses,
and kick them when they dozes.
Democracy is like dancing. Over an abyss.
It is easier to dance in a chorus line because if you make a mistake the other dancers are there to cover for you.
Until we get truly united and create a strategy to get our country back we are in danger of facing the "hook."
tyree @ 113:
Can't argue that that isn't one aspect of religion. Now days that aspect is called being a manager. Have an interesting book "Mathematical Cuneiform Texts". It's made up of word problems that generally go 'You have X amount of work to do. How long will it take 6 workers to complete?'
Guess who had time to sit around studding such texts back then...
Ron @ 121:
Ron, I'm done...sorry for my blathering....now I wonder where Tom Delay is going....
Ron @ 121:
This is an open thread and short of the violent overthrow of a country to be named later or assasination ANYTHING GOES! (Except, of course conspiracy theories which end up hijacking the thread as if it were an airplane fated to crash into a tower.) :)
Andy @ 124:
I think I know and it isn't where he thinks he's going.
Andy @ 120:
Ok, that answers my question. :)
Of course, as far as I know, there is no evidence that earth was spawned from an atom. Perhaps the universe began as some sort of (almost incomprehensible) singularity, but not quite an atom. :)
Indeed, the riddle of the "first cause" has yet to be solved. Personally, though I don't default to a supernatural intelligence just because the first cause concept is so puzzling. In fact, to me, it seems a poor answer, since such an intelligence would not only require its own cause, but would be far more complex than that which it is supposed to explain.
Or, if this entity is supposed to have existed forever, without beginning or end, well, perhaps the universe has existed forever, without beginning or end, and itself evolved from simple beginnings. :)
Anywazy..........thanks again for the conversation.
Great, powerful clip. Thanks for posting it.
This only relates because ultimately corporate greed is the connecting thread between Iraq and almost everything in our lives, including the music we listen to -- RIAA downloading lawsuit as the straw that broke the camel's back: Let's teach the heartless, greedy bastards we're the customers and boycott Sony. I'm putting my money where my mouth is. Please join me.
Ron @ 126:
probably a place where he is forced to watch a Hillary campaign speech for eternity....
xoites defends Constitution @ 125:
Actually, even some of those conspiracy theories have been allowed to stand lately. :) (Or at least questions about the causes of that infamous date.)
Andy @ 129:
Andy @ 120:
Oh, the answer to that is easy: WE DON'T KNOW YET! :)
Believe it or not human beings have not figured it all out. That does not mean there is no answer, we just do not know it.
Andy @ 129:
:lol: Ok, that I would definitely like to believe in. :lol:
Ron @ 121:
How about Leibniz's Monadology?
xoites defends Constitution @ 132:
We didn'nt know about the internet 5,000 years ago. Perhaps someone else did.
To understand religion, we must understand why it is so prevalent. Evolutionary theory would say that since the tendency toward religion is common to all human populations, it is quite likely an evolutionary selected trait. Likewise, since there is only local consistency among religions, the specific religion is not a survival trait, just the tendency.
But, what is the survival value of this tendency? My guess is that this tendency allows many of us to become "sheep" and a few to become "leaders" (and some "wolves", too). In ancient hunter-gather societies, I'm sure that a tribe was better off in general cooperating and following one leader, even if that leader was sometimes wrong. Individuals acting on their own would never be as likely to survive as an organized tribe. The ability to suspend rationality and believe in an afterlife where all your suffering will be rewarded makes it easy for you to be manipulated. Evolution only needs you to survive long enough to procreate and keep your children alive long enough to survive without you. It does not care if you have a happy life.
How does this relate to today? We see in the video strong "sheep" tendencies. In politics, we see the the "leader" plus "sheep" mentality of the conservatives is stronger than the disjoint "individuals" on the left. If everyone in your tribe goes in the same direction as the leader, that tribe will travel further than the tribe without a clear leader.
Can we do anything about this? I think it will be very hard to cure the faithful of this disease (or addiction, I can't decide which it is). Education helps a lot (which is perhaps one reason the conservatives keep cutting back on religion). Direct attacks are fun, but probably don't accomplish much. Ultimately, I suspect we'll have to come up with a "methadone" religion that has the same pallative effects on the addict, but less impact on society. Anyone care to create the next Scientology for the masses? One that is not quite as whacky as any other religion.
Ron @ 135:
If someone did then i do wish he would come forth and spout the megabucks number!
"It’s sad, and should be required viewing in every big-box Bush-voting church in America." - Bluegal
Those guys are hopeless basket cases. If they really believe that the second coming of Jesus Christ will arrive before they cancel Ugly Betty (kudos to Bill Maher for that line) I doubt if this will have any effect on them.
xoites defends Constitution @ 137:
LOL
I still can't understand how there can be a war and these nutbags "don't know" when asked how they feel about dead children. It is all over the blogosphere and much of the MSM. A more believable response from these people would be to say that they just don't care. But that would be very anti-Christian, wouldn't it? These people are a stain on humanity.
Retired Navy @ 140:
They have no idea where their faith really lies.
Retired Navy @ 140:
Who the hell has time to pay attention to current events when standing on street corners day after day handing out religous pamphlets?
136 Glenn
I'm thinking...
xoites defends Constitution @ 143:
So am I, always.
karen...what you said is why religion is such a controversial political topic....no one knows until you die.
Just from my own experiences, I do believe there is an afterlife.
What it is I don"t know. Fanatical right wingers are delusional in my view because they never question things and condemn people for not being a follower...my evangelical mother in law already told me i was going to burn in hell in my own home.
What makes me ill is when politicians "use" religion to get votes the same way you have to wear a flag pledge pin so you don't get called unpatriotic......same thing.
To me your relationship with God is personal. When you base wars, elections, and discriminate because of individuals personal religious faiths....that crosses the line for me because it disrespects individuals rights to formulate their own beliefs in something that is unknown.
Retired Navy @ 140:
They were very sincere about their beliefs. The fellow at the beginning was actually a nice guy, but I couldn't get over how disconnected he was from the real consequences of war - it's something they choose not to think about because it leads to bigger questions which may shake their beliefs.
That's why most fundies (and notice how neocons do the same thing) don't want to be around people who have different opinions - they really want us to shut up.
Retired Navy @ 140:
Sadly, they are genetically programmed to act this way. Religion has long outlived its usefulness and this is the result: unthinking, sheepish masses. We can rail against them, but it does not seem to change them. They have the cognitive dissonance required to convert almost any event into something that reinforces their belief. The trick is to figure out how to deprogram them. Got any ideas?
Glenn @ 136:
I used to have an article (which I haven't been able to find again) were a scientist named I think named Thomas Cray or Grey who proposed that homo sapiens speciated on a specific chromosome that caused a folding in our brain around the structures dealing with language. The gist was this folding permitted humans to use language to tell falsehoods.
This may not seem like a good survival trait. But sometimes a lie, especially when no real information is available, turns out to be a good guess.
Problem only rises when an idea based on faith is kept even when contradicted by the tangible...
I had a special fondness for the Shakers. Now here was a religion i could get behind (if not participate in.)
They believed in not having sex. To show their devotion to God (and to deal with all that excess sexual energy) they would come together and "shake." Much modern dance could have been based on this, but the abstinance part was lost in translation.
In any event (SUPRISE! SUPRISE!) this sect died out.
Ever wonder why the Roman Catholic Church is opposed to contraception?
RagingGurrl @ 146:
I questioned a pastor on this once and his answer was it was Gods will that the innocent died. My response was how could something that could have been "avoided" based on force be God's will...and the usual Christian response followed...free will.
150 Andy
God gave US free will so that all the bad shit could be blamed on us sinners and God could go golfing.
Andy @ 150:
And as long as you are a Christian, you will be forgiven for killing the innocent, and of course you can still go to heaven. What a deal.
Comments are closed on this entry