How to lose with dignity -- or not

For a couple of decades, supporters of private school vouchers have insisted that Americans really want public funding for private tuition, but elected officials won’t budge. So, proponents keep putting vouchers to statewide referenda — and they keep losing.

Utah was supposed to be the breakthrough for the voucher crowd. It’s perhaps the most consistently reliable conservative state in the union, with a high percentage of religious families who might want tax dollars for their church’s schools. Under these circumstances, they’d finally win one, right? Wrong — Utah voters rejected the latest statewide voucher scheme by a wide margin. The measure lost in every county in the state.

The funny part, however, is the reaction from the leading supporter of the voucher effort.

Voucher supporter Overstock.com chief executive Patrick Byrne - who bankrolled the voucher effort - called the referendum a “statewide IQ test” that Utahns failed.

“They don’t care enough about their kids. They care an awful lot about this system, this bureaucracy, but they don’t care enough about their kids to think outside the box,” Byrne said.

Got that? Disagree with the right on voucher schemes that don’t work, and you’re a child-hating moron.

Haven’t guys like Byrne ever heard of losing with dignity? Maybe a little class?



Login or Register to post comments.

70 comments

You missed Byrne's better (worse) quote from HERE

“I’m ashamed of Utah that this could even be a close vote,” said Patrick Byrne, CEO of Overstock.com, who has donated millions of dollars to support vouchers. “This is parents looking at their kids getting a third-rate education and other kids getting basically a death sentence and saying, ‘That’s OK by me.”‘

This guy sounds like a douchebag. He's probably in some airport men's room stall "falling" onto a cop's penis.

FWIW - I say we boycott "The Big O". I hate their damn commercials. It's a store, not sex.

The Dallas Morning News had an editorial that suggested if you didn't support vouchers you were probably racist.

I had been looking at a sofa on Overstock.com....no way in hell they're getting my money now.

Byrne doesn't believe in equality and public standards. He believes in putting tax dollars in corporate pockets and forcing another class change. He wants poor people to wear rags and take the job title "vassal" and swear fealty to a local education Lord. I hear he also hates Jews and black people. EQUIVOCATION, WHAT.

All class , too bad it is all 4th .

Voting against the voucher bill means you're stupid and hateful? Really? Can we get that quote on billboards all over the state?

Nothing gets the vote out and brings home popular support like calling a majority of voting citizens nasty names. I'm just amazed that Mr Byrne continues to have such trouble getting his beloved legislation sold at the state level. Perhaps if he uses more swear words...

he lost his neo-con play book. he was supposed to crow that this was a great victory for his cause and the voters have spoken.
like that clown gopper's take on the republican rout in kentucky.
"yeah, we wanted to loose. yeah. that's the ticket...have you met my wife, morgan fairchild?"

Overstock.com chiefie is mad that utes are not listening to his money instead of their brains.

maybe, just maybe, people don't hate themselves enough to keep voting against their own best interests.

Overstock.com is a Thug business.
http://deseretnews.com/dn/view/0,1249,635209449,00.html
May 22, 2006
"Patrick and Jack Byrne, the president and chairman of Overstock.com, did a political version of that recently. They combined to spend $1 million on ads designed to help crash John Edwards' vice presidential campaign two years ago."

If you would shop at Walmart, by all means buy more cheap crap from Overstock.com

f the voucher pimps who want to destroy public education. There's nothing they don't want to privatize

Byrne shows as much class as his crappy company, none at all.

I didn't realize that the public schools in Utah were so terrible in the first place.

Haven’t guys like Byrne ever heard of losing with dignity? Maybe a little class?

Really. That's unsportsman-like conduct. Didn't he learn not to be such a sore loser in school?

Zifnab @ 7:

Voting against the voucher bill means you're stupid and hateful? Really? Can we get that quote on billboards all over the state?

Nothing gets the vote out and brings home popular support like calling a majority of voting citizens nasty names. I'm just amazed that Mr Byrne continues to have such trouble getting his beloved legislation sold at the state level. Perhaps if he uses more swear words...

and maybe the utes should all stop shopping at overstock.com so he can be truly overstocked.

Hey! now THERE'S an idea for a movement - stop shopping at overstock.com!

No guys i'm afraid Byrne is like many other GOP individuals lately...they're like school on Saturday...no class.

10 miss_kitty Says:

Thanks, Great story!

As someone who has dealt with Patrick for many years, I can tell you that he is no neocon, no Neanderthal Bush lover, nor is he a movement conservative. He is much stranger than that. He has a PhD in Philosophy from Stanford, runs an online surplus store, and is quite possibly insane. You can read his biography here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patrick_M._Byrne. The best place to follow his corporate exploits is here: http://www.jeffmatthewsisnotmakingthisup.blogspot.com/.

Enjoy!

Squeaky Wheels @ 13:

I didn't realize that the public schools in Utah were so terrible in the first place.

I have an aunt who lives in Utah, and I remember back in the late-80's/early-90's, she was a teacher and complained about Utah having shitty schools... ranked something like 49th in the country. It was mostly due to lack of funds (surprise, surprise). However, I don't know if anything changed since then.

"Haven’t guys like Byrne ever heard of losing with dignity? Maybe a little class?"

Hell, guys like Byrne can't even win with dignity. How on earth could you expect anything different when they lose?

Dude, it's all about the NO!

ha-ha

Private schools fair no better than public schools. Look at schools run by private companies in Philadelphia and other cities and they do not do any better. We should look at Europe for direction. The students there are very highly educated for free.

/mr @ 18:

As someone who has dealt with Patrick for many years, I can tell you that he is no neocon, no Neanderthal Bush lover, nor is he a movement conservative. He is much stranger than that. He has a PhD in Philosophy from Stanford, runs an online surplus store, and is quite possibly insane. You can read his biography here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patrick_M._Byrne. The best place to follow his corporate exploits is here: http://www.jeffmatthewsisnotmakingthisup.blogspot.com/.

Enjoy!

Oh yeah! That's the nut-case who accused the SEC and entire stock market were in some grand conspiracy to plunge the value of Overstock.com's stock right after it went IPO. Now I remember who he is. :lol:

Yeah... this guy is the definition of "sore loser".

.

I just closed my Overstock.com account.

Vote with your bucks, folks - it's the only thing they understand.

.

Asking why neocons don't exhibit dignity is like asking why fish never win the Tour de France.

Utah was the first state to opt out of "No Child Left Behind" funding because it hamstrung the public school system there.

Their voters went to the polls and chose to raise taxes on cigarettes and booze, to pay for the education for their children. It's working.

California is now 49th in public education, and they're getting the No Child Left Behind funding, which isn't doing shyt for the schools there.

And you're right when you say private schools are not faring any better than public schools because there's no accountability for private schools - they can take your money and still not teach or educate your child for shyt. Charter schools, too.

But Byrne isn't the only neo-con spouting this shyt. Harold Ford was a big champion of voucher programs, as is Artur Davis and Al Wynn - hell, most of the DLC members are water carriers for voucher programs and privatization of Social Security. What dipshyts.

draftedin68 @ 24:

.

I just closed my Overstock.com account.

Vote with your bucks, folks - it's the only thing they understand.

.

I dunno man... he's probably going to sue you now for being part of the "Sith Lord" conspiracy. :lol:

that's it, i will never buy from overstock.com again. let's see how many others will
boycott them and watch their reichwingnut profits go down the tub.

I think the point that Utahns, who are perceived to be highly religious and LDS (Mormons) on the whole, would want to send money to church schools is largely incorrect. A very large number of people in Utah wouldn't have a private school to attend if they wanted to. Often the private schools are available to NON-LDS kids (e.g., Catholic schools). The LDS church has a seminary building next to almost every junior high and high school in the state. They don't need the state money to function incredibly well.

Moreover, many students can travel over an hour a day on a bus to get to the only junior high or high school in a large area. Why would these people want a cent of their money to go to private schools. Utah public schools are surprisingly good if not highly stressed like most schools in the country, and most people, including religiously LDS people, know this. They might not have a ton of resources, but the students largely still perform well. Even with vouchers, only the rich can send their kids to private schools. Utahns are starting to see the neo-cons' anti-"socialist" crap for what it is.

People talk about Utah like it's an alien planet. Utahns have exactly the same concerns and sensibilities as the rest of the country. Public education in Utah is one of the most important, if not perfect, institutions in the state. Why would we vote to send our tax dollars to the rich more than we already do? I'm so proud of my home state for voting this one down.

“They don’t care enough about their kids. They care an awful lot about this system, this bureaucracy, but they don’t care enough about their kids to think outside the box,” Byrne said.

Got that? Disagree with the right on voucher schemes that don’t work, and you’re a child-hating moron.

Haven’t guys like Byrne ever heard of losing with dignity? Maybe a little class?

With not a small amount of irony, I find that this was the same reaction by Dems after losing SCHIP once or twice....

Just sayin'

How much do you want to bet the dirt bag Byrne is against the S-CHIP bill which would actually benefit children not a bunch of lame 'charter' schools. My apologies to dirt and bags.

draftedin68 @ 24:

.
I just closed my Overstock.com account.
Vote with your bucks, folks - it's the only thing they understand.
.

Here's the magic word: feedback@overstock.com. Please inform them of your vote.

I will never buy anything from Overstock.com again.

Jay @ 30:

“They don’t care enough about their kids. They care an awful lot about this system, this bureaucracy, but they don’t care enough about their kids to think outside the box,” Byrne said.

Got that? Disagree with the right on voucher schemes that don’t work, and you’re a child-hating moron.

Haven’t guys like Byrne ever heard of losing with dignity? Maybe a little class?

With not a small amount of irony, I find that this was the same reaction by Dems after losing SCHIP once or twice....

Just sayin'

Errrrrrrr.... Jay, ummm since the S-CHIP program DOES help children and the voucher program only helps private 'charter' schools that's a pretty nonsenical comment there. Most of these 'charter' schools are nothing but religious brain-washing camps that care little about real education anyway!

You should have seen some of the ads they were running. In one the voice over talked about how "a liberal lobbying group in washington" wants to tell you how to educate your children (up pops the logo of the national education association) and then something about liberal washington insiders and they put a picture of Ted Kennedy up. The first time I saw it was during Saturday Night Live and I thought it was a send-up; when I realized they were serious it didn't seem as amusing. I am trying to see if I still have a copy of the ad on TiVo so i can post it. The other really obnoxious ad was when they claimed anyone who voted against vouchers was against families with lower incomes getting a good education.

I cannot tell you how happy I was when referendum one went down in flames; especially since they tried to jam it through the state legislature without a vote. All credit goes to the UEA.

People buy a lot of crap from him. He may have a point.

Haven’t guys like Byrne ever heard of losing with dignity? Maybe a little class?

We need more little classes and less of vouchers.

Weren't the Ruby Ridge kids home schooled?

The concept of a voucher system is a very interesting thing to begin with. For one, our public school system is broken. It won't be fixed anytime soon, and my spouse, who is a public school teacher attributes this mainly to the teachers. She cites examples of teachers and principals, calling students "little Monters", "Their little idiots", and such things. This along with impropriety in general. A kindergarten teacher she works with spends most of her day surfing the web while trying to ignore her students. This is in a lvl 2 school on the 10 lvl public school system, so it's poor and mainly full of minorities. The reasoning for this kind of problem is that teachers are so protected by their union, that it's difficult to be fired. This is even the case in incidence of child molestation, which is in no way uncommon in public schools.

I'm not saying that teachers are overpaid, or anything like that. They certainly aren't, and our country is far behind the curve in this department at all three levels of education. The problem is a lack of competition. Remember that public school systems and day cares were one of the main causes of the falls of many empires such as Rome and Greece. When you standardize education, where does innovation come from? I cannot teach in public schools even though I'm a PhD candidate at my perspective university. This is significant in showing that the standardization of our public schools is not just in creating little robot workers, but in teaching them with robot employees. To teach in our public school systems, at the grade school and high school level, you're required to have an education degree. This means that every teacher your kids will have in public schools will have the same undergraduate degree. Where does the innovation come from? Does this show why we're falling behind?

I'm for the voucher system, but only if it excludes private religious schools. Funding schools such as Montessori, Waldorf, and other types of alternative education systems that usually hold educators to higher standards than public school would be a wonderful thing for our country. That and it would create competition between educational facilities that are federally funded. This can only be good for our kids.

All this said, most funding for public schools comes from local property taxes anyway. Federal funding is less than 8% of total budgets for average American schools. This is why many top ranked schools have rejected the no child left behind act, and decided to actually teach their children rather than just test prep them all year long.

In a nutshell, Vouchers (good), Vouchers for religious private schools (very very bad, in fact unconstitutional), Current system (probably even worse).

conservatives losing with dignity and class? that ended with mcveigh and nichols.

"Haven’t guys like Byrne ever heard of losing with dignity? Maybe a little class?"

Oh, so in other words you're saying - don't act like a member of the loonie liberal left?

Simple solution: don't shop, or stop shopping, at overstock.com. I thought about doing so once, but never did because their ad campaign sucked so bad, I didn't want to encourage them. Now there's no question; the big O is going to be what their balance sheet reads when it comes to my help for their bottom line.

The whole voucher argument kills me. People coplain about their property taxes being high and not wanting to fund public education they don't want, but then the private school they want to put their kid in is even more expensive than the public option with the taxes taken into account. I attended 12 of 13 years in a private religious school, and spent 1 in a public high school I wasn't any less challenged in the public school than the private school. But, it cost my parents an arm and a leg to put me though the private one. Maybe all the conservative destruction of public schools has shifted the balance of education quality recklessly toward the private side since I was a kid, but my life experience told me neither was far and away better than the other, and this was in a middle class suburban setting.

I'm not against the idea of vouchers per se, but they way they want to implement it and raid other peoples' taxes for their children is dishonest and elitist.

I won't be buying from Overstock.com anymore. Jerk.

I also went to a good public school, but that's only because I grew up in small towns with only one district. If you live any any reasonably sized city and can't afford to rent or own in a good district, you're screwed. These schools are terrible. Many don't even have text books to offer students.

Terrible @ 34:

Jay @ 30:

“They don’t care enough about their kids. They care an awful lot about this system, this bureaucracy, but they don’t care enough about their kids to think outside the box,” Byrne said.

Got that? Disagree with the right on voucher schemes that don’t work, and you’re a child-hating moron.

Haven’t guys like Byrne ever heard of losing with dignity? Maybe a little class?

With not a small amount of irony, I find that this was the same reaction by Dems after losing SCHIP once or twice....

Just sayin'

Errrrrrrr.... Jay, ummm since the S-CHIP program DOES help children and the voucher program only helps private 'charter' schools that's a pretty nonsenical comment there. Most of these 'charter' schools are nothing but religious brain-washing camps that care little about real education anyway!

You have your facts wrong. The voucher program is entirely different from the charter school program. Charter schools are "chartered" by their state departments of education and are NOT to be confused with religious or parochial schools. In fact, they are public schools funded by taxpayer dollars, at least in my state they are. There is no religious education going on in my child's charter school. I have sent children to public, parochial and charter schools, and I think that taxpayer dollars should NOT be used to fund parochial schools. I still believe in separation of church and state and I tell everyone who e-mails me those messages decrying the lack of prayer in public schools that it does not belong there!!

I'll be boycotting Overstock.com, f...him! School vouchers for private schools rape the public school system that already in in dire fiscal condition due to bush's 'leave every child behind' policy. Those globalist want everyone dumb and dumber like the pres so they can control the world, de-country us and use people as their slaves with no rights. We still have the power to stop them together we can win! Let's start with impeachement and boycotting of all bush's buddies!

I just want to ask again: Why do so many liberals/progressives have such tunnel-vision in political races? As we've seen time and time again over the last 30 years, the Federal government has limited power to influence a great number of issues. But still liberals/progressives seem to always concentrate our efforts there.

Where are the web sites encouraging liberals to run in very, very local races? Damn people, the whole reason that our school systems are so screwed is because of the concerted effort on the part of religious extremists, beginning in the early 80s, to take over our local governments, especially school boards. I still have, somewhere, the "informational pamphlet" I got from Pat Robertson on "How to return God to Our Schools". And you know what the first section is on? "How To Regain Control of Your Local School Board".

As liberal/progressives, if we want to fix the problems with our schools (among a myriad of other problems), we have to be willing to eschew the "limelight" of national politics and roll up our sleeves to do the dirty, under appreciated work of taking back control of our local governments.

I contribute to a local progressive blog here in Utah. If you are interested in a rundown on the entire voucher saga that has unfolded here over the last year, take a look here. My reply to Patrick's petulant little hissy-fit is first on the list. What a piece of work.

Cody @ 29:

I think the point that Utahns, who are perceived to be highly religious and LDS (Mormons) on the whole, would want to send money to church schools is largely incorrect. A very large number of people in Utah wouldn't have a private school to attend if they wanted to. Often the private schools are available to NON-LDS kids (e.g., Catholic schools). The LDS church has a seminary building next to almost every junior high and high school in the state. They don't need the state money to function incredibly well.

Moreover, many students can travel over an hour a day on a bus to get to the only junior high or high school in a large area. Why would these people want a cent of their money to go to private schools. Utah public schools are surprisingly good if not highly stressed like most schools in the country, and most people, including religiously LDS people, know this. They might not have a ton of resources, but the students largely still perform well. Even with vouchers, only the rich can send their kids to private schools. Utahns are starting to see the neo-cons' anti-"socialist" crap for what it is.

People talk about Utah like it's an alien planet. Utahns have exactly the same concerns and sensibilities as the rest of the country. Public education in Utah is one of the most important, if not perfect, institutions in the state. Why would we vote to send our tax dollars to the rich more than we already do? I'm so proud of my home state for voting this one down.

Thanks fer the insight, Cody! I was thinkin' that there are so many LDS kids in the public schools that vouchers wouldn't matter to most of the voters in Utah. Good fer you guys!

The problem we have here in Grand Rapids (MI) is that we have had a strong Christian Reformed school district in the area fer decades, so even when our public schools were performin' well it was a real task to get a millage passed to keep up to speed. A few proposed millage increases in a row failed back in the '80's and the performance level of our students started to slide. Before ya know it there was disaffection with the public schools; white flight to the Christian Reformed and Catholic schools, combined with flight to the more affluent 'burbs followed. The GRPS has been spiralin' downward since about 1986.

What saddens me most about this is that the (mostly racial minority) students in the GRPS can't help but notice not only the difference in the amenities when they compare their schools to those in either the parochial or suburban districts; and more sadly they can't help but notice the differences between themselves and those who attend the parochial/suburban schools. And whether its a matter of art class or math class, these GRPS kids can't help but realize that More White Kids = Better Schools.

That's a lesson that shouldn't have to be taught because it's an equation that shouldn't be true.

I wonder if any of the private schools that would have received tax money under this measure would be subject to the No Child Left Behind provisions? Wingnuts demand that public schools get tested six ways from Sunday, but they'd probably scream like stuck pigs if their precious private schools had to deal with the same gauntlet.

I disagree. The public education system in America has been on a downward slide for a long time now. American Universities are gradually lowering the standards to get in and while this may have something to do with the massive growth in the number of people attending college, it speaks profoundly of the decrease in the education quality of our youth. I am not saying that vouchers are the answer, however I feel that government monopolies are every bit has harmful as their corporate counterparts. I think that vouchers are a worthwhile experiment. After all, education is one of the few things left to the states to determine for themselves (mostly) so 50 states could equal 50 case studies of how to improve our disturbing education slide.

Happy to say I've never purchased anything from Overstock.com.
Right wing pricks don't get to play with my money.

MF @ 50:

American Universities are gradually lowering the standards to get in and while this may have something to do with the massive growth in the number of people attending college, it speaks profoundly of the decrease in the education quality of our youth.

I have no problem at all with colleges and universities lowering their admission standards. Why shouldn't everyone who has the desire to attend be allowed that opportunity, especially at state schools? We all pay taxes to support them. Higher education should be like health care - accessible to everyone, not just those who have passed some test of eligibility beforehand.

I understand your point about education in the lower grades, but that's a separate issue. In what way does it help solve that problem to allow fewer people to attend college?

Holy shit! I've bought over $1200 worth of stuff at Overstock in the past year. Why didn't anybody tell me it would go to stupid shit like parochial schools???

Of course Byrne's a sore loser! He's a mormon, for cryin' out loud. If you think otherwise, wait 'til Mittens loses, and all the boo-hoo, "I lost 'cuz I a mormon!" crap will flow like water down the Colorado river.

Register your complaints at overstock.com. I used the live chat. The reps knew who Byrne is, and I'm guessing they're learning something about him tonight

https://sales.liveperson.net/hc/74613876/?cmd=file&file=visitorWantsToChat&site=74613876&SESSIONVAR!skill=service-overstock_information

Five2Nine @ 43:

I also went to a good public school, but that's only because I grew up in small towns with only one district. If you live any any reasonably sized city and can't afford to rent or own in a good district, you're screwed. These schools are terrible. Many don't even have text books to offer students.

You are right. Thanks to our republican friends (who have done everything they can to undermine every facet of the common good), some school districts can't even afford paper!

And after they wreck something, the repukes have their privatization parasites (cronies) swoop in suck-out the few remaining school dollars in the name of keeping taxes low (for the ultra-wealthy).

The fact is, many school districts in this country are outstanding. So the only way the repukes can diminish the whole, is by using a "rigged" testing system. Unlike every other country in the world, we educate and test everyone the same way. This almost gaurantees a 50% failure rate (especially when compared to countries that only test a small "elite" group of students). This allows the wingnuts to perpetuate the myth that our entire educational system is failing; which is a pile of rightwing B.S.

In fact, I would take five smart kids from our school district, and debate any ten wingnuts anytime. Limbaugh, O'Rally, Hannity, Coulter, etc.....even the decider guy. I think the kids would take their lunch.

Well, I'll never buy from overstock.com again.

I went to public school in Utah, though it's getting to be quite a long time ago. Even back then class sizes were very large and state spending was very small. I don't live there now, but all I can say is good on ya, Utahns, for recognizing crap when you see it. And good on ya again, for opting out of NCLB. I know that raising taxes on things like booze and ciggies to fund essential services isn't the best way to run a system; it's sort of one step up from the bake sale, but when we've got the government we've got, sometimes that's all you can do, and I only wish Oregon, where I live now, had done the same for child health care.

And I'm another one who'll have to cancel my Overstock account. I've bought a bunch of stuff from them over the years, but some things just aren't worth it.

Let me tell you why school vouchers SHOULD be allowed (coming from a liberal, based on the advice of my father who is president of the school board where I grew up, and who is also a liberal).

Lets say that it costs 5000 / student / year....

If you could get school vouchers for each student in the amount of $2000, each additional student who left the public schools would be giving the schools an extra $3000 to spend on the remaining students.

Class sizes would go down.

$ / student spending would go up.

There would be no need to expand the physical buildings. etc.

My wife is a public school teacher, and I am disgusted by how little some tenured teachers work, and how little they care about actually doing their job.

For every terrible teacher, I know there are many dedicated, underpaid ones, but there is a problem with the system, and status quo isn't the answer. Maybe school vouchers isn't the answer either, but something has to give, and I would be willing to give it a try (even though I would still send my kids to public school).

The first place to pass school vouchers is going to face a lot of lawsuits on the separation of church and state. No way that I want to have my tax dollars supporting religious indoctrination.

J.C. @ 52:

MF @ 50:

American Universities are gradually lowering the standards to get in and while this may have something to do with the massive growth in the number of people attending college, it speaks profoundly of the decrease in the education quality of our youth.

I have no problem at all with colleges and universities lowering their admission standards. Why shouldn't everyone who has the desire to attend be allowed that opportunity, especially at state schools? We all pay taxes to support them. Higher education should be like health care - accessible to everyone, not just those who have passed some test of eligibility beforehand.

I understand your point about education in the lower grades, but that's a separate issue. In what way does it help solve that problem to allow fewer people to attend college?

I agree one hundred percent that the opportunity for higher education should be available for anybody who wants to give it a go. I am still pissed at the republican rubber stampers who raised interest on federal student loans and replaced a good amount of grants with loan monies, but that is not the point. The relationship between lower admission standards and poor quality of education in secondary schools is not mutually exclusive. If you don't believe me, go volunteer at your local university's writing center. The number of simple grammatical errors will blow you away.
The only point I was trying to make is that our education system is failing. If our education system continues to fail it will fail the poor kids a lot more than the rich kids and the class divide will just get bigger. Remember, us liberals will always have an uphill battle...because we think. We need another generation of thinkers.

Thanks for pointing out the Overstock.com connection. I always like to know where NOT to spend my money.

Wow. So his plan B is to call all the voters fucking idiots, and baby killers? That's... probably not wise.

Especially with the heavy LDS population. Think what you will of their religion (especially historically -- I'm sure no fan), but the whole point of the modern ones I've met IS "family" and spending time with children. Even South Park pulled their punches when sending up the Mormons (wimps!).

Heck (or should I say, "oh my heck"), their mandatory "family night" and creepy cultish "extended family" way of running business and their church is their most successful hook for new recruits. Saying they hate their kids really won't work.

1. "(Utah)...with a high percentage of religious families who might want tax dollars for their church’s schools."
As with most voucher schemes, this isn't really just about "wanting" tax dollars for schools -- a more accurate phrase would be TAX GRAB. If one "wants" tax dollars to subsidize the religious private schools their children are ALREADY going to, that's simply a TAX GRAB, as in "Gimme some tax funds to subsidize my personal, private choice....Oh, and let's screw over and bankrupt the public school system while you're feeding me at my trough."

2. "Voucher supporter Overstock.com chief executive Patrick Byrne - who bankrolled the voucher effort - called the referendum a “statewide IQ test” that Utahns failed."
GREAT! PERFECT!!! Use that phrase over and over in counter-ads the next time a voucher scheme gets on the ballot in Utah or neighboring states. "This is the attitude -- the arrogant greed -- of those behind this pro-voucher scheme who want to grab your tax dollars to subsidize their children's private schools."

3. DO. NOT. BUY. ANY. OF. OVERSTOCK.COM'S. USELESS. CRAP.

Well, as some people have pointed out, Utah Mormons just don't have the tradition of supporting private schools. I haven't had much contact with the LDS Church for many years now, but I know that some have started doing home schooling. In the more rural parts of the state just about everyone is Mormon, so the question of separation of church and state becomes somewhat moot. The Wasatch Front is more like other parts of the West, but there just isn't a tradition of private schools. There is always an LDS "seminary" just off-campus from the high school for religion classes, but it's not officially part of the public school, and other religious groups can get release-time for a religion class if they have the numbers to do so.

There is a historically based distrust of the federal government in Utah that goes back to the conflicts that the territory had with the US in the nineteenth century. Utah Mormons tend to be very conservative, very patriotic, and very compliant with authority. But you push them hard enough and they'll go over to this historically based defiance. I think this may be what happened with NCLB. The government started messing with their kids. Now it's rich people aligned with the government trying to mess with the schools again. The rethugs shouldn't assume they can do anything they want with these people just because it's always been a red state.

Overstock.com was heavily involved with that whole "swift boat" crap from before the last presidential election.

You folks need to pay more attention.

Thanks for the tip, guys; now we'll be buying a whole lot more at overstock.com!

I've lived in Utah for over 30 years, and the public schools have been consistently under-funded because the Utah lege is dominated by far-right yokels from Kane County and other rural districts (the "cowboy caucus") who refuse to spend any money on public education. The whole voucher thing was just yet another attempt to create what I've always called Mormon Madrassas, where they can teach the holy writ according to Peepstone Joe without any state interference (although, as someone pointed out, there is a Mormon seminary next to every public school above grade school in the state). The same applies to the higher education system here; "why spend money on them danged 'UU-niversities' where people are taught to ask questions and become homos and do drugs, when we have the Lard's own BYU right down the freeway?", and where people are most definitely taught NOT to ask questions. Seriously, I've also sent two kids through Utah public schools and both have gotten great educations. The Utah lege are the lords of privatization; despite overwhelming evidence, they bow down before the private sector like some idol (perhaps because they're all bought and paid for by lobbyists!) With very few execptions, you won't find a more corrupt nor more sanctimonious and self-righteous bunch of pricks anywhere.

Glad to see the link to wasatchwatchers, I'll start reading it now!

They don't even win with class, they have to twist the knife even when the winning was gained by cheating. So of course they could never lose with class. They're bullies, that's what they do, knock you down and gloat or being knocked down, cry.

Yes, Byrne could lose with dignity if he had owned it.

signature: “I like to drink coffee before bed. I dream faster.” (c) Steven Wright: Coffee and cigarettes.

70 comments

Login or Register to post comments.