Go Home

Senator John McCain's Born Identity

[Note: First an appearance from Lawrence O'Donnell's The Last Word on this topic, below my weekly column at AJE.]

What does he want? Revenge. For what? Being born.

This is the way famous gunslinger Doc Holliday answers equally famous lawman and good friend Wyatt Earp’s inquiry - in their depiction in the movie Tombstone - into why their sworn enemy, Johnny Ringo, is such a misanthrope.

Sadly, this description would be equally accurate in explaining the actions of another Arizona transplant filled with endless rage: Senator John McCain.

I first encountered the seething side of McCain when I was writing my 2008 book, The Real McCain, which was critical of him while pointing out a then-controversial fact, one no longer in dispute among those who lionized him back then: Namely, that the Led Zeppelin-groupie relationship he then enjoyed with many in the media was based on a faulty premise.

John McCain was not a maverick (which he has since admitted after long identifying with the title), but a man driven by a need to fight. To fight for his own redemption, to fight with those who dared disagree with him, and most particularly, to fight with anyone who had delivered him a perceived humiliation of any sort. Think Yosemite Sam on a bender, or Vladimir Putin in those half-naked martial arts pictures.

Sure, McCain was also motivated by the very same political expediency which drives too many politicos, as well as coveting an appearance on the Sunday morning talk circuit, the way an ambitious twenty-something blonde does meeting Edward Pattinson, or marrying Hugh Hefner.

But the driving force for McCain has been pure vitriol and spite. When I first pointed out this inconvenient truth in my book -- that many Republicans, including some willing to go on the record, were sure McCain was motivated by demons and not decency -- I was criticized or dismissed in many quarters. Yet, it was obvious to me back then that his battles with fellow Republicans and Democrats had become personal, crusades for the eternally perturbed Abe Simpson stand-in.

I broke two stories in my book that spoke to McCain’s temperament, first that he had physically assaulted a member of his own party after taunting him (Republican Representative Rick Renzi), and second, that he had called his wife a very not-safe-for-work term of non-endearment. In perhaps an emblematic McCain moment, during a policy meeting with a fellow Republican, McCain “called the guy a ‘sh—head.’ The senator demanded an apology. McCain stood up and said, ‘I apologize, but you’re still a sh—head.’”

There’s a reason the dude was nicknamed “McNasty” in high school.

So when others still saw McCain’s breaking from President Bush on taxes, healthcare, the environment and gun control in the early 2000s as a sign of “independence,” I tried to point out what I had learned: He was just doing it because he hated Bush for beating him in the primaries. And when others saw his loss to then-Senator Barack Obama and thought he’d work with Obama to display his maverickyness once Obama was sworn in, I warned that in all likelihood we’d see McCain once again do his best Judge Elihu Smails impression.

But even I couldn’t have expected how truly ridiculous he’s become. As Deputy Political Director Michael McMurray of NBC News pointed out in a tweet just before Christmas, outside of Afghanistan, “the AZ senator didn't support any major Obama WH policy in '09-'10.” In fact, it has been much worse than that.

Bush’s tax cuts for top earners, immigration reform, a nuclear arms treaty and even a military suicide prevention bill were not worthy of McCain’s support during the last two weeks. Not supporting a bill to prevent military suicides? Really? It’s almost like this particular Scrooge got a visit from the Ghost of Christmas Crazy while napping after an especially large portion of Quaker Oats.

As journalist David Corn recently pointed out, looking at McCain’s increasingly desperate attacks against repealing the Don’t Ask Don’t Tell policy of allowing gays to serve in the military only if they were as vocal as a Buddhist Monk about who they really were, “…McCain practically threw a tantrum on the Senate floor, decrying ‘this bizarro world’ and denouncing senators in favor of repeal…Looking as if steam would shoot out of his ears at any moment, McCain went on to exclaim that ending DADT would endanger ’the survival of our young men and women in the military.’"

Of course, as Corn also wrote, “Not only had McCain flip-flopped, he had become an angry crusader, seemingly full of rage at a policy initiative he once quasi-endorsed…It seemed more personal than policy -- as in he really doesn't fancy seeing a victory for President Obama, the fellow who prevented McCain from becoming BMOC.”

That is really the gist of it, and it’s at the heart of who McCain has been his entire time in Washington, whether most journalists have been willing to see it or not. He’s not a statesman, nor has he ever been. He’s a petulant bomb thrower. He’s Simon Cowell in a suit.

In fact, in a slightly alternative universe, it wouldn’t really be all that hard to imagine McCain standing on a Times Square street corner screaming at passersby that they all deserve to go to hell, or challenging random strangers to a fight to the death using sticks to determine who gets his clay marble collection.

But in this one, he was just elected to another 6-year Senate term. And that tells you a helluva lot about the predicament in which we currently find ourselves as a nation.

[Follow Me On Twitter: @cliffschecter]

Share This Post

Link To This Post


34 Comments
Artist formerly known as gempei's picture

Vladimir Putin will just make me lose dinner.

Old Denny's picture
Why

would McCain have his Navy records sealed so that no one could see them?

His base is also Arpaio's base: the nearly-deads.


"Courtesy is owed. Respect is earned. Love is given." --Unknown author, found in Guide to Texas Etiquette by Kinky Friedman

Mc Joe Stalin and the evil dumb bitch.

All of you Democrats = Republicans assholes need to chew on that.

kingdom2000's picture

It has been very clear over the last year that at his core McCain is an egomaniac whore. He has not real soul but only believes whatever will get him the praise he thinks he already deserves. As a huge egomaniac whore, that means any criticism is just you being too stupid to see why he is right (even if why he is right seems to change with whoever his audience is).

I believe that McCain, when he admitted to caving to torture as a POW, was probably directly responsible for no telling how many American deaths with whatever information he leaked (and keep in mind he had access to admirals) as he has shown a williness to cave at every opportunity on stances both big and small. You don't flop around, give up your moral stances with such ease as he does and yet still claim that in something as high pressure and terrifying as being a POW that somehow managed to not reveal information that cost lives. The McCain we see daily just doesn't match the story that McCain has been selling for decades.

Last in his class at Navy, crashed multiple planes, bombed and murdered civilians, snitch ass POW, left devoted wife because an auto accident made her unappealing(no mirrors at Johnny's home), Keating 5, opposed MLK holiday, introduced Palin, mad at America for voting in the Black dude...

Grandjester's picture

at Annapolis, fifth from the bottom, but IIRC at least one of those below him died during the term.

RayMD's picture

"snitch ass POW" is about as absolutely depraved a remark one can make about a person who went through God knows what for 5 years?

I don't like an awful lot about this man's doings.... but that ignorant, depraved remark is about as low as you can get.

By the way, fuck you.
Stick your ass in a fucking VC prison and let them torture you to this side of death.

You tell us brave-ass just how tough you are....and what you wouldn't beg like a screaming child to have stopped.

Fuck you.

towntalk's picture

"snitch ass POW" is about as absolutely depraved a remark one can make about a person who went through God knows what for 5 years?"

Agreed.

Mike The Riverine's picture

The Uniform Code of Miliary Justice Article 105 states:

"“Any person subject to this chapter who, while in the hands of the enemy in time of war—
(1) for the purpose of securing favorable treatment by his captors acts without proper authority in a manner contrary to law, custom, or regulation, to the detriment of others of whatever nationality held by the enemy as civilian or military prisoners; or
(2) while in a position of authority over such persons maltreats them without justifiable cause; shall be punished as a court-martial may direct.”

As McCain did inform while a POW, and was released by the North Vietnamese for his cooperation, and was not tried via court martial, I would say being called a "snitch-ass POW" is the least punishment he's ever gotten.

My Vietnam Service Ribbon officially gives me the right to call this prick a traitor, no matter low long the NVA held him. He's a fuck-up, and worse, a nasty old bastard. If we had an officer like him, he would have gotten fragged in his tent.


Democratic Party progressive, Vietnam veteran and proud Union member for 41 years

RayMD's picture

Clearly, I don't know enough about McCain's service.

"He was shot down October 26, 1967, and by November 9, 1967 he was giving interviews to foreign correspondents, providing information on his prior command, casualties and tactics, in direct violation of the Code of Conduct. (The U.S. military Code of Conduct is the definitive code specifying the responsibilities of American military personnel while in combat or captivity. Article V of the Code is very specific in ordering U.S. military personnel to avoid answering questions to the utmost of their ability and to make no oral or written statements disloyal to the United States and its allies, or harmful to their cause. Any willful violation of the Code is considered collaborating with the enemy.)

The Communist Vietnamese erected a bust of John McCain beside the lake where he was shot down. His defenders say that this is a tribute to the PAVN gunners that shot him down.

In the interview that he gave on November 9, 1967 to VNA International, he claims when he bailed out and landed in the lake, that locals pulled him out and took him to the hospital. Yet in the U.S. News and World Report - May 14, 1973. McCain is quoted as saying "I think it was on the fourth day (after being shot down) that two guards came in, instead of one. One of them pulled back the blanket to show the other guard my injury. I looked at my knee. It was about the size of a football . . . when I saw it, I said to the guard, Ok, get the officer'...an officer came in after a few minutes. It was the man that we came to know very well as 'The Bug'. He was a psychotic torturer, one of the worst fiends that we had to deal with. I said, Ok, I'll give you military information if you will take me to the hospital."

While testifying before the Senate Select Committee, the very man McCain claims was responsible for his own torture, his interrogator, "The Bug" was appearing. When the moment of confrontation came, McCain rose from his seat, walked from the podium to the floor and stood face to face with the man who was responsible for torturing him and countless other Prisoners of War...McCain then grabbed the man and embraced him!" http://www.farfromglory.com/john_s_mccain.htm

You don't owe an apology raymd, except for citing farfromglory.com

You were right with your first comment that "snitch ass pow" was a depraved remark. McCain's experience as a POW in Viet Nam does not make him more qualified to serve as Senator or President. But then, his experience as a POW doesn't warrant an attack either.

That farfromglory.com crap is as a vile an attack as the Swift Boaters perpetrated on John Kerry

LeftandLeft's picture
[Comment Deleted By Administration For Violation Of Terms Of Service]
glogrrl's picture

man's daughter to advance his senatorial career.


“The greatest evildoers are those who don’t remember because they have never given thought to the matter, and, without remembrance, nothing can hold them back,”

Biff Limbaugh's picture

sorry cliff but i haven't had the chance to read your book but is the real smoking gun/achillies heel mccain's p.o.w. experience? which is never challenged.

Why would anyone bother insulting a person who has come to epitomize "stupid" to the degree that this man does do stupid in the flesh? He has never been one of the sharper knives in the drawer from the very start of his Naval career to his running for the Senate and the Presidency. The man is without question intellectually deficient which leads him into all sorts of situations and clashes with others over which he has no control of either the circumstances or his own responses. Let's give the worn out, beat up, over wrought chap a break and just simply ignore him. Let him rant. Don't listen. Don't respond. Let him blather on and on and on. He is in the minority....in more ways than one.

Regarding the voters of Arizona, well, let's just give them two passes on the quality of their judgment.....one for McCain and the other for their governor. Two-for-two sort of sums them up, eh?

Holy Moly!!

cmac50's picture

Sure, McCain was also motivated by the very same political expediency which drives too many politicos, as well as coveting an appearance on the Sunday morning talk circuit, the way an ambitious twenty-something blonde does meeting Edward Pattinson, or marrying Hugh Hefner.

I agree with everything you say about McCain, but this paragraph is not good. It really isn't. First of all, even this 60-ish grandmother knows that ROBERT Pattinson plays a character named EDWARD who has no place in the dreams of twenty-somethings; he's more of a teen-idol kinda guy. Furthermore, it's a rare twenty-something blonde who wants to meet Hugh Hefner. The man strikes most people under the age of 70 as a randy old goat. Girls who set their caps for him need therapy, and not for their ambitions. Finally, since you seem to have missed it, we are in an age in which ambitious twenty-something women, whether blonde, brunette, or redhead, are looking for jobs with six-figure salaries and ladders to the top. Boyfriends don't figure in this meme.

It's okay. Just delete the paragraph and carry on.

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

Hef just married a 24 year old.


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

glogrrl's picture

Translation: he's boinking her, but he'll never marry her. Why buy a cow when you can get the milk for free?


“The greatest evildoers are those who don’t remember because they have never given thought to the matter, and, without remembrance, nothing can hold them back,”

Margaret's picture

I'm so glad to be able to read you again. I've missed you in the two plus years since I decided to stop giving Aravosis any of my traffic. Yeah, it's been obvious to all but the DC toady media that McCain is just a bitter, angry old man. The only principles he has are the kind that seek revenge.


Barack Obama: Change we can only imagine

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

Diabolus est Deus Inversus

Kreskin's picture

Are any of these Republicans balanced ? McCain has lived a lie all of his adult life ... at least , the only reason he got anywhere is because of his daddy and Arizonans , the majority of them proving to be assholes and fools , I mean how else can you explain that wretched bitch Brewer actually being elected ( this time ) governor and this McCain psycho being elected yet again after his performance of the last two years in particular ? Good write Cliff .


"The poor have sometimes objected to being governed badly; the rich have always objected to being governed at all."

Ape-Man's picture

I honestly think all the balanced republicans have quit, retired, or gone independent.


"Government by organized money is just as dangerous as Government by organized mob"
-= Franklin Delano Roosevelt =-

dadams's picture

mclame is exactly what happens when
a senile old self-important asswipe can't
tell his morning cereal bowl from the toilet bowl
and digs right in.

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

What kind of prize did he find?


Diabolus est Deus Inversus

MtnWoman's picture

Evan Thomas did a profile on McCain in Feb 2008 and to me this excerpt does a lot to explain McCain:

"He has been preoccupied with escaping the shadow of his father and establishing his own image and identity in the eyes of others," reads a psychiatric evaluation in McCain's medical files. "He feels his experiences and performance as a POW have finally permitted this to happen." Released after the 1973 Peace Accords, McCain returned to the United States a hero. "Felt fulfillment when his Dad was introduced at a dinner as 'Commander McCain's father.' He had arrived," noted the psychiatric report in 1974."

http://www.newsweek.com/2008/02/02/what-these...

Remember McCain didn't have some grand idea for governing. In his book "Worth Fighting For: A Memoir" he said he was running for President because it had become his ambition.

"I didn't decide to run for President to start a national crusade for the political reforms I believed in or to run a campaign as if it were some grand act of patriotism. In truth, I wanted to be President because it had become my ambition to be President. I was sixty-two years old when I made the decision and I thought it was my one shot at the prize."

I think what he really wanted to do was surpass his father - he may not have become an Admiral but damn it, he became the President!

JohnnyBravo's picture

Who voted for this bitter old man?


NOBODY 2012

ysbaddaden's picture
)O(

Diabolus est Deus Inversus

cpinva's picture

But in this one, he was just elected to another 6-year Senate term. And that tells you a helluva lot about the predicament in which we currently find ourselves as a nation.

is that the people that voted for him are just as clinically insane as the sen. is. i have no sympathy for them.

Ape-Man's picture

Ya, seriously.
But then Crashy McShortbus is an old school bigot, just like them. That's all that counts for some people. And if he isn't an old school bigot, then he's got to be one of the most misunderstood people ever.


"Government by organized money is just as dangerous as Government by organized mob"
-= Franklin Delano Roosevelt =-

MN-Sunshine's picture

Personally, I think McCain is trying to do two things.

First, I think he is sucking up to the Republicans who were disappointed that he, their choice for President, failed to win the election. They put a lot of stock in him and he failed them. So he's trying to show what a great Republican he is by opposing anything supported by Democrats, especially Obama.

Secondly, McCain is stuck in candidate mode. As a candidate, if Obama said Yes, McCain said No, if Obama said Tastes Great, McCain said Less Filling. If McCain were to agree with anything Obama wants now, then McCain would be conceding that he shared opinions with Obama and maybe people were justified in voting for Obama. McCain needs to continue to prove to the world that Obama is wrong, wrong, wrong, and that the people who voted for him were wrong, wrong, wrong.

cordandwire's picture

It appears his character has been consistent. But now that he's old he's just mean spirited and addled. A great republican fit for Lindsey and Joey to pal around with. Can't you see them peeping on McCain and Palin out back?!

McGrumpy's erratic behavior is his age. Not to besmirch the elderly, but it's true that certain personality traits become more pronounced as one ages. The elderly also become more set in their ways. McCain could even suffer from early dementia without anyone knowing it. The guy is in his mid 70's for crying out loud. Given his history, is it surprising he acts like an unreasonable grumpy old man? He needs to retire.

snoozie's picture

It doesn't take a shrink to see that McCain has - and has had for many decades - serious mental health issues. Other than his rapidly approaching senility, which has also been noticeable for some time, "age" has nothing to do with what ails this man. In fact, speaking as someone being fairly close in age to the cowpoke, I hope you remember these words when you're in your 70s and realize just how ignorant you sounded in your youth.

Comments are closed on this entry