Wingnuts can't resist linking immigrants to swine flu; Olbermann can't resist slamming them for it
By David Neiwert Wednesday Apr 29, 2009 9:00am
Keith Olbermann, on Countdown last night, brought the whammy down on the wingnut talking heads at Fox (and the rest of the conservative media as well) for their ongoing attempts to blame immigrants for the spread of the swine flu from Mexico:
Well, yes, you are a racist. Exactly how does that apply, though, to the people who the Centers for Disease Control confirmed actually carried the Swine Flu from Mexico to the U.S., a group of Catholic school students from New York City, who spent Spring Break in Cancun. Uncontrolled Catholic immigration, open borders for private school kids reckless?
Anyway, unswayed by the facts, the Republican echo chamber tried to stir the American melting pot with a classic recipe of hate and fear.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: I thought that this line, though, was very ironic, this morning in one of the articles I read about surveillance at the Mexican border. You thought we had an immigration problem, well now we might actually want to prevent the sick people from crossing over the border.
UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Chaos in Mexico; from earthquakes to Swine Flu, will it mean more illegals heading for the U.S.
GLENN BECK, FOX NEWS ANCHOR: Does anybody wish maybe we could control the border just a little bit at this point.
SHEPPARD SMITH, FOX NEWS ANCHOR: Everybody is e-mailing, going the illegals are bringing it across the border. Relax.
SEAN HANNITY, FOX NEWS ANCHOR: Tonight, Swine Flu spreads from Mexico to the United States. Is this the latest border crisis.
UNIDENTIFIED MALE: The U.S. is not currently testing travelers from Mexico. But customs officials are wearing protective clothing.
MICHAEL SAVAGE, “THE SAVAGE NATION”: Illegal aliens are carriers of the new strain of Human Swine Avian Flu from Mexico. Is this a terrorist attack?
UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Some, though, say the solution is to close the border.
UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Now talk that we should even close the border?
BECK: If this is so important, why haven‘t we closed the border.
NEAL BOORTZ, “THE NEAL BOORTZ SHOW”: There‘s the bio-terrorism angle. What better way to sneak a virus in this country than to give it to Mexicans.
This kind of talk -- directly associating the targets of a "drive them out" campaign with disease -- is classic eliminationist rhetoric. It's not surprising that it's bubbling up out of Fox News' fetid cauldron, either.
Tom Allison at Media Matters put together a first-round look at some of the ugliness:
-- Savage declaring that Mexicans "are a perfect mule -- perfect mules for bringing this virus into America."
-- Michelle Malkin warning that the pandemic was the product of "uncontrolled immigration."
-- Beck warning that the pandemic will create a crush of people trying to flee north across our border.
And that's just scratching the surface. As Eric Ward at Imagine 2050 observes, some of the nativist right's more inflammatory figures were saying even uglier things.
Writes Nezua at The Sanctuary:
The stances of those who most vocally oppose immigration today are so predictable that one could paint a face on a septic-tainted soccer ball and paste up word balloons and rest well, knowing that The Nativist Lobby point of view on any immigration-related topic will end in "deport them all" and "seal the borders" if not "round them up" and other tired ideas. And nobody reading now needs a reminder of how throughout time, both Latin America as well as all immigrants have been slurred and painted with the brush of disease by those resistant to changing demographics.
The NCLR's blog points out that this fearmongering has real life-and-death consequences:
It's unfortunate, then, that certain individuals with an obvious axe to grind are shamelessly exploiting a public health emergency for their own purposes. It's not surprising that some are implying that all immigrants are a threat to our health-that's standard fare on the hate group circuit.
Ironically, the very act of attempting to demonize and stigmatize entire groups, and even entire countries, is likely to impede these and other critical steps that the authorities are taking to protect all Americans from the spread of the flu, for example:
* If affected individuals are driven underground and deterred from seeking treatment or reporting their illness, it will hamper the authorities' ability to accurately track the disease's progress, or to develop the most effective vaccines.
* Once an outbreak is identified, its containment is dependent to a great extent on having as many people as possible adhere to protections the government might authorize, such as reductions in public events or closures of public facilities. Open, inclusive communication through the media and community organizations is essential to the success of such strategies, which may be undermined if some population groups are excluded.
Here's a video Media Matters assembled:
From the Media Matters report by Allison:
During the April 24 edition of his nationally syndicated radio show, Michael Savage stated: "Make no mistake about it: Illegal aliens are the carriers of the new strain of human-swine avian flu from Mexico." Savage also stated, "If we lived in saner times, the borders would be closed immediately." Savage went on to theorize that the outbreak might be part of a bioterrorism threat: "[C]ould this be a terrorist attack through Mexico? Could our dear friends in the radical Islamic countries have concocted this virus and planted it in Mexico knowing that you, [Homeland Security Secretary] Janet Napolitano, would do nothing to stop the flow of human traffic from Mexico?" Savage continued: "[T]hey are a perfect mule -- perfect mules for bringing this virus into America. But you wouldn't think that way, would you? Because you are incapable of protecting America's homeland, Napolitano." Savage also stated: "How do you protect yourself? What can you do? I'll tell you what I'm going to do, and I don't give a damn if you don't like what I'm going to say. I'm going to have no contact anywhere with an illegal alien, and that starts in the restaurants." He added, "I will have no any illegal alien workers around me. I will not have them in any of my properties, I will not have them anywhere near me."
During the April 27 edition of his nationally syndicated radio show, Neal Boortz asked: "[W]hat better way to sneak a virus into this country than give it to Mexicans? Right? I mean, one out of every 10 people born in Mexico is already living up here, and the rest are trying to get here. So you give -- you give -- you let this virus just spread in Mexico, where they don't have a CDC." Boortz went on to say: "So if you want to get that epidemic into this country, get it going real good and hot south of the border. And, you know, then just spread a rumor that there's construction jobs available somewhere, and here it comes. Because we're not gonna do anything to stop them from coming across the border."
In an April 25 blog post titled "Hey, maybe we'll finally get serious about borders now," syndicated columnist and Fox News contributor Michelle Malkin suggested that the outbreak was due to the United States' "uncontrolled immigration," writing: "I've blogged for years about the spread of contagious diseases from around the world into the U.S. as a result of uncontrolled immigration. We've heard for years from reckless open-borders ideologues who continue to insist there's nothing to worry about. And we've heard for years that calling any attention to the dangers of allowing untold numbers of people to pass across our borders and through our other ports of entry without proper medical screening -- as required of every legal visitor/immigrant to this country -- is RAAAACIST." Malkin added: "9/11 didn't convince the open-borders zealots to put down their race cards and confront reality. Maybe the threat of their sons or daughters contracting a deadly virus spread from south of the border to their Manhattan prep schools will." Contrary to Malkin's suggestion, an April 27 Associated Press article reported of the New York City high school students infected with swine flu to whom she referred: "Officials think they started getting sick after some students returned from the spring break trip to Cancun."
Additionally, on the April 27 edition of his nationally syndicated radio show, Fox News host Glenn Beck stated: "Gee, it would be nice if we had border security now, wouldn't it?" Beck went on to assert: "But if you are a family and you're down in Mexico and you're dying and those in America are not, why wouldn't you flood this border? Why wouldn't you come across this border? It's exactly what I warned of -- different scenario, different reason of -- I was talking about economic collapse. People start to come and rush this border, then what happens? Gee, it would be nice if we had some border security."
More at America's Voice.








Login or Register to post comments.
And, typically, not one Native American in the bunch.
... like a group of militant Catholics trying to impose the nativity imagery over Santa Claus in a battle for Christmas supremacy.
The really crazy thing is that there has been one death in america from swine flu, while there has been thousands of deaths in america from regular flu, yet the CNN hosts have spent three solid days on the subject, and they are still at it. Get a grip CNN. Let's get some perspective on the news, and stop avoiding the torture and wiretapping stories! We see you CNN! Can you hear us?
How long should we watch Cooper Anderson struggle with the same questions day after day after day. Is that for his benefit, because obviously it's not helping. He just goes around and around.
The new old gop (grope, offload, piss) bastards trying to keep the USA pure and white.
Does anyone actually believe this shit? More than the 1% of child and women haters?
to write a complete list of every group the GOP is against?
I have a 1TB drive if that may help.
sure is an interesting person....
NUTTER ALERT!!!
The Pride of Oral Roberts University.
Avian Flu's more of an Asian thang
So should we blame (gri)malkin and family?
Deport them
It's the Christians' fault! If they would stop eating that unclean pork, none of this would happen. The swine!
They put lipstick on it and everything!
malkin's lipstick is smeared.
for the shoe fetish!
Israeli Deputy Health Minister Yakov Litzman apparently feels that "swine flu" is offensive to Jews and Muslims so he prefers the "Mexican Flu" label.
But while Mr. Litzman is obviously quite sensitive to the pigs' concerns, he has apparently not considered the concerns of Mexican nationals.
Nor the swine industry.
Unless you are Native American or Mexican, you came here to this country as an immigrant. All of those white faces on the TV telling us to fear immigrants are immigrants.
originally get here from Asia, anyway?
We are ALL immigrants.
Humans either more or less evolved from an area in africa or asia....or we all magically appeared in a garden somewhere in the middle east.
Born here, raised here, American Citizen here and everywhere I go! Maybe my grandparents immigrated and became citizens but I know where I was born and to who, or is it "whom", I can never remember. Glad that isn't on a Citizenship test.
Yes, and when you get down to it, all life on Earth came from somewhere else so please..let's talk about the FLU.
I suppose it's true that Native Americans migrated here a few millenia ago. How many generations must you & yours be in one place before you're considered a "native"?
if the answer to the question is "him" then it's "whom".
so to whom are you speaking? to him
who is a crazy, nut? Lou Dobb's...I mean "HE" is.
Due to objections from the swine industry they are considering a new name for the swine flu. So far it's a tie between calling it "M1A1" or "bacon lung".
TO be honest....WE are the Martians.
Racism is everywhere. Here in Korea: Everything Korean = good/excellent/BEST. Everything bad = foreign import.
Did you know, there are NO gay Koreans? It's an American disease brought here by American G.I.s. So is AIDS. No good Korean boy could be, or is, gay!!! And only foreigners have AIDS. (facts don't matter)
Cockroaches never existed here, until foreigners came. Etc., etc.
It wearies me.
Though there appears to be anecdotal evidence to support Asian explorers reaching the West Coast and parts of South America (c/f "1421: The Year China Discovered the World" by Gavin Menzies).
Sorry, I repeated.....computer is fouling up.
They tend to repeat on you.
:)
I knew after I posted this, I'd get a fart joke....I'm just surprised it took this long. ;)
...invaded this nation infecting the native countrymen/women with various deadly plagues. The careers of Malkin, Beck, Savage, et al are totally depended on the ignorance of their listeners.
Mexican-American/Native American woman was sitting in a college classroom listening to the professor rant and rave about the promiscuity of Native women, and the STDs they eventually gave Europe. If I hadn't felt so small and ashamed, I might have reminded him of the European men's diseased d--ks...
I thank her all the time for teaching me the awful truth. There are many Americans who are completely ignorant to their own history, and a few who know the truth and are too ashamed to discuss it.
*
Now, if only Fox News can work President of the United States, Barak Hussein Obama into it somehow. Wait, wait... wasn't Hussein Obama in Mexico just a short while ago? Oh shitttttttt. It was Obama that brought it back. Or wait... wasn't Hilary down there too. It was Clinton's fault. Of course it was.
..and the tour guide at the Museum died the next day.
no, no. for 8 years everything was Clinton's fault. Now everything is Obama's fault.
I wonder if the wingnuts are going to harp on the very real possibility that a US corporation operating down in Mexico is responsible for the outbreak? It seems that Smithfield Farms is operating a pig farm very near ground zero which has little regard for basic sanitation. It's been making people sick miles around it for months.
Hurray for the free mexican market!
Same shit, different day.
Savage clearly doesn't understand that aerosol transmission is an imperfect vector at best. I doubt swine flu is 100% contagious - meaning, if you're in a room with an infected subject, everyone isn't going to catch it, and if those people then go home, everyone in their immediate family isn't going to catch it, then everyone in the neighborhood, then everyone in the city, then everyone in the state, then everyone in the country, then we'll all be dead.
And, no, terrorists are not going to use Mexico as an incubator. Biological warfare isn't the same as Six Degrees of Kevin Bacon. You can't count on sufficient numbers of infected people crossing the border to initiate a second wave of infection in the United States.
But if the ter'ists infect Kevin Bacon.... hmmmmmmm?
'Cause my Bacon Number is 3. (That makes yours 4.)
We're all doomed!
Bacon.....
Wait a'min. Bacon, pork, swine, flu.... THE BASTARDS!
Michelle Malkin hasn't been deported to the Philippines yet?
She came back with teh flu.
Excellent article (Guardian UK) about the probable origins of the Swine Flu AND the global lack of preparedness for this outbreak, which was accurately predicted a few years ago.
The swine flu crisis lays bare the meat industry's monstrous power
For instance:
are a sorry outrage. Overcrowding, pumped full of every kind of drug and antibiotic. Do a little research on the life the hen on your dinner table had, or the ham or steak for that matter. The food industrial complex is bad news for all.
Driver's license check, credit rating, internet romance compatability ratings. I prefer little red hens, but when they are not available I try Free Range hens from free states.
I tried to do just that on a single Chicken McNugget. (I'm going to need a bigger internet.)
you cannot be sure they are from identifiable hens or that they didn't come from Scotch eggs.
I don't think anyone can convince a majority of people (worldwide) to give up meat, no matter how many gory facts are released. My answer has been to cut my meat intake to about one-fifth of what it was before. If everyone cut back... Take away the market.
last night in Leno's monologue/pre-show stand up ......he said what does Wal-Mart call people coming up
from mexico........'employees' blaming the flu epidemic on anyone is unfounded. i do have an opinion that may not be very popular on this site. i'm for controlling/reducing immigration. for me it's about space NOT race. i just believe people should be here legally. i feel illegal/undocumented workers have been a NET liability to this country. the cost burden is shifted/subsidized to/by the TAX paying public. this has been a strategy by the corporations to reduce wages and the ability to bargain. currently i believe this issue is so big that nothing will get done. so these people will continue to be taken avantage of "cheap labor"/sex trade.
You'll get much flaming for stating a rational, nuanced opinion. So you're fine.
Plus, legal immigration is just fine, I imagine for just about anybody of any political stripe. It's demonizing or scapegoating of immigrants as a group that bakes my cheese.
Specifically, that "illegal" immigrants could be "legal" if they wished. Not true -- especially as regards Mexican immigrants. The underlying problem is not immigrants avoiding a "legal" path, it's that most immigration has been made "illegal."
On the other hand, you're spot on as far as corporate motivations IMHO.
it could be......regardless i'm against illegal/undocumented workers. overall a NET liability to this country. especially the last 20 yrs. with ability to get work and ease of getting in/out of this country
maybe many aren't concerned about becoming legal. although i do recall the marches in 2006. these people work here most often as "cheap labor" and taken advantage of. they often send a good amount of money back to mexico. i just think it should be controlled. lawmakers don't want to do anything because of big business(big box stores,construction,warehousing,agriculture). personally, i believe it's a component/element to the crisis that exist today the economic income gap
between the haves and have nots.
....bedwetting, chickenshit, blubbering, insane, incoherent blabbermouth?
[sighs, takes a deep breath, and tries to feel sympathy for whatever basic humanity still exists in these cretins]
Wear a mask before taking too deep a breath....or you'll be soooorrrryyyyy.
... I can't picture these loons getting a sentence out without spraying the place with saliva.
You'd think that maybe THEY have the Rush Flu already, feverish doodoo-heads that they are.
the French, Bonkers?
...they're...they're French, for starters. Geez!
(I totally jest. Got me some French blood, as a matter of fact)
i just laugh my head off everytime
is see that pic of michelle malkin
keith uses. malkin looks like she
is under dick cheney's desk just
s#cking away. she could probably
peel chrome off a bumper.
EXCEPT THAT the Government is sitting on 50 million doses of Tamiflu they got with a NO-BID Contract from Donald Rumsfeld's old company after scaring the pants off everybody over "bird flu", and this stuff has a SHELF-LIFE! If they can't peddle it to a panic-stricken public they will have to throw it away! FOLLOW THE MONEY! >>> BUSH!
Maybe republicans can appoint a czar and declare "war on
micro-organisms."
You think that the government's having to throw something away has ever bothered a politician?
...I can think of one particular blue dress that would have saved us all a lot of heartache had it been thrown in a landfill rather than stuffed in a friggin' Hope Chest.
:D
(hah...Clenis jokes...normally the province of wingnuts, but I couldn't resist)
I knew they had several states, including Texas. I am sorry to hear about Canada.
Did I use the wrong word? Please replace with substitute in order to make sense of my post.
The irony here is that they are hyperventilating and frothing at the mouth over what is so far a nonevent in the US. Mexico appears to have a healthcare problem (I am not sure it is a "crisis" even there), and that is reason for federal officials here to be vigilant, but there is absolutely no crisis in the US as yet. That is not to say there could not be one in the near future, but that as of right now there is really nothing to see.
just might have a little problem in her bid to be a white supremecist.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJkHykGRXrw
They'll have her doing their laundry.
Time to start treating the media the way they treat us. I'm sick of being lied to and manipulated on a daily basis.
That last line he said was hilarious. And why is Shep Smith still on Fox? He's looking like Custer at Little Big Horn these days. He was funny, too, calling out the xenophobes.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WxWxFhkCces
These are the same people that tout the "global economy" as the best thing since sunshine and sliced bread and YET, they want everyone that is different or looks different or has a different culture to stay in their own country (especially the brown skinned people) and to just "show me the money!" but leave my culture alone.
Kinda different sides of the same coin, no?
is unquestionably an American coin and says "In God We Trust."
I love that in the transcripting, the loathsome trifecta of Steve Doocy, Gretchen Carlson and that other dickhead are "unidentified".
Would have been better if they had been referred to as Curly, Larry, and Moe, but now I'm just needlessly nitpicking.
you'd be insulting comedic legends. And, we wouldn't want that, would we?
Malkin is looking bloated and haggard.
think ugly look ugly!
...since, objectively speaking, she's sort of cute. But conservative kool-aid guzzling, like overexposure to the sun, cigarette smoking or a poor diet, will age a person prematurely.
She looks like a fucking fish. As in a fetal alcohol syndrome baby. She's a nasty looking woman. Especially when her mouth is open.
And you clearly have yours. Haha...
I just mean that she isn't deformed, scarred or covered head to toe with hair or something like that (not to attack the deformed, scarred or hirsute people of the world. I am sure they are by and large lovely folks).
Anyway, no:
I don't find her attractive in the least, but that has everything to do with her blackened soul and horrid facial expressions which spring from her vitriol and fearmongering.
Ok, bailing on this! I've gone as far as I would care to go in evaluating someone's personal appearance.
She reminds me of a pirahna and acts like one too. Or one of those crappy asian carp that come flying out of the water when you start your boat motor.
she's into ragtime music.
Michele, your parents were........?
...the one Fox commentator to show a little sense here. Chill, people!
Add Rep. Paul Broun (D-GA) to the list of folks beating this drum - on c-span this morning, right off the bat, he started to blame illegal aliens, and he seemed particularly interested in whether the toddler who died was an illegal alien.
video is here
The whole interview is a hoot.
Broun is a Republican, not a Democrat.
Well the nuns at (gri)malkin's school's warned her
Her face set that way permanently.
latino vote, latino vote, latino vote.....
They only pay attention to Latino concerns every four years, and only then for a couple of weeks.
Mexico. I knew that the xenophobes would have a field day with their despicable "Mexicans have cooties" meme. I even said to someone "Lou Dobbs is going to be all over this one," although I haven't heard any bullshit from him yet.
This situation has almost zero to do with immigration/illegal immigrants, yet that's what all of Fox news want to address. So, instead of discussing ways the world can come together and help save lives in Mexico and elsewhere, they want to discuss racist, ludicrous scenarios that only feed paranoia and advance myopic views on immigration. I am sickened by this nativist bullshit.
I hadn't mentioned this, but one of my aunts is in Baja California right now, and we want her to be able to come home for safety's sake. We're worried. We're worried, and we need solutions.
But the Rethugs are not interested in solutions, only how they can manipulate this scary situation to scapegoat Hispanics in this country. They're beyond contempt and I think beyond help too.
BREAKING NEWS!!!
It has just been reported that the swine flu has been confirmed to have been originated from the deep throat of Fox News' only "Jack-Pot Baby" Michelle (Macalang) Malkin!
Stay tuned for more updates
Are they sure it's really bacon lung and not normal flu? normal flu has killed many thousands you know, and it's everywhere. Maybe Malkin has regular flu.
Seriously? The guys who made it possible for every U.S. company to flee to South of the Border and immediately cut their labour pay to a fraction of what it was?
These guys have the balls to complain about Mexicans?
Are they racist?
Aren't these people attempting to be de-spic-able?
They need not try for they already are.
Keith Olbermann is such a f**king twott.. hes so far left its incredible... I think he should just stfu cuz no one cares about his slamming the right wing conservatives. Hes nothing but Obama's boytoy.
and this is your first comment?
What's the matter, run out of friends to exchange witty banter? Yeah I know. I too have kicked all the right wing scum out of my life.
Welcome :)
when it comes to trolls, don't you agree?
Spoken like someone who has never actually watched Olbermann's show.
Check out this website http://www.swine-flu-tracker.com/ that tracks the spread of swine flu, it really puts things in perspective.
Login or Register to post comments.