Go Home

The Department of Justice's inspector general has finally released its report (434 pg pdf) on the FBI's involvement in detainee interrogations in Guantanamo, Afghanistan and Iraq. Reuters reports that the "Bush administration's top security officials ignored FBI concerns" and that the "FBI, alarmed by interrogation techniques such as the use of snarling dogs and forced nudity, clashed with the Defense Department and CIA over their use." Please do dig into the document and let us know in the comments any parts that may merit more attention. Emptywheel noticed already that "this report does not and cannot discuss the issues that OLC, Condi Rice, and John Ashcroft apparently faced tells you what we need to know about torture." Hmmm?

Also, David Kurtz notes that:

The IG's report has been delayed in part because the Pentagon slow-rolled its review of the report for classified information.

FBI Director Robert Mueller testified to Congress last month that he had "reached out" to the Pentagon and the Department of Justice "in terms of activity that we were concerned might not be appropriate -- let me put it that way." But it was clear from his testimony that the Justice Department's essentially unilateral legalization of torture had prevented the FBI from investigating the abuses its agents witnessed.

For those interested, here is Chairman Conyers' response (via email, after the jump)

"While I take comfort in knowing that, for the most part, FBI field agents followed the agency's policies regarding interrogations, I find it very disturbing that many senior FBI and DOJ officials failed to take strong action after identifying interrogation abuses. It is my hope that upcoming testimony before our Committee from David Addington, John C. Yoo, John Ashcroft, Daniel Levin, and Douglas Feith will help me understand better why these gaps in policy existed and whether Congress needs to take further action. I will also ask FBI Director Robert Mueller and Attorney General Michael Mukasey to testify before the Committee soon about the conclusions in this report.

"This report highlights the lack of consistent policies and what seems to be a dependence on the Office of Legal Counsel's (OLC) well-known torture memos for guidance. Further, when field agents reported harsh interrogation tactics, the OIG found that senior officials in the FBI and the Justice Department failed to take effective action. The discussion of the discredited OLC opinions in this Report makes even more important our Committee's continuing review of the role of Administration lawyers concerning its troubling interrogation policies. Former Attorney General John Ashcroft did not cooperate with the OIG's requests for information but we hope to hear more from him about this as we seek his testimony on this very issue next month."

Highlights from today's report include the following:

· The vast majority of agents in the field acted in accordance with FBI policy. More than 200 FBI agents, however, observed or heard of harsh interrogation techniques by others, in some instances apparently exceeding the guidelines of military interrogation policy.

· The OIG determined that FBI leadership failed both to provide timely and effective guidance to agents about how to respond to such activity, and to take appropriate steps to end such abuses.

· The report concluded that the FBI and DOJ had little impact in changing military interrogation policies at the sites where abuses were found, in part because of much maligned, and since rescinded, Office of Legal Counsel opinions approving harsh interrogation techniques.

Share This Post

Link To This Post


20 Comments
iraqhusseinconcilable's picture

Perhaps the FBI can organize a coup and have everyone in the White House, half of congress , the DOJ and most of the supreme court arrested and thrown in Gitmo . What a nice dream .

Orangutan.'s picture

"If you are not outraged.. You aren't paying attention."

Friar Tuck's picture

Maybe they would be more outraged if one of thier own was found duct tapped and dressed like a woman, displayed on the vegas strip? alive but fully humilitated and well lost thier job too!

Or wait, how to humilate the FBI, ask then more questions then they can answer, get a good lawyer and play back the interrogation tape to the media.

The men in black, dont do jack. Just sit on thier butts and spy on ppl. To me the FBI is like the very old party line phone lines in the early 70s in the sticks. They would gossip all day, listen in on phone calls and then call each other back and gossip more.

The partyline. Protecting your country via the Waltons standards!

The Very Appeasing and Bitter Ceci Hussein's picture

I am not surprised. This is the exact result when people decide to stick their heads in the sand and watch American Idol instead of keeping abreast of the treachery of the government.

I don't know how anyone could sleep knowing that people have been tortured in their country's name.

Does George Bush even sleep?

dadams's picture

The Very Appeasing and Bitter Ceci Hussein @ 4:

I am not surprised. This is the exact result when people decide to stick their heads in the sand and watch American Idol instead of keeping abreast of the treachery of the government.

I don't know how anyone could sleep knowing that people have been tortured in their country's name.

Does George Bush even sleep?

gw does sleep, but it must be very uncomfortable with
cheney's hand always twiching up his ass.

enough's picture

There seems to be a war on in the DOJ. Time for somebody to step up and tell what they know. Time for a few heroes. Everybody seems so cowed, so silent, so unwilling to defend the constitution and the law. Could the Senate Judiciary committee start asking some questions and issuing subpoenas?

The Very Appeasing and Bitter Ceci Hussein's picture

dadams @ 5:

gw does sleep, but it must be very uncomfortable with
cheney's hand always twiching up his ass.

Not to the 28 per-centers who are watching the daily puppet show. To them, it must be like "Punch and Judy". ;)

Lol.

Darrell Kern's picture

The only concern the FBI has is being caught!

Frybread's picture

The Very Appeasing and Bitter Ceci Hussein @ 4:

I am not surprised. This is the exact result when people decide to stick their heads in the sand and watch American Idol instead of keeping abreast of the treachery of the government.

I don't know how anyone could sleep knowing that people have been tortured in their country's name.

Does George Bush even sleep?

He has to drink himself to sleep these days.

tjb's picture

enough @ 6:

There seems to be a war on in the DOJ. Time for somebody to step up and tell what they know. Time for a few heroes. Everybody seems so cowed, so silent, so unwilling to defend the constitution and the law. Could the Senate Judiciary committee start asking some questions and issuing subpoenas?

And how about the start of every Senate Judiciary meeting start with Pat Leahy asking for a report from the highest on the ladder in charge of that Anthrax investigation.
Like how's it going,how many men are on the case? Do you expect any arrests anytime soon? It would seem to me he might be interested in how close they are getting to that creep who is still on the loose.

motorfingaz's picture

"They hate us for our freedoms".

- GW Bush

Winning the "hearts and minds" of muslim people?

Bush apologizes to Iraq over Quran shooting
Government spokesman says words not enough, demands soldier stand trial

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24724080/

GMB's picture

I hate to criticize the ones who weren't actually torturing people, the ones who objected to what they saw, but they don't have telephones? Conyers' and Leahy's offices don't have phones? The New York Times doesn't have phones? I can understand that when witnessing the CIA torturing somebody, it can be a dicey proposition to put the cuffs on them, read them their rights, and get them to a cell in the US. Even if their superiors have no trouble condoning torture, and their statutory authority is limited because it was taking place on soil of ambiguous jurisdiction, there's still a moral obligation to say it is wrong until you find someone that doesn't tell you to shut up and sit down. Isn't there?

Critter's picture

It's crazily redacted. In the section on the other iraq prison (p.232, 233) it describes an agent "ryan" (alias) who reported a military guard saying something redacted. A few paragraphs down, it reveals he was talking about shooting the 6 detainees about to be released in the back.

Someone hung a wanted poster of him in the lounge. He moved to an airport hangar and took the next flight home, feeling people were gunning for him.

He also reported a conversation with an interrogator talking about detainees being stripped naked and sujected to "water interrogation"

MN USA's picture

I'd prefer that sadists not be allowed to act on behalf of my country. Anyone who approved of, oversaw or performed torturous acts on others should be prosecuted for war crimes. For all their talk about morality, the Bush administration seems to have a deficit in that arena.

Paul's picture

This nation must conduct war crimes tribunals. If it cannnot find the will to do it, the job must be turned over to the ICC at the Hague.

Liberal AND Proud's picture

We are no better than any other regime on this planet that tortures.

We no longer have a right to criticise any other nation on this planet that justifies torture on the basis of their own "national security" and self interests.

Liberal AND Proud's picture

The Very Appeasing and Bitter Ceci Hussein @ 4:

I am not surprised. This is the exact result when people decide to stick their heads in the sand and watch American Idol instead of keeping abreast of the treachery of the government.

I don't know how anyone could sleep knowing that people have been tortured in their country's name.

Does George Bush even sleep?

Of course he sleeps.

Ignorance is bliss.

George :^)'s picture

Yah! a little late but good way of looking good for the up coming new government.But if there was a chance McSame would be President---As usual-no problem-fighting terrrrrrorists to protect americans.

pjcarter's picture

Think back to ll the fuss over Senator Durbin's comments on the Senate floor when he commented on an FBI report. He was right! And now, things have come full circle.

Comments are closed on this entry