We're Beyond The Public Option
By dday Monday Jul 20, 2009 6:00pmTake a look at this ad from America's Health Insurance Plans, the insurance industry lobby.
See what's missing? The words "public option." Or really, any attack on the current plan in Congress at all. The spot associates AHIP with a reform banning denial of coverage for pre-existing condition in exchange for getting every American covered, gently asks for the final bill to be bipartisan, and... that's it.
Similarly, Olympia Snowe, who signed on to the letter calling for a delay in the deadline for reporting a health care bill out of the Senate, positively called for a public option on day one in a speech this weekend in Maine.
What this shows me is that we have now moved beyond the public option as the fulcrum point for the health care debate. We don't know what form it will take or how accessible it will be to all Americans, but if there's a bill signed by the President, it will include a public option. The major players have given up on that score and moved on to other issues to try and derail health care, particularly costs. We've seen much more criticism about cost controls and surtaxes on the wealthy over the last week than any discussion of the public option.
That's because those other facets of the policy don't poll as well as a public option does. They're also harder to explain and quantify. And the forces defending the status quo have found a much easier path by arguing for more delay, questioning costs, lying about the impact on small businesses, claiming that Democrats are engaging in class warfare, raising specters about rationing, and generally using that fiscal scold pose, saying we cannot pay for health care reform while protecting federal health care funding for their districts and localities. On the far right fringe you have lies about how the bill "outlaws private insurance," but in general, the status quo forces think they can trap the bill with a discussion about its cost, not its function.
Of course, the larger effort here is to destroy the Democratic agenda and basically ensure a first term without substantive accomplishments. And Obama is right to use Jim DeMint's "Waterloo" line against him, make it famous, and condemn those who would turn an urgent need for tens of millions of Americans into a game of political hardball:
Just the other day, one Republican Senator said, and I’m quoting him now, “if we’re able to stop Obama on this, it will be his Waterloo. It will break him.” Think about that. This isn’t about me. This isn’t about politics. This about a health care system that is breaking America’s families, breaking America’s businesses and breaking America’s economy. And we can’t afford the politics of delay and defeat when it comes to health care. Not this time, not now. There are too many lives and livelihoods at stake.
What we may see is a brief scaling back on the deadline, which should still leave enough time to report a bill out of both houses in September and reconcile them by October. But the fights ahead for health care appear to be playing out over cost and who pays. The public option is in the bill, as long as it gets dragged over the line.








Login or Register to post comments.
Single payer.
Help FAIR, Healthcare Now!, Physicians for a National Health Program and the Raging Grannies deliver a message to the media.
"Include Single-Payer in Healthcare Debate"
Petition delivery
Tues. July 28, noon - 1 pm
ABC News
77 West 66th St.,
(between Central Pk West and Columbus Ave.)
NYC
Abbybwood, R.N., (Ohio, Florida, California and New York)
Member, "Physicians for a National Health Program"
It's not just accessability - its the cost. And the cost is all over the map. Today I had a patient WITH health insurance who used to have Medicaid. she was used to getting her medication for free. She was FUrIOUS that there was a copay and didn't even really understand the concept. I think everybody should have to pay something. there are people who abuse the system. But I think the amount we all pay should be based on our income. Doctors need to have some protection against frivolous lawsuits (not the ones they might deserve) so that they can stop practicing defensive medicine. And controls need to be in place so doctors can't make money through the expensive tests they order. Well, I could write a book.
NOBODY SHOULD PROFIT OFF ILLNESS. cAPITALISM AT IT'S LOWEST.
... is what those who pay thousands of dollars in premiums (I have seen $18,000/yr) will do with the money they will save.
I vote for the single payer system. It is a shame what the GOP is trying to do. At least President Obama is trying to do something the Republicans have deliberately avoided for the last eight years. This smear campaign is disgraceful, but I believe that the president will ultimately prevail.
http://blackpoliticalthought.blogspot.com
... but they were not opposed to hijack it, modify it, claim it as theirs. Luckily they did not succeed in ruining it. So I don't think they are all that opposed to the ideas, just that it will be the opposition who will get the credit.
Security was to dump BILLIONS of dollars into Wall Street through their "privatizing" scheme. Isn't it ironic that they accomplished the SAME THING with the Wall Street "bail-out" just before Obama moved into the White House.
The Republican Party is a private club of selfish skumbags who want nothing more than to maintain control over the wealth of the United States. Their own GREED is their only motivater.
You have no idea what you are talking about. Republicans have been locked out. They have a plan but the Dems will not let it be heard. Please inform yourself before speaking. Try wathing something other than MSBC.
n/t
Just caught the tail end of something on CNBC this morning. Someone was talking about an AON Survey which cited that 93% od businesses would stay with the plan they offer currently. Pisani properly asked him why they are opposed to the public option. I searched AON but could not find 93%
You can trust us, we would't think of lying to you again.
the ones who arent insured currently and whom actually would benefit from health care reform. he cares more about doing the bidding of his masters: the healthcare and insurance industries. derail this at any cost and make Obama suffer. nothing but politics, all the time, 24/7. he offers nothing and doesnt care to, its all about ruining Obama. what a complete and utterly transparent partisan. for the insurance and healthcare lobbies hes the highest level of 'useful idiot' there is. what an ahole.
They are shooting for mandatory coverage for everyone, purchased from them. Lose your job? No matter, because you, personally, will be paying us for your coverage. You can pay it from your unemployment insurance that the government gives you. Preexisting condition? No problem. We'll still take your premium payments. We won't pay to treat you, at least not very well, but no one can say you don't have coverage. Illness doesn't care where you live, and neither do we. Refrigerator box? Your shell of car that you can no longer afford to drive? We really don't care. Just give us the money. Or else, because it is federally mandated. We mean business. We are business!
It's all about making profits for the stockholders.
They are NOT in the health care "business".
They are in the PROFIT "business".
And we are all the SUCKERS who have been paying for them to tell us "NO!..We don't cover THAT!"
SINGLE PAYER FOR AMERICA NOW!
DEEP SIX THE FOR-PROFIT INSURANCE CORPORATIONS!
BECAUSE THEY DON'T REALLY GIVE A DAMN ABOUT THE AMERICAN PEOPLE'S HEALTH!
Abbybwood, R.N.
You have no idea what you are talking about. Republicans have been locked out. They have a plan but the Dems will not let it be heard. Please inform yourself before speaking. Try wathing something other than MSBC.
Please, please, tell me where to find this wonderful Republican plan. Because, you know, they don't have to wait for the Dems to "let it be heard."
There is absolutely nothing that the Dems in Congress could do to stop the Republicans from proposing alternative legislation.
There is absolutely nothing that the Dems in Congress could do to stop the Republicans from publishing an alternative plan, putting it on a webpage, giving us details.
So don't hand me this crock of s*** that we should inform ourselves before speaking, unless you going to give me a source for this wonderful alternative plan.
Lets deep six profits made by the company you work for, assuming you work. Then we will see how well you like the unemployement line. But you will have Free Healthcare.
Your system is rigged. You're no different than casinos. It's gambling, plain and simple, and your industry changes the rule when it starts taking it on the chin, just like casinos that ban card counters from the blackjack table. You ban people from being insured, or raise their premiums, if they have a pre-existing condition, are at higher risk for say, cancer, when there's a history of cancer in their family. Never mind that they may never get cancer...They are a bad risk, right? And then if that same person who you refuse to cover is involved in an accident, let's say they fall in the bath and break their hip, they have to pay medical costs out of pocket. But they broke their hip, and they can't work, so they end up not being able to pay the hospital, they can't pay for the p.t. that they got, so the costs go to the other people who use the services, resulting in escalating costs for those who do have insurance.
The big difference between your industry and casino gambling however, is that if someone doesn't have a quarter to drop into a slot machine, it simply means that they don't have a chance to gamble. It doesn't mean that the price of things outside of the casino goes up. But if someone doesn't have insurance, the price of health care, to them, rises dramatically.
It seems like a system that doesn't work. That people realize this now is bad for you. But if you'd been smart about it, you would have seen this coming and put your capitAl into a business that wasn't a gamble.
I mean, really. "Assuming you work." Yes, all liberals and progressives are just parasitic welfare mooches sponging off all you hardworking conservatives.
I'm sure it will shock you to know that some of us actually have jobs. I have a job and also run my own business.
And I support single-payer healthcare.
Put that in your pipe and smoke it.
The insurance industries aren't a business. Businesses create wealth, the insurance industries only parasitize wealth. What that makes them, I don't know, but it isn't a business.
Agree with everything else you said. And how.
Deleted duplicate
and your Doctor." That's always one of the top three talking points for Republican heads.
Have you noticed that they NEVER complain about letting YOUR INSURANCE COMPANY step between you and your Doctor?
In my mind, this is what it comes down to: who can manage your health care plan better... YOUR INSURANCE COMPANY... or your Doctor?
Thank you!
(P.S. We have a public system now that works quite well where there is no one to step between you and your doctor. It's called MEDICARE.):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=biTdTvg6K7w
Plus, the ads are slick and professional. Everything's rosy and everyone's smiling ... it's like a Hallmark card.
People are so easily duped by that crap. It makes me ill.
They'll block it if they can and accept it if they must--with poison pills if possible. We have not gotten to the point that progressive change is inevitable.
Time to redouble efforts.
.."as affordable as possible". Ah yes,that little word "possible", there in lies the rub. As affordable as our CEO's will allow so long as their criminal compensation packages remain intact.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0qDuG0ZYD5I
Here is my take on single payer -
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wgECKj9LSH4
“But the fights ahead for health care appear to be playing out over cost and who pays.”
The whole thing has always been about who pays. To cover the uninsured, either tax payers pay, or it comes out of corporate profits. The money doesn't grow on trees.
When single payer was taken off the table, that meant that maintaining corporate profits was prioritized. We're hearing a few concessions on driving up future costs, but with the disparity between what U.S. consumers pay and people in the rest of the industrial world pay now, that indicates corporate profits will stay healthy in the insurance industries as the rest of the economy ails.
In a situation of real reform, we would be concerned about what to do with the money we would SAVE, instead of discussing ways to PAY. I don't think in a free trade environment that our economy will be competitive when saddled with the most expensive health care in the world, the most expensive defense in the world (before the wars), 2 wars, a trillion dollars of corporate welfare towards Wall Street, a drug war being fought in the dumbest and most expensive approach imaginable, and so forth.
Remember, the reason we're discussing paying instead of saving is a symptom of massive corporate corruption of the government, with influence peddlers deciding policy. It is this corruption that is the root cause of the problems.
As far as the public option is concerned, that option is not available to anyone who can otherwise get insurance through their employer, according to Sebelius on the Daily Show. I wonder what kind of demographic the public plan is going to wind up serving or whether it will scale to a point where it can negotiate significant discounts.
Health care is not a commodity.
what congresscritters have , everything else is BS .
Worried about becoming a socialist country , tax rate for 85% of americans is what 35% , sales tax here ( WA )is almost 10% , and sales tax is on after tax dollars . round it up to 50% , not counting devalaution of the dollar , which in the last 2 years is running at what say 30%+ , not alot of coin left over the good times . Soon i will be in the back of my van , what a great nation we have become .
Im an elder now , it is saddening to me , for the youth of this ( world ) country , it has become what Upton Sinclair wrote about years ago . Now i know how the dog felt having his tail chopped off ( Jack London ) to provide food . Class war without a doubt in my view .
Single parents you have it the hardest , you cant take this to the bank , you have my utmost respect .
It is morally repugnant to profit off the misery or ill health of Americans. It's criminal that medical bills to the private for-profit MEDICAL/INSURANCE INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX make up 62% of all bankruptcies filed in the U.S. each year. Americans spend 2.5 Trillion Dollars a year on Health care. The overhead at the private for-profit MEDICAL/INSURANCE INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX is upwards of 35% of the health care dollar spent each year in the U.S. That is approximately $900 Billion a year the MEDICAL/INSURANCE INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX uses for BRIBING CONGRESS and their lavish lifestyles, huge salaries plus perks and bonuses. All the while milking the hard-working men/women of this great nation of their hard earned money.
On the other hand Medicare has an overhead of 2%, Canada's system is 1.5%, Europe's 2.5% on average. The money that could be saved by eliminating the private for-profit MEDICAL/INSURANCE INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX is estimated at $900 Billion a year. Enough money to help pay for putting all Americans on MEDICARE/SINGLE-PAYER TYPE HEALTH CARE SYSTEM.
We have to fight back and call, write e-mails, letters-to-editors, Congress and to the White House to let them know how Americans feel about the private for-profit MEDICAL/INSURANCE INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX that currently provides the health care in this country.
Here are some Senators and blue dog(dems) who are on the wrong side of Health Care reform. Give them a call and demand,
"MEDICARE/SINGLE-PAYER TYPE HEALTH CARE FOR ALL NOW!"
Thanks to Dateline_Molly for this chart that shows how much money was paid to Senators by the MEDICAL/INSURANCE INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX to OBSTRUCT health care refrom. Link . Now, when I call each member I can quote to them how much money they were PAID/BRIBED by the MEDICAL/INSURANCE INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX to throw their constituents under the bus and deny them SINGLE-PAYER HEALTH CARE.
(blue dogs)
Ross D-AR, Boucher D-VA, Kind D-WI, Pomeroy D-ND, Tanner D-TN
Polis (CO), Titus (NV) and Altmire (PA)
These are the problem Democrats on the Energy and Commerce Committee: John Barrow (GA-12), Bruce Braley (IA-01), Bart Gordon (TN-04), Baron Hill (IN-09), Jay Inslee (WA-01), Jim Matheson (UT-02), Charlie Melancon LA-03, Zack Space (OH-18) and Bart Stupak (MI-01).
Joe Lieberman I-CT, Chuck Grassley R-IA, Lindsey Graham R-SC,
Susan Collins R-ME, Olympia Snowe R-ME, David Vitter R-LA,
Saxby Chambliss R-GA, Tom Coburn R-OK, Jon Kyl R-AZ,
John Thune R-SD, Richard Lugar R-IN, Jim DeMint R-SC
Jeff Sessions R-AL, Richard Shelby R-AL, Mel Martinez R-FL,
John McCain R-AZ, Mitch McConnell R-KY, Jim Inhofe R-OK,
Lamar Alexander R-TN, Dick Burr R-NC, John Cornyn R-TX
Mark Pryor D-AR, Thomas Carper D-DE, Mary Landrieu D-LA,
Max Baucus D-MT, Kent Conrad D-ND, Ben Nelson D-NE,
Maria Cantwell D-WA, Kay Hagan D-NC, Blanche Lincoln D-AR,
Ron Wyden D-OR, Evan Bayh D-IN, Diane Feinstein D-CA,
Arlen Specter D-PA
Here are the toll-free numbers for the Capitol Hill Switchboard:
(House and Senate)
1-800-828-0498
1-866-338-1015
1-866-220-0044
1-800-473-6711
Also give the President a call or write an e-mail:
White House Comments Line:
1-202-456-1111 M-F 9:00-5:00 est. (NOT A TOLL-FREE #)
President Obama's e-mail: http://www.whitehouse.gov/contact/
Nothing rattles the Congress and White House more than informed CITIZEN/VOTERS ringing the phones off the hook for real health care reform. Call the House, Senate and the White House and demand,
"MEDICARE/SINGLE-PAYER TYPE HEALTH CARE FOR ALL NOW!"
SEMPER FI!
The Insurance Companies already ration health care inside the US. Americans need to get organized and fight these Insurance Companies because they sure do not have your best interests in their profit margins.
Americans need to organize and fight the Insurance Companies since they are definitely already organized!
insurers is something to behold. They say they want reform, then send the likes of DeMint out to kill the whole deal. How do you trust them?
its the wars and bailouts that are killing us , ending those two would put us back on solid ground . All of the talk of health care is diverting us from the real objective , ENDING the wars , no more bailouts to wall street , rebuild the working class of american by ending imports that we once produced here , bring back our mfg base , then we can deal with health care , case in point if no one can afford it what is the fucking point .
...that delays are bad. I think delays are going to backfire against those who are trying to derail healthcare. I look around, and am seeing momentum continually building as regards public opinion, and am seeing cracks in the MSM unified propaganda front. I think that a rush to get legislation is only going to ensure that we get a shitty deal. Time seems, from my perspective, to be working against the corrupt politicians, because they are losing control of the message. The more times they publicly get called on their bullshit, the more outrageous they begin to appear to even the most credulous. Their credibility, never much to begin with, is fraying. In short, I think people are waking up to the fact (or recalling) that they are empowered and always have been.
The constant reminders of how much each of these corrupt politicians have accepted in bribes is undermining their arguments and their positions. Awareness of their corruption is seeping into the national consciousness, despite the best efforts of the MSM propganda machine to control the dialog. I think that if we go into 2010 elections without passage of a plan that actually serves the interests of the vast majority of Americans, the guilty parties are going to get decimated in the polling places. These pols are isolated from reality and are oblivious, and they are completely and seriously misreading the will of the majority (that includes Obama). I think they are going to be shocked at how they are eventually going to be punished in future elections for selling us all down the river.
Even if the crooks do pass something this year that screws the American People, there is nothing that they can do today that cannot be undone and set to right, once they have been kicked out of office and replaced with people of integrity (it's our choice alone whether or not that happens). They might win a battle or two, but they are still going to lose the war that they initiated and are waging on the American People. I think a single payer system is inevitable, because it's the only thing that is going to work without bankrupting the nation. The health insurance racketeers will eventually become history, because their rapacious parasitism cannot be sustained. We're already on that path to achieving single payer, and the worst the crooks and criminals can do is delay it arrival somewhat.
JMO.
I can't think of anything else that has had as big an impact informing people that the U.S. health empire's propaganda is lies. Hell, my parents never figured out a VCR much less a DVD player, and, even though their town has a movie theater (don't laugh -- most towns don't today in that state), they haven't gone to a movie in years. Even they saw "Sicko" because we drove up and played it for them on our laptop over a holiday.
Now would be a really good time for an updated Sicko V2.0 to hit the theaters. It could help solidify the public opinions from a fact-based perspective. Congress needs to percieve the public as a nest of angry hornets. A Sicko rerun would help with that.
You free loaders just want someone else to pay for your bad health and bad habits. The system does need to be tweeked, not overhauled. I am in the health insurance business. There are affordable plans availible but you liberals would rather have $150 cable bills, when there are $50 options, cell phones, cars you can't afford, and many other things that are not priority and them cry because health insuranc is too expensive we need the rich to pay for it.
Look at MA there health system is more than broke and everyone is required to have health insurance. Last year 26,000 fines were levied on people that did not carry insurnace and thier helathcare cost is based on thier income and most that were uninsured could have gotten it for free.
Every single republican ammendment was rejected. But you do not hear the liberal media talk about that. There is a Republican bill on the table but the liberal leaders of congress will not let it be entered into the mix. You know why, because it makes sense.
Did you know that if the current bill passes that it will not go into effect unitl 2013. So what is the rush? Hmmm what is 2013 oh the year after the election. Obama will campaign that he got healthcare for everyone so re-elect me. If we are in such dier need of helathcare reform why do we need to wait until 2013 before it goes into effect?
If this bill was so good then why did the ammendment to make all of congress and be a part of the public plan fail on a partisan line vote? Why is it not good for the people that make the law? If it were going to be so good shouldn't they have to be enrolled in the plan? Seems fair to me. This will be just like the Stemulus package that has not worked. Rush it through and then complain about the miss uses of he money.
I have a business that pays for 75% of the premium and did you know that 30% of my workers do not participate? They are uninsured because they can't afford it. They have 40K cars, buy expensive houses, have the premium cable packages, shop high end stores. Then they complain when I dock them for being sick and require a doctors note to return to work if they have been out for more thatn 3 days. I pay for flu shots at my office for the entire family it cost me about 1500.00 a year and still I have employees that do not get the shot. How ironic that the ones that miss the most work are the ones that don't take care of themselves and be responsible. But thye have no problem asking for advances on thier pay when something goes wrong and they can't pay the docotrs visits. I had one person wanted me to pay her a higher salery because she did to enroll in the helath insurance. I was saving money for her to not be on the plan. So even if we offer something for low cost, provide free services there are those who are too stupid to take advantage of it.
So lets punish me the small busness owner. Truth be known if this bill passes, there will be another 10 on the unemployment line because it will elieminate the need for my services. You free loaders do not think about that.
Vampire!!!
DO think about.
People like you who use the police, firefighters, the military, roads and public utilities, public schools and universities, then bitch about socialised ANYTHING.
As for bad life choices, asshat, lets look at mine: Physically fit, non smoker, vegetarian, cancer. See how that works, stupid?
If everyone got medical care at no cost, your concerns in paragraph 6 would be abosolute non extant. See how that works?
Use your head for something other than a hatrack. You are an embarrassment to yourself.
talking about the GOP being shut out of the debate. I remember how they operated when they had the House. Tom DeLay would count the votes and if they had too many Dems on board, they would rewrite the bill to make it unpalatable. They ran roughshod over the opposition and they did it for money. Republicans deserve many years out in the wilderness, if not extinction.
http://www.liquiddaddy.blogspot.com/
Login or Register to post comments.