Measuring the Bush Recession

bush_recession_0cff4.JPGAs the American economy plunges deeper into crisis, the conservative chattering classes are hoping for a replay of their 2001 blame game. Having successfully perpetuated the myth that President Bush "inherited a recession" from Bill Clinton, right-wing mouthpieces from Rush Limbaugh to Fred Barnes began blaming Barack Obama for the Bush recession literally within hours of his election. But as a quick glance at the data shows, across virtually economic indicator from GDP, unemployment and consumer confidence to home prices, foreclosures and manufacturing output, ownership for this mushrooming economic calamity squarely belongs to George W. Bush.

Gross Domestic Product. U.S. GDP shrank by 0.3% in the third quarter (July through September), a decline which followed the downward revision of the Q2 number from 3.3% to 2.8%. But while "recession" is traditionally defined as two consecutive quarters of GDP contraction (which is almost certain to occur), the quarterly Survey of Professional Forecasters by the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia concluded that the United States entered a recession in April.

Recession at the State and Local Level. While there is debate as to whether or not the United States has technically slipped into a recession, at the state and local level there is no doubt at all. According to Moody's Economy, by the end of September 30 states were in recession, up from just five in March. 19 more states were deemed "at risk." (Only Sarah Palin's petro-state of Alaska was forecast to experience economic growth.) 276 of 380 metropolitan areas measured by Moody's had also sunk into recession. Combined with the downward spiral of home prices, these regional economic contractions are having a devastating impact on state and local tax revenue - and government services.

Unemployment. In October, the American economy shed 240,000 jobs, catapulting the losses for the year to 1.2 million. At 6.5%, the unemployment rate hit a 14-year high. The percentage of the adult population now working dropped to 61.8%, its lowest level in 15 years. The Philadelphia Fed survey forecast 222,000 more lost jobs per month through the end of the year. With some analysts now predicting unemployment will hit 8% by the middle of 2009, President Bush's reversal on extending jobless benefits could not come a moment too soon.

Jobless Claims. Of course, the corollary to skyrocketing unemployment is an explosion of new jobless claims. The Labor Department today released figures showing new unemployment claims jumped to 542,000 last week, a 16-year high. First-time jobless claims have now remained above the 400,000 for 17 straight weeks.

Consumer Confidence. Given those dismal numbers, it's no surprise that consumer confidence nose-dived in October to its lowest level on record. Even with steep declines in gas prices, consumer confidence dropped 23 points to 38.0, its worst performance since the Conference Board began the survey in 1967.

Consumer Spending. Consumer spending, long the engine of American economic growth, is also in a tailspin. It dropped 0.3% in September and at annual rate of 3.1% for the third quarter, its worst performance since 1980. And outlays for big-ticket items such as cars plunged by 2.9%. With disposable income growing only by a tenth of one percent, Americans for the second month plowed more money into savings.

Home Prices. The news from the collapsing housing market, the sector that triggered the economic crisis, remains dark. Earlier this week, the National Association of Realtors calculated that median home prices in the third quarter plunged by 7.7% compared to the same time frame in 2007. Almost 80% of the metro areas (120 out of 152) measured experienced declines. New numbers from the Commerce Department reflected that weakness; new housing starts and permits fell to the lowest annual rates since 1960 and 1959, respectively.

Home Foreclosures. While Congress and the Treasury Department debate whether and how to help American homeowners on the brink of foreclosure, the crisis only deepens. In the third quarter, 766,000 homeowners received a foreclosure notice, a staggering 71% increase from the same period in 2007. Overall, nearly a fifth of American homeowners - 7.5 million of them - may now be "under water" on their mortgages, with levels in Nevada (47.8%), Michigan (38.6%), Arizona (29.2%), Florida (29.2%) and California (27.4%) all topping 25%

Manufacturing. While the woes of the auto industry dominate the headlines this week, the American manufacturing sector overall is in deep trouble. As the Washington Post reported, in October "the Institute for Supply Management's index of conditions in the manufacturing sector is at its lowest level since the nation was in a recession in September 1982." Ian Shepherdson, chief U.S. economist for High Frequency Economics, called the figures "hideous" and noted "when you see a number like this, it's very alarming."

Stock Market. Of course, the highest profile economic failure of George W. Bush, America's first MBA President, has been on Wall Street. This week, the Dow dropped below 8,000, its lowest level in six years and nowhere near the 10,588 when Bush took office. In all, over $6 trillion was erased from U.S. equities just this year. Alas, history has proven once again that Wall Street and the economy overall simply do better under Democratic presidents.

Consumer Prices. In the current crisis, even seeming good news is bad news. Led by dismal home prices and plummeting oil and gas costs (which may dip below $2 a gallon), the Consumer Price Index dropped 1.0% in October. That decline this week sparked fears among some economists and on Wall Street that the United States could face the prospect of deflation. While still seen as unlikely, a chronic drop in prices at a time of low interest rates could limit the ability of the federal government to spur economic activity.

Health Care. The downward spiral of the Bush economy is also producing dire consequences for Americans' health care. Patients and providers alike are feeling the pinch. A survey by the Kaiser Family Foundation found that one in three Americans had had trouble paying medical bills in the past year. Half had someone in their family skip bills or forego medical care. For the first time in a decade, orders for prescription medications are down (albeit by 1%). Hospitals, too, are suffering. New data this week from the American Hospital Association showed decreases in both admissions and elective procedures as well as a spike in the number of patients who can't pay for care.

Hunger. With the decline of the American economy has come another, quietly growing crisis: hunger. Even before the steep downturn in September, the U.S. Department of Agriculture estimated that the number of children who went hungry in 2007 - almost 700,000 - jumped by 50% over the previous year. Overall, 12.2 of Americans - 36.2 million people - don't "have the money or assistance to get enough food to maintain active, healthy lives."

Leading Economic Indicators. The grim data for jobless claims, manufacturing and personal income combined to produce a steeper than expected drop-off in the Conference Board's index of Leading Economic Indicators. Designed to predict economic activity six to nine months out, the LEI fell 0.8% in October, its third decline in the past four months.

President-elect Barack Obama is almost certainly right in describing the economy he will inherit from George W. Bush as facing "an unprecedented crisis, or at least something that we have not seen since the Great Depression." Bank of America CEO Kenneth Lewis expects no turnaround until at the least the middle of 2009. The Philadelphia Fed's survey estimated the recession would last 14 months. But whatever the duration of the American economic downturn, there can be no question as to its paternity.

This is George W. Bush's recession.

(This piece is crossposted at Perrspectives.)

Related Reactions

Advertise Here

Login or Register to post comments.

73 comments

He'll just buy stock in Rogaine.

I am no Bush apologist, but he is only a symptom of a much greater

disease.

The disease is called modern American consumer culture. We are as

much to blame as he is. We, the American electorate, are so dumbed

down, so addicted, so jaded, so self centered, so lazy, so apathetic

that we let our most precious treasure become second to convenience

and Dancing with the Stars.

consumerism didnt outsource tech jobs and manufacturing

consumerism didnt make wages stay flat for 8 years

consumerism didnt open up the borders for cheap workers to be used by the corporatists

consumerism didnt make it easy for the wallmarts of the world to exist

consumerism didnt destroy the unions

consumerism didnt destroy the ability for the avg worker to get healthcare

I want to say, "Eat me", about the consumer b.s., too.

We wouldn't even HAVE an economy if it wasn't for WE THE PEOPLE (we are not "CONSUMERS"; we are CITIZENS).

Citizen consumption in the U.S. makes up 70% of our economy. I assume you want that down to 0%, right?

I am as Liberal as the next guy, but this rending of cloth and beating on our chests about how evil it is to live in a civilized society - PIFFLE!

Greed by the financial sector of the economy in particular put us where we are today, and that came about because of GOP/Conservative mantras about free market = good, egalitarianism and social services = evil! and all the while they were gaming the system, and hiding behind St. Ronald and his now in shambles Voodoo Economics of the Holy Trickle Down cult.

Blaming all this on US, the citizens, is even crazier than right wingers blaming Katrina on gays and lesbians.

Heh

So jaded...coming from you totally cracks me up.

Yes, you are one of the many here who are completely and totally jaded.

Me, I am cautiously optimistic. I wish a few more were, too.

And Uncle Joe (above), exactly.

you watch TV

speak for yourself.

is all about blaming others and taking absolutely no responsibility or having any accountability.

This is what conservativism is. Fuck it up and blame someone else. Always blame someone else.

Lie, lie, lie...blather, rinse, repeat.

...and that's why they invented religion and are so into it. When all else fails and there are no more humans to blame - you can always turn to gawd.

that lying to god is THE ultimate sin, no?

How they get away with this is just beyond me. I mean absolutely, completely beyond me.

I am not even religious and *I* know that lying to god is the quickest road to hell.

Sheeesh.

Ain't no god.

Ain't no hell.

They know it. That's why they do what they do.

Enjoy your life.

Uhm

Reread, hon. :-)

Gotcha...

ayup, ayup, ayup...

It's barely started.

Correct -- we'll be paying for this "disaster by design" for many years to come. While the crooks point their fingers, and laugh all the way to Dubai.

That's the wonder of liberalism.

I just rinse myself off once in awhile and I'm good to go.

Lard-Ass Blimpaugh and all the rest of the ignorant reslugs just can't handle the real truth.

Bush has transferred Billions to his buddies. They are doing just fine, thank you very much.

have almost two more months in office - so we can probably kiss many more billions good-bye.

Mission Accomplished!!

He transferred all this money to them and he isn't worth anywhere near what they are. He probably wouldn't be invited to their houses now that he cannot do anything else for them.

.

Wait 'til the November employment figures are out - all those "conservatives" who fired their Obama supporting employees will be coming in.

The Chimperor displaying the attributes needed to be a member of the GOP...he is standing upright and displaying his opposable thumb.

Hillary Rodham Clinton the new Secretary of State.

Watch as he and the repubs will try to blame this all on Bill and the dems.

The media and politicians have been avoiding the word "recession" for two years now. Check news articles from 2007 and you'll see "Are we in a recession?" pieces from March and April of 2007.

We've been in one on a local and regional level for a long time now. The only reason they are finally starting to admit it is because it's undeniable. REalistically we're entering a "depression" now but they won't use that term until half of America is living on the streets and even Wal-Mart is losing money.

in perpetuating the myth about Clinton? I know people of all walks of life and political views, and only the crazed hardcore Rethugs blame Clinton. But then, they blame him for everything bad anyways so who cares?

)O(

Seems like a lot of Democrats on this website seemed to have absorbed a lot of it.

Bush aint finished yet.
He's continuing to act at his "Free market" Master's behest on his way out the door,leaving behind the smoldering ruins of a greed gutted finacial system.

And

a gutted environment. The Endangered Species Act is being attacked by this filthy bastard. May he rot in hell.

its nothing personal , hes just takeing orders like they ALL DO!

Maybe you've already seen it, but in case you haven't...
Denied!

Gee

bush,I wonder if you'll be avaiable for advise if President Obama needs it?.....HAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHHHA.................

At least the guy's consistent!

is already referring to it as the "Obama recession."

That guy Obama is amazing!

He hasn't even taken office yet and he's managed to destroy the fine economy that the Repignicans left for him!

Amazing!

You know the rest.

Jon you don't seem to understand, the county was in terrible shape when Bush took office. We were in the middle of the Clinton recession and only the brave and genius leadership of George W. Bush kept the county afloat. Then we had several years of such prosperity that we were the envy of every nation on earth. All the birds sang a sweet melody to our nation. Then Obama started running for office, hypnotizing just over half of the voters, and causing the current most terrible recession and general economic meltdown. The republicans make their own reality and it is up to you to conform.

this notion, floated by the MSM, that there is an impending recession.

Haven't we been in a recession since at least the beginning of the year, if not since the last quarter of 2007?

Who really cares what the right wing idiots are saying the only ones they are convincing are right wing nutz. I havent listened to Faux, hannity or LImpdickblaugh in ages Fruck them in their tight arses

Osama Bin Laden, what a chump. He went to all the trouble (allegedly) of flying planes into the World Trade Center to bankrupt America when all he really had to do was wait and let Bush do it for him.

Remember when pundits were saying that America's never had to sacrifice anything for these wars? Or how 'bout how we'd never been to war and still had a tax cut? These wars were just bought on the "buy now, pay nothing till 2009" plan. Guess what time it is? Payment is due now. Exactly the way Cheney and all his 2001 secret energy summit pals planned it to go down.

Sometimes the mom in me comes out and begin personalizing things and lately I've been wondering how the holidays with the whole Bush fam will be. I know how my family is and I can imagine one brother tossing back a few too many brewskis, mom hissing at dad and then dad having to deal with the elephant (son) in the room and pretend he's normal and that he just hasn't pissed away 8 years of modern civilization as we know it when really you just wanna smack the snot out of him. Thanksgiving with the Bush's. Now that would be a hell of a movie!

)O(

Oliver Stone is working on a TV version of that for Hallmark cards.

Lifetime or Sci-Fi?

Court T.V.

You're right.
Win.

the fucking retard has made the Bush name so toxic that no member of his family (or their descendants) will ever get elected again but that would be giving the average American voter way too much credit.

'Bush' will never have the same nasty cache as 'Hitler,' yet the chimp has certainly done his damnedest to make it that bad. He's still working on it though. He's got 60 days.

.

Not so sure about that. In the coming years it'll be fun watching them try to rehabilitate Jeb.

Doesn't seem like there's much hope in the following generation. I doubt the twins have the stomach for it and lord knows Jeb's spawn are nothing to write home about. Don't know what Neil has produced, so maybe there's the "hope"...

The Bush name is attached to Prescott Bush, who was involved up to the gills in a plot to overthrow FDR's presidency in the 30s. And then was found guilty of trading with the nazis.

And look, he managed to get relected multiple times as a senator for Connecticut. And his son Bush Sr. got to be president.

Heck Bush senior left the economy in taters in the early 90s. Anyone remember the "fun" that was 91/92? With stores literally begging people to shop?

And look, his idiot son got to be president for 2 terms.

So my understanding is that the Bush ain't done screwing this country by a long shot. And there will be plenty of idiots supporting them all the way to the white house soon enough.

This people may be a new breed of vermin. A genetically engineered super-vermin if you may, the likes of which the world has never seen before.

)O(

Nah... Bush's are going to recover in less than one term. New
Fri, 11/21/2008 - 14:30 — Tyler Durden
The Bush name is attached to Prescott Bush, who was involved up to the gills in a plot to overthrow FDR's presidency in the 30s. And then was found guilty of trading with the nazis.

And look, he managed to get relected multiple times as a senator for Connecticut. And his son Bush Sr. got to be president.

Heck Bush senior left the economy in taters in the early 90s.
__________________________________________________________

I'm still trying to lose weight from all those taters I ate.

You know what they call an Irish seven course dinner?

A baked potato and a six-pack.

The Republicans discovered in the early eightys that a puppet figurehead was the way to go. When Reagans brain went bye bye, they got a taste of power unparalleled, and no possibility of blame.
They were forced to give Bush senior his chance though. Junior was then installed because of his stupidity, and appeal to morons who wanted to drink a beer with him. You see where that got us.
Mccain then sold his soul to the puppet masters. Who's next? Puppet Palin. Ahhh the future.

the Cons thought Quayle was gonna be their man after Daddy Bush got done with his second term. Then Bubba screwed up all their plans by winning in '92. But they found an idiot that was even more compliant than Danny.

Isn't it ironic that as hard as one tries, it's nearly impossible to find anybody in America willingly ready to admit they voted for this man twice...yet he won millions of votes each time. There should be a special tax just for them because they deserve to share a greater burden for cleaning up the mess he is leaving behind.

Goofy Friday Idea: Your ballot for President should work like a stock certificate...things get better, you profit! Things get worse, you pay!

I'd rather just take away their right to vote. If you vote for a chimp that screws up the whole country, you don't deserve to vote again.

but I like to use anagrams as a divination tool

Nicolae Ceausescu = Cocaine Cause Slue

Just sayin'

(I had to look up "slue" but it kinda makes sense)

The fear I have is that let's say Obama and his Administration can manage to dig us out of this chasm and right the American ship, the voters will turn around and forget that Neocons got us into this mess and turn around and vote Republicans back into power.

from the namby-pamby Dems who are too afraid to remind Americans who it is that keeps getting us into these messes.

they keep forgetting why the electorate in the last 2 election cycles sent them there.

who drove us into this ditch. That's the only downside to the "let's all kiss and make up" mantra called bipartisanship. Americans tend to have short memories. The American public should never be allowed to forget Bush, his policies, and his attack on the middle class of America.

Every Con out there is responsible. That needs to be said and re-said over and over again. People need to shout it from the rooftops. The Republicans and their rightwing ideals, beliefs and policies put us in the predicament we're in now. And not just now but several times throughout our nation's history. They always drive our country into the ditch.

Why would you even bother taking this apart piece by piece. Any claim that Obama is somehow more responsible than Bush for this fiasco is vapid. Ignore it.

The ruling government is very limited in it's control of a nation's economy with the global market the way it's been for how many years now? Trade deals (free apparently) were favoured by both Dems and Repubs alike and obviously when the economy tanks, there is little a reigning Prez can do about it. Just as when an economy is booming, does it really have anything to do with the elected leader? I think not.

What did Bush do to stop the speculation in oil futures? That really effed up the world economy in a hurry.

Why would any government official want to stop the speculation in oil futures? Higher the prices, the more they earn.

Create so many diversions that people hardly even take note of the looting of the Treasury. At least if we all get laid off, we won't have to pay off Bush's credit card.

have a national enema day on January 19th, 2009?

For his crimes and for what he has done to this country let alone to the rest of the world , I'd like to see Bush prosecuted and strung up by his walnuts . This guy is an absolute criminal and a madman , there is no way , absolutely no way , that he and his gang should be allowed to get away with all of it and go scott free . To just forgive and forget ( lets just move on ) would be absolutely irresponsible and criminal in itself not to mention dangerous , but with these gutless , unprincipled and no backbone Dems it's a good bet these criminals will never pay , unbelievable .

Jonathan Turley said Bush can actually pardon people (himself included) for things that they haven't been charged with yet. A sort of pre-emptive pardon. The fuckers are gonna get off scot-free. Mark my words.

When did flat out lying ever inhibit conservatard blowhards? It's all they do. It's all they got.

A new Fairness Doctrine, and the REALITY of what republicans's DID for eight years will, and, has exposed these corporate carnival barkers for what they are.

They were not able to stop the landslide defeat of their fascist employeers the last two times around, and it is only going to get worse in the years and decades to come. If anything, their numbers are going to dwindle significantly.

The only people who still listen to these assholes are the chronically stupid, and the hate-filled bigot homophobes who love the little fetuses, but hate all of them fetuses once they are born.

A Republican just told me that Obama is president and has been president since the election on November 4th. These people are too damned ignorant to vote. This is how Repugnants get away with lies. The Repug masses are just too stupid to know any better. They are too stupid to vote.

As the American economy plunges deeper into crisis, the conservative chattering classes are hoping for a replay of their 2001 blame game. Having successfully perpetuated the myth that President Bush "inherited a recession" from Bill Clinton,

Ha ha ha!

By that logic (8 years from Clinton to the Great Depression Redux), then Ronald Reagan was responsible for the 1993 WTC bombings and, pretty much, Bush 41 was probably responsible for 9/11, since he had been in the WH less than 9 years before that event.

And Abe Lincoln was responsible for Pearl Harbor, too. I almost forgot to mention that!

[Comment Deleted By Administration For Violation Of Terms Of Service]
[Comment Deleted By Administration For Violation Of Terms Of Service]
73 comments

Login or Register to post comments.