TOPICS

Special Comment: What is "pro-America", Senator?

DOWNLOAD (45)
WMV QuickTime
PLAY (59)
WMV QuickTime

Due to the ongoing hatred and vile nature of the McCarthy McCain/Palin campaign and Republican politicians and pundits, Keith Olbermann is moved yet again to another Special Comment. This time, Olbermann castigates the entire notion 'Us vs. Them' notion that the Republican Party mouthpieces have been perpetuating in their support for John McCain's candidacy. And worse, for someone who has made his ability to reach across the aisle in a bipartisan manner a mainstay of his campaign, John McCain's allowing his proxies to divide Americans into "good" and "bad" camps shows how far he has slid from his "maverick" days.

(Senator McCain,) I disagree with you on virtually every major point of policy and practice.

And yet I do not think you "anti-America." I would not hesitate to join you in time of crisis in defense of this country.

Fortunately you did not echo this chorus of base hatred.

But neither have you repudiated it.

What is "pro-America", Senator?

Transcripts below the fold:

I have frequently insisted I would never turn the platform of the Special Comment into a regular feature.

But as these last two weeks of this extraordinary, and extraordinarily disturbing, presidential campaign project out in front of us, I fear I may have to temporarily amend that presumption.

I hope it will be otherwise, but I suspect this will be the first of nightly pieces, most shorter than this... until further notice. And thus a Special Comment tonight about the last five days of the divisive, ugly, paranoid bleatings of this Presidential race, culminating in the sliming of Colin Powell for his endorsement of Senator Obama.

There was once a very prominent sportswriter named Dick Young whose work, with ever-increasing frequency, became peppered with references to "my America."

"I can't believe this is happening in My America"... -- "we do not tolerate these people in My America" -- "this man does not belong in my America".

His America gradually revealed itself.

Insular. Isolationist. Backwards-looking. Mindlessly flag-waving. Racist. No second chances. A million rules, but only for the other guy.

Dick Young died in 1987, but he has been re-born in the presidential campaign as it has unfolded since last Thursday night.

In that time, Governor Sarah Palin, Congresswoman Michelle Bachmann, McCain spokesperson Nancy Pfotenhauer, and Rush Limbaugh, have revealed that there is a measurable portion of this country that is not interested in that which the vast majority view as democracy or equality or opportunity.

They want only... control -- and they want the rest of us, symbolically, perhaps physically... out. Governor Palin:

"We believe that the best of America is not all in Washington D.C.," you told a fund-raiser in North Carolina last Thursday, to kick off this orgy of condescending elitism. "We believe that the best of America is in these small towns that we get to visit, and in these wonderful little pockets of what I call the real America, being here with all of you hard working very patriotic, very pro-America areas of this great nation." Governor, your prejudice is overwhelming.

It is not just "pockets" of this country that are "pro-America" Governor.

America... is "pro-America."

And the "Real America" of yours, Governor, is where people at your rallies shout threats of violence, against other Americans, and you say nothing about them or to them.

What you are seeing is not patriotism, Governor.

What has surrounded you since your nomination, has been the echoing shout of mob rule. Indeed, that shout has echoed to Minnesota, where the next day an unstable Congresswoman named Michele Bachmann added to the ugly cry.

"I wish the American media would take a great look at the views of the people in Congress and find out, are they pro-America, or anti-America. I think people would love to see an expose' like that."

For nearly two years, Ms. Bachmann, who made her first political bones by keeping the movie "Aladdin" from being shown at a Minnesota Charter School because she thought it promoted paganism and witchcraft, has had a seat in the government of this nation, a seat from which she has spewed the most implausible, hateful, narrow-minded garbage imaginable.

Well, Congresswoman, you have gotten that "expose'" you wanted, have you not?

Though not perhaps in the way you imagined.

Since giving voice to your remarkable delusion that there are members of Congress who are "anti-America," and the extraordinary tap-dance of sleaze and innuendo about Senator Obama which followed...

...the challenger for your house Seat, Elwyn Tinklenberg, has been inundated by donations -- 700 thousand dollars in the three days after you spoke.

Because the America you perceive, Congresswoman -- with its goblins and ghosts and vast unseen hordes of traitors and fellow travelers and Senators who won't ban "Aladdin" -- exists only in your head, and in the heads of the others who must rationalize the failures in their own lives and of their own policies as somebody else's fault -- as a conspiracy to deny them an America of exclusionism and religious orthodoxy and prejudice, about which they must accuse, and murmur, and shout threats, and cleave the nation into pro-America and anti-America."

And back it comes to the McCain campaign.

And Senator McCain's talking head, Ms. Pfotenhauer, who on this very network Saturday, and seemingly without the slightest idea that dismissive prejudice dripped from every word, analyzed the race in Virginia.

"I can tell you that the Democrats have just come in from the District of Columbia and moved into northern Virginia," she said. "But the rest of the state, 'real Virginia,' if you will, I think will be very responsive to Senator McCain's message."

Again, a toxic message...

The parts of the country that agree with Nancy Pfotenhauer... are real -- the others, not.

Ms. Pfotenhauer, why not go the distance on this one?

It was Senator McCain's own brother who called that part of Virginia nearest Washington "communist country."

Cut to the chase, Madam.

No matter the intended comic hyperbole of Joe McCain...

This is the point -- isn't it?

Leave out the real meaning of "Communism," Madam -- Joe McCain reduced it to a buzz-word; it has no more true definition right now than does "Socialism," or the phrase "a man who sees America like you and I see America."

It's about us... and them.

The pro-... and the anti.

Never mind, Madam, that the bi-secting of this country you would happily inspire, means taking a tiny crack in a dam and not repairing it but burrowing into it.

It is not enough that Senator McCain and Senator Obama might differ.

One must be real and the other false.

One must be pro-America and the other anti.

Go back and -- as your boss Rick Davis said today -- "re-think," Mr. McCain's insistence not to drag the sorry bones of Jeremiah Wright into this campaign.

And whatever you do, Ms. Pfotenhauer, allow no one enough time to think... about the widening crack in the dam.

And now all of this comes together to attack Colin Powell.

"Secretary Powell says his endorsement is not about race," writes Rush Limbaugh... the grand wizard of this school of reactionary non-thought.

"OK, fine. I am now researching his past endorsements to see if I can find all the inexperienced, very liberal, white candidates he has endorsed. I'll let you know what I come up with."

It is not conceivable that Powell might reject McCain for the politics of hate and character assassination, or just for policy.

In the closed, sweaty world of the blind allegiances of Limbaugh -- one of "us" who endorses one of "them," must be doing so for some other blind allegiance, like the color of skin.

The answer to this primordial muck, must be addressed to one man only.

Senator McCain -- where are you?

I disagree with you on virtually every major point of policy and practice.

And yet I do not think you "anti-America." I would not hesitate to join you in time of crisis in defense of this country.

Fortunately you did not echo this chorus of base hatred.

But neither have you repudiated it.

What is "pro-America", Senator?

Is it pro-America to call a man a racist because he endorses a different candidate?

Senator, you have based your campaign on many premises, but the foremost (and the most nearly admirable) of all of them, have been the pitches about "reaching across the aisle," and putting, as your ubiquitous banners reed, "country first."

So when Colin Powell endorses your opponent, you say nothing as your supporters and proxies paint him in this "Anti-America" frame and place him in Governor Palin's un-real America.

Senator McCain -- did not General Powell just "reach across the aisle?" Did he not, in his own mind at least, "put country first?"

Is it not your responsibility, Senator, to, if not applaud, then at least quiet those in your half of our fractured political equation?

Is it not your responsibility, Senator, to say "enough" to Republican smears without end?

Is it not your responsibility, Senator, to insist that, win or lose, you will not be party to a campaign that devolves into hatred and prejudice and divisiveness?

And Senator McCain, if it is not your responsibility... whose is it?



Login or Register to post comments.

79 comments

frist

and the only candidate I hear calling for UNITY is Obama.

I never believed the talk during the primaries that McCain was a loose canoon.... but now I absolutely see that he is.... TOTALLY IRRESPONSIBLE and DESPERATE

Ummm, why was Keith cut off?

Our understanding is he ran over the time alloted to his show. Ask Rachel Maddow. :) -- Sitemonitor.

Our video recorders are set to time slots. Keith ran over into Maddow's time.

Ah, damn that Keith and his time hogging.

Safer to record the Hardball - Countdown - Rachel Maddow set as a single block, plus an extra minute after it, in case breaking news caused an overrun?

KO nailed it again with another SC on GOP attempts to monopolize what is pro/anti-American. What does the banner "Country First" mean anyway?

"Country", you know, that "America" that people are supposed to be "pro". From the views of Palin, Bachman, and Limbaugh, that would seem to be the small town, isolationist, bigoted, anti-intellectual, homophobic, religious extremist, misogynist, militaristic, bellicose, jingoist, testosterone poisoned, hypocritical, sociopathic part of our beloved nation.

Or it could be just a meaningless slogan to excite mindless enthusiasm.

That sure sounds UNAmerican to me. What is ProAmerican is defending the Constitution/Bill of Rights (which protects our privacy and separation of church and state), defending the country from abuses of power by the politicians and the power-brokers, defending our morality (opposing torture, going to war only by requirement not choice), by building and not diminishing our image abroad (which strengths us). Sounds to me like small-town America sure has it wrong; manipulated by the politics of fear, they are UNAmerican crowd.

Michele Bachmann Overdrive Performs 'Taking Care of Diss-ness'
http://satiricalpolitical.com/?p=4168

The Daily Show pun of "Bachmann Turncoat Overdrive" nails the sentiment

He was cut off because he wont shut the f up, he drags his point on and on, I agree with him for the most part but my f can he blow wind....

Oberman has very little time to "blow wind" as you put it compared to the dearth of fascist ramblings televised or on radio from the wacked out right. I could listen to his truth and never complain as you have.

He's eloquent and cogent. If you want to look for someone who needs to "shut the f up" why don't you just go and listen to Limbaugh? Otherwise, quit your whining.

So what, I'm still voting for Obama. Go away now, Troll.

He wasn't cut off -- on air. He finished his comment, running over into the Maddow show. This DVR capture is cut off because the timer on the box thought, "9 o'clock -- Miller time!"

I love Olbermann's Special Comments but this one could have been much more powerful. It was ok, but it wasn't anywhere near enough.

Thanks for knocking it out of the park again Keith!! You hit the nail on the head with this one!! Thank you!!!

It's no surprise that KO often gets worked up during these commentaries but by the end of this one he seemed genuinely furious to me (watched the whole thing on Youtube).

This was GREAT!!! Very pointed comments that should have been said in Junior's face 7 years ago.

Remember the simple rallying cry of "Your either with us, or your against us"? That's simpleton ideology, promulgated by a simpleton, for simpletons.

Thinking people were deathly afraid of the power that Junior was awarded by an ignorant public, by acting the part of the simple cowboy and illegally invading a soverign nation. At that time Phil Donahue was fired because he spoke out. He was one of the highest rated shows of his kind... but his kind were no longer supported in that Neo Nation or ours.

Now, not only are Keith's ratings growing, but another salient voice has been added to the non-simpleton choir: Rachel Maddow!

Yay Keith and Rachel!

Olbermann takes the anti-America fascist reactionary right to the carpet. Hear, hear Kieth!

An unfortunate cut-off in the quicktime version at the beginning of the next to last sentence of his "Special Comment". Otherwise, thanks as always for hosting these. I know can always catch them here.

v-r-

i just want to ask everyone to gather all the good vibes and well wishes and prayers we can all muster and send them madelyn dunham’s way so that she will get and be well enough to see her grandson inaugurated President of the United States…

don’t worry barack, we’ll have your back! hurry home to see your gramma… be safe!

Obama leaving campaign trail to visit grandmother
http://ap.google.com/ article/ ALeqM5g3m4YaeYwDHXS6hHdZJi8pm6cZdAD93UINL80

(also posted at TP)

I heard this on Rachel Maddow's show. Lots of well wishes for his grandma. She helped raise an exceptional person.

There is a super-surplus of this type of screed found in the speeches of Palin, Bachman and McCain claiming to speak for "real America", "real Americans" and "pro-Americans". While Ms. Palin and her husband dabble in anti-American political groups seeking separation of Alaska, she tries to paint any American who disagrees with her as America haters.

She is a hater of Americans, a divider who wants to lead or, if she can't, leave desolation behind her.

I know that her supporters don't think that she should be examined before being elected to a position of possible successor to the Presidency. It's unfair to examine her own actions after she has defined others as terrorist and unpatriotic. She's only been at it for six weeks, can't we take her political handlers' words for it?

Oh, that there were a dearth of her kind, although she would not be missed.

wasn't cut off in the actual show...

Pro-America is the part of America where the people are Paid to be American, Unlike the Amateur America where we choose to be American because we love this Country and are ready to take it back.

America is learning the painful truth that there are fascists amongst us. The corporate media has been too bullied and intimadated by the intolerant right to point out the fact. Fortunately KO and Rachel Maddow haven't.

People like Palin only think in myopic ways. What she meant by "pro-America" is that you are "pro-America" only when you accept and support her ideals. In her mind, SHE is America.

And what a horrible mind she has.

I think every person in America needs to read this. I am sick of this mindset that is being propagated by McCain and his surrogates. This demagoguery does nothing to help our nation. My God, I think republicans are wrong on every issue, but I know that they are American through and through. Why does every Republican have to paint things in this good v. evil dichotomy? THINGS ARE NOT BLACK OR WHITE! Thinking in such simple terms mitigates the complexity and diversity that is our modern world and places us on a road where very bad things can happen. Keith O. made some excellent points in this special comment. I am just extremely agitated and quite angry that there are people saying that because I don't believe in one, myopic way I am anti-American. I am sorry but that mindset is anti-American and against everything that this nation has fought and stood for.

Well said Keith...As usual.

Who they are and how to deal with them!

Keith has started the coversation 'cause they're all 'round uz!

This: "I'm more American than you" crap is childish republican dribble. Now I will go buy 100 flags,paint my house with stars and stripes.....I'll show-um...nanner nanner nanner.

I thought it was "neener neener neener"? Dang... I'm always the last to know the truth.

This: "I'm more American than you" crap is childish republican dribble. Now I will go buy 100 flags,paint my house with stars and stripes.....I'll show-um...nanner nanner nanner.

I was an American that proudly displayed my flag on Flag Day, 4th of July and at times just because I was a proud American. I can no longer do that ..... The Republicans have made it an ugly symbol of their Party and I, in no way, care to be part of their biased, bigotted beliefs.

... too many other people have worked, fought, suffered, or died, to preserve "the Republic for which it stands".

These thugs don't deserve to get sole ownership, unchallenged.

To me, within this last decade, the most anti-American act undertaken was to misrepresent a national security threat from Iraq, with knowledge that no such security threat existed, in order to divert America's war with the terrorists that attacked us on Sept 11, 2001 in Afghanistan to nation building in Iraq, fulfilling an agenda advocated by the Project for The New American Century (PNAC) for the last decade. Those who would take impeachment off the table for this treasonable like act can never be elevated to other than the lesser of two evils. The consequences have been devastating. First, the Taliban has been allowed to recoup when, while we had the best ally in Pakistan we're going to ever get, Musharraf, we could have done much more damage to Al-quaeda. Now, Pakistan's central government is much weaker, and has less capability to deal with the Islamic extremists. Second, the big winner in the Iraq war was Iran. $550B to eliminate an Iranian national security threat? Now, of course, PNAC knew that defeating Iraq would enhance Iran's standing. Therefore there is NO WAY that war with Iran wasn't contemplated as soon as the 6 month cakewalk war with Iraq was concluded. That's why talking with Iran is off the table for the neocons. McCain has Randy Scheunemann from PNAC as his principle foreign policy advisor.

The above paragraph is, to me, by leaps and bounds, the most un-American issue to surface in recent times.

As far as Colin Powell's endorsement, Powell only restates the obvious - Palin represents poor judgment on the part of McCain, indicating that "experience" doesn't lead to "wisdom", and that Obama has been vetted and is not wanting on his comprehension of the issues.

(Probably my last post. Will be a new ballgame anyway if Obama wins and we're no longer the loyal opposition. Don't forget to turn out - don't take anything for granted, especially Ohio or Florida.)

It is unfortunate that prez campaigns get so ugly. And worse yet is the republican push to separate and alienate groups. But it reminds me how much hate and fear they have fostered these past 8 years. It is sort of a slash and burn philosophy. What happened to the honor McCain claimed years ago? Apparently, lost in the drive to be prez; it was too heavy to carry both honor and ambition.

♫♫♪ BACHMANN BURNER OFFAL DIVE ♫♪♫

Hopefully this will cost her her Congressional Seat.

Did her mother have any kids that lived?

She's dead from the neck up.

Who votes morons like Michelle Bachmann et al in? What the hell is wrong with some of you people?

They never get out of the US, they have no World View. If they could only see the Us as the rest of the World sees us they might be surprised. It used to be the US Moron Factor was only about 26%, but that has grown of late to near 40 odd percentile.
Maybe it's the home schooling by unqualified parents who's only education (sic) is bible school.

Hell, they probably never get out of their home STATE. Seems that the folks I've met in my travels in the U.S. who have never been anywhere are overwhelmingly ignorant right wingers. They've never actually interacted with someone who thinks/acts/believes/looks different than them.

I have seen the same thing. Take SC for example, most S. Carolinians have never gone more than 300 mile.

We have our morons also. Funny thing is, they try to be like your morons. Our big morons even take money from your big morons.
Scary.

That the supposed "Pro-America" crowd wants to exclude people based on race and religion, censor freedom of speech and elevate propaganda to an art form.

If only they realized this is the type of behavior Americans used to slam the USSR for. The truth, I believe, is the supposed "Pro-America" crowd secretly admires the control China and the USSR had over its people.

I've said it before, but it warrants saying again--that's the only way the Republicans can win is by creating the illusion that the country is divided.

Black versus white didn't stop Obama.

Their Christianity versus Our Christianity didn't stop Obama.

Pro-choice versus pro-life didn't stop Obama.

So now they're pulling out all the stops: Muslim versus Christian, terrorist versus patriots, Pro-America versus Anti-America, communists/socialists versus capitalists.

With any luck, people have caught on.

I really do. And thank God for Keith Olbermann and MSNBC.

We are awash in distraction, nonsense, and media created controversy over flag pins and other bullshit while the country burns down around us.

Welcome to the McCain/Palin We Hate Most of America Campaign.

You need an R to be considered pro America. You can a conservative corporatist tool with neocon tendencies (aka Obama) or an even more right wing tool (aka Webb) and as long as you have something other than an R next to your name, you are an American hating pinko. Now if you eat babies, push ladies off cliffs, have gay sex while snorting coke and being humped by a donkey, all fine as long as you have an R next to your name.

KO speaks the eloquent truth and asks the right questions. Too bad nobody of any importance in the GOP will bother answering them truthfully.

Any one notice she resembles that ugly bitch Katarine Harris, from Florida that helped steal the election from Gore. Both ugly from the neck up and then down.

"...party to a campaign that devolves into hatred and prejudice and divisiveness"? Isn't that pretty much the GOP platform?

I'd vote Republican.

Best KO rant ever. He is 100% red-hot on target with this one.

damn! all this time I thought you had to register to comment...i've been visiting this website for a long long time, actually, i never missed it by a day...i always liked the videos.. this i guess will be my one and last post.
Just want to say good job to the dude/girl who's maintaining this website. i'm not going to register b/c i come here mostly out of habit..if i see a good video i watch it if i don't i move on to dailykos (which was introduced to me by Mr. O'reilly when I was in 2nd year undergrad and strong supporter of him AND F-ing Bush - i was young and stupid...also remember it was only 2 years after 9/11 when Bush was riding high in favor ability).
please know that you've got the silent viewers of your website. keep up the good work.

in 14 days, you will be sayin' President Obama!

Wow

I just makes me want to vote Republican! I just love all the division but I dinant learn it in homeskool! I learnt it from the Buttpublican partie! Yeehaw, and paaahraze the Lard!

Everyone is opening their eyes!! :] I love keith olbermann :] and rachel :]

:]

President OBAMA... Sounds right. :]

Again, I watch Countdown almost every night and respect the hell out
of KO, but these "Special Comments" are getting downright annoying.

KO is not the nations moral or intellectual compass. And if he does one
of these at the drop of every outrage how fucking special are they.

Give it a fucking rest already.

Sincerely,

A fan since his sportscaster days.

So many outrages

So little tolerance for the outraged...

KO is just as important a compass as anyone else. The is the "real America" and if you don't like what he has to say do what I do with FAUX, ignore it exists. I for one look forward to the Special Comments because KO for one has the balls to say what I think.

KO and RM - Now that's a team! Seriously, I love KO's Special Comments, because he does have the balls to say what you think - what I think- what most of America thinks.
KO and RM both make their thinking visible. I like that in a commentator.

In other words, "Don't bother me, I don't want to have to think."

Across the aisle

And crush someone.

I pooped my pants!!

Another excellent piece. Thank you, Keith!

wasnt george allen making a similar point about "real" virginia right before he made the "maccacca" comment?

I think this whole "Pro-America, Anti-America thing could either get really ugly and possibly violent...OR...it will increase the rate of defection of true fiscal conservatives from the GOP from a trickle to a flood.
This jingoistic bullshit they're exhibiting is just so bloody transparent to anyone with a brain in their freakin heads...
It really makes one wonder...how a group (GOP) that acts increasingly anti-American, can accuse others (everyone that isn't them) who would preserve the constitution, and the Bill Of Rights as un-American.
Cognitive dissonance? Projection? Head Up Ass?

America was founded by men who were, above all, courageous. Courageous enough to sit side by side with people who believed differently than they did, and to give them a vote, too. They weren't so small-minded that they felt threatened by difference. They were courageous enough to keep their integrity and not resort to torture, when they had captured British soldiers and the redcoats were bombing New York City.

This "pro-America" vs. "anti-America" mentality is exactly the opposite--it stinks of fear and cowardice. "You're different and you scare me! Go away!" Unfortunately, our so-called leaders in gov't have been promoting fear and cowardice for the last eight years.

When the campaign is for the presidency of the USA, and all participants are exclusively USA citizens, why is it that McCain rallys are chanting USA? It's because they actually fear for "their America" and they feel the winds of change blowing. It's too much to ask them to understand that everybody wants a better America but we disagree on how to make the changes we need. I pray that "their America" disappears and is soon gone forever. Stoopid Utopian.

Someone needs to put a sock in Keith's mouth during one of these Special Comments. When you blast off every night with the kind of self righteous indignation that Keith spouts you do nothing to bring the country to together as Barack Obama intends. You simply continue to alienate and divide.

Let the Republicans do and say whatever they want. Ignore them. The only people that are listening wouldn't listen to Keith anyway. So just smile a big Barack Obama smile and let it go....SIR....

Or is it only Olbermann you want to gag?

Here's an idea: why don't you just change the channel if you can't stand to listen?

That means it's not all there, the end is cut off.

If you're going to put it up at all, why not do the entire piece?

Fer chrissakes, will everyone please quit bitching about the truncated clip. Go read the rest of the comments above, you'll find it's not an evil plot to piss you off, it's due to a DVR not knowing that Keith's comment ran into Rachel's time period. Now if you stayed with Rachel immediately following, you would have heard the ending!

They could just go to the MSNBC site and watch it there is they want to hear every soundbite.

Olbermann is a constant pleasure, as he sees the possibilities of America, and the dangers of what has now become of "conservatism". Edmund Burke would be horrified at Bush/Cheney/McCain/Palin/Limbaugh/ O'Reilly/Hannity/et. alia. Keep commenting, Keith: they're special.

79 comments

Login or Register to post comments.