Go Home

Another Runaway General

Apparently, our General staff is shot through with Little Caesars who fancy themselves the masters of the universe or something. Last year it was McChrystal and insubordination. This year it is Caldwell, a three-star in charge of training Afghan troops who stands accused of using psy-ops against visiting American Senators and Congressmen so they would give the war effort more troops.

He needs to be relieved of command immediately and his ass needs to be on a plane bound for Washington for a public humiliation and firing.

The U.S. Army illegally ordered a team of soldiers specializing in "psychological operations" to manipulate visiting American senators into providing more troops and funding for the war, Rolling Stone has learned – and when an officer tried to stop the operation, he was railroaded by military investigators.

The orders came from the command of Lt. Gen. William Caldwell, a three-star general in charge of training Afghan troops – the linchpin of U.S. strategy in the war. Over a four-month period last year, a military cell devoted to what is known as "information operations" at Camp Eggers in Kabul was repeatedly pressured to target visiting senators and other VIPs who met with Caldwell. When the unit resisted the order, arguing that it violated U.S. laws prohibiting the use of propaganda against American citizens, it was subjected to a campaign of retaliation.

"My job in psy-ops is to play with people’s heads, to get the enemy to behave the way we want them to behave," says Lt. Colonel Michael Holmes, the leader of the IO unit, who received an official reprimand after bucking orders. "I’m prohibited from doing that to our own people. When you ask me to try to use these skills on senators and congressman, you’re crossing a line."

The list of targeted visitors was long, according to interviews with members of the IO team and internal documents obtained by Rolling Stone. Those singled out in the campaign included senators John McCain, Joe Lieberman, Jack Reed, Al Franken and Carl Levin; Rep. Steve Israel of the House Appropriations Committee; Adm. Mike Mullen of the Joint Chiefs of Staff; the Czech ambassador to Afghanistan; the German interior minister, and a host of influential think-tank analysts.

The incident offers an indication of just how desperate the U.S. command in Afghanistan is to spin American civilian leaders into supporting an increasingly unpopular war. According to the Defense Department’s own definition, psy-ops – the use of propaganda and psychological tactics to influence emotions and behaviors – are supposed to be used exclusively on "hostile foreign groups." Federal law forbids the military from practicing psy-ops on Americans, and each defense authorization bill comes with a "propaganda rider" that also prohibits such manipulation. "Everyone in the psy-ops, intel, and IO community knows you’re not supposed to target Americans," says a veteran member of another psy-ops team who has run operations in Iraq and Afghanistan. "It’s what you learn on day one."

Of course, we all realize that it goes on. Images are manipulated and messages are massaged. Before they appear before Congress, Generals confer with image consultants to lead the star-struck officials before them where they want them to go.

But this is a whole new level of evil. Not only did Caldwell intentionally violate U.S. laws against propagandizing American legislators, he punished the guy who stood up and said it was wrong. If that isn't intent and malice aforethought, I don't know what is.

Congressional delegations – known in military jargon as CODELs – are no strangers to spin. U.S. lawmakers routinely take trips to the frontlines in Iraq and Afghanistan, where they receive carefully orchestrated briefings and visit local markets before posing for souvenir photos in helmets and flak jackets. Informally, the trips are a way for generals to lobby congressmen and provide first-hand updates on the war. But what Caldwell was looking for was more than the usual background briefings on senators. According to Holmes, the general wanted the IO team to provide a "deeper analysis of pressure points we could use to leverage the delegation for more funds." The general’s chief of staff also asked Holmes how Caldwell could secretly manipulate the U.S. lawmakers without their knowledge. "How do we get these guys to give us more people?" he demanded. "What do I have to plant inside their heads?"

According to experts on intelligence policy, asking a psy-ops team to direct its expertise against visiting dignitaries would be like the president asking the CIA to put together background dossiers on congressional opponents. Holmes was even expected to sit in on Caldwell’s meetings with the senators and take notes, without divulging his background. "Putting your propaganda people in a room with senators doesn’t look good," says John Pike, a leading military analyst. "It doesn’t pass the smell test. Any decent propaganda operator would tell you that."

At a minimum, the use of the IO team against U.S. senators was a misue of vital resources designed to combat the enemy; it cost American taxpayers roughly $6 million to deploy Holmes and his team in Afghanistan for a year. But Caldwell seemed more eager to advance his own career than to defeat the Taliban. "We called it Operation Fourth Star," says Holmes. "Caldwell seemed far more focused on the Americans and the funding stream than he was on the Afghans. We were there to teach and train the Afghans. But for the first four months it was all about the U.S. Later he even started talking about targeting the NATO populations." At one point, according to Holmes, Caldwell wanted to break up the IO team and give each general on his staff their own personal spokesperson with psy-ops training.

Remember the blurbs in the news about unnamed politicians whose records had been improperly accessed? Maybe it wasn't just one guy at the State Department. Maybe he was the fall guy, but the real culprits were these psy-ops folks accessing records on politicians before visits. My Senator, Claire McCaskill, is a pretty high profile member of the Armed Services Committee and she has made several trips to Afghanistan. Was she one of those against whom these tactics were employed?

Caldwell shouldn't just get to walk away from the mess he created like McChrystal did, though. He needs to face criminal charges, and possibly he needs to face war crimes charges if an intrepid prosecutor can build that case. He needs to hang high and be made an example of. He definitely needs to lose his rank and his bennies. He needs to be made to suffer public humiliation. If he is not, then the civilians have ceded control and we aren't that far from being ruled by a de facto military junta, and that is not the country I want to live in.

I've been saying it for -weeks- months over a year...it is time for Obama to channel Truman and fire a whole bunch of these flag rank f***heads and pin stars on the shoulders of men like Lt. Colonel Holmes, Paul Yingling and Bob Bateman.

Believe me yet?

Share This Post

Link To This Post


31 Comments
Handypants's picture

"According to experts on intelligence policy, asking a psy-ops team to direct its expertise against visiting dignitaries would be like the president asking the CIA to put together background dossiers on congressional opponents."

I think it is far worse. It is nothing short of lying to congress. Any deception about something as important as military action is treasonous.


"I know that there are people who do not love their fellow
man, and I hate people like that!
" ~ Tom Lehrer (1928 - )

In 2002, the Pentagon announced that it was considering spreading false propaganda in the foreign press. However, the military has spread propaganda within the U.S. in an operation so aggressive that one participant, a military analyst, called it "psyops on steroids"

http://www.washingtonsblog.com/2009/10/herdin...


"Great minds discuss ideas; average minds discuss events; small minds discuss people." ~ Eleanor Roosevelt

Margaret's picture

Those guys fall over themselves for more war.


Barack Obama: Change we can only imagine

MountainMan23's picture

maybe ..


Democracy is too important to be entrusted to politicians.
Rise Up!
Protest!

not stupid's picture

Lindsey Graham the only one who really was Brainwash, he was really happy to have a large Persian rug for $10.00 from an Iraqi (who probably wanted to feed his family). What a good job Sir
Half the money that the pentagon has receive since ST Ronny the biggest joke in the last 40 years, privatize most of the government and instead of just a few CEOs now all those co for profits are more expensive that if the government was running things it.
Please let the pentagon explain who is getting the money. Are the still paying Halliburton, Black water!!!!!!!

MountainMan23's picture

.. they've all changed their names !!


Democracy is too important to be entrusted to politicians.
Rise Up!
Protest!

thinkerfromiowa's picture

"I've been saying it for -weeks- months over a year...it is time for Obama to channel Truman and fire a whole bunch of these flag rank f***heads and pin stars on the shoulders of men like Lt. Colonel Holmes, Paul Yingling and Bob Bateman."

Of all the presidents I can personally remember -- I was almost 3 years old when FDR died -- Truman was the one who had real guts in the Oval Office. But after watching Barak Baby for 2 years, I am totally convinced that he has something else than guts inside his belly. Of course it takes guts to stand up to these renegade generals, unless down deep in your heart you believe they are right. We desperately need FDR or Truman in the White House now, but unfortunately they are dead. There is one person who I think has what it takes to stand up to these goons, but unfortunately, she has other responsibilities right now -- like serving as Secretary of State.

fiver's picture

You had me going all the way to the end. No kidding, I bought it hook, line and sinker. Well done.
It not only expresses just how screwed we are with our present Democratic leadership, but just how hopeless it looks for the near future.

Hillary Clinton's got what it takes. That's snark at its finest. I want to cry, but I can't stop chuckling.

Allow me to return the favor in a small way. Hillary Clinton, Cool Under Fire


Corruption favors the wealthy.

Medical Diagnosis by Video's picture

Mrs. Clinton is a war monger, without the need for PsychOps. Recall her speech on the Senate floor about Saddam and his WMD? Look it up. The military would get anything they want, and more, from Clinton.

David762's picture

Truman wasn't such a great President ... he signed the National Security Act of 1947 into law, which helped in a very large way to create the post-WW2 Military Industrial Complex. The CIA & NSA job was to create out of thin air, or exaggerate out of all proportion, the threat of the USSR, which started the Cold War.
Which reminds me of another not so great President, Woodrow Wilson, who signed the legislation which created the Federal Reserve System -- a politician who ran on "no war in Europe" and then worked very hard to sway public opinion and get the USA into that European WW1.
Then we have President Clinton, who kicked "extreme rendition" into gear, as well as greatly increased domestic spying, and then pulled the plug on the separation between banking and investment services, culminating in the economic meltdown of September 2008. But of course, you are talking about Hillary -- a Republican-turned-Democrat who never met a foreign military conflict that she didn't like, especially if it helped the apartheid Zionist Republic of Israel.

Either you have your snark on, or else you have no sense of history -- I cannot decide which it is.


"Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable."
-- John F. Kennedy

Probably by an investigator chosen by General David "Has anybody seen 190,000 M-16s anywhere?" Petraeus.

Or maybe by that same guy who investigated the psy-op involving retiring generals taking their talking points from Donald Rumsfeld then appearing on the networks as "independent" retired generals as they beat the drums for the Iraq War.

Oops. That one was only investigated and reported by a NYT journalist then the story simply disappeared - until he won a Pulitzer for it - then it disappeared again.


Corruption favors the wealthy.

MountainMan23's picture

Is that why he's become such a lap-puppy of the military and the billionaires?


Democracy is too important to be entrusted to politicians.
Rise Up!
Protest!

ixnay's picture

Our approach to prevent our fall is to pretend we're not an empire. Creative no doubt. But as deeply flawed as every other approach to establish and maintain an empire before ours.


CTHULHU 2012 "Why vote for a lesser evil?"

Steve E's picture

"we must guard against the acquisition of unwarranted influence whether sought or unsought, by the Military-Industrial Complex - the potential for the disastrous rise of misplaced power exists and will persist." Amen.

Rufus's picture

President Truman didn't fire MacArthur because he had guts.

He fired him because he was an Artillery Captain in WWI combat, and he knew that being Commander-In-Chief trumped the stars.

Too bad President Obama never served as an Artillery Captain in combat.

Col. Kilgore's picture

... a few senators were subjected to a sales pitch. Golly, I'm shocked.

If you re-frame a sales pitch as "psy-ops" then you can really get some people up in arms, heh, so to speak. Christ, Fox News is psy-ops 24/7, broadcast over our own airwaves. We subsidize it. Should we expect less in an actual war zone?

Taarak's picture

That was my first question. What is entailed in the Psy-Ops? Misinformation? Shit, the entire Iraq war was an exercise in psy-ops in that case. I would like more details, but I’m sure they are…um… top secret.

winston61's picture

fire all those brass hat sons of bitches. Fucking officers. The only way you can hurt these bastards is to take away their shiny brass buttons and stars. Their careers and power are the only meaningful things to those assholes. Let a few colonels and generals know what it feels like to be unemployed.

That will not do it -- they all have lucrative jobs lined up ... as (1) members of conservative think tanks, (2) Faux Nudes ex-military pundits, or (3) on the Board of Directors of defense contractors in the Military Industrial Complex.

To really hurt them, We the People ned to take away all their shiny toys that go "boom". It's time, past time, to gut the Defense and Intel budgets and cash in that "peace dividend" that never occurred at the end of WW2, or the end of the Cold War.
And while we are at it, let's rescind the War Powers Act which allows a President to get the USA into unwanted, unnecessary foreign conflicts -- that power properly belongs to Congress. If the President no longer has that power, nor the standing army which encourages such actions, this would be a far safer peaceful world.


"Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable."
-- John F. Kennedy

Antiskeptic's picture

The term is "malice aforethought"...premeditation. Carry on! :)

roci's picture

in the White House, he's be busted so low, he'd end this week by saluting Buck Privates in Greenland. This is the same sort of "stuff" that Truman relieved MacArthur for, and this man ought to be gone even faster.

Kreskin's picture

This country has become one big train wreck .

Kreskin's picture

Gee what would they do with no occupations and no war ? Besides , they gotta keep the money laundering operation going , the military defense contractors and the profiteers on Wall Street have families to feed .

surfjac's picture

...but do you really think in this "age of looking ahead", anyone is going to be punished? Forget about it. We're heading into a time when really stupid people will be running things, the middle class will be destroyed and you'll be unpatriotic if you complain about it. This country is no longer moving forward; we are moving backward and all the blogs in the world isn't going to change that.
Sorry, what just happened in Wisconsin and what is happening in Montana to name two stories in the news today have got me convinced I should just head for the jungles of Central America, never to return.


Mickey: "It was an epiphany. Do you know what an epipany is?"
Keoni: "NOT NOW MICKEY!"

Mooster's picture

Caldwell and McChrystal. McChrystal was guilty of insubordination, and deserved to be fired. If you call that 'getting to walk away', okay, but it was the appropriate action. What Caldwell has done is a much more serious matter. The man should be courts martialed and get some first hand experience behind bars. This was not just a matter of a military man doing things that offend the sheltered, this is criminal behavior that must be punished.

Paul's picture

He can no longer be considered trustworthy and he does not appear to accept that he is obliged to always be truthful. Without integrity, he has nothing to offer. Regardless the fact that the list of VIP's they were manipulating are people without honor, morals or integrity and are, generally, irredeemably corrupt, the civilians must be in control of the military, not the other way around. Taking retributive measures against a junior officer who had the integrity and honor to obey the laws was a dishonorable thing to do. This guy no longer deserves to have stars pinned on his uniform. Time for him to hang up the uniform and go home.

Medical Diagnosis by Video's picture

Let's see if the Dems show any spine in getting rid of this rat bastard "general" who should spend time in Leavenworth.

Fire all of these crooks posing as patriots, take away all their shiny toys, and throw them in the brig.

LOL, this will never happen. We cannot even prosecute self-acknowledged treasonous war criminals.


"Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable."
-- John F. Kennedy

yakfitguy's picture

The US military is infested with Fascist traitors and leftovers from the Cheney cabal. It must be purged.

Period.


The whole religious complexion of the modern world is due to the absence from Jerusalem of a Lunatic Asylum. -Havelock Ellis

kryptos242's picture

What is the surprise here? People in power have spent a great deal of time and effort to control the way the masses think/feel. So now they have turned their attention to people of power. We should have known this was going to happen. What I still find so interesting (except for people who come to this site) is how docile the American public has become on the most disturbing issues of the day. We really need a strong revolution in order to wake citizens up to what depths the government will go to for control and deception.


kryptos242

...(skipping Colonel completely) would probably not be a good idea, unless there were a compelling reason to do so. Making General takes many years and someone who gets political promotions like that will probably not be genuinely respected by other officers.

The officer that comes to mind when political promotion is mentioned is Alexander Haig. Not a good model to emulate.

Comments are closed on this entry