Read time: 4 minutes

Tom Nichols Blames A 'Poisonous Nostalgia' For White Male Resentment

The conservative never-Trumper was on Morning Joe plugging his new book.

Tom Nichols, conservative commentator and U.S. Naval War College professor, was plugging his new book, "Our Own Worst Enemy: The Assault from Within of our Modern Democracy" this morning.

And he had what I thought was a good explanation for a lot of the political insanity these days. He says that white men are wallowing in "poisonous nostalgia" because the world as they grew to understand is changing so much. I grew up in a neighborhood that sounds just like his small Massachusetts town, and it rings true to me.

"We want to believe things are not our fault and things are so terrible and we would do better and wouldn't have to be so angry if things weren't so awful all the time," he said.

"Every age has its advantages and disadvantages. but the notion that somehow in 2021 -- when we're living longer, healthier, the world is mostly at peace, whether people want to believe that or not, it's true -- people want to believe this is the worst time ever. And it's a poisonous nostalgia that looks back and there's no way a democratic government can keep up with that unless they can invent a time machine."

Nichols pointed out the loss of industrial jobs is not new.

"I do not come from a privileged family, my parents were Depression-era high school dropouts. I grew up among factories that by the time I was a child were empty and rotting, " he recalled. "I played in abandoned -- with abandoned equipment and empty factories and coal yards and railroad trestles. I write about that this morning in USA Today, there are two things about that. A lot of that happened before people were willing to admit that happened. I talked to a friend in a book and said I remember when all those factories were full. I said that was impossible we broke the windows in that factory when we were 11, like 50 years ago. people have convinced themselves there was once this golden age they remember that was only taken away in the last few years."

(Again: I grew up playing on an asbestos site, toxic waste dumping was everywhere in my neighborhood. And the Philly area where I live now? These abandoned factories and industrial sites have been here a LONG time.)

Katty Kay couldn't quite bring herself to ask what it had to do with outright misogyny, but hinted at it.

"Is it overly simplistic to say that's driving some of the people out there saying things aren't as good for me as they used to be?"

"No," Nichols replied, "I think that's directly a cause of a lot of this. And, you know, again, there are some of these stories from my own hometown where people that I grew up with who are now prosperous. I had a friend who, you know, working-class guy I went to school with since we were small children, spends his weekends on his boat, and he says everything is changed, it's awful."

"What he means is the street we grew up on, we had a neighborhood barber, candy store and diner, and one of them is an antique shop now, another is a Spanish storefront church, and the library is closed. He just wants it to be -- it's like a mid-life crisis for a lot of white males for whom they want it to be 1969 again. I think that the problem of becoming a minority is really anxiety-producing for a lot of them. But again, the answer to that is more democracy, not some kind of illiberal backlash and trying to turn the clock back by force. But they've been told by politicians and political entrepreneurs that with just enough willpower and rage and anger and resentment they can turn the hands of time back and, you know, make it 1965 again."

He talked about selective memory. "I don't know if I wanted to be a black man dealing with my hometown cops. I don't know I wanted to be a woman who had to ask for permission to get a car loan, you know, in 1962. We have this very selective memory about what was great about it."

"I think anyone who is nostalgic for the 1970s - I talk about this in the book -- people see the 70s as a benchmark," he added. "I was a teenager in the 70s and I cannot imagine a decade I would rather not go back to in my hometown and the way I grew up. But people have, you know, sanitized these memories and turned them into sepia-toned photographs if their minds that aren't true."

Yes. This is exactly what I hear from far too many of the white people I grew up with. Our Southwest Philly neighborhood was a veritable Nirvana, to hear them tell it. But I remember gang fights, a black kid getting killed, cops brutalizing people, proud ignorance, and racism. A whole lot of racism. They still speak lovingly of the late Mayor Frank Rizzo, famous for promoting police brutality against black men.

I couldn't wait to get out.

Can you help us out?

For 17 years we have been exposing Washington lies and untangling media deceit, but now Facebook is drowning us in an ocean of right wing lies. Please give a one-time or recurring donation, or buy a year's subscription for an ad-free experience. Thank you.

More C&L Coverage

Discussion

New Commenting System

Our comments are now powered by Insticator. In order to comment you will need to create an Insticator account. The process is quick and simple. Please note that the ability to comment with a C&L site account is no longer available.

We welcome relevant, respectful comments. Any comments that are sexist or in any other way deemed hateful by our staff will be deleted and constitute grounds for a ban from posting on the site. Please refer to our Terms of Service (revised 3/17/2016) for information on our posting policy.

Please Do Not Use the Login Link at the Top of the Site.

In order to comment you must use an Insticator account. To register an account, enter your comment and click the post button. A dialog will then appear allowing you create your account.

We will be retiring our Crooks and Liars user account system in January, 2021.

Thank you.
C&L Team