Keeping Extremisms Out of the U.S. Military
By Jon Perr Thursday Nov 12, 2009 5:00pm
Revelations that the FBI, the Pentagon and even his medical colleagues were aware of Fort Hood shooting suspect Nidal Malik Hasan's extremist ideology have raised serious questions about the U.S. military's ability to screen, monitor and remove dangerous personnel from its ranks. But far from justifying the discrimination against patriotic American Muslims predictably called for by the usual suspects, the Fort Hood bloodbath should remind Americans that extremisms of all stripes have no place in the armed forces of the United States.
A nation which has chosen to depend on an all-volunteer military must have clear standards for admitting and retaining those courageous few who wish to serve in its name. Needless to say, they should not pose a threat to themselves or their fellow servicemen and women. They should uphold their oath to the Constitution of the United States and its government. And importantly, they should not undermine either American national security objectives or our timeless democratic values by advancing their own.
To be sure, as the always execrable Michelle Malkin fumed in the wake of the Fort Hood slaughter, potential Al Qaeda sympathizers and possibly deranged Muslim extremists like Major Hasan and Sgt. Hasan Akbar must be prevented from entering or quickly weeded out of the American military.
But the danger to America's security at home and goals abroad hardly ends there.
Consider the growing infiltration of neo-Nazi groups within the armed services. In 2006 and again in 2009, the Southern Poverty Law Center, a group which monitors racist and right-wing militia groups, concluded:
A decade after the Pentagon declared a zero-tolerance policy for racist hate groups, recruiting shortfalls caused by the war in Iraq have allowed "large numbers of neo-Nazis and skinhead extremists" to infiltrate the military, according to a watchdog organization...
The report quotes Scott Barfield, a Defense Department investigator, saying, "Recruiters are knowingly allowing neo-Nazis and white supremacists to join the armed forces, and commanders don't remove them from the military even after we positively identify them as extremists or gang members."
That zero-tolerance policy was put in place in the aftermath of the devastating Oklahoma City bombing which killed 168 Americans, the largest death toll from a terrorist attack on the U.S. homeland before 9/11.
As the New York Times recounted:
The 1996 crackdown on extremists came after revelations that Mr. McVeigh had espoused far-right ideas when he was in the Army and recruited two fellow soldiers to aid his bomb plot. Those revelations were followed by a furor that developed when three white paratroopers were convicted of the random slaying of a black couple in order to win tattoos and 19 others were discharged for participating in neo-Nazi activities.
But a more widespread if more subtle threat to the success of America's military and foreign policy objectives may be the creeping Christian fundamentalism extending throughout the U.S. Army, Navy, Air Force and Marines.
The aggressive push to entrench Christian conservative personnel and propaganda at all ranks of the armed services manifests itself with growing frequency. An early warning came in 2003 in the guise of Lt. General William Boykin. Boykin, who later became a deputy under secretary of defense, claimed during speeches to prayer groups and churches that militant Islamists sought to destroy America "because we're a Christian nation." General Boykin also explained to evangelical audiences that Muslims worship an "idol" and not "a real God." While President Bush expressed his disagreement (noting Boykin "didn't reflect my opinion" and "it just doesn't reflect what the government thinks"), Boykin remained on the job.
Meanwhile, evangelical proselytizing at the Air Force Academy makes a mockery of both Pentagon policy and American values of democracy and religious freedom. In May, 2005, Lutheran minister and Captain MeLinda Morton was removed from her post after warning evangelical Christians were trying to "subvert the system" in trying to win converts among cadets at the Academy. A June 2005 study at USAFA described other incidents of religious intolerance, insensitivity and inappropriate proselytizing, and concluded:
"Additionally, some faculty members and coaches consider it their duty to profess their faith and discuss this issue in their classrooms in furtherance of developing cadets' spirituality."
Even minor restrictions on proselytizing produced an avalanche of opposition from Focus on the Family, the Christian Coalition and other groups which protested that new proposed guidelines abridged "the constitutional right of military chaplains to pray according to their faith."
Undaunted, the push to proselytize in the U.S. military continues. In 2007, an inspector general's report highlighted ethics violations among current and former officers, including two major generals, for appearing in uniform for a promotional and fundraising video for the evangelical group Christian Embassy. As the Washington Post noted, the report "offers a vivid picture of how inappropriately intertwined Christian Embassy had become with Pentagon operations by the time the video, with its extensive scenes inside the Pentagon, was filmed in 2004." Nonetheless, the New York Times reported earlier this year that military personnel were shown videos featuring football's Terry Bradshaw professing his Christian religion as part of an official military production dealing with depression, suicide and "the importance of faith."
The blind eye turned towards these extremist ideologies may not merely overlook the next Terry McVeigh. At a time when the United States is trying to win hearts and minds among Muslim faithful in Iraq and Afghanistan, the new crusader culture risks undermining the fight against Al Qaeda.
As Jeremy Scahill documented in the Huffington Post in May, these kinds of incidents are an affront both to the U.S. military code of conduct and America's Afghan allies:
Lieutenant-Colonel Gary Hensley, the chief of the US military chaplains in Afghanistan, is seen telling soldiers that as followers of Jesus Christ, they all have a responsibility "to be witnesses for him."
"The special forces guys - they hunt men basically. We do the same things as Christians, we hunt people for Jesus. We do, we hunt them down," he says.
"Get the hound of heaven after them, so we get them into the kingdom. That's what we do, that's our business."
(The U.S. military later confirmed that Bibles meant to be distributed to Afghan civilians were destroyed.)
After that embarrassment, Joint Chiefs Chairman Michael Mullen reminded his countrymen:
"It certainly is, from the United States military's perspective, not our position to ever push any specific kind of religion, period."
In the wake of the Fort Hood massacre, General George Casey, chief of staff of the Army, explained one reason why:
"As great a tragedy as this was, it would be a shame if our diversity became a casualty as well."
Which is exactly right. Americans are still trying to determine whether Major Nidal Malik Hasan was a would-be Islamic jihadist, a disgruntled serviceman, criminally insane or possibly all of the above.
In the mean time, thousands of Muslim American soldiers, sailors, marines and air force personnel continue to defend their countrymen around the world. Some now reside at Arlington National Cemetery, like 20 year old Army Specialist Kareem Rashad Sultan Khan, having given their lives for our nation.
Which is why it is so essential both that Americans now resist the dark urge to prevent Muslims from serving in the United States military while remaining vigilant in keeping religious, racial and political extremism of all kinds out of it.
NOTE: For information on how you can help support the victims of the Fort Hood tragedy, visit the BBB listings for the Fort Hood Chaplain's Fund, the local Red Cross, USO Fort Hood, Fort Hood Fisher House and other charities serving Fort Hood and the Killeen, Texas community.
(This piece also appears at Perrspectives.)








Login or Register to post comments.
..we have our own terrorist group forming right here..one that uses the cross rather than the crescent as their symbol.
if the govt was really interested in keeping
the extremists out of the military,then why
are they taking convicted felons?
give me a break.
you can't serve your country if you are gay, but
it's ok if you are a convicted felon.
bullshit to the brain-dead who made this possible.
of all stripes.
We have too many thugs in the military.
I am just getting out of the military this month and have seen first hand how white supremacism is rampant, especially in the nearly all white, all male domains of the infantry, rangers, and special forces that I was a part of. I have been deployed to both Iraq and Afghanistan (just got back from afghanistan a few weeks ago) and it's an uphill battle as a minority sometimes in these enclaves. If you are a muslim soldier trying to be in Rangers/SF...you have LOTS of dreary days ahead. I wrote about it on my blog...http://www.haroldsleft.com/2009/08/racist-me-but-i-was-only-joking.html
What unit were you in ?
How big a grip does the KKK have in the ranks?
Oh, btw, your link needs to be re done.
Harold. I checked out your blog. Here's an active link to it.
haroldsleft. I recommend people to check this out.
I would say the KKK has very little grip in the active army. What has a grip is more of your typical type neo-nazi group. I was the only black in my unit for a while until another young guy came around, he was on a different team, and he got abused by the team and kicked off, because "he's not like us".
...Thank you for your brave service. ♥
Nice blog you have there. For some reason, I always have a difficult time logging into those blogs.
KKK: It would seem to me that the KKK and the neo nazi movement would be almost one in the same. Almost.
When I was in, racism was alive and well.
But, it was underground. It was hidden from view.
You never really knew who was and who wasn't.
And to be honest, racism knows no race. There were racists of every color and creed.
People gettin their hate on.
Will be quite interesting I'm sure.
military intelligence. gung ho and military kinda go together. Just so they are on our side I guess.
With the christofacists in the brass and the neos in the ranks the ones pulling the strings can get them to do anything they want including turning their weapons on us.
there are many factors in keeping people "happy" on the job. Often, what was once a satisfying position can become a downright burden if circumstances change. A good boss/manager is largely responsible for determining whether an employee has fallen short of the job requirements. Rarely will an employee ask to be voluntarily terminated, regardless of how unhappy he/she is.
Sounds like there were some "warning signs" here. But foresight is rarely 20/20. I know my boss's certainly isn't.
You've encapsulated a lot of what I've been thinking lately, and I'm feeling great frustration and a bit of despair.
But at least they're keeping the gays out, right? Ugh.
Thousands of gay people have had their careers and lives destroyed by DADT. But screwy lowered recruitment standards and screening means that psychos and criminals are more welcome in the armed forces than gay people, who have ALWAYS been there serving. And tragically persecuted due to systemic blackmail, coercion and sheer prejudice. I wish this country would just grow up sometimes.
...aren't going to volunteer to serve.
That's one wacko group we don't have to worry about.
Not only did I serve in the Air Force for four years
As a boy I lived for a few years in Wacko Texas.
I still say we could get rid of all the world's military forces
Put all our fighting age youngsters in a nightclub with plenty of pounding loud music
Shitloads of hooch and drugs
Let them do what comes naturally
And lay bets for our national interests.
I call it Apocalypse A'Go Go.
A scary thought the Dominionists in the military. Every day we read of the rise of the "Paliban". Be VERY aware and be Very afraid.
Shouldna that be Rebiblecans?
The way you said it makes them sound like heavy drinkers.
Either way they may as well be drunk.
Our macho military is not afraid of muslim extremists and skinheads. But they are terrified of THE GAYS !!!
It doesn't help that Obama delivered the kind of speech I'd expect from W.
What the hell was all that about being met with justice in this world and the next? That's the kind of talk that prejudices trials. Those comments just pandered to anti-Muslim sentiment and it's doubly disappointing coming from Obama who himself had to face prejudice because of his "Muslim name."
Not his finest moment.
http://the-billablog.blogspot.com/2009/11/oba...
...who runs it.
...and how they are using it to conquer the world.
ter·ror·ism emanates from spiritualism (spir·i·tu·al·ism) IMO.
History of the emblems... Red Cross ;) Elizabeth Hanford Dole,
... there were large groups of white supremacists and even a few neo-nazis around the base. Everyone knew it, yet no one said anything. You report the guy with the Nazi paraphernalia in his desk, and no one even bothers to check. You accuse a few guys whose room was broken into and trashed of being gay, and they send an NCIS team that afternoon. That's not an exaggeration, either, it's exactly what happened.
Atheists are the most hated and despised members of any branch of the military. Even more so than Wiccans.
Atheists in foxholes, some say they are myths,
Creations of the mind who just don't exist.
Yet, they answered the call to defend, with great pride.
With reason their watchword, they bled and they died.
They took Saratoga from the British crown,
Secured America's freedom at the Battle of Yorktown.
From Sumter to Appomattox, fields flowed with their blood.
When the cannons grew silent, the flag proudly stood.
From the Marne to the Argonne, in trenches and tanks,
They defeated the Germans -- the whole world gave thanks.
They were bombed at Pearl Harbor, fought on to Berlin.
Many freethinking women served along with the men.
Still war keeps erupting -- Iraq, Bosnia, and Kosovo.
Where is the peace that eludes people so?
It is broken by tyrants who bear crosses and creeds,
That overshadow reason with hate and cruel deeds.
So atheists prevail until your work is complete.
Mothers mourn, children cry, and bigots plan your defeat.
By air, land, and sea, you answer freedom's call.
Without god or faith, you seek liberty for all.
.
... for the record, it was not I who penned the aformentioned poem, I believe it was [Alice Shiver] and it was recited at this monument dedication in rural Alabama, where the [Cleveland family] donated the land, as part of a freethought park.
Lake Hypatia, Alabama July 4, 1999, well look at that...[Alabama] the "Bible Belt"!
Ya mean like:
http://www.latinamericanstudies.org/nicaragua...
... and I don't want to pay for "Fort Hood Chaplains". Go figure :-/
"The very concept of sin comes from the Bible. Christianity offers to solve a problem of its own making! Would you be thankful to a person who cut you with a knife in order to sell you a bandage?"--Dan Barker (1949— ), Former evangelical preacher; maintained a touring musical evangelical ministry for 17 years.
We need to let nutzis in the volunteer military that pursues our nation's corporate-hijacked agenda because not enough 'regular folks' will serve therefore we keep out gay people because the nutzis don't like them and we hire mercenary nutzis and rapists like Blackwater because there aren't enough nutzis available to fill the ranks at what we pay our troops and we give bloated contracts to corporate insiders to provide other services for which our volunteer force is insufficient and we don't want a universal draft because citizens would demand an end to senseless wars that make all of this possible. We've had enough money to throw around for the necessary contracts, bribes and kickbacks and may still if we don't go and do something stupid like making sure our people have health care.
There is also the issue of the rising numbers and militancy of radical evangelicals in the military, especially the air force. They scare me a hell of a lot more than any Muslims do.
that you can't have a coup these days w/o the AF.
Military personnel are trained to kill and that's exactly what Hasan did. What's so extreme about that?
So an Army doctor that probably hasn't touched a weapon since boot camp shoots 43 people? Lay off the X-Box people! He was kicked out of Walter Reed Hospital because he wasn't towing the Army line and expressed the thought that five or more tours in the War On Terrorism might make you bat-shit crazy. His patients at Fort Hood told him enough is enough and they weren't going back over seas so they were confronted by their own and a massive shooting took place . Hence the 43 soldiers shot. The doctor is a patsy and was shot 4 times to make him a "dead man tells no tales" casualty. Going to be interesting what he has to say at his trial. Of course if the Army lets him get that far.
he was picked on ruthlessly by all of his fellow soldiers after 9/11.
then he snapped and he shot em.
everybody's talking about al qaeda and islam and how hateful the religion is.
nobody's even thinking that maybe, just maybe, a bunch of bitter racist soldiers made their own 40-something year old psychiatric version of Kip Kinkle.
he got tired of being picked on for his religion.
he got scared of getting picked on even harder in a chaotic war zone.
he resented what he saw as a war against his religion.
he .. got tired .. of being picked on.
so he snapped and opened fire.
***
I dunno about y'all, but I felt kind of sorry for Kip Kinkle. I felt kind of sorry for the trenchcoat mafia. I also felt sorry for their victims. but those kids were ruthlessly picked on, with no support group.
kind of like Maj. Hasan
and from where I'm sitting, I do kind of wonder if he snapped, Colombine-style. I don't think this was a terrorist attack. I think this was a desperate "suicide by cop" incident.
One must remember that Obama represents the "sane" end of the political establishment.
Obama’s attempt to cast these wars of aggression as a crusade for freedom was aimed not merely at comforting the grieving loved ones of those cut down by gunfire last Thursday. Rather, it is part of a conscious attempt to overcome the antiwar sentiment of the American people in preparation for a major escalation of the war in Afghanistan.
http://www.wsws.org/articles/2009/nov2009/oba...
I'll start here:"Obama’s attempt to cast these wars of aggression as a crusade for freedom was aimed not merely at comforting the grieving loved ones of those cut down by gunfire last Thursday. Rather, it is part of a conscious attempt to overcome the antiwar sentiment of the American people in preparation for a major escalation of the war in Afghanistan."
Please cite references where President Obama called for a crusade.
Please cite references that President Obama has called for more troops in Afghanistan.
You have a right to your own opinions, you DO NOT have a right to your own facts.
Let's not forget that Czech commanders in Afghanistan were caught wearing Nazi insignia (SS emblems) on the helmets.
Sure glad the NATO mission is fighting for tolerance, democracy and freedom.
Login or Register to post comments.