Go Home

Death of an Ordinary Housecat

Move Along...

[Image via Flickr]

There's nothing to see here. Move along. Nothing, that is, but this report of a minor incident in Russellville, Arkansas: “Democratic Congressional candidate Ken Aden’s campaign manager returned home to find his family pet slaughtered, with the word 'liberal' painted on the animal’s corpse.”

A statement from the Aden campaign describes the cat as an adult mixed-breed Siamese and included a graphic description of the pet's injuries.

The statement said that the four children of campaign manager Jacob Burris “discovered the gruesome scene as they exited the family vehicle to enter their home” after “the perpetrators scrawled 'liberal' across the cat’s body and left it on the doorstep of Burris’ house."

“To kill a child's pet is unconscionable,” the candidate is quoted as saying.

I know, I know. It's not the most important story in the news this week. In a time of war and financial crisis, there are a lot bigger stories to report than the death of a house cat. It was just an ordinary pet like millions of others, a playmate to some children and a companion to their parents.

Nor is this an electoral scandal. The Aden campaign said they “did not believe the Womack campaign to be responsible,” adding that “before Christmas ... a (radio) station owned by Womack’s father, actually promoted a toy drive held by Aden’s campaign for children in the Third District.”

People, especially conservatives, will rush to say it's an isolated incident of random violence that could've happened to anyone. They've said that before. Lots of times, in fact.

The shooting of churchgoers at a liberal Unitarian church in Knoxville was an isolated incident.

The shooting of police officers in Pittsburgh was an isolated incident.

The shooting of deputies in Okaloosa, Florida was an isolated incident.

The killing of a Tucson man and the shooting of his wife and daughter (the nine-year-old was shot in the head at point-blank range) was an isolated incident.

The murder of an African-American woman and the raping and wounding of her sister, followed by the killing of a homeless man, was an isolated incident.

The killing of an African-American security guard at the Holocaust Museum was an isolated incident.

Except …

The man who shot those Knoxville Unitarians had these books on his bookshelf:  Liberalism is a Mental Health Disorder by Michael Savage, Let Freedom Ring by Sean Hannity, and The O'Reilly Factor, by Bill O'Reilly. Michael Savage said the ACLU “will kill us all,” that “the white male has nothing to lose … you haven't seen him explode … his ugly side,” and that “the radical left and the radical Muslim are blood brothers.” Hannity has a book called Deliver Us from Evil: Defeating Terrorism, Despotism, and Liberalism. O'Reilly calls liberals “Nazis” and encouraged Al Qaeda to attack liberal San Francisco.

The killer said he shot those people because “liberals” are “destroying America.” Hmm. Wonder where he got that idea? “Who I wanted to kill was every Democrat in the Senate & House, the 100 people in Bernard Goldberg's book.” That would be the book entitled “The 100 People Who Are Screwing Up America.” (Hint: None of them are conservatives.)

The man who killed those Pittsburgh police officers was afraid that Obama would take away his guns and deprive him of other rights.

So was the man who killed those deputies in Florida.

The accused killers of that Tucson man – including a woman who was identified by the little girl who was shot in the head – were extreme right-wingers in the anti-immigration movement.

The man who killed that woman, raped and wounded her sister, and then murdered a homeless man was a right-wing white supremacist. He was on his way to a Jewish Community Center when he was arrested.

The man who shot that security guard was a right-wing tax protester.

These are the deaths of human beings, not pets. Their absence is still being felt every day – by family and friends, by co-workers, by an entire community. Nobody will mourn a little housecat from Russellville, Arkansas – nobody except four children and their parents.

So why does it matter? The Talmud says that when someone destroys is a single soul it's as if they've annihilated "a universe entire." Who can doubt that there are living souls inside the creatures that live among us and inhabit our emotional worlds? Killing a pet is a sick act. The dehumanization of psychopathic human beings often begins in childhood with the torture and killing of animals.

The same gradual dehumanization can take place in a society, too. After Gabrielle Giffords was shot I refused to raise the volume or turn up the heat on our rhetorical divide, and opted for a “moment of silence” instead. But just as there's a time for silence, there is also a time to speak.

If we don't speak now, when will the dehumanization stop? Of course, the cat's killers don't represent an entire movement. But where's the outrage within the right over the violent and extremist rhetoric? Where was the outrage when people died, over and over?

Here are the kinds of statements that are still tolerated by the conservative movement without censure or criticism:

Ann Coulter said “the only way to talk to a liberal is with a baseball bat,” that "We need to execute people like John Walke... to physically intimidate liberals, by making them realize that they can be killed, too," and “My only regret with Timothy McVeigh is he did not go to the New York Times building."

"Even Islamic terrorists don’t hate America like liberals do," said Coulter. Sure, she's getting increasingly strident as her star continues to fade. But she's got plenty of company.

Leading conservative publication Human Events has a regular "Guns & Patriots" section.

Andrew Breitbart said "We outnumber (liberals) in this country, and we have the guns… I’m not kidding."

Rush Limbaugh said “I tell people don't kill all the liberals. Leave enough so we can have two on every campus – living fossils ..."

Rep. James Hansen said of President Bill Clinton, “Impeach him, censure him, assassinate him."

Michele Bachmann said she wanted her supporters “locked and loaded” and “on the front side of the political battle.”

CNN commentator Erick Erickson suggests that "mass bloodshed" might be appropriate if the Supreme Court's rulings on abortion aren't to his movement's liking.

Glenn Beck says liberals are "the enemies of God," coming "for the kill on religion," and are "enemies of freedom." He also said he was "thinking about killing Michael Moore … I could kill him myself, or if I would need to hire somebody to do it … No, I think I could. I think he could be looking me in the eye, you know, and I could just be choking the life out -- is this wrong?"

If liberals are Nazis, fascists, mass murderers, enemies of freedom, if they should be shot, hanged, choked, beaten, killed, then what's wrong with killing a liberal's cat?

There's no way to tie one public personality's violent rhetoric to any specific act. But the climate of violence is everyone's responsibility, especially those who look the other way when their allies speak violently. t's true that not all the ugly rhetoric is on one side, but it's vastly greater on the right.

When I wrote about bank crimes a while back one or two commenters began mentioning violent acts against Wall Street executives. But they're commenters, not public voices. I immediately toned down my rhetoric, which wasn't violent but was strong. It's a balancing act every day: To convey injustice without encouraging vigilante justice. To express outrage without fostering rage.

Here's what I keep thinking: If someone were ever hurt by someone who had read something I'd written I'd be devastated. I'd devote a large part of my life to reflecting on what role I might have played in the violence, and to helping reduce the violence from that moment on. I think bankers should be investigated, and the lawbreakers among them should be prosecuted. But if one were hurt, especially because of anything I'd done - however unintentionally - I'd be heartbroken.

Wouldn't you?

But there hasn't been a single moment of reflection, much less remorse or contrition. Not from Hannity. Not from O'Reilly. Not from Savage or Goldberg.

Now a cat is dead. Not a first responder or a churchgoer or a toddler in an Oklahoma day-care center. Just a cat. We don't know if it was male or female. We don't even know its name.

If there wasn't any remorse or reflection after a litany of human death and injury, there certainly won't be any over the death of a tiny creature in a little Southern town. The town was Russellville, Arkansas, in Pope County, population 27,000 or so. Bet you didn't know it's the county seat.

They'll probably arrest some teenagers sooner or later. Just kids. Just kids who learned this behavior somewhere.

And it was 'just' a cat. It was just a companion for an Arkansas family, a playmate for its children. The kids will cry but life will go on. The rhetoric won't change. The incident will be forgotten in a week.

There's nothing to see here. Move along. It was an isolated incident.

Share This Post

Link To This Post


11 Comments
karoli's picture

I was so horrified by it yesterday I couldn't even talk about it. Hell, even the neighbors' cats are friends here...we even have a beloved pug who hangs out with cats as well as dogs.

How could anyone be filled with this much hate? It just goes beyond what I can imagine.

You succeeded. Truly gut wrenching examples of the manifestations of ignorance, hatred, and violence.

Tax the Rich's picture

I have been wondering for a couple of years now, about the possibility of a Civil War? Seriously.

These right wing morons are so out of touch with reality, and so completely manipulated and duped by the fascist oligarch's - who are the ones actually oppressing the dumb asses - that I can see the rest of the country saying "we need to put these crazy feckers in their place."

It's only going to get worse, because these wing nuts are so incredibly stupid and completely lacking in critical thinking skills, that they will never figure out it is the GOP's old money trust funder's who are raping them.

Stupid, hate filled, racist, bigoted, misinformed brainwashed dumb asses, who are always irrationally outraged at the people who would help them, while defending the evil oligarch fascist scum that is screwing them.

And they are armed to the teeth too.

Wonderbar.

U.S.A.,U.S.A.,U.S.A.,........................................


Rush Limbaugh is what a smart person thinks a stupid bigot sounds like.

woodrowfan's picture

yeah, I've wondered the same thing.

LynneA's picture

I've been thinking about these "isolated incidents" and all the hate talk for 15 years or so, now. Do you realize this sort of speech is pretty much all you can listen to many parts of the country? I've driven across the country several times during that period; I know. What effect do you suppose this is having on at least a segment of the population - especially when this is the stuff they hear?

EEP EEP's picture

Isn't it odd that these isolated incidents always seem to be isolated to the right side of the political spectrum

keefer55's picture

They are happening from the east coast to the west, and the heartland also.
Imagine the outcry if Keith Oberman or Racheal Maddow started making veiled suggestions that their listeners assassinate the Koch Bros., or that they wished that they could choke the life out of Eric Cantor...They would be off the air and under investigation within hours.
How do we turn it around? I, for one, talk about liberalism, the rights of others, and wear my politics on my chest. Every time that I open my wallet, the first thing that you see is my ACLU card. That has started some interesting conversations. I also collect and shoot pistols and rifles. Like the man said..."The second amendment is for when they won't allow you to use the first one."
Every American should learn to shoot. Heck, the government even has a bureaucracy for it -the Civilian Marksmanship Program - they'll sell you a battle rifle from WWII or Korea, and ammo, too.
Once liberals start rubbing elbows with Bubbas on the range and refuting the hate talk radio bullet points and the GOD fearing, fraidy-cats that eat it up, maybe we can unite towards a common goal...like annexing Canada.

DaveZ's picture

To sum up the conservative response I've read: the cat obviously died of natural causes and the Democratic staffer made the whole story up.

As proof they claim the children who found the cat weren't distraught enough. To quote:

Hmm... Hmm... hmmm... hmmm... 
The 5 year old helps unbuckle his younger 3 and 2 year old siblings? Dad loads them all up for a trip to the ... gas station? 5 year old is more concerned with the letters than the dead kitty??? Dad now says he didn't want any high level publicity about the cat?? 
 
Hmmm...hmmm..hmmm... 
How old was the cat? Died a natural death perhaps? And Dad cooked up a story he now realizes went too far and became too popular? 
 
Keep on this one Erik. It's like the nooses drawn on the dorm room doors. Too ... convenient. Not normal in the telling details. Might turn out, Dad did something himself to his own dead cat for publicity. 
 
Can't believe it? Remember those nooses, and how the "victims" wanted attention? Something funny going on here...

Or

Plus, put yourself in his shoes: Somebody harms your pet that way, that CLOSE to your home, and you wouldn't IMMEDIATELY call the police, viewing this as a potential deadly threat to your 5, 3, and 2 year old? 
 
Something is not normal in this man's reaction to such alleged presumed vengeful violence. Nobody, not even a liberal, rolls over that fast and takes the dead cat out into the woods before phoning police. You want them to see WHERE exactly you found it, and want to know exactly how and where the cat was killed. You know, in case the killer is still around... 
 
Make sense?

And

Now - Before we get ahead of ourselves, let's take a moment to remember that other examples of partisan violence (lady that carved 'B' on her face, suicide of census worker with 'Fed' scrawled on him) ended up being hoaxes or frauds. I don't want to cast aspersions on Burris, just want to proceed with caution. We have only his word for it so far since the cat is buried.

----

Even if a conservative knows the act was evil, since it happened to a liberal - the whole thing must be made up.

They are evil. There is a thin line of distinction between the asshole who killed the cat and the ones now playing apologist for conservative violence.

Malleus's picture

Well, police regularly shoot dogs in drug raids, whether the raid is authorized or not, whether the dogs are aggressive or not (usually they're just barking, what dogs usually do with violent strangers invading their homes).

Maybe this is some pissed off conservative drug cop's doing.

Limp-Dick Blimpaugh's picture

Just another sick and mentally disturbed Reslug terrorist that we read about.

One small correction. I think the author included a small handful of conservatives so as to appear "balanced."