August 25, 2014

Melissa Harris-Perry did a nice job of taking apart Villager Joe Klein for his "cringe-worthy" op-ed he wrote this week for Time, where he did his best to malign Michael Brown for his own shooting and opined about the need to have an honest discussion about race relations in the United States. That discussion, as Harris-Perry discussed in her commentary above, is something Klein really doesn't seem ready to have yet when you dissect his article.

Dear Joe,

It's me, Melissa. I'm writing to you today about your column Beyond a Simple Solution for Ferguson. You write:

At first, it seemed a perfect metaphor for 400 years of oppression: a white police officer shoots an unarmed black teenager multiple times. He is shot with his hands up, it is reported, at least once in the back.

Joe, when a community is reeling from an unarmed teen shot to death, when his body was left for hours in plain view of the community. When no arrests have been made for his slaying, when those who are protesting the killing are met with militarized local police force and teargas, it is not a metaphor.

The people of Ferguson and the nation are mourning the death of a real person. They're responding to actual events and actions taken by the local government. That this death and those actions are consistent with the long history of similar deaths and actions makes them historically rooted, not metaphorical.

But the perfection of the metaphor is soon blurred by facts. The gentle giant, Michael Brown Jr.–nicknamed Bodyguard by his friends–seems pretty intimidating in a surveillance video

Joe, seems pretty intimidating is not a fact. The fact is the surveillance video shows an apparent petty crime. One that officer Wilson did not know about when he stopped Michael Brown and one that does not carry a death sentence even if a person is guilty of committing it.

An autopsy, requested by Brown’s parents, shows six bullet wounds; the kill shot is into the top of the victim’s head–which raises another possibility, that the officer, Darren Wilson, fired in self-defense.

Joe, it is certainly a possibility, but let us traffic in facts. Officer Wilson was armed. Michael Brown was not. Officer Wilson shot Michael Brown. Michael Brown is dead. Officer Wilson has not been arrested.

On the day that the Ferguson police finally made Officer Wilson's name public, they also released the surveillance video you mentioned, despite knowing that it had no bearing on the officer's decision to stop Michael Brown. Those are the facts.

You cite these statistics:

Blacks represent 13% of the population but commit 50% of the murders; 90% of black victims are murdered by other blacks.

Joe, if you want to just recite random crime facts that have nothing to do with this case, how about this one? 83 percent of white victims are murdered by other white people. Your statistics about black perpetrators have nothing to do with what happened August 9th. We know who shot Michael Brown to death and it wasn't a black man.

And how about this statistic? On average between 2006 and 2012, nearly two times a week in the United States, a white police officer killed a black person. Twice a week. That fact would suggest Michael Brown had plenty of reason to be afraid of Darren Wilson. Now you go on:

... a debilitating culture of poverty persists among the urban underclass. Black crime rates are much higher than they were before the civil rights movement.

Joe, the American crime rate overall, regardless of the race or victim is higher than it was in 1960 and crime has dropped precipitously since its peak in the 1980's and '90's. And it is not culture, but rather poverty that is debilitating, because it severely reduces access to sufficient nutrition, housing, health care, educational opportunities and sustainable employment.

As to the culture of poverty, is it American jazz and blue or hip-hop that you're referring to? Because those are some of the cultural products of the black American poor.

You write:

Absent a truly candid conversation about the culture that emerged from slavery and segregation, they won’t be solved at all.

Joe, we have finally found a place of agreement. The culture that emerged from slavery and segregation does require a candid conversation. We need to lay bare the implicit assumptions held by many of white superiority and black inferiority that come from slavery and segregation. Curfews, militarized police, teargas deployed on people exercising their First Amendment rights and public officials who insist there is no race problem and that outside agitators are responsible for all the troubles, definitely appears to be the residue of a cultural pathology bred by the legacy of segregation.

Now Joe, I would be very interested in having a candid conversation about that.



Can you help us out?

For 18 years we have been exposing Washington lies and untangling media deceit, but now Facebook is drowning us in an ocean of right wing lies. Please give a one-time or recurring donation, or buy a year's subscription for an ad-free experience. Thank you.


We welcome relevant, respectful comments. Any comments that are sexist or in any other way deemed hateful by our staff will be deleted and constitute grounds for a ban from posting on the site. Please refer to our Terms of Service for information on our posting policy.