October 1, 2021

Carl Bernstein is not mincing words.

"Democracy is in peril because the Republican party has become the party of Trumpism, and the party of disenfranchisement," he told CNN's Brianna Keilar.

"What we have seen in Idaho, what we have also seen in Arizona, in these supposed recounts ordered because of supposed voter fraud, is it doesn't exist. It is part of the big lie. The big lie is not just about the lie that Donald Trump did not lose the election, a few months ago, but rather it looks toward 2024, and the idea that we are going to have another, quote, 'rigged election.'

"They're setting this up so that there can be no legitimacy in our electoral process. And the Republican party has been taken over by this movement, that is the most radical political movement of our lifetime, that has come to power in any form in Washington, in our state legislatures, but I think what we really need to acknowledge here is that we are in a civil war in this country.

"We are in a cultural civil war such as we have never seen since 1860 to 1865, and that the radicalism of the Republican party today is almost comparable to a secessionist movement in this country because of what the Republican party now advocates in a kind of Trumpism, doesn't need Donald Trump anymore, he's fanned the flames, he's ignited them and the movement and we need in journalism, in particularly in the media, to start looking at what's going on in the country outside of Washington."

"Republicans are not fixing their internal problem, right? They're leaning into it. So what should Democrats be doing that they're not doing?" Keilar asked.

"First of all, let's look at the Republicans," Bernstein replied, putting the attention where it belongs.

"They're being very successful at what they're doing. Given the astonishing ideology to which the Republican party has become enslaved, disenfranchisement, controlling through authoritarianism in the United States, let's take a moment to look at what General Milley said. The head of our military said of Donald Trump's movement and Trumpism that they are like brown shirts, they are like Hitlerism.

"This is the chief of our military, a great hero incidentally for coming forth, unlike in others who have served in the Trump presidency and saying these things aloud. The Republican party has become captured by this movement, and that's what we need to look at. It is not just these incidents that we see, let's look at January 6th, and how that was revved up and incited by those around Donald Trump if not by Donald Trump himself. And how the Republican party is trying to suppress legitimate investigation of what happened on January 6th.

"So we are in a real civil war, a cultural civil war in this country, such as we haven't seen in 100 years, and we, you know, we keep, in media and politics, looking at our country and in Washington as if it is disconnected from our culture itself. We need to start covering our culture and what has happened in the last 20, 25 years in this country, that Donald Trump was able to enflame and ignite."

Keilar asked what he thought was missing from the press coverage.

"I think that it needs to be at the top of our agenda to understand that what happens in Washington, that, quote, our 'political culture' and, quote, our 'media culture,' is disconnected from this larger cultural phenomenon that goes so deep into who we are as a divided people. a divided people, the likes of which we have not seen in 175 years. and that includes the anti-war movement days of the 20th century," Bernstein said.

"This is something very different, the division that is separating and polarizing us in this country is vicious. It is deep. It is full of hate and anger. And most of that hate and anger is resting on big lies. It is somewhat one-sided in terms of who is responsible for this. And it is this far-right movement of authoritarianism that Donald Trump was able to exploit so successfully. We need to look at who we are as a people, not just who we are in politics, not just who we are in media, and we examine social media, let's look at the people. Let's go out into the country, talk to the people, look in these towns and in cities and urban areas and what the divisions are and what is being advocated in the name of Republicanism today that is a foreign and alien ideology to this country, the which -- the likes of which no party in our history has embraced a majority or minority, one of the two parties has never embraced a radical agenda such as we are seeing now."

Maybe the media should be talking more to the people who oppose the brownshirts? Just a suggestion.

Bernstein didn't articulate it very well, but Republicans are attacking and undermining the democratic values that are the foundation of America -- who we are, and what we aspire to be. America doesn't stand for what any old loudmouth idiot decides it does -- but where are the media influences to counter their destructive narrative? They have Fox News, but they don't have American news. We don't have characters on TV shows talking about these values in any depth. Shows like All In The Family were just a cultural blip, I guess.

Covid exposed the division, but it didn't cause it.

I keep thinking of "The House I Live In," the public service film Frank Sinatra made in1951, and how much we need to expose people to more like this.

Can you help us out?

For 18 years we have been exposing Washington lies and untangling media deceit, but now Facebook is drowning us in an ocean of right wing lies. Please give a one-time or recurring donation, or buy a year's subscription for an ad-free experience. Thank you.


We welcome relevant, respectful comments. Any comments that are sexist or in any other way deemed hateful by our staff will be deleted and constitute grounds for a ban from posting on the site. Please refer to our Terms of Service for information on our posting policy.